Banning Items to Save lives

Banning which of the following would save the most lives in the US?

  • "Assault" Weapons

    Votes: 6 24.0%
  • Cigarets

    Votes: 12 48.0%
  • Alcohol

    Votes: 2 8.0%
  • Cats

    Votes: 5 20.0%

  • Total voters
    25
When there's a shooting sports thread, I might offer my opinion about what risks we can tolerate in that sport, but so far we've had only general treads about the appropriateness of guns in society and their regulation

Any discussion of the cost and benefits if guns in society must necessarily consider the immense benefits of sport.

As for lightning I dispute that we do everything possible to avoid lightning strikes. We handle the special case of strikes on buildings, but after that most people ignore the issue as being so unlikely that there are more important issues.

Put in economic terms, tax dollars spent on something as rare as assault rifle deaths cost lives by diverting precious resources away from effective programs.

We cannot actually do everything. We cannot address every risk regardless I'd size, we have not got enough money to fund programs that works save a lot more lives than an assault rifle ban.

We should use our money in the most effective way above make the biggest difference. Spending a couple hundred million on a regulatory regime to save a handful of lives is insane, when there are thousands of lives that could be saved with a better allocation.
 
There is no proposal to ban hunting rifles currently being considered and such a proposal would be deeply unpopular.

Even in Canada where we implemented restrictions on the AR15 the ruger mini remains a non restricted firearm.

And no I do not think there it's a any evidence gun control works, I simply pointed out that even if you thought it did assault rifle homicides are rare.

Nobody's proposing to ban all hunting rifles. Just hunting rifles capable of unleashing mass carnage in a very short period of time. If your precious AR-15 and/or Mini-Ruger are incapable of doing this then, I agree, let them be. I have a feeling they likely will be left alone if what you say is true.

But to say that ANY ban would be worthless is asinine. Any ban is better than what they have going on now. Who knows, maybe if they're able to push through one ban, another will follow. Perhaps then some stricter regulations. Heck, one day they may end up with a reasonable amount of weapons being owned by reasonable people being used for reasonable purposes (and being locked up the rest of the time in a safe). They'll start with the heavy duty weapons that no reasonable person owns (or can justify owning) anyway, and then eventually (after years of fighting the NRA) they'll put restrictions and regulations on handgun ownership (as there should be).
 
Any discussion of the cost and benefits if guns in society must necessarily consider the immense benefits of sport.

You''re one of these guys that thinks billiards, bowling, and darts are sports, aren't you?

Sure, call it a sport. Hell, any twig necked dweeb can do it.. But hey.. If it makes you happy, we'll call you an athlete if you like.
 
Shooting is a sport and has all the benefits of any sport. If you disagree take it up with the IOC which has recognized shooting sports by including several shooting events in the Olympics.

Ok, restrict all handguns and assault weapons of all shapes and sizes.
Keep hunting rifles, but not semi-automatic ones.
And for sport, legislate only rubber bullets.

Its a sport, why would you need anything other then rubber bullets?
 
Shooting is a sport and has all the benefits of any sport. If you disagree take it up with the IOC which has recognized shooting sports by including several shooting events in the Olympics.

Your right. How could sport survive if people could not own a Bushmaster with a high capacity magazine.
 
Any discussion of the cost and benefits if guns in society must necessarily consider the immense benefits of sport.

As for lightning I dispute that we do everything possible to avoid lightning strikes. We handle the special case of strikes on buildings, but after that most people ignore the issue as being so unlikely that there are more important issues.

Put in economic terms, tax dollars spent on something as rare as assault rifle deaths cost lives by diverting precious resources away from effective programs.

We cannot actually do everything. We cannot address every risk regardless I'd size, we have not got enough money to fund programs that works save a lot more lives than an assault rifle ban.

We should use our money in the most effective way above make the biggest difference. Spending a couple hundred million on a regulatory regime to save a handful of lives is insane, when there are thousands of lives that could be saved with a better allocation.
While even I can see social benefits in tramping through the woods in quest of a deer, it'd be for hunters to explain how sitting in heated treestands or duck blinds waiting for their proximity alarms to go off is a sport. Likewise, I can see winter biathalon as a sport, but a whole lot of target shooting—especially from stands—appears no more sportive to me than needle threading—real demanding hand-eye stuff—and I can't see why laser-guns couldn't produce even more precise scores. Is windage really what you guys compete against? I don't mean to deride your sport or hunting. Neither is in any way seriously hampered by any regulations I have heard of, either proposed or existing, though as you have said, the criminal penalties attaching to administrative paperwork might have needed revision. It's the guns-for-protection sociopaths we have to worry about, not the sportspeople they use for protective cover.

Since you dispute that we do everything possible to avoid the lightning you're so fond of bringing into every post, please tell us a few of those possible measure we don't take. I certainly disagree that we ignore the issue; Environment Canada issues many warnings and the media faithfully transmit them along with preventive advice. Are you proposing compulsory grounded metal-mesh union suits and fines for going without? How would that equate to having to fill out a form for a gun you own?

Regulation of dangerous goods is part and parcel of ordinary life in any organized society, why should we not regulate guns and those who own them, just as we regulate cars and drivers, or cranes and their operators, or boats and those who operate them, or poisons, or pesticides, or where you can and cannot throw your trash …? The list is endless. But the question for you is about one sort of dangerous goods only: What's wrong with regulating guns and their owners?

PS: As I have said repeatedly, I do wish you'd spare us the 'registration doesn't save lives' nonsense; no one would believe you if you said a license plate on a car would save lives, and I can't speak for people who think guns would be different. If that really is the level on which you want to discuss gun regulation I'll leave you to find an audience at that level.
 
You''re one of these guys that thinks billiards, bowling, and darts are sports, aren't you?

Sure, call it a sport. Hell, any twig necked dweeb can do it.. But hey.. If it makes you happy, we'll call you an athlete if you like.

If any twig necked dweeb could do it, it wouldn't be an Olympic sport. In real life shooting accurately requires strength, endurance, cardio vascular fitness,and significant muscle control.

You try supporting a 17lb rifle in firing position while holding your breath and stabilizing your posture well enough to hit a dime at 500 yards. Then do it consistently all day long.
 
If any twig necked dweeb could do it, it wouldn't be an Olympic sport. In real life shooting accurately requires strength, endurance, cardio vascular fitness,and significant muscle control.

You try supporting a 17lb rifle in firing position while holding your breath and stabilizing your posture well enough to hit a dime at 500 yards. Then do it consistently all day long.

I've got better things to do, but if it makes you feel more like a 'man' then go ahead. Just switch to rubber bullets for the rest of us, ok?
 
If any twig necked dweeb could do it, it wouldn't be an Olympic sport. In real life shooting accurately requires strength, endurance, cardio vascular fitness,and significant muscle control.

You try supporting a 17lb rifle in firing position while holding your breath and stabilizing your posture well enough to hit a dime at 500 yards. Then do it consistently all day long.

Ah yes, the Olympics. Quite right, they only let in true athletes... For example, do you know how hard it is to sit up straight on your horse during a round of Dressage?

Get real buddy.. I'm sure it requires skill, but you're not an athlete by ANY stretch of the imagination.
 
Ah yes, the Olympics. Quite right, they only let in true athletes... For example, do you know how hard it is to sit up straight on your horse during a round of Dressage?

Get real buddy.. I'm sure it requires skill, but you're not an athlete by ANY stretch of the imagination.

Real athletes, like those who do Dressage, synchronized swimming and badminton.
Yup.
A real good argument.

In any event, make them all switch to rubber bullets, since its just a sport.
 
Ah yes, the Olympics. Quite right, they only let in true athletes... For example, do you know how hard it is to sit up straight on your horse during a round of Dressage?

Get real buddy.. I'm sure it requires skill, but you're not an athlete by ANY stretch of the imagination.

In the same way as guys who play hockey on the weekends aren't either. We generally reserve the term athlete for the top tier and don't usually apply it to weekend amateurs with a passing involvement in the sport.

I also ski, cycle, lift weights, play tennis, and swim, but not to an extent that I would ever call myself an athlete there either. I am just a reasonably active person with a moderate involvement in a variety of sports, one of which is shooting.

On the other hand, the top competitive shooters are in fact athletes.

The point that target shooting is a physically challenging and well recognized Olympic sport had been established so let's move away from the childish personal attacks.
 
Real athletes, like those who do Dressage, synchronized swimming and badminton.
Yup.
A real good argument.

In any event, make them all switch to rubber bullets, since its just a sport.

I gotta step in here.. Badminton can be very tiring, and synchronized swimming (while foolish looking) requires an enormous amount of strength, agility, and stamina.

His nonsense about holding a 17 pound rifle all day is just that (nonsense).

In recent history the Olympics has had several pistol shooting competitions, several shotgun competitions, and just two rifle competitions (three if you count the air rifle). One of the rifle competitions is "rifle prone" meaning you're lying down while shooting. The other is "rifle three positions" meaning you're standing, kneeling, and lying down. These are NOT marathon sports. They are NOT required to aim a rifle all day (or even hold it all day).

His "physical prowess" is in holding his breath for a few seconds while he aims a 20 pound gun REALLY carefully. That's it. Sure, maybe they're required to do this several times in a day (maybe as many as 50 to 100 times in a day). Anybody who has ever spent any time at a shooting range knows that this isn't terribly hard on the body. As I said before, I'm sure it requires skill, but so does pinning a tail on the donkey.
 
Plainly you have never tried it.

It requires significant physical fitness, training, and skill to avoid muscle shake while holding a weight.
 
I also ski, cycle, lift weights, play tennis, and swim, but not to an extent that I would ever call myself an athlete there either. I am just a reasonably active person with a moderate involvement in a variety of sports, one of which is shooting.

I'm glad that you keep fit. However, I don't really care what you do the rest of the time. The argument was whether or not firing a rifle makes you an athlete. It doesn't. Firing a gun at the Olympics doesn't make one an athlete any more than it makes a dressage rider (or whatever they're called) an athlete.
 
I'm glad that you keep fit. However, I don't really care what you do the rest of the time. The argument was whether or not firing a rifle makes you an athlete. It doesn't. Firing a gun at the Olympics doesn't make one an athlete any more than it makes a dressage rider (or whatever they're called) an athlete.

The IOC dissagree with your fanatic view.
 
I'm glad that you keep fit. However, I don't really care what you do the rest of the time. The argument was whether or not firing a rifle makes you an athlete. It doesn't. Firing a gun at the Olympics doesn't make one an athlete any more than it makes a dressage rider (or whatever they're called) an athlete.

Simply more silliness from fuji and trying to make or support arguments which are equally silly.
 
Hey, if you need to fire a gun to feel like a man, then go ahead. But don't hide behind this "it's a sport, and I'm an athlete" crap.

It is a sport but I never claimed to swim, ski, shoot, or cycle at a level that would justify calling myself an athlete. Like most people in most sports my involvement is pretty casual. I shoot maybe once a month, about a often as I ski or play tennis.