Bad Job References

The question becomes, would you hire an unknown with no references ? This board is based on references.

Everyone here are private, anonymous individuals. The chance of a law suit are slim. Even if the person is know, I am not sure if an individual can be sued for a review that might be deemed as false.
 
Employment lawyers must love cases like this. Both the company and prospective employee could burn up tons of hours arguing their case.
 
Why is it not fair for a reference to give an honest accounting of the employee's performance?

I believe the logic is that the company might be held liable if one of their employees gives a reference (positive or negative) to a former employee. The thing is how would an employer know who is giving references unless they are monitoring everything: e-mails, phone, LinkedIn, etc.?
 
A lot of bad information being presented in this thread. I'm a little surprised (but not a lot) that so many people are completely clueless as to the way it actually works.

Credit and police checks are different than reference checks (or to be precise, they're a very specific form of reference check). These kinds of checks are usually done for specific kinds of jobs. For example, if you're handling or have access to money or in a position where your lack of cash could lead you to do unscrupulous things against your employer. Police checks are definitely required in some cases (e.g., working with kids) but not everyone does them.

Generic reference checks are usually either character references or verifying what you put on your resume. If you say you worked at X or went to school at Y, it's totally fair game for your prospective employer to verify that. And if you lie anywhere on your resume, it can be grounds for termination with cause at any point when your employer finds out (the bigger the lie, the greater the chances you'll get nuked). This is a great way for an employer who wants to get rid of you to do so; they just go back and scrutinize your resume to see if there's anything there they can nail you on for lying.

Character references are usually provided by the candidate but an employer can always cold call one of your previous employers. Usually they'd only do this if they were suspicious about something but it all depends on the employer and how thorough they are in their reference checks.

Most employers (at least the sophisticated/professional ones) won't give a "bad" reference check per se. Instead, they will be cagey in their answers to avoid legal ramifications so you have to read between the lines. But to get around that all you have to do is ask the magic million dollar question: "Would you hire this person again?" Any answer but an unqualified "Yes" is a red flag.

There are a lot of stupid people out there. Quitting a job on bad terms can and will come back to haunt you. So will lying on your resume. HR departments aren't stupid. They see resumes all the time and for an HR professional who has done hiring it literally takes seconds to spot red flags on a resume. Most of the time they just pitch such a resume and move on to the next one. It's not worth the time and effort to verify whether there's really a problem or not. That's why potential employees need to be forthcoming and not burn bridges when they leave previous jobs, however satisfying it might be to walk out in a blaze of glory.

Now you know.

Being cagey with a persons financial future can be a mistake especially if that person had no written reprimands while he worked for you.My brother worked for a company in a accounting position for 13 years.He decided to leave and work for more pay and better advancement.HR at his previous company tried the smug thing you suggested"No, we wouldn't hire him again"(he pissed the VP off because he was basically their go to guy, but they respected neither his time or his salary compensation) and got sued civilly for it.It took almost 2 years but he won the case.Basically, if you have a long term employee, and you don't have an established written history of reprimands you simply can't tell anyone who calls that they are not competent enough to work at your company.There needs to be a basis for that kind of judgement especially when financial compensation is involved.
 
I'm surprised that your friend did not follow the basics when it comes to providing references. The first thing he needs to do is to call those who he plans to use as his reference and tell them about the position he is applying for, the critical skills that they are looking for, and whether he can use this person/company as a reference. No business or person should be used as a reference if they have not been notified in advance. It's just good networking.

When he calls such a person, he can indicate the nature of the job and it's requirements so that the reference can offer their comments within the context of the future position. If they were pleased with his performance, they may choose to build on those points. If they are not comfortable in being asked, your friend would likely pick up on this and decide not to use them. I once called a reference regarding a prospective hire, and the reference said, "I can't believe he used me for a reference". Needless to say, it did not go well.

I'm also surprised to see that more than one of these references appeared to provide a negative response. Typically, people will just say that the former employee "is not eligible for hire", which is code for saying that the guy was not suitable and they don't want to say anything negative that could lead to legal challenges. It sounds like your friend has a few challenges ahead of him.
 
I believe the logic is that the company might be held liable if one of their employees gives a reference (positive or negative) to a former employee.

Why should they be? An employee's opinion on a fellow, former employee is no responsibility of the company's. And even if it were, an opinion isn't an issue of true or false. If the reference is making up incidents that did not occur, that's another issue, but that'd still be on the employee and not the company.
 
Why is it not fair for a reference to give an honest accounting of the employee's performance?

Because you're only getting one side of the story.

I have a friend who was turfed from a very high paying corporate job. He had won numerous awards, car, bonuses, free trips, his employees LOVED him. He's a very personable guy.

Anyway, he got fired / let go / packaged out, call it what you want because his new boss hated his guts. (Probably because he saw him as a threat.) The new boss played politics and did what it took to get my friend fired. End of story.

In massive corporation where he worked, it's not like at a smaller company where you're working with the owner. In massive corporation, you're just a number and the wheels won't stop turning because you're shown the door.

So getting back to your point, there is not always an "honest accounting" of someone's personality. There are 3 sides to every story, his, hers, and the truth.
 
Usually in my field, they don't want or care about previous employer references, they want to see Client References.

If a guy has a good reference from 3 clients, odds are, he's a keeper.
 
Because you're only getting one side of the story.

I have a friend who was turfed from a very high paying corporate job. He had won numerous awards, car, bonuses, free trips, his employees LOVED him. He's a very personable guy.

Anyway, he got fired / let go / packaged out, call it what you want because his new boss hated his guts. (Probably because he saw him as a threat.) The new boss played politics and did what it took to get my friend fired. End of story.

In massive corporation where he worked, it's not like at a smaller company where you're working with the owner. In massive corporation, you're just a number and the wheels won't stop turning because you're shown the door.

So getting back to your point, there is not always an "honest accounting" of someone's personality. There are 3 sides to every story, his, hers, and the truth.

james, out of curiosity, was your friend able to land a new job of similar pay/benefits, utilizing his skills?
 
Because you're only getting one side of the story.

I have a friend who was turfed from a very high paying corporate job. He had won numerous awards, car, bonuses, free trips, his employees LOVED him. He's a very personable guy.

Anyway, he got fired / let go / packaged out, call it what you want because his new boss hated his guts. (Probably because he saw him as a threat.) The new boss played politics and did what it took to get my friend fired. End of story.

In massive corporation where he worked, it's not like at a smaller company where you're working with the owner. In massive corporation, you're just a number and the wheels won't stop turning because you're shown the door.

So getting back to your point, there is not always an "honest accounting" of someone's personality. There are 3 sides to every story, his, hers, and the truth.

New question: why would you put down your boss who hated your guts as a reference?
 
Anyway, he got fired / let go / packaged out, call it what you want because his new boss hated his guts. (Probably because he saw him as a threat.)
Your friend must have gotten a huge severance package. Large corporations don't want lawsuits and usually pay out much more than what the law requires.
 
Why should they be? An employee's opinion on a fellow, former employee is no responsibility of the company's. And even if it were, an opinion isn't an issue of true or false. If the reference is making up incidents that did not occur, that's another issue, but that'd still be on the employee and not the company.

As long as there is a small chance of getting sued a company won't risk it. Actually spoke with a friend of a friend who is a legal counsel for a fairly large company and that's part of the reason they have a policy forbidding employees to give out references.
 
Why should they be? An employee's opinion on a fellow, former employee is no responsibility of the company's. ...

I believe that there have been lawsuits in the states where it was claimed that unfair/untrue negative references were given and the company was found liable.

I have received a couple reference letters that were one sentence long. "Mr. Blabla work in the position of *** from the date of ### to the date of ###"

Technically it's not a negative reference but it sends the appropriate message. I have yet to see something along those lines for a good reference.
 
Because you're only getting one side of the story.

I have a friend who was turfed from a very high paying corporate job. He had won numerous awards, car, bonuses, free trips, his employees LOVED him. He's a very personable guy.

Anyway, he got fired / let go / packaged out, call it what you want because his new boss hated his guts. (Probably because he saw him as a threat.) The new boss played politics and did what it took to get my friend fired. End of story.

In massive corporation where he worked, it's not like at a smaller company where you're working with the owner. In massive corporation, you're just a number and the wheels won't stop turning because you're shown the door.

There are alot of people who think they matter
Fact is most jobs could be handled by a trained monkey
People with lists of degrees & awards often think way too highly of themselves

It's funny how you big him up for things like awards & popularity (both of which are total politics) then take an abrupt left and claim he was only fired because his manager "probably" was afraid of him
 
james, out of curiosity, was your friend able to land a new job of similar pay/benefits, utilizing his skills?

No, but he was only terminated in the last couple of months.

He's very good at what he does, but it's never easy to land a comparable job sometimes.
 
Your friend must have gotten a huge severance package. Large corporations don't want lawsuits and usually pay out much more than what the law requires.

19 years working for massive corporation.

1 month salary for every year of employment.

Not bad, but nothing to write home about in my opinion.