Bands You Just Don't Get

Sonic Temple

Dreamers learn to steer by the stars
Feb 14, 2020
25,691
42,996
113
NOTL
Ok - so I have been listening to early Genesis this week - only the Peter Gabriel era and I have I been through their their catalogue a few times - again only the Peter Gabriel stuff and I gotta say - I don't get the hype. Boring as hell, musicianship is great don't get me wrong but cmon - what was the hype. Appreciate Peter's solo stuff 10000000X over his Genesis years, Phil Collins did wonders for Genesis and loved all the stuff he with them vs Peter's stuff.

Currently listening to Trespass and fck - can't wait for this record to end - and spinned it twice just to make sure I gave it a fair chance. Ok, 'Stagnation' is currently playing and must say it has grown on me - maybe need to play it a few times more.......still though - prefer Collins era Genesis over Gabriel but love Gabriel solo stuff.

1653657276297.png 1653657295738.png 1653657314000.png 1653657329652.png 1653657362618.png1653657380106.png

None of the above did nothing for me - I don't get the fuss that has been made of this era of the band.
 
Ok - so I have been listening to early Genesis this week - only the Peter Gabriel era and I have I been through their their catalogue a few times - again only the Peter Gabriel stuff and I gotta say - I don't get the hype. Boring as hell, musicianship is great don't get me wrong but cmon - what was the hype. Appreciate Peter's solo stuff 10000000X over his Genesis years, Phil Collins did wonders for Genesis and loved all the stuff he with them vs Peter's stuff.

Currently listening to Trespass and fck - can't wait for this record to end - and spinned it twice just to make sure I gave it a fair chance. Ok, 'Stagnation' is currently playing and must say it has grown on me - maybe need to play it a few times more.......still though - prefer Collins era Genesis over Gabriel but love Gabriel solo stuff.

View attachment 147199 View attachment 147200 View attachment 147201 View attachment 147203 View attachment 147204View attachment 147206

None of the above did nothing for me - I don't get the fuss that has been made of this era of the band.
Their greatest lineup and era.
 
Ok - so I have been listening to early Genesis this week - only the Peter Gabriel era and I have I been through their their catalogue a few times - again only the Peter Gabriel stuff and I gotta say - I don't get the hype. Boring as hell, musicianship is great don't get me wrong but cmon - what was the hype. Appreciate Peter's solo stuff 10000000X over his Genesis years, Phil Collins did wonders for Genesis and loved all the stuff he with them vs Peter's stuff....

 
  • Like
Reactions: Insidious Von
Until I saw American Psycho, I thought Huey Lewis and the News was something I left in the toilet bowl in the morning.

 
I cannot for the life of me understand the popularity of Imagine Dragons and Walk Off the Earth.

And yet for some bizarre reason, WotE keeps showing up on my Spotify playlists.
 
I thought The Beatles started out as a boy band, the psychedelic era was John Lennon hooked on Delaudid. Till recently I didn't understand this song.

In the Cardi ward, they gave me Delaudid to buy me time or give me a happy ending.

 
Ok - so I have been listening to early Genesis this week - only the Peter Gabriel era and I have I been through their their catalogue a few times - again only the Peter Gabriel stuff and I gotta say - I don't get the hype. Boring as hell, musicianship is great don't get me wrong but cmon - what was the hype. Appreciate Peter's solo stuff 10000000X over his Genesis years, Phil Collins did wonders for Genesis and loved all the stuff he with them vs Peter's stuff.

Currently listening to Trespass and fck - can't wait for this record to end - and spinned it twice just to make sure I gave it a fair chance. Ok, 'Stagnation' is currently playing and must say it has grown on me - maybe need to play it a few times more.......still though - prefer Collins era Genesis over Gabriel but love Gabriel solo stuff.

View attachment 147199 View attachment 147200 View attachment 147201 View attachment 147203 View attachment 147204View attachment 147206

None of the above did nothing for me - I don't get the fuss that has been made of this era of the band.
The Gabriel Genesis version is pretty boring and meandering but that's 70s Prog Rock for ya. The Gabriel solo stuff did nothing for me either...I really don't enjoy his voice.
The Collins-fronted Genesis is way better ...some truly great pop music there. Phil Collins solo also had some enjoyable hits.
One band I never got was REM. How the hell did they become so popular at one point?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sonic Temple
I don't get the Beatles. All I see and hear is the beginning of the "boy band" era. The 60's version of the Backstreet Boys.
Worst music ever.
a little over the top...but i get your point
2 versions of the same song
1 is completely sanitized white bread drivel...the other is marbled dark rye......guess which ones..you be the judge
 
Ok - so I have been listening to early Genesis this week - only the Peter Gabriel era and I have I been through their their catalogue a few times - again only the Peter Gabriel stuff and I gotta say - I don't get the hype. Boring as hell, musicianship is great don't get me wrong but cmon - what was the hype. Appreciate Peter's solo stuff 10000000X over his Genesis years, Phil Collins did wonders for Genesis and loved all the stuff he with them vs Peter's stuff.

Currently listening to Trespass and fck - can't wait for this record to end - and spinned it twice just to make sure I gave it a fair chance. Ok, 'Stagnation' is currently playing and must say it has grown on me - maybe need to play it a few times more.......still though - prefer Collins era Genesis over Gabriel but love Gabriel solo stuff.

View attachment 147199 View attachment 147200 View attachment 147201 View attachment 147203 View attachment 147204View attachment 147206

None of the above did nothing for me - I don't get the fuss that has been made of this era of the band.
Part of the problem might be you heard the latter stuff first, and had that set in your mind when you listened to the earlier stuff. When they became a 3 piece band their style changed significantly, almost like a completely different band.
This reminds me of something similar in the early 80's regarding Rush(I'm a huge fan). Moving Pictures was released around 1981 and was a huge success and a great album. They followed up that album with Signals. Problem was everyone was expecting another Moving Pictures. In fact, Signals was very different but still a great album. It was the expectation that led to initial confusion or disappointment.
 
Genesis with Gabriel is amazing. No, not typical pop music. That’s why it’s great.

Gabriel’s solo stuff I am a massive fan of.

Phil Collins era…. Over played and too commercial. It’s not terrible, but nothing he sings is on any of my playlists.

Rick Beato on his YouTube channel did a random assembly of the top ten songs on Apple and Spotify on separate videos. He has an incredible ear, and can break songs down. Every song, be it pop, country, or Rap, was using the same chord structure. 1, 4, 5, and 6.

(There are 7 chords on a key, and these chords sound sweet. Think of Boston, More than a feeling. Those 4 chords.)

The Beatles had 27 #1’s, and only used that chord structure in one them. I doubt anything Genesis did with Gabriel remotely had revolved on those 4 chords.

Music today is garbage because there is 0 creativity. Record execs just demanding mass consumable hits.