Blue Jays: 2016 Edition

Minnesota and Yankees coming up . If they don't win these 2 series time for a managerial change
Yup!!

And I hate to see it happen because I think Gibby is probably a nice guy, but as far as managing skills I think he's not that good.

And dont even get me started on Shapiro, he had to fix what wasnt broken.
Now we have a shit bullpen because of him
 
and exactly how did you get that feeling? Another one of your observations from inside the club house again???
Why don't you take a flying leap, head first, into a cement wall?

Maybe that would knock some sense into your head!

Perry
 
Yup!!



And dont even get me started on Shapiro, he had to fix what wasnt broken.
Now we have a shit bullpen because of him

Really? The bullpen was awful at the beginning last year and finished just above average in a lot of statistical categories but were a tier below the top bullpens of Pittsburgh, KC, St. Louis and ..wait for it Cleveland. The Indians had a better bullpen than the Jays last year.

So lets review these disastrous moves that destroyed a slightly above average bullpen. Pardon me if i miss any.

(1) Traded Hendriks for Chavez - Hendriks has started the year horribly with 28 hits in 16 innings pitched and in now on the DL. Anyone want him back now?
(2) Traded for Drew Storen - Obviously has not worked out. At the time of the trade, they used an area of strength in the offense for one of the better reliever options on the market. His track record was better than anyone the Jays had brought in a while, had closing experience and solid career FIP, WHIP strikeout rate...
(3) Let Mark Lowe sign in DET - Lowe is struggling in the eighth inning role and is now the Tigers 4th best bullpen option.
(4) Brought in Gavin Floyd - seems to be working out ok thus far. Subsititute Hendriks and Lowe in for Floyd and yes Chavez..the bullpen is probably in worse shape.

The rest of the motley crew are AA holdovers...Osuna (amazing), Cecil (opposite of that) , Tepera, Venditte..Biagini was a Rule 5 pickup.

Now I'm sure people are going to say AA would have ninja'd Aroldis Chapman out of Cincy's fire sale. Well the Dodgers agreed to a major prospect package for him before they backed out when Chapman was facing possible gun charges. Then the Yanks coughed up 4 prospects for 130ish games of Chapman.

So what would you have done differently if Shapiro/Atkins are so bad at building the bullpen?
 
Gibbs is a one and done type coach, like Dave Cameron and Claude Noel, nobody will ever hire him again.
 
Really? The bullpen was awful at the beginning last year and finished just above average in a lot of statistical categories but were a tier below the top bullpens of Pittsburgh, KC, St. Louis and ..wait for it Cleveland. The Indians had a better bullpen than the Jays last year
Right, but you have to look at our bullpen stats after the all-star break when all the trades were made

So lets review these disastrous moves that destroyed a slightly above average bullpen. Pardon me if i miss any.

(1) Traded Hendriks for Chavez - Hendriks has started the year horribly with 28 hits in 16 innings pitched and in now on the DL. Anyone want him back now?
You cant judge Hendriks over 16 innings, plus he isnt healthy like you said and Chavez is.
The part that pisses me off is why did Hendriks have to go??


(2) Traded for Drew Storen - Obviously has not worked out. At the time of the trade, they used an area of strength in the offense for one of the better reliever options on the market. His track record was better than anyone the Jays had brought in a while, had closing experience and solid career FIP, WHIP strikeout rate
Storen trade was on paper smart. It hasnt worked out so far, but that trade was a good one


(3) Let Mark Lowe sign in DET - Lowe is struggling in the eighth inning role and is now the Tigers 4th best bullpen option
Lowe reportedly isnt happy in Detroit. Maybe thats why he's not performing??
Besides you cant judge Mark Lowe over 13 innings.
And again though, why not keep a proven pitcher like him?? He's only 32.
I wouldve kept him


(4) Brought in Gavin Floyd - seems to be working out ok thus far
No, its not working out so far. He gave up another game-ending dinger the other day.
Floyd is 33 and over 13 MLB years has an ERA of 4.34. Thats shit!!!
Why even sign a guy like that??


Now I'm sure people are going to say AA would have ninja'd Aroldis Chapman out of Cincy's fire sale. Well the Dodgers agreed to a major prospect package for him before they backed out when Chapman was facing possible gun charges. Then the Yanks coughed up 4 prospects for 130ish games of Chapman.

So what would you have done differently if Shapiro/Atkins are so bad at building the bullpen?
I would not have tinkered with the team as much as Shapiro has.

Letting AA go was a mistake, and I wouldve kept Lowe/Hendriks.
I also wouldve kept Navarro (very valuable pinch-hitter/catcher).
And I perhaps wouldve added a proven reliever to replace Hawkins.

The bottom line is Shapiro has tinkered too much with the team
 
I think it's safe to say the Gibbons watch is on. This is starting to spiral out of control.

You guys forgot to mention that Eric Wedge will replace Gibby. Whoever will need to teach the boys how to play small ball. Especially with the bottom half of the lineup. Travis comeback may save Gibby?
 
The bottom line is Shapiro has tinkered too much with the team
What makes it worse is that he tried to do it on the cheap. Brought in a bunch of tier 3 pitchers and hoped some of the shit would stick to the wall. By the time he had to trade away a classic leadoff man for Storen there were a bunch of free agent pitchers (not even talking Chapman-like) he didn't even take a shot at and kept Revere at the same time.
 
Jimmy Paredes hits his first home run as a Jay, where was the silent treatment.

Rougned Odor is lucky that it was Jose he punched and not Sid Seixeiro. Sid would have crushed his skull with his array of chins.
 
http://www.bluebirdbanter.com/2016/5/18/11691610/blue-jays-report-cards-at-the-quarter-pole

Can't disagree with most of his assessment. Maybe bump EE to C for carrying the team for a week and leading the team in RBIs.
Tulo is coming around, but Martin, Storen, Cecil and Goins have simply sucked.
Martin has 1 extra base hit in the first quarter of the season! That's epic bad.

But I'm putting most of the blame on Gibby. Goins has been lost at the plate while Barney has been hitting 300+ while playing GG defence. Forget platoon, just start Barney.

Cecil and Storen have sucked and Gibby should have stopped putting them in high leverage situation after the first 3 weeks. You can see the team get deflated when they give up the lead late in the game.

In order to make the playoffs, a team needs approx mid-90 wins. This means we have to win almost 2 of every 3 games rest of the way.
Without any changes, don't see any way this will happen.
 
Last edited:
What makes it worse is that he tried to do it on the cheap. Brought in a bunch of tier 3 pitchers and hoped some of the shit would stick to the wall
He gambled, and he lost.

I give Shapiro credit for bringing in Happ though, that was a good move
 
And I hope Jays dont wait till all-star break to fire Gibby and to perhaps acquire some relievers, because by that time we might be 10 games under .500 and the season will be lost
 
3 solo HRs by EE, Paredes and Saunders. No runners on base, low team OBP. So many things wrong with this team.

Goins looked completely useless at the plate tonight. Taking strikes and swinging at balls in the dirt. They should put him out of his misery and send him down to get his confidence back. I think they claimed Paredes in preparation to make a move.
 
Ya Goins needs to go down.

Travis is doing well in rehab , if all goes well he might be back up next week
 
Some good news in an otherwise miserable Blue Jay week:

https://www.thestar.com/sports/blue...devon-travis-moves-up-to-triple-a-bisons.html

Rehabbing Devon Travis moves up to Triple-A Bisons

Blue Jays second baseman Devon Travis is getting closer to returning to the big leagues, moving up to Triple-A Buffalo on Thursday as he continues his minor-league rehab assignment.

“He’s moving up the ladder, so that’s a good sign,” said DeMarlo Hale, the Jays bench coach and acting manager during John Gibbons’ three-game suspension. “I don’t have a time limit, but you get to Triple-A, you’re getting pretty close.”

Travis, who has been on the disabled list since last July 28 when a recurrent shoulder injury effectively ended his rookie season, started his rehab assignment last Friday in Class-A Dunedin. In four games, he went 5-for-14 with two doubles and five RBI.

The 25-year-old, who made a remarkable debut last April when he hit six homers in his first month in the big leagues, is working his way back from off-season shoulder surgery to repair a congenital condition known as Os Acromiale, which occurs when four parts of the acromion bone at the top of the shoulder fail to fuse together.

He is a candidate to hit in the leadoff spot for the Jays upon his return. Hale said there’s “no question” he could be a spark plug for the team’s flagging offence, but he didn’t want to put undue pressure on a player with just 62 major-league games under his belt.

“There’s a lot of guys in there that can do that.”
 
Why don't you take a flying leap, head first, into a cement wall?

Maybe that would knock some sense into your head!

Perry

That would knock some sense into me????

Coming from the guy who continues to make comments about situations in the club house he has no idea about... No merit at all to your dumb and useless theories on the chemistry of the team.

Your a goof bro....
 
Last edited:
I sent an e-mail to Jays Event to get my band The Anal Johnsons to play a pre game concert, but I haven't heard back.

The Jays are going through what the Red Soxs endured after losing Brook Jacoby to the Yankees. The Nationals are prospering with Ben Revere at lead off. He's a consistent contact hitter that steals bases, without him the Jays hitters are out of sync. Kevin Pillar could fill that role but he's not ready.
 
Right, but you have to look at our bullpen stats after the all-star break when all the trades were made


You cant judge Hendriks over 16 innings, plus he isnt healthy like you said and Chavez is.
The part that pisses me off is why did Hendriks have to go??



Storen trade was on paper smart. It hasnt worked out so far, but that trade was a good one



Lowe reportedly isnt happy in Detroit. Maybe thats why he's not performing??
Besides you cant judge Mark Lowe over 13 innings.
And again though, why not keep a proven pitcher like him?? He's only 32.
I wouldve kept him



No, its not working out so far. He gave up another game-ending dinger the other day.
Floyd is 33 and over 13 MLB years has an ERA of 4.34. Thats shit!!!
Why even sign a guy like that??



I would not have tinkered with the team as much as Shapiro has.

Letting AA go was a mistake, and I wouldve kept Lowe/Hendriks.
I also wouldve kept Navarro (very valuable pinch-hitter/catcher).
And I perhaps wouldve added a proven reliever to replace Hawkins.

The bottom line is Shapiro has tinkered too much with the team

So some of your defenses like for Lowe and Hendriks are that the sample size is small yet you can be judge jury and executioner on Shapiro after the quarter pole.

And they did not let AA go. He had a job offer as the #2 and choose to leave. He said as much.

Ended up taking a role as the #4 in LA for maybe less money? That's on him. If he could not operate under a management structure like many of the big clubs have adopted where the GM does not make all the baseball decisions (including the one he joined, Andrew Friedman is 1, maybe 1.5 layers above his GM yet is heavily involved in personnel decisions) he is going to probably have to go to a smaller market or an expansion/relocation situation to get the supreme powers he had in Toronto.
 
The Nationals are prospering with Ben Revere at lead off. He's a consistent contact hitter that steals bases....


I'm sorry, WHAT?!

"Highlights" of Ben Revere 2016 stats:

12 Gm
57 PA
3 Runs
5 Hits
1 Double
1 Triple
0 SB
2 CS
3 BB
10 K
.096 BA
.158 OBP
.154 SLG
.312 OPS

The success the Natinals have had, has virtually nothing to do with Ben Revere.
Rather, it's in spite of him.

http://www.baseball-reference.com/pl...everbe01.shtml

Here's Pillar's stat list, just a touch better than Mr. Revere's.

http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/p/pillake01.shtml