Ban Cinelli Yes or No

He's a hate mongerer who IMO is no different than Ernst Zundel. He got booted out of the country for similar rhetoric to Cinelli's. Canada did not ignore Zundel and neither should TERB ignore Cinelli.
 
if you are gonna ban him then you might as well take Cinema Face along with him, pretty much two sides of the same coin, and no I dont think either should be banned but given a warning to tone down the crap they both spew at first.
 
TQM said:
that dense?

believe what you write?

"Look, I was merely trying to point out that discussions of free speech on this board are pointless."

That's a lie.

You've thought I should be reminded about how I've been banned. That's what you were trying to do, and not point out the alleged pointlessness of free speech discussions. You were trying to make digs at me. That's why you suggested I'm a "slow learner."

Saying I'm a slow learner is saying I need to learn something here - that I should learn to back off this topic. Can't you understand that I'm proud of the fact that I won't back down on issues I care about? Even if you entirely disagree with me, can't you respect the depth of my conviction?


You entered the thread hoping to take a cheap pot shot at me. You've certainly done this before. And like most threads you fail to put something forward on the issue being discussed.

I don't really care if the ownership is listening to me or not. I don't care if they ban me or not. This is a political discussion forum and I'm discussing a subject I didn't start, but care about.

Give me a reason, for once, why I shouldn't equate you with dirt under my fingernail. Try, for once, to say something substantive about an issue. I'm sure you've got it in you.

Control yourself man, or you'll spurt. Was I making fun of you? Yes, hard not to actually. Was I reminding you of when you were banned? Yes, thought that was obvious. Was I also pointing out that the reason you were banned is that you somehow confused free speech on this board with real life, and challenged the owners on how they should conduct their business? Yes to that also. You really do take yourself too seriously you know.
 
I don't believe the members of this board have banning rights.

Let the moderators do their job. They know the rules.
 
zaig said:
I have always been a big believer in free speech, but Cinelli's postings go way past that concept. Aside from being a huge anti-semite, conspiracy spreading idiot, who does not have an ounce of logic in his twisted brain, the hate and venom he spreads is really quite counter productive. At first I actually found his ranting a bit entertaining, in a wierd sort of way, but now its just plain stupid. Could you imagine what he must be like in real life, very sad.
Of course, if he is banned, he will then spread his hate and venom elsewhere and state that he was banned by the World Zionist conspiracy. Which reminds me, I think there is a meeting on Thursday.
So with this in mind, I have 2 suggestions.
1. Ban Cinelli OR
2. Whatever thread he either starts or contributes to, totally disreguard, as if he is being censored or shunned.

Talk amongst yourselves.

.after 42 posts who gives a fuck what you think?
 
The guy is a total jerk. This is supposed to be an SP review board. When was the last time he posted a review? He probably can't get it up and like Hitler only as one ball .. or maybe none :)).
 
the concept of free speech only works if it's free for all...especially for those that take positions that are outside the norm.
 
some people here are very testy. Assoholic, I wasn't aware of the fact that to start a thread you need a minimum of required posts. I think you belong with Cinelli. Oh, and by the way, who gives 2 cents what you think.
 
..number of posts equates to time spent here, after 42 posts you are no one.
I think the only people who should be banned are the people calling for other people to be banned.
Don't like it , put on your lipstick and high heels and leave.
 
TQM said:
Really, you have no business having an opinion.

First, I didn't equivocate Cinelli's rants with shouting fire in a movie theatre.

I pointed out that shouting fire in a movie theatre wasn't an example of free speech. I pointed out that loutish loudness in a restaurant isn't an example of free speech. I pointed out that slander and libel aren't examples of free speech.

Speaking freely isn't what free speech is about. Promoting hate isn't an example of free speech either. That's why Canada has both laws giving citizens the right to free speech as well as laws against promoting hate.

Cinelli is a promoter of hate.

If you want to ban anyone for...slander and libel against a group of people why aren’t you going after CF? :rolleyes:


Cinema Face actually makes speech but all Cinelli does ... post articles and links from other sources!
p.s. Actually recently Cinelli has been posting some interesting articles... IMO
 
persis said:
Cinema Face actually makes speech but all Cinelli does ... is posting articles and links from other sources!

Do you have some sort of mental handicap? There are a lot of things you don't seem to understand.
 
cypherpunk said:
Do you have some sort of mental handicap? There are a lot of things you don't seem to understand.
I see you are talking about yourself again puck!
 
I find it interesting that whenever someone posts anything that is even remotely anti Jewish, it is immediately labelled anti-Semitic. Why are discussions involving Jews-Israel off-limits? Those who want to ban Cinelli are concerned that his posts have merit and might possibly influence the thoughts of others. We will read Cinelli's posts and make up our own minds.
 
How about we all chip in and buy him a one way plane ticket to Iran :p lol
 
S.C. Joe said:
How about we all chip in and buy him a one way plane ticket to Iran :p lol

be more fun to turn him in for belonging to an escort reveiw board
 
dev0 first,

"whenever someone posts anything that even remotely anti Jewish, it is immediately labelled anti-Semitic."

Tell me, little one, you didn't actually say that. Do you know what the term 'anti-semitic' means?

That was precious.

persis second,

I haven't looked at cinema face's stuff. But if you can provide some links where he cites the Ku Klux Klan as authoritative evidence for something I'll be glad to have the opinion he should be banned too.

The fact is, I don't read most of you. But if I come across something as offensive, I'm not afraid to let you know. And if you are repeatedly offensive, I'll be of the opinion that you should be banned.

That doesn't mean the ownership here will agree with me. But true freedom of expression is to allow me to make my case.

third, Asterix,

So we come to the mutal agreement that you weren't here to caution about the uselessness of discussions about free speech. That's a starting point, littlest.

Now we need to straighten out the facts. I wasn't banned because I challenged the ownership or moderators to accept my views as to who to be banned. I did not "challenge" the ownership or moderators to do anything.

Nor have I ever, ever, ever confused free speech on this board with "real life." I'm the one who has consistently pointed out that this is privately owned, and not a public space. It has been your constant tactic to get seriously confused over the basics.

You think I take myself too seriously. I think your flaw is that you don't take yourself seriously enough, child.

You envision that I'm popping with anger. You think you've succeeded in getting under my skin. My behaviour you think confirms everything you've thought about me.

Really, there's nothing I can say that would change your mind about this. But rest assured, littlest, you are nothing more than half a coffee break for me. Nothing more than an attempt to practice writing. You're essentially target practice. And this is simply because really, you rarely have anything to say of any substance on any issue. Your only use then can be to be for verbal target practice.

That's a shame, littlest. You're capable of being better than you want to be. So shoo - go back to arguing abortion with papasmerf. I'm sure that's a much more useless activity and useless posting is your modus operandi.
 
addendum

for Asterix.

At the end of April, if I remain unbanned, you'll be able to read some reviews. I leave for Vegas in a couple of weeks.

I won't review anyone if they don't want to be reviewed, so I can't promise particular names yet. So terribly glad to see you're reading me.
 
JohnFK said:
Agreed. Other people can tell him (Cinelli) to F.O. or ignore him once they read his rubbish.

I hate censorship.

Why can't I buy Mein Kampf (and judge for myself) from Indigo?

Censorship. Somebody deciding for me.

And I love Jews, believe in the Holocaust and hate fascism and nazism.

p.s. You can download MK but I really don't care for it.
I believe that it is available at the library.