Banning Items to Save lives

Banning which of the following would save the most lives in the US?

  • "Assault" Weapons

    Votes: 6 24.0%
  • Cigarets

    Votes: 12 48.0%
  • Alcohol

    Votes: 2 8.0%
  • Cats

    Votes: 5 20.0%

  • Total voters
    25
So then presumably you reject the assault rifle ban as "a stupid distinction" and "cherry picking".

Well we agree on that!

However if you do want to talk about such a ban then perhaps it is relevant to point or we are talking about very few of the gun homicides.

Glad we agree on something.
Then the debate should be amended to include gun control for all types of weapons. after all over 100,000 Americans have died from gunfire in the last decade.
After all, only a little more then 6,000 US soldiers have died in battle over the last decade compared to 100,000 civilians.
The US has become more dangerous then battle.
 
Glad we agree on something.
Then the debate should be amended to include gun control for all types of weapons. after all over 100,000 Americans have died from gunfire in the last decade.
After all, only a little more then 6,000 US soldiers have died in battle over the last decade compared to 100,000 civilians.
The US has become more dangerous then battle.

And that's as many abortions that are performed in Florida in a year.... but that's only relevant if you want to continue comparing apples and nuts.

OTB
 
You're trying to solve a problem that already kills fewer people every year than lightning strikes do. I think you are over-selling this claim that it will lead to fewer gun related deaths.

If you want to do something about gun crime in the United States, and you want it to be statistically significant, it is somehow going to have to impact gang related shootings with handguns. Nothing else really will show up in the stats...

My argument is simply that banning assault rifles WILL have an effect on gun related deaths. Not a huge effect. It won't stop the senseless murder of thousands of other Americans already killed by handguns, stabbings, vehicular homicide, etc.,. Even if the ban is done right, I'm sure criminals will still somehow get their hands on assault rifles and many people will still be killed as a result. But that it will have SOME effect.

Dollars to lives, it's probably not the best bang (or lack their of) for your buck.. However, it isn't worthless (as OTB would like to have us believe).
 
My argument is simply that banning assault rifles WILL have an effect on gun related deaths. Not a huge effect. It won't stop the senseless murder of thousands of other Americans already killed by handguns, stabbings, vehicular homicide, etc.,. Even if the ban is done right, I'm sure criminals will still somehow get their hands on assault rifles and many people will still be killed as a result. But that it will have SOME effect.

Dollars to lives, it's probably not the best bang (or lack their of) for your buck.. However, it isn't worthless (as OTB would like to have us believe).


I havce no idea where FUJI gets this idea that fewer people died from guns, although he plays with by cherry picking it with 'assault gun' claims. Oh, I forget he makes things up.

At least the number of people dieing from lightening, something you can't do much about, is going down. Last year was the lowest total in 10 years. As of October a total of 28 died by lightening last year.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/08/lightning-deaths-us_n_1949536.html

I can't remember the last time someone used a lightning bolt to terrorize anyone in a robbery or at a school or cinema. Who'd a thunk it, FUJI and OTB together, buddies in defence of an idiotic position.
 
I havce no idea where FUJI gets this idea that fewer people died from guns, although he plays with by cherry picking it with 'assault gun' claims. Oh, I forget he makes things up.

At least the number of people dieing from lightening, something you can't do much about, is going down. Last year was the lowest total in 10 years. As of October a total of 28 died by lightening last year.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/08/lightning-deaths-us_n_1949536.html

I can't remember the last time someone used a lightning bolt to terrorize anyone in a robbery or at a school or cinema. Who'd a thunk it, FUJI and OTB together, buddies in defence of an idiotic position.

I ignored his claim about lightening strikes.. I'm sure many hundreds of people are murdered each year with assault rifles.. Assault rifles are used in gang shootings, organized crime shootings, mass murders, etc.,. While only 50 odd people die each year as a result of lightening strikes..
 
I ignored his claim about lightening strikes.. I'm sure many hundreds of people are murdered each year with assault rifles.. Assault rifles are used in gang shootings, organized crime shootings, mass murders, etc.,. While only 50 odd people die each year as a result of lightening strikes..

...... and then he's indignant when people laugh at his posts.
 
My argument is simply that banning assault rifles WILL have an effect on gun related deaths. Not a huge effect. It won't stop the senseless murder of thousands of other Americans already killed by handguns, stabbings, vehicular homicide, etc.,. Even if the ban is done right, I'm sure criminals will still somehow get their hands on assault rifles and many people will still be killed as a result. But that it will have SOME effect.

Dollars to lives, it's probably not the best bang (or lack their of) for your buck.. However, it isn't worthless (as OTB would like to have us believe).

I don't see any evidence anywhere that it will have any effect, nor any reason to believe that it will.

Moreover you are proposing to ban a firearm that is just about the most popular firearm in the United States, inconveniencing millions upon millions of people, in exchange for no detectable benefit.

And please don't start up with this "even one life" nonsense, if we really thought so we would ban skiing, hockey, swimming, and pretty much every other sport, because sooner or later somebody is going to be killed. Unless you think we should all be locked into our homes, with a police escort to cross the street, in reality we do accept some level of risk in our lives--and the level of risk represented by a few people a year being killed by lightning, or anything else that infrequent--is a risk we happily accept in MANY human endeavours, many of them quite "trivial" in nature.

It is worthwhile talking about what we can do to reduce the number of people murdered by handguns every year--that is a real problem. You and I will probably disagree on what should be done, and what would be effective, but certainly we would both agree that it's actually a problem worth solving, in whatever way it needs to be solved. But assault rifles represent such a tiny fraction of the gun crime in the United States and Canada that really, whatever policies we already have around these things--they're working, the problem, if there ever was any problem, was long ago solved to a level that makes it a complete non-issue, leaving aside the sensationalism in the media.
 
And please don't start up with this "even one life" nonsense, if we really thought so we would ban skiing, hockey, swimming, and pretty much every other sport, because sooner or later somebody is going to be killed.

I would have thought you'd be above this nonsensical argument.

Skiing, or any of the other sports you mention, are done exclusively for recreation. An assault rifle is bought for recreation (if you're a psycho), for self protection (a dog works better), for hunting (what a joke), and for killing other humans. There is a difference.
 
the problem, if there ever was any problem, was long ago solved to a level that makes it a complete non-issue, leaving aside the sensationalism in the media.

Actually you're wrong (but that's an interesting way of interpreting events). It wasn't solved long ago. There are no solid facts on how many people are killed by assault rifle, because these facts aren't kept by police (to the best of my knowledge). They attempted to "solve" the "problem" of assault rifles back in 1994 with a ban full of so many holes it had zero effect. That "ban" was lifted in 2004 and they haven't made anything close to an attempt since.
 
It is worthwhile talking about what we can do to reduce the number of people murdered by handguns every year--that is a real problem.

I do agree with you here. However, this wasn't part of my argument. I never argued that the Assault Rifle ban would solve everything. I only argued that it would obviously have SOME effect (where as OTB was sure the effect would be ZERO).

I'm not being outrageous here.. If that kid in Connecticut didn't have access to his mother's legally purchased Bushmaster XM (a civilian version of an M14, I believe) then he would have had to go into that school armed with handguns and/or hunting rifles & shotguns.. Would kids still have died? You bet. Would less kids have died? I'd say yes. The lethality of the latter is far less than that of the former... If you don't believe me, just ask the military.
 
I don't see any evidence anywhere that it will have any effect, nor any reason to believe that it will.

Moreover you are proposing to ban a firearm that is just about the most popular firearm in the United States,
It seems a bit of paradox. How is it that one can say with certainty that limiting access to what is currently the most popular firearm would have no impact. Sorry fuji. That is counter intuitive.
 
Actually you're wrong (but that's an interesting way of interpreting events). It wasn't solved long ago. There are no solid facts on how many people are killed by assault rifle, because these facts aren't kept by police (to the best of my knowledge). They attempted to "solve" the "problem" of assault rifles back in 1994 with a ban full of so many holes it had zero effect. That "ban" was lifted in 2004 and they haven't made anything close to an attempt since.

Actually they are kept by the FBI. Rifles of all kinds are a miniscule part of gun homicides. Almost all shootings were with a handgun.
 
I would have thought you'd be above this nonsensical argument.

Skiing, or any of the other sports you mention, are done exclusively for recreation. An assault rifle is bought for recreation (if you're a psycho), for self protection (a dog works better), for hunting (what a joke), and for killing other humans. There is a difference.

I bought my "assault rifle" for the same reason why I bought skis, so I can participate in a sport.
 
...

Moreover you are proposing to ban a firearm that is just about the most popular firearm in the United States, inconveniencing millions upon millions of people,...
The same kind of inconvenience as not letting people drink before driving?

in exchange for no detectable benefit. ...

Based on....
 
It seems a bit of paradox. How is it that one can say with certainty that limiting access to what is currently the most popular firearm would have no impact. Sorry fuji. That is counter intuitive.

This is one of those moments that should cause you to re-evaluate your beliefs about firearms. You believed certain things, which led you to have certain expectations, but now you have come upon a surprising fact, which totally violates all your assumptions. You now have a choice--continue on with wrong beliefs, or step back, assess, and re-evaluate what you think about firearms and their owners.

The reality is that firearms owners don't commit crimes, and rifles aren't popular with those who do. The criminals prefer handguns. The people who buy "assault rifles" tend to be law abiding types who don't kill anybody. The people who are doing all the killing want a firearm they can conceal under their clothese--and an AR15 is a big scary rifle, hard to conceal. As a result--and go check the statistics for yourself--despite the AR15 being a wildly popular firearm few people are killed with it.

Really--this is one of those moments. Challenge your assumptions! Check the stats out yourself. Scratch your head. Realize that you have been fed a song and dance by the anti-gun crowd.