Auston Matthews For MVP?

As usual, you are twisting things out of context.

"somebody posted a link regarding the death of former NHL'er Danny Grant and people were posting testimonials and condolences etc. Somehow Darts thought it was appropriate to post some trivia questions including "How did Steve Shutt become a member of the Canadiens"?"

We (maybe not you) were talking about Danny Grant playing junior with the Petes and I asked if Steve Shutt was on the same team. Another member answered he wasn't.

"and continues to do the same to this day. He had one today, talking about awarding points in hockey games and he is wondering how often the team that wins the coin flip in the NFL ends up winning the game."

We we talking about how other sports like basketball and football handle overtime so I mentioned how the NFL does it.
 
Anyway, care to say something about Auston Matthews for Hart?

Steph Curry of the Golden Gate Warriors is a solid M.V.P. candidate most years.
 
were talking about Danny Grant playing junior with the Petes and I asked if Steve Shutt was on the same team. Another member answered he wasn't.
So because they weren't on the same team makes a question about Shutt relevant? Just bizarre.

Once again, this is comparable to someone mentioning ice hockey and you determine that is appropriate to talk about the polar ice caps because he used the word ice.

Plus you just admitted that you brought Shutt into the discussion in the 1st place and then used that as justification for your trivia. Should we post the roster of the Petes so you could pick other irrelevant names to ask more trivia.

Does any of this make sense to you or is it all over your head?
 
So because they weren't on the same team makes a question about Shutt relevant? Just bizarre.

Since this is bothering you so much, why don't you dig the thread from the archives? We were talking about Grant's line mates when he was with the Petes so I ask if Shutt was one of them. What is so bizarre about that? Nobody else on that thread thought it was bizarre.

Question: Why are you bringing up ice caps?
"Once again, this is comparable to someone mentioning ice hockey and you determine that is appropriate to talk about the polar ice caps because he used the word ice."
 
At this moment I think Jack Campbell is the Leafs MVP, and I'm not being sarcastic.

Maybe you're right. However, the Sabres did outshoot the Leafs 36-22 to-night so it's a team loss.
 
Since this is bothering you so much, why don't you dig the thread from the archives? We were talking about Grant's line mates when he was with the Petes so I ask if Shutt was one of them. What is so bizarre about that? Nobody else on that thread thought it was bizarre.

I agree. But then asking trivia about a player completely unrelated to Danny Grant in his testimonial thread was completely inappropriate. You have failed to acknowledge that.
 
I agree. But then asking trivia about a player completely unrelated to Danny Grant in his testimonial thread was completely inappropriate.
Go ahead and pull the thread from the archives and show me where I disrespected Danny Grant's memory by asking who were his linemates when he was with the Petes. We need to settle this now so you don't keep bringing it up for the next 100 years.
 
Go ahead and pull the thread from the archives and show me where I disrespected Danny Grant's memory by asking who were his linemates when he was with the Petes. We need to settle this now so you don't keep bringing it up for the next 100 years.

Don't need the archive. After you found out he wasn't a linemate you still felt it necessary to later ask a trivia question about how Shutt became a member of the Habs. Acknowledge that that was inappropriate. It was established that any discussion of Shutt detracted from a thread honouring Grant.
 
I think it would be great if Matthews won the Hart (and maybe the Rocket as well). Last Leaf to win was Ted Kennedy 65 years ago.

"Hart Memorial Trophy Most valuable player to his team during the regular season Babe Pratt 1943–44 [15][16]
Ted Kennedy 1954–55"
 
Hey Shack, since you brought up Danny Grant is it ok to say that his linemates with the Peterborough Petes were Andre Lacroix and Mickey Redmond? That's the answer and it is not meant as a trivia question at all.
 
Hey Shack, since you brought up Danny Grant is it ok to say that his linemates with the Peterborough Petes were Andre Lacroix and Mickey Redmond? That's the answer and it is not meant as a trivia question at all.

1)I only mentioned Danny Grant as a reference to your posting history discussion.
2)I have not idea what purpose it would serve.
3)It is your threadabout Matthews and the Hart, so feel free to derail it as much as you like. I guess you've lost interest.
 
)It is your thread about Matthews and the Hart, so feel free to derail it as much as you like.
IMHO I think Matthews is the most valuable Leaf and should be a serious candidate for the Hart, especially if the Leafs make the playoffs. I think a while back one or more members said Andersen is the most valuable Leaf.

I know some members have said that Nylander and Marner are overrated, so I thought it's only fair to say that Matthews is definitely earning his salary albeit much more than what an RFA would normally get.
 
I'll cut them a little slack as this was their 3rd game in 4 nights.

Yes, 3 games in 4 nights is rough but if the Leafs make the playoffs 3 games in 4 nights (or 5 nights if one counts the first night) is common and against better teams than Buffalo and Ottawa.

Boston Bruins (A2) vs. Toronto Maple Leafs (A3)

Thursday, April 11, 7 p.m.: Maple Leafs @ Bruins | NBCSN, SN, CBC, TVA Sports

Saturday, April 13, 8 p.m.: Maple Leafs @ Bruins | NBC, CBC, TVA Sports

Monday, April 15, 7 p.m.: Bruins @ Maple Leafs | CBC, TVA Sports, NBCSN

Wednesday, April 17, 7 p.m.: Bruins @ Maple Leafs | CBC, TVA Sports, NBCSN

Friday, April 19, 7 p.m.: Maple Leafs @ Bruins | NBCSN, CBC, TVA Sports

Sunday, April 21, 3 p.m.: Bruins @ Maple Leafs | NBC, CBC, SN, TVA Sports

Tuesday, April 23, 7 p.m.: Maple Leafs @ Bruins | NBCSN, SN, CBC, TVA Sports
 
Last edited:
Another crap post by Dart. In playoffs 3 games in 4 nights but so is the other team. Buffalo was well rested. They haven't played since Thursday. They've also won their last 3 games so they're on a roll.
 
Another crap post by Dart. In playoffs 3 games in 4 nights but so is the other team. Buffalo was well rested. They haven't played since Thursday. They've also won their last 3 games so they're on a roll.

Not just that, but the list of games RockyDarts posted do not include even ONE instance of 3 games in 4 nights.
 
Another crap post by Dart. In playoffs 3 games in 4 nights but so is the other team. Buffalo was well rested. They haven't played since Thursday. They've also won their last 3 games so they're on a roll.
Buffalo is not Boston or Tampa Bay. So, Leafs lost badly to an inferior team.
 
Buffalo is not Boston or Tampa Bay....

There's some crack analysis right there.

Did Danny Grant ever win the Hart Trophy?
 
Another crap post by Dart. In playoffs 3 games in 4 nights but so is the other team. Buffalo was well rested. They haven't played since Thursday. They've also won their last 3 games so they're on a roll.
Yea, Leafs never stood a chance.