Banning Items to Save lives

Banning which of the following would save the most lives in the US?

  • "Assault" Weapons

    Votes: 6 24.0%
  • Cigarets

    Votes: 12 48.0%
  • Alcohol

    Votes: 2 8.0%
  • Cats

    Votes: 5 20.0%

  • Total voters
    25
Drinking and driving actually kills a significant number of people, unlike people with assault rifles. They aren't even remotely in the same ball park...

Gee, and here I thought drinking and driving was already banned.
 
Gee, and here I thought drinking and driving was already banned.

Murder is banned too.

The analogy to banning firearms to prevent shootings would be to ban cars to prevent drunk driving. Plainly in both cases the crimes themselves are already banned....

Of course the difference is that, unlike with assault rifles, drunk driving ACTUALLY does kill a lot of people.
 
Of course the difference is that, unlike with assault rifles, drunk driving ACTUALLY does kill a lot of people.

The difference is that, unlike cars, assault weapons are designed to kill a lot of people.
 
The difference is that, unlike cars, assault weapons are designed to kill a lot of people.

Ive tried with this guy to explain that already. No use. Doesnt understand cars were not created to kill people unlike guns. Dudes actually comparing gun deaths to lightning lol. He actually said unlike assault with assault rifles drunk driving actually does kill people LOL. Cause ya assault rifles never killed anyone lol. Im convienced the guy is retarded lol
 
The difference is that, unlike cars, assault weapons are designed to kill a lot of people.

And the other difference is, that unlike assault weapons, cars actually do kill a lot of people.

You guys keep fear mongering over this point while ignoring the reality of the situation. "OMG guns were designed to kill people! BOOOOO!!! SCAAAARRY!!!! BOOOOOOO!"

Meanwhile assault rifles kill almost no-one and cars inflict a daily carnage. You are out of touch with reality and scaring yourselves silly for no good reason.
 
Ive tried with this guy to explain that already. No use. Doesnt understand cars were not created to kill people unlike guns. Dudes actually comparing gun deaths to lightning lol. He actually said unlike assault with assault rifles drunk driving actually does kill people LOL. Cause ya assault rifles never killed anyone lol. Im convienced the guy is retarded lol

Ask him about skis.
 
Let me point out something you guys are missing:

"Guns were designed to kill people" <-- this is just rhetoric, fluffy words, that mean nothing

"Cars actually kill people" <-- this is objective reality, people really die
 
Let me point out something you guys are missing:

"Guns were designed to kill people" <-- this is just rhetoric, fluffy words, that mean nothing

"Cars actually kill people" <-- this is objective reality, people really die

Using your own logic, we shouldn't worry about anything that causes death as long as it doesn't kill more people than cars?

So we should allow people to build pipe bombs because they rarely actually kill people, and when they do it's still less than the total number of car deaths?

What about asbestos? Cars kill way more people than asbestos does. Should we start using asbestos in houses again?
 
We should also stop screening people at the airport.. I mean.. How many people a year REALLY die from terrorist attacks on planes?
 
Let me point out something you guys are missing:

"Guns were designed to kill people" <-- this is just rhetoric, fluffy words, that mean nothing

"Cars actually kill people" <-- this is objective reality, people really die

Let me point out something you are missing, Guns actually kill people! THIS IS OBJECTIVE REALITY PEOPLE REALLY DIE! LOL And its not rhetoric, thats what they were designed for! Numpty! They're a dangerous thing. The fact that your making it debatable is crazy and as gun owner yourself sounds like an irresponsible mentality.
 
And I'm tired of my tax dollars paying for lifeguards at the pool.. How many drownings could their possibly be in a year? I'm sure WAY more people die from car accidents than they do from drowning in a public pool.
 
And damnit, I want to own a Bengal Tiger.. If I chain that mother fucker up he probably won't eat anybody.. And if he does, it'll only be one or two..

Until they ban driving, I want the right to own a fucking Bengal Tiger.. Otherwise it's just hypocritical.
 
And damnit, I want to own a Bengal Tiger.. If I chain that mother fucker up he probably won't eat anybody.. And if he does, it'll only be one or two..

Until they ban driving, I want the right to own a fucking Bengal Tiger.. Otherwise it's just hypocritical.

Bengal Tigers are completely safe. They have never killed anyone. I seen one at the zoo the other day locked up in a cage. Safest thing in the world. My Grandma was even there. I wouldnt let her ski though or stand under a tree holding a key up towards the sky in a thunderstorm. Bengal Tigers way more safer then skis or lightning
 
Murder is banned too.

The analogy to banning firearms to prevent shootings would be to ban cars to prevent drunk driving. Plainly in both cases the crimes themselves are already banned....

Of course the difference is that, unlike with assault rifles, drunk driving ACTUALLY does kill a lot of people.

You seem generally to be a pretty smart guy and I am therefore amazed at the arguments you make and positions you take on this thread which for the most part are really quite silly.

I haven't heard anyone suggest banning guns generally. Nor have Have I heard anyone suggest that banning assault style will prevent murder. I have hear people suggest that banning assault style rifles and large capacity magazines may reduce the killing ability of mass murders. I have heard this view shares by Generals Powell and McCytstal and others who are far more knowledgeable than me and frankly you. I have heard the contrary vew expressed by Lapierre and keen who are indirectly on the payroll of the gun and ammo manufacturers. Making the argument that banning assault style guns and larges capacity magazines etc will not END murder etc as a reason not to is disingenuous at best and frankly beneath you.
 
You seem generally to be a pretty smart guy and I am therefore amazed at the arguments you make and positions you take on this thread which for the most part are really quite silly.

I haven't heard anyone suggest banning guns generally. Nor have Have I heard anyone suggest that banning assault style will prevent murder. I have hear people suggest that banning assault style rifles and large capacity magazines may reduce the killing ability of mass murders.

I am specifically talking about this proposal to ban assault rifles, which is why I am talking about things like the frequency of deaths by lightning--which kills more people. Plainly if we broadened the discussion to all gun crime, specifically handgun crime, I wouldn't be talking about lightning strikes because handgun murders are far more common--in fact, one of the leading causes of death for young men. But assault rifles kill almost no-one, despite the media attention they garner whenever it does happen.

There's this fear mongering campaign insinuating that this is a big problem, and needs some sort of national strategy, expensive national regulatory regimes, enforcement regimes, programs to track and monitor these assault rifles, and either grandfather or confiscate the ones that are in the public now.

And all of this because when a mass shooting occurs it generates a lot of national headlines and media attention and therefore everybody assumes it is a big problem.

Objectively, though, it is not a big problem--it kills remarkably few people, and there is no evidence that banning assault type rifles will even resolve the problem. Lanza may have felt cool with his AR15, but Lepine and Breivik both did the same thing with a rifle that is not even proposed to be subject to any of these bans.

So, after you expensively ban these rifles, at great inconvenience to the millions of people who own them, and at great cost through the programs to confiscate or regulate them--all that's going to happen is that mass shooters will switch from using the semi-automatic rifle used by Lanza to the semi-automatic rifle used by Lepine and Breivik, and kill just as many people.

It is foolish and wasteful in the extreme.
 
Let me point out something you are missing, Guns actually kill people! THIS IS OBJECTIVE REALITY PEOPLE REALLY DIE! LOL And its not rhetoric, thats what they were designed for! Numpty! They're a dangerous thing. The fact that your making it debatable is crazy and as gun owner yourself sounds like an irresponsible mentality.

Fear mongering. Last year rifles of all kinds killed 323 people in the United States, less than one in a million. And that includes hunting rifles and ordinary semi-automatics. "Assault type rifles" will be a fraction of those 323 shootings, depending on how you wind up defining that term.

So objectively this is not a problem. In fact almost no-one is killed, and you are just blathering away wholly disconnected from the objective reality that lightning strikes kill more people than assault rifles do.
 
all that's going to happen is that mass shooters will switch from using the semi-automatic rifle used by Lanza to the semi-automatic rifle used by Lepine and Breivik, and kill just as many people.

How are you so sure those weapons won't be included in the ban?

As I've said from the beginning, a ban done right would have SOME effect.
 
Using your own logic, we shouldn't worry about anything that causes death as long as it doesn't kill more people than cars?

I don't know where you want to draw the line. Cars are at one extreme, they inflict a massive number of deaths. Assault rifles and lightning strikes are at the other extreme, killing almost no-one.

Plainly there is a point at which we just accept that there are risks in life and we move on. I would think most people consider lightning strikes to be so rare that they basically never worry about that, whereas I think your average person does have some fear and trepidation about one day being in a serious automotive accident.
 
You also dance back and forth between arguments.

On one hand you say assault style weapons don't kill enough people to warrant a ban.. Then on the other hand you say that too many assault style weapons will still be available to make a difference.

So which is it?