Really? The bullpen was awful at the beginning last year and finished just above average in a lot of statistical categories but were a tier below the top bullpens of Pittsburgh, KC, St. Louis and ..wait for it Cleveland. The Indians had a better bullpen than the Jays last year
Right, but you have to look at our bullpen stats after the all-star break when all the trades were made
So lets review these disastrous moves that destroyed a slightly above average bullpen. Pardon me if i miss any.
(1) Traded Hendriks for Chavez - Hendriks has started the year horribly with 28 hits in 16 innings pitched and in now on the DL. Anyone want him back now?
You cant judge Hendriks over 16 innings, plus he isnt healthy like you said and Chavez is.
The part that pisses me off is why did Hendriks have to go??
(2) Traded for Drew Storen - Obviously has not worked out. At the time of the trade, they used an area of strength in the offense for one of the better reliever options on the market. His track record was better than anyone the Jays had brought in a while, had closing experience and solid career FIP, WHIP strikeout rate
Storen trade was on paper smart. It hasnt worked out so far, but that trade was a good one
(3) Let Mark Lowe sign in DET - Lowe is struggling in the eighth inning role and is now the Tigers 4th best bullpen option
Lowe reportedly isnt happy in Detroit. Maybe thats why he's not performing??
Besides you cant judge Mark Lowe over 13 innings.
And again though, why not keep a proven pitcher like him?? He's only 32.
I wouldve kept him
(4) Brought in Gavin Floyd - seems to be working out ok thus far
No, its not working out so far. He gave up another game-ending dinger the other day.
Floyd is 33 and over 13 MLB years has an ERA of 4.34. Thats shit!!!
Why even sign a guy like that??
Now I'm sure people are going to say AA would have ninja'd Aroldis Chapman out of Cincy's fire sale. Well the Dodgers agreed to a major prospect package for him before they backed out when Chapman was facing possible gun charges. Then the Yanks coughed up 4 prospects for 130ish games of Chapman.
So what would you have done differently if Shapiro/Atkins are so bad at building the bullpen?
I would not have tinkered with the team as much as Shapiro has.
Letting AA go was a mistake, and I wouldve kept Lowe/Hendriks.
I also wouldve kept Navarro (very valuable pinch-hitter/catcher).
And I perhaps wouldve added a
proven reliever to replace Hawkins.
The bottom line is Shapiro has tinkered too much with the team