Ban Cinelli Yes or No

assoholic said:
I doubt very much he denied the Holocaust,
Read his post then. I don't think there is any equivocation on his part.

By calling him a Holocaust denier you imply he is an anti-semite.
Or did you think you were such a clever fella,
that we did not even realize what you are doing.

Not at all though there are many holocaust deniers that are anti-semitic though it is only your opinion on what you think I think about what Lancs thinks that offends you. For the record, I mostly think of Lancs as a shit disturber and someone upset at any country that no longer accept the 'wisdom' of British rule.




And I'm still waiting for you to show me where I said he was inciting racial hatred and where I said he should be banned.
 
basketcase said:
"And I'm still waiting for you to show me where I said he was inciting racial hatred and where I said he should be banned.
"

..let me guess this tactic is to throw out a
nonsensical statement to change the subject.
I never said any such thing.
You think you're clever, you are not.
You seem to care about one thing and one thing only.
 
Talk about attempts to change the topic.

You have accused me of saying cinelli was inciting hatred, that he shuld be banned and accusing everyone who criticizes Israel anti-semitic yet the best you can do is infer what I think and you refuse to back up these claims.
 
basketcase said:
Talk about attempts to change the topic.

You have accused me of saying cinelli was inciting hatred, that he shuld be banned and accusing everyone who criticizes Israel anti-semitic yet the best you can do is infer what I think and you refuse to back up these claims.

.I called whoever called for him to be banned a
dickwad who after 47 posts, should have known better
then to think he could make that decision.
What you are babbling about I have no idea.
And do not care.
 
Ban Cinelli?

Sure, but only if you're willing to ban all the fools that attempt to reason with him. I have a hard time determining which is more pathetic; Cinelli's posts or the posts of those who respond to him.

Personally, I find it easy to ignore him so a ban isn't necessary.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Ban Cinelli?

Sure, but only if you're willing to ban all the fools that attempt to reason with him. I have a hard time determining which is more pathetic; Cinelli's posts or the posts of those who respond to him.

Personally, I find it easy to ignore him so a ban isn't necessary.

Count me in too. I don't really see what all the fuss is about him. He strikes me more as some kind of spam my computer hasn't quite got the hang of deleting outright.
 
basketcase said:
Lancs a Holocaust denier? Who would have thought?

In his own words,




You say that like its a bad thing.


The numbers just don't add up. Granted the germans were a terribly efficient lot but work out the math. take the silly inflated number that you lot love to shout out and divide by the number of years they were hypothetically doing what you claim.. Thats one hell of a throughput even at 24 hrs/day 365 days/year considering that there was a lot of other stuff going on as well that the germans had to contend with. The bigger the number, the bigger the lie, the more absurd it becomes.

The attempt to brand me as a "denier" just won't work as I couldn't care less . Try the guilt trip on someone more maleable.
 
LancsLad said:
You say that like its a bad thing.


The numbers just don't add up. Granted the germans were a terribly efficient lot but work out the math. take the silly inflated number that you lot love to shout out and divide by the number of years they were hypothetically doing what you claim.. Thats one hell of a throughput even at 24 hrs/day 365 days/year considering that there was a lot of other stuff going on as well that the germans had to contend with. The bigger the number, the bigger the lie, the more absurd it becomes.
I had no idea you were so talented in estimating the numbers killed. Given that the number of 6 million Jews killed has been correlated by many sources over the intervening years, what exactly are you coming up with?
 
Well as one of "lookingforitallthetime's" pathetic reasoners, I guess I should wade in.

1) banning is the Mod's and Fred's call, it's their sandbox.

2) Cenelli is clearly one of, if not the most delusional people I can
remember posting here on TERB.

3) Cenellia is unable to conduct a reasoned argument.

4) Cenelli clearly crosses the line between being against the policies of the
Israeli Government and being anti-Semitic.


4.5) This is utterly pointless.
 
Asterix said:
Given that the number of 6 million Jews killed has been correlated by many sources over the intervening years
As for myself there is no doubt about the six million Jews who were murded. What I find far more troubling is the popular historical amnesia over the four million others: Slavs (principally Poles), Romani, homosexuals, Aristocrats (non-German) etc. . . who were likewise systematically murdered by the Nazis and have almost entirely been forgotten.
 
Asterix said:
I had no idea you were so talented in estimating the numbers killed. Given that the number of 6 million Jews killed has been correlated by many sources over the intervening years, what exactly are you coming up with?


Take the inflated estimate of 6 million.

The so called campaign was alleged to have been conducted from early'42 to May '45, so say 40 months.

Thats 150,000 per month. With no down time factor for repairs/maintenance equipment replacement they would need to handle over 200 cases/hr, 24 hrs /day/ non stop. thats a very large amount of resources and logistical manpower to have been allegedly diverted from a two front war.

And don't forget there were lots of others that the germans handled as well, when you factor in a few million for Polish Catholics and other groups they frowned on the numbers become unwieldy, even for the terribly organized germans.

Thats the point I was trying to make.
 
Aardvark154 said:
As for myself there is no doubt about the six million Jews who were murded. What I find far more troubling is the popular historical amnesia over the four million others: Slavs (principally Poles), Romani, homosexuals, Aristocrats (non-German) etc. . . who were likewise systematically murdered by the Nazis and have almost entirely been forgotten.

Not to mention the number of Ukranian, Baltic, and Russian people who were killed by the Nazis. Now explain to me what the hell Lancs is trying to sell.
 
LancsLad said:
Take the inflated estimate of 6 million.

The so called campaign was alleged to have been conducted from early'42 to May '45, so say 40 months.

Thats 150,000 per month. With no down time factor for repairs/maintenance equipment replacement they would need to handle over 200 cases/hr, 24 hrs /day/ non stop. thats a very large amount of resources and logistical manpower to have been allegedly diverted from a two front war.

And don't forget there were lots of others that the germans handled as well, when you factor in a few million for Polish Catholics and other groups they frowned on the numbers become unwieldy, even for the terribly organized germans.

Thats the point I was trying to make.

You are completely clueless, have the mindset of a junior college accountant, and have clearly read nothing of what happened. Beyond sad.
 
Asterix said:
You are completely clueless, have the mindset of a junior college accountant, and have clearly read nothing of what happened. Beyond sad.



Oh really, do tell sage and wise one.

Just be careful as TQM will be critiquing all responses.
 
Asterix said:
Not to mention the number of Ukranian, Baltic, and Russian people who were killed by the Nazis. Now explain to me what the hell Lancs is trying to sell.
The Ukrainians and Russians are Slavs and included in that catagory, I did, however, forget to mention the Balts.
 
LancsLad said:
Oh really, do tell sage and wise one.

It doesn't take someone sage and wise to acknowledge documented history. Evidently there are still asses who refuse to recognize it.
 
Asterix said:
It doesn't take someone sage and wise to acknowledge documented history. Evidently there are still asses who refuse to recognize it.




Work the numbers, not even jerry is that thorough.


.
 
Lancs I like you and generally agree with you, but in this case you remind me of the SAS Officer who was captured in a raid on occupied France and was being worked over and was well on his way to being killed by a group of Wehrmacht Heer soldiers when a SS Officer came in placed the soldiers under arrest for abusing a Officer POW, took the SAS Officer into his custody and had him escorted by his orderly to a POW camp.

When the war ended said SAS Officer had to be personally taken to a death camp before he would believe that the SS which had saved his life was the same organization which had systematically murdered millions of people.



Not entirely on point I know. . .
 
Are you guys still on this banning thing:D
p.s. how do you like my new sign?
 
Aardvark154 said:
Lancs I like you and generally agree with you, but in this case you remind me of the SAS Officer who was captured in a raid on occupied France and was being worked over and was well on his way to being killed by a group of Wehrmacht Heer soldiers when a SS Officer came in placed the soldiers under arrest for abusing a Officer POW, took the SAS Officer into his custody and had him escorted by his orderly to a POW camp.

When the war ended said SAS Officer had to be personally taken to a death camp before he would believe that the SS which had saved his life was the same organization which had systematically murdered millions of people.



Not entirely on point I know. . .



I'm not saying that there were not many people killed. My point has always been the vastly inflated numbers as claimed by a certain group, as their perpetual guilt source over society, yet the dreadful lack of discussion over the millions of others that were killed by the germans. Seems that those with the best media contacts can work the info dissemination better than the others.

I'm trying to suggest that people think about the numbers for themselves and realize that the impact went far beyond that one vocal group.