No he didn't. You are just blatantly lying. He never said that.But Netenyahu said Israel will never withdraw from west bank .
No, he did not say that. You are BLATANTLY lying. It has been pointed out to you MANY times what he actually said, and yet you keep on lying -- when you know full well that is not what he said.He said there will be no palestinian state, therefore Israel will never withdraw from the west bank. So we aren't talking about military occupation because it's permanent and not temporary.
They never had Israeli citizenship. Ever. In fact, they openly rejected Israeli citizenship and refused to recognize that Israel even existed, so it's not possible that they could have had citizenship in a country they weren't in that they refused to recognize.It's a violation of international law to revoke the citizenship of someone if he has no other citizenship.
They weren't present. The territory they were in when Israel declared independence wasn't occupied by Israel until 20 years later.Anyone who is present in a certain territory the day a new state declares its independence gets automatically the citizenship of the new state.
And I am telling you that they were not present in Israel when Israel declared independence. Note that the borders of Israel changed dramatically in 48 and 49 due to the Arab war of aggression against Israel. Moreover they refused to recognized Israel and they to this day refuse to abide the conditions the UN set for their return. They have never been Israeli citizens and at least until the 1980s they refused to even recognize that Israeli citizenship even existed.I'm talking about the ones deported in 1948
1. No they weren't, Haganah captured Haifa a month before independenceThe ones deported from Haifa were present in Israel the day it declared independence,
You cited Haifa and you were proved wrong.Half of Palestinian refugees left after Israel declared independence
There is no doubt Arab leaders called on people to leave, in the case you mentioned, Haifa, we have written proof.also the fact that another half left before independence contradicts Israeli false claims that they followed a call by Arab leaders to evacuate
I suggested no such thing.As you can see from Moviefan comments he was suggesting to deport or ethnically cleanse the arabs in the west bank so that Israel keeps a jewish majority.
...those people are born in a territory controlled by Israel but kept stateless by Israel.
Hmm. It seems like someone needs to be reminded -- yet again -- that the Palestinians were offered their own state and that they rejected those offers. No one is being "kept stateless."...so it's ok that a minority gets citizenship and keep the majority stateless so that they don't exceed 20%
Wow you keep making up crap. In 1950, Jews were 88% of the population. Now they are 75%. So where does this alleged 20% limit come from?This is what it did in 1948 and the reason why nowadays it continues to deny those refugees deported in 1948 the right to return to their homes.
Another reason is that it's hard for israel to fence the arabs in east Jerusalem like it does with the ones in the west bank
Northern Cyprus?I read your Wikipedia link about military occupation , it says that by definition an occupation is temporary usually few years....
If we are going to discuss that area, do you mind if we use its proper name? Much of that area you call East Jerusalem is called the Jewish Quarter. It puts things in perspective to recall that it is territory the Arabs ethnically cleansed in 48.Another reason is that it's hard for israel to fence the arabs in east Jerusalem like it does with the ones in the west bank
Again after having lost the point you try and throw up sand by quibbling. Dozens of democracies have state religions, including Malaysia which is a democracy with Islam as the state religion.Greece has an openly atheist Prime minister
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...th-russian-patriarch/articleshow/46874099.cms
You cannot revoke the citizenship of someone who was never a citizen. You continue to embarrass yourself with idiotic statements which defy not only facts and history but all logic.It's a violation of international law to revoke the citizenship of someone if he has no other citizenship.
That would apply to exactly zero people. No one was deported. Even if you are referring to those who fled or who were allegedly chased out that would apply to less than 10 of the Palestinians now alive a great many of whom have been kept in camps and denies any rights for 60 years by Lebanon, Jordan, Syria etc.I'm talking about the ones deported in 1948
As usual you have it backwards The point of the security wall is not to keep the Palestinians in it is to keep them out. Not unlike the borders that virtually every country maintains.Another reason is that it's hard for israel to fence the arabs in east Jerusalem like it does with the ones in the west bank
Pretty funny.Greece has an openly atheist Prime minister
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...th-russian-patriarch/articleshow/46874099.cms
Israeli security forces are strong and pervasive enough to maintain law and order and prevent Palestinians inside Israel from forming militias like Hamas. That would certainly change if Israel were an Arab majority state.Another evidence that your claims regarding Palestinians and Arabs who according to you want to ethnically cleanse jews are wrong: There are 1.5 million Arabs living among jews in Israel and they aren't murdering their Jewish neighbours everyday. So you're only anti arab racist who falsely argues that arabs and Palestinians are bloodthirsty murderers. .
Israel isn't present in Gaza and in the West Bank law and order is a Palestinian Authority responsibility. So your question really should be why have Hamas and Fatah failed to prevent attacks on Jews?So why Israeli which is strong failed to maintain law and order in West Bank and Gaza ?
Isn't possible. The Arabs won't allow it.So one state solution that gives equal rights to jews and arabs
