Because you're only getting one side of the story.
I have a friend who was turfed from a very high paying corporate job. He had won numerous awards, car, bonuses, free trips, his employees LOVED him. He's a very personable guy.
Anyway, he got fired / let go / packaged out, call it what you want because his new boss hated his guts. (Probably because he saw him as a threat.) The new boss played politics and did what it took to get my friend fired. End of story.
In massive corporation where he worked, it's not like at a smaller company where you're working with the owner. In massive corporation, you're just a number and the wheels won't stop turning because you're shown the door.
So getting back to your point, there is not always an "honest accounting" of someone's personality. There are 3 sides to every story, his, hers, and the truth.