Thats great Georgie, I'm glad you have an inquisitive mind :thumb:not defensive at all, just asked a question
:biggrin1:
Thats great Georgie, I'm glad you have an inquisitive mind :thumb:not defensive at all, just asked a question
Is it just me, or does this team look more dangerous with an extra guy or two that doesnt swing for the fences all the time. They look more dangerous with Carrera and Barney in the lineup. Imho.
Philip
No, you are right. I brought this point up earlier, shack's response was Jays are a homerun hitting team and therefore should swing for the fences at all times. This is just plain wrong, even a homerun hitting team has to be able to mix up their play with bunts, opposite field hitting, moving runners along, hitting a single when the situation dictates it......etc.....etc.Is it just me, or does this team look more dangerous with an extra guy or two that doesnt swing for the fences all the time. They look more dangerous with Carrera and Barney in the lineup. Imho.
Philip
No, you are right. I brought this point up earlier, shack's response was Jays are a homerun hitting team and therefore should swing for the fences at all times. This is just plain wrong, even a homerun hitting team has to be able to mix up their play with bunts, opposite field hitting, moving runners along, hitting a single when the situation dictates it......etc.....etc.
But lets see, maybe the hitting will start coming around now
Very different than what I said.shack's response was Jays are a homerun hitting team and therefore should swing for the fences at all times.
Very different than what I said.
I said they were not designed to play small ball, meaning not a lot of bunting and base stealing, which is what was suggested they do much more of. But they can still hit with men in scoring position, and hit the opposite way or hit line drives for doubles etc. There are many ways to score without bunting or always swinging for the fences.
So Saunders sits?The Jays look better with Carerra hitting lead off. I really like it.
Philip
So Saunders sits?
You dont sayThere are many ways to score without bunting or always swinging for the fences
Which was my initial point. I wrote:I said they were not designed to play small ball, meaning not a lot of bunting and base stealing, which is what was suggested they do much more of. But they can still hit with men in scoring position, and hit the opposite way or hit line drives for doubles etc
Even a homerun hitting team has to be able to mix up their play with bunts, opposite field hitting, moving runners along, hitting a single when the situation dictates it
You dont say
Which was my initial point. I wrote:
The guys down the lower part of batting order that should lay down the occasional bunt have mostly failed to do so. This is on the hitting coach Jacoby.
It's very unlikely that they will learn bunting at this level if they don't know it already. Basic skills should be taught at lower levels, the American League is not a development league.
Not hitting singles up the middle when the situation dictates it, is on Gibby. I have seen our sluggers do this too many times, they swing for the fences when a single up the middle could tie or win us the game. Again, this is on Gibby.
No, it's on the hitters. Unless Gibby perhaps has some sort of message like "basehit will do, but why not try to jack one into the third deck for us".
You need a strong manager who will give his hitters shit when they dont play fundamental baseball.
Like Cito. No wonder he never won.
Gibby comes across as a bit weak in that department. No wonder players love the guy, he never reprimands them when they need it
I like Saunders. I like Bautista DH, Edwin at first, Carrera in right, and Smoak off the bench and giving occasional day offs. If Collobello was around that would have been Smoaks role anyways. They didn't sign him to play everyday.
I also like Barney at second, with either Travis or Goins as a utility back up, with the other in AAA. Travis should go back down, no? Once Tulo comes back, I think second base should be Barneys until someone takes the job away, or Barney proves this is all a fluke and he's meant to be a bench player lol.