Ban Cinelli Yes or No

Asterix said:
I had no idea you were so talented in estimating the numbers killed. Given that the number of 6 million Jews killed has been correlated by many sources over the intervening years, what exactly are you coming up with?


...6 million is a made up number, Jews were rounded up and killed.
The number is not really that important.
That it happened is beyond doubt.
 
bbking said:
....first of all Lancs the number killed come from the Allies themselves from records kept by the Germans who very proud to keep very up to date numbers.

What I find disturbing about your post is this sense that a group is trying to guilt you into feeling bad about what happened. For instance should White Americans today feel quilt over slavery ... no ... all Americans should feel guilt over the institution of slavery as a policy of early American society ... it should be out there and remembered as something that should never be forgotten so that it never happens again. The fact that a certain group of Americans brings it up or discusses reparation should not be figured as perpetrating a guilt trip on another group of Americans. The discussion itself reminds society that this past event in social structure should never occur again.

Similar is the Holocaust ... this was crime against all humanity in that a certain group of a society decided that other groups were not fit to live in that society. The German society, either through direct or indirect action allowed Jews, Homosexuals, mentally ill, gypsy's and a whole host of other groups to be wiped out from German society.

The fact that one group, the single largest group, reminds us of this tragedy is by no means a guilt trip. The crime of the leaders of a society deeming large segments of that society unworthy of living is something we should never forget least we become a member of the group that someone decides is not worthy of living.


bbk



You make a valid point, but in response I will repeat that unless pressed heavily on this issue they claim almost exclusive rights to the persecution. The "OH Woe is me" routine just whines on and on.

When I was but a young lad, a good buddy whose dad was a Polish catholic had his tatoo number on his arm as a souvineer of a concentration camp. His dads comments were always that it was like their suffering never existed as far as the mass media, and by extention , the great mass of society, was concerned.

.
 
LancsLad said:
You make a valid point, but in response I will repeat that unless pressed heavily on this issue they claim almost exclusive rights to the persecution. . .

When I was but a young lad, a good buddy whose dad was a Polish catholic had his tatoo number on his arm as a souvineer of a concentration camp. His dads comments were always that it was like their suffering never existed as far as the mass media, and by extention , the great mass of society, was concerned.
I mentioned much of this above in #170.

I agree with what you wrote above editing out but one line. Jews made up approximately 60 percent of the victims of the Holocaust, but the other 40 percent are almost totally ignored.
 
LancsLad said:
You make a valid point, but in response I will repeat that unless pressed heavily on this issue they claim almost exclusive rights to the persecution. The "OH Woe is me" routine just whines on and on.

When I was but a young lad, a good buddy whose dad was a Polish catholic had his tatoo number on his arm as a souvineer of a concentration camp. His dads comments were always that it was like their suffering never existed as far as the mass media, and by extention , the great mass of society, was concerned.

.

The Holocaust has become one of the major points in the make-up of every Jew. It sometimes gets us to forget that the Jews suffered much though out history, all around the world. The Nazis grabbed a hold of a prejudice that was already there. The Jews hold on to the Holocaust and will never let it go. It will probably work it's way into their religion.

I first heard there were 10 million Jews killed. This I found out later is the total number of people estimated to have been killed in camps. 6 million were said to have been Jews, and the rest were others. It is a very sad part in the history of the world. I don't think there is any question as to the the fact that it happened, but I think it is good to question the numbers and go over how it happened. We must learn from history to improve our future. It does not seem that we have really learned from this.

In my own experience I have come to realize that it is not just W.A.S.P.s that have racism and hatred in them. We just have managed to hold more power and wealth over the last while. This means we can and have done more damage. One look at a few of the African countries of late will show the same sort of things happen when hatred is let rule with any race. We can all commit acts of great horror, and we can all suffer at the hands of others.

As far as the freedom of speech we do have limits with things such as libel. I often think that much of the lies spread through racism should be considered a form of libel against a group. Lies spread with malicious intent.

I have heard that it is illegal in the UK and many other European countries to deny the holocaust.
 
Back to the original point

zaig said:
I have always been a big believer in free speech, but Cinelli's postings go way past that concept. Aside from being a huge anti-semite, conspiracy spreading idiot, who does not have an ounce of logic in his twisted brain, the hate and venom he spreads is really quite counter productive. At first I actually found his ranting a bit entertaining, in a wierd sort of way, but now its just plain stupid. Could you imagine what he must be like in real life, very sad.
Of course, if he is banned, he will then spread his hate and venom elsewhere and state that he was banned by the World Zionist conspiracy. Which reminds me, I think there is a meeting on Thursday.
So with this in mind, I have 2 suggestions.
1. Ban Cinelli OR
2. Whatever thread he either starts or contributes to, totally disreguard, as if he is being censored or shunned.

Talk amongst yourselves.
The only reason I would ever consider banning someone like Cinelli would be if he brought undue negative attention to this site.

By that I mean if his anti-Semitic, bordering on pro-Islamic fundamentalist, pro-Al-Qaeda postings were to draw the attention of security agencies in the US and Canada and that led to an investigation of the TERB membership - even those not participating in the Politics forum - and IP addresses, email accounts, etc., were forced to be handed over to authorities and then used as leverage or the basis of an investigation, I would be pissed.

Because at the end of the day, this is an escort review board, not a politics discussion site. That is what has always worried me about this forum in the post 9/11 landscape. And if this house of cards came crumbling down due to his ridiculous postings, that would be a travesty.

Just my two shiny pennies.
 
fucking unbelievable thread.

Lancs - really you've outdone yourself.

they claim almost exclusive rights to the persecution. The "OH Woe is me" routine just whines on and on.

Why don't you provide us with just one link where there is a claim to exclusivity to over persecution? Do you want to know why? You don't do it because you can't. Either you're very stupid, or you're deliberately making it up. And either way, it's a testament to your hatred that you'd willingly author a line like that.

Why don't you provide us with just one link to the "whine" you claim? Where is this "OH Woe is me". But of course it's the very same reason. There are no such links.

You see you just happen to "feel" that way. But not in your wildest imagination could you think that that feeling is in any way hatred.

In two sentences you manage to belittle the Holocaust, misrepresent Jewish reaction to the Holocaust, and turn it into a compaint against Jews.

Thick.
 
TQM said:
Lancs - really you've outdone yourself.

they claim almost exclusive rights to the persecution. The "OH Woe is me" routine just whines on and on.

And either way, it's a testament to your hatred that you'd willingly author a line like that.


You see you just happen to "feel" that way. But not in your wildest imagination could you think that that feeling is in any way hatred.
How do you interpret that as a testament to hatred?
 
jazzpig said:
How do you interpret that as a testament to hatred?

Things much like this were said about the Indians and Blacks in other posts. I don't seem to remember them being called hatred.
 
jp,

Why is it hatred - downplaying the impact of the Holocaust, calling Jews "whiners" over it, and then deliberately mischaracterizing Jewish reaction to it, is straightforward anti-semitism 101. It's right out off the first page of the Hatred text - the chapter on Jews.
 
bbking said:
Sorry, I disagree ... without the reminders then people like you just dismiss the event as simple whining. That is a very sad truth. It is much easier to look away from the ugly truth and blame somebody else than it is to take ownership and pledge to make sure it never happens again.


Can't ever say for sure it will never happen again, times and values tend to be rather fluid things.

I have no desire nor obligation to take "ownership" for what has happened, it wasn't my doing, so 60 years later the constant whining just grates on the nerves.

A lot of people suffered greatly at the hands of the Germans but we don't all go around using it as some sort of crutch to extort sympathy and concessions from succeeding generations in perpetuity.
 
TQM said:
Why is it hatred - downplaying the impact of the Holocaust, calling Jews "whiners" over it, and then deliberately mischaracterizing Jewish reaction to it, is straightforward anti-semitism 101. It's right out off the first page of the Hatred text - the chapter on Jews.



TQM our moral compass.:rolleyes:


Not for me thank you. I don't but into that guilt trip and really don't care if you agree or not.
 
well lancs,

putting a "smilie" on your message really means a lot. Apropo, playing the mental midget.

Wouldn't consider myself a moral compass - but hanging around here makes it easy to seem like one. (As if it's wrong to be a moral compass).

Don't ever forget the fact that you disgust me, child.
 
Oddly enough, a few who were here a couple years ago used to refer to me as a moral compass. I got bored with the whole idea and found it much more satisfying to make fun of people.
 
TQM said:
Why is it hatred - downplaying the impact of the Holocaust, calling Jews "whiners" over it, and then deliberately mischaracterizing Jewish reaction to it, is straightforward anti-semitism 101. It's right out off the first page of the Hatred text - the chapter on Jews.
Sorry, I don't see how that constitutes hatred.
That's the whole point here. It's easy to label somebody anti-semetic just because they don't agree with you or you get offended.
 
TQM said:
putting a "smilie" on your message really means a lot. Apropo, playing the mental midget.

Wouldn't consider myself a moral compass - but hanging around here makes it easy to seem like one. (As if it's wrong to be a moral compass).

Don't ever forget the fact that you disgust me, child.



If I disgust you, GREAT.

As for me being a child, well lets just say that : You're a big poo poo head.:D


Look another smilie.
 
LancsLad said:
TQM our moral compass.:rolleyes:


Not for me thank you. I don't but into that guilt trip and really don't care if you agree or not.

Lancs you're a funny guy but, and you know it's not something I'd do lightly, I have to agree with TQM on this one.
 
Cinelli probably loves this thread.