The pricing is out of whack, otherwise I'd consider giving this a shot..
You know it's not that bad. I am still thinking about it. I guess I'll try out a 24hr thing and see if the bikes are any good first.
But if you buy the yearly membership that works out to $8/month. You then get as many 30min or less trips as you like for free for the whole year. You don't pay anything extra, if it's a 30min trip. That is not a bad deal.
If you go for an hour it isn't much more, $1.50 for an hour long trip, that's pocket change, and an hour on a bike is actually a reasonable chunk of time in the city. Even if you go 90 minutes it works up to $5.50 which is still not a lot of money.
It only gets really expensive (and fast!) if you decide to take a bike out for a day. After 90 minutes they start dinging you to the tune of $16/hour, which adds up to the price of a cheap bike pretty quickly. So it's really not something that's useful if your idea is rent a bike for a day trip to Toronto Island or something like that.
But for those trips under 90 minutes it's OK, and you can reset that clock by docking the bike--so if you go for 3 hours, and you stay in their "zone" where they have docks, you can reset that clock and keep it to pocket change territory.
Depending on what you plan to do with it, that's really not bad.
However I would like to see them expand their coverage area--right now it's really just the downtown core, basically bloor/spadina/jarvis/lake. That's really not big enough. It should be the whole former "City of Toronto" at a minimum, ideally expanding to include at least the main streets of Scarborough, North York, and Etobicoke at some point.