Ban Cinelli Yes or No

zaig

Member
Jan 26, 2004
172
0
16
I have always been a big believer in free speech, but Cinelli's postings go way past that concept. Aside from being a huge anti-semite, conspiracy spreading idiot, who does not have an ounce of logic in his twisted brain, the hate and venom he spreads is really quite counter productive. At first I actually found his ranting a bit entertaining, in a wierd sort of way, but now its just plain stupid. Could you imagine what he must be like in real life, very sad.
Of course, if he is banned, he will then spread his hate and venom elsewhere and state that he was banned by the World Zionist conspiracy. Which reminds me, I think there is a meeting on Thursday.
So with this in mind, I have 2 suggestions.
1. Ban Cinelli OR
2. Whatever thread he either starts or contributes to, totally disreguard, as if he is being censored or shunned.

Talk amongst yourselves.
 
You seem to be able to see thru his evil way. Do you not trust the rest of us to do the same?
 
I stopped looking at his stuff a long time ago. Just not interesting enough. My eyes would glaze over. In that respect, and that respect only, rather like the 'this day during the Clinton presidency' or the punning threads. Who can be bothered to read that stuff??

jwm
 
danmand,

That's not the issue.

Sure, 99% of readers will see through Cinelli. (Actually, here, it's probably less than that). But the issue runs deeper than that.

Free speech is a right. But with every right comes a corresponding duty - in this case the duty to not abuse that right. Cinelli is violating this duty.

Just because you have a right to free speech, it doesn't imply you have a right to hurl racial epithets at someone on the street. It's no limit on your free speech right that you aren't allowed to do so.

Just because you have a right to free speech, it doesn't follow that you have a right to start lecturing loudly in a movie theatre while the movie is playing. Again, this is not a limit on your free speech right.

Just because you have a right to free speech, it doesn't follow you can deliberately attempt to mislead people, libel, or slander.

You're in your favourite restaurant and the guy at the table next to you starts acting up - rude, obnoxious, loud, insulting. You aren't required to put up with it.

More to the point, you can well imagine that the restaurant that tolerated such loutish behaviour. You go back to the restaurant and it happens again. How many times would you go back if it keeps happening? At some point it will turn you off the place.

The same thing happens and has happened here. I don't want to hang out in a place where cinelli hangs out. Forget the free speech issue. Being in a place with him is seriously uncool. Now if there were many of me, and people started leaving, the owners of the place would do something.
 
TQM said:
That's not the issue.

Sure, 99% of readers will see through Cinelli. (Actually, here, it's probably less than that). But the issue runs deeper than that.

Free speech is a right. But with every right comes a corresponding duty - in this case the duty to not abuse that right. Cinelli is violating this duty.

Just because you have a right to free speech, it doesn't imply you have a right to hurl racial epithets at someone on the street. It's no limit on your free speech right that you aren't allowed to do so.

Just because you have a right to free speech, it doesn't follow that you have a right to start lecturing loudly in a movie theatre while the movie is playing. Again, this is not a limit on your free speech right.

Just because you have a right to free speech, it doesn't follow you can deliberately attempt to mislead people, libel, or slander.

You're in your favourite restaurant and the guy at the table next to you starts acting up - rude, obnoxious, loud, insulting. You aren't required to put up with it.

More to the point, you can well imagine that the restaurant that tolerated such loutish behaviour. You go back to the restaurant and it happens again. How many times would you go back if it keeps happening? At some point it will turn you off the place.

The same thing happens and has happened here. I don't want to hang out in a place where cinelli hangs out. Forget the free speech issue. Being in a place with him is seriously uncool. Now if there were many of me, and people started leaving, the owners of the place would do something.

Weren't you yanked off your soapbox once before when trying to pursue this?
 
Asterix,

No. But do you seriously think that would stop me? I mean - you and I have had our differences, but do you think seriously, I'd back down from a position that I sincerely believed? Do you think I'd let it be swept under the carpet - that I'd prefer to be a 'club member"? Me?
 
I'd love to see him gone,

but if that's not possible, I'd rather have him wasting his time trying to convince us sex perverts of his political perversions than out in the real world doing damage.

Actually I am really reluctant to hate someone for their honestly-held opinions but I don't believe that his are honestly-held. And I am genuinely, personally offended by the hate for my people that he promotes.

I'm surprised that he hasn't been banned already but I guess those who run the board are aware of what constitues hate speech in Canada.

Sure, I'd rather he was slowly roasted and then lightly battered, but whatEVER...
 
This is exactly what I do. Any time I see a posting by him, I pass it by. Just ignore the pest and he'll go away.

jwmorrice said:
I stopped looking at his stuff a long time ago. Just not interesting enough. My eyes would glaze over. In that respect, and that respect only, rather like the 'this day during the Clinton presidency' or the punning threads. Who can be bothered to read that stuff??

jwm
 
Dq,

Really, you have no business having an opinion.

First, I didn't equivocate Cinelli's rants with shouting fire in a movie theatre.

I pointed out that shouting fire in a movie theatre wasn't an example of free speech. I pointed out that loutish loudness in a restaurant isn't an example of free speech. I pointed out that slander and libel aren't examples of free speech.

Speaking freely isn't what free speech is about. Promoting hate isn't an example of free speech either. That's why Canada has both laws giving citizens the right to free speech as well as laws against promoting hate.

Cinelli is a promoter of hate.
 
TQM said:
No. But do you seriously think that would stop me? I mean - you and I have had our differences, but do you think seriously, I'd back down from a position that I sincerely believed? Do you think I'd let it be swept under the carpet - that I'd prefer to be a 'club member"? Me?

No, but I remember you were booted before when trying to question the approach of the board's owners, which you seem to be flirting with again. Some people are slow learners I suppose.
 
We Northerners do a pretty good job on hate I think. I spent a fair bit of time learning about it in school (law school, actually, where we read the OWHolmes decision as well as our own courts' decisions on the limits of freedom of speech. It's a balance to be sure.

Of course free speech protects speech you don't like, but still there can be reasonable limits, and we have laws and precedent which delineates those limits. Personally I think Cinelli falls on the wrong side of those limits, but this ain't my board.

DQ: I don't see how you can call Cinelli's posts "one man's reasoned speech", and fail to see the potential danger in letting what clearly is not reasoned at all but false news intended to promote hate against an identifiable group be disseminated. If enough people see the venom as reasoned speech available as a choice in the marketplace of ideas, it doesn't make it less hateful, it makes it dangerous to everyone.
 
d-dude,

DQ, being obtuse. He is hard-wired into thinking anything I write is wrong - to the point where he misinterprets me to a sometimes breathtaking extent.

He's so confused in his ideas that there isn't much point in counter-argument.
 
DATYdude said:
Of course free speech protects speech you don't like, but still there can be reasonable limits, and we have laws and precedent which delineates those limits. Personally I think Cinelli falls on the wrong side of those limits, but this ain't my board.

Please cite an example. I've never seen Cinelli cross the line with unacceptable speech.
 
again, no Asterix....

and I'm not the one who started this thread. But I'm willing to answer it honestly and fully.

If that bothers you, or anyone, why would I care?

Do you really think this is an issue of being a slow learner? Of course you don't. I take pride in my honesty and I'd encourage you to give it some consideration.

And if you're going to engage in insults, you could learn some lessons here as well. If you're going to attempt to insult someone, have a point. Your appearances in this thread are pathetic. (And there's an example of an insult, but having a point.)
 
Dq,

I do ignore you! Do you actually have that much of an ego to think that I read you? You're an imbecile, who thought Stalin was a good guy and who thinks its okay to badger somebody about their ethnicity or religion. (Don't think I've forgotten, little one).

Yes - I absolutely ignore you........ except............. except........... except when you don't ignore me. Check it out, little one. You responded to me here (as usual). Etiquette requires I respond back. Most of the time, I respond by pointing out you're an imbecile. Once in a blue moon you say something tolerable in a response and on such occasions I ignore you ther too. Now if you actually managed something bright.......... (I know wishful thinking, eh? But then again if you take an infinite number of monkeys and an infinite number of typewriters......)
 
TQM said:
and I'm not the one who started this thread. But I'm willing to answer it honestly and fully.

If that bothers you, or anyone, why would I care?

Do you really think this is an issue of being a slow learner? Of course you don't. I take pride in my honesty and I'd encourage you to give it some consideration.

And if you're going to engage in insults, you could learn some lessons here as well. If you're going to attempt to insult someone, have a point. Your appearances in this thread are pathetic. (And there's an example of an insult, but having a point.)

God, you're even crankier then usual. I'm guessing that porn star experience thing didn't work out. Look, I was merely trying to point out that discussions of free speech on this board are pointless. The owners do as they see fit. This isn't the real world, or maybe you've forgotten.
 
Last edited:
so what's offensive about cinelli?

Well, his anti-semitism is certainly a fine starting point. Just look at a list of his posts. His singular focus on Jews controlling this and that and how evil Israel is an how 9/11 is a hoax involving Jews should have you concerned.

You can start, though, with some of his links:

In this post https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?p=2046215#post2046215

he links to a known anti-semitic site (check it out for yourself): iamthewitness.com.

In this post https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=185487&page=2

he links to the website of the well known ku klux klan leader David Duke.

www.davidduke.com

Here`s another post where he provides a link to an obvious hateful site:

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?p=2040972#post2040972

http://www.gnosticliberationfront.com/zionist crimes history.htm

This post by cinelli offers us another great link:

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?p=2040926#post2040926

- give us a link to this splendid site:

http://theuglytruth.wordpress.com/

All this in about a couple of weeks of posts. If you dig far enough you will find links to just about every well known documented anti-semitic site there is.

One doesn`t have to make the case for cinelli as a hatemonger. He makes it quite well himself.
 
Asterix do you really

that dense?

believe what you write?

"Look, I was merely trying to point out that discussions of free speech on this board are pointless."

That's a lie.

You've thought I should be reminded about how I've been banned. That's what you were trying to do, and not point out the alleged pointlessness of free speech discussions. You were trying to make digs at me. That's why you suggested I'm a "slow learner."

Saying I'm a slow learner is saying I need to learn something here - that I should learn to back off this topic. Can't you understand that I'm proud of the fact that I won't back down on issues I care about? Even if you entirely disagree with me, can't you respect the depth of my conviction?


You entered the thread hoping to take a cheap pot shot at me. You've certainly done this before. And like most threads you fail to put something forward on the issue being discussed.

I don't really care if the ownership is listening to me or not. I don't care if they ban me or not. This is a political discussion forum and I'm discussing a subject I didn't start, but care about.

Give me a reason, for once, why I shouldn't equate you with dirt under my fingernail. Try, for once, to say something substantive about an issue. I'm sure you've got it in you.
 
Dq,

when you ignore me, you'll find I've ignored you. Can't be more clear than that.