Are Guns Different from Alcohol?

Are guns different from alcohol?

  • Yes

    Votes: 31 83.8%
  • No

    Votes: 6 16.2%

  • Total voters
    37
May 8, 2010
1,013
1
0
Those who oppose gun control legislation frequently argue that if alcohol is not banned guns should not be restricted either.

Are guns different from alcohol?
 
Those who oppose gun control legislation frequently argue that if alcohol is not banned guns should not be restricted either.

Are guns different from alcohol?

In Canada you have to jump through many hoops in order to get the required permit to buy a gun . Courses have to be taken . Checks are made by the RCMP . All kinds of questions are asked on the gun permit application . They ask you questions about your marriage or if your divorced or split up with a girlfriend within the past year. The RCMP want to know who these people are and will contact them to ask questions about you . This is no bull . They do and will contact these people .

If you wish to go hunting then a course must be taken and passed in order to hunt . There is even a special course for turkey hunting .

If one wishes to own a hand gun then you must belong to a registered gun club . You have to now take the gun clubs hand gun course . If you pass the gun club will send papers to the attorney general ( they will do their own checks on you ) and that's how you will get papers to bring a hand gun to and from the club . Get caught not going straight home or strait to the gun club with a hand gun , then your in big trouble.

It's not as easy as people think it is . Now are the bad guy's on the street doing this ? NO . Just the law bidding citizens .

With booze you only have to be the legal drinking age . Any freak or nut case of age can buy that shit , drink it and start driving . Drunk driving happens everyday on the road . That's why we have ride programs . When an accident happens or someone is killed it's OH WELL another drunk driving case . People aren't reacting the same . Many people die on the road because of drunk drivers .

People talk about gun control . Take away the guns and people won't die . Well then take away the booze and even a larger number of people won't die . Can't do that can we . It's only alcohol . Tell that to the person who has lost a love one because of alcohol .

In Canada you are not allowed to own a hand gun unless you belong to a certified gun club . Tell that to the gang members in TO .

Take away my right to own a gun and I will oppose your right to drink alcohol .
 
In Canada you have to jump through many hoops in order to get the required permit to buy a gun . Courses have to be taken . Checks are made by the RCMP . All kinds of questions are asked on the gun permit application . They ask you questions about your marriage or if your divorced or split up with a girlfriend within the past year. The RCMP want to know who these people are and will contact them to ask questions about you . This is no bull . They do and will contact these people .

If you wish to go hunting then a course must be taken and passed in order to hunt . There is even a special course for turkey hunting .

If one wishes to own a hand gun then you must belong to a registered gun club . You have to now take the gun clubs hand gun course . If you pass the gun club will send papers to the attorney general ( they will do their own checks on you ) and that's how you will get papers to bring a hand gun to and from the club . Get caught not going straight home or strait to the gun club with a hand gun , then your in big trouble.

It's not as easy as people think it is . Now are the bad guy's on the street doing this ? NO . Just the law bidding citizens .

With booze you only have to be the legal drinking age . Any freak or nut case of age can buy that shit , drink it and start driving . Drunk driving happens everyday on the road . That's why we have ride programs . When an accident happens or someone is killed it's OH WELL another drunk driving case . People aren't reacting the same . Many people die on the road because of drunk drivers .

People talk about gun control . Take away the guns and people won't die . Well then take away the booze and even a larger number of people won't die . Can't do that can we . It's only alcohol . Tell that to the person who has lost a love one because of alcohol .

In Canada you are not allowed to own a hand gun unless you belong to a certified gun club . Tell that to the gang members in TO .

Take away my right to own a gun and I will oppose your right to drink alcohol .


owning a gun and drinking liquor are privileges not rights and Canada has less gun crimes than the U.S between 100-200 people a year are killed by guns in Canada the U.S it is over 9000-10,000
 
Yes of course they're different. Guns were invented and meant to harm or kill. Alcohol is often a way of socializing and relaxing. Alcohol on its own is not a bad thing.
 
owning a gun and drinking liquor are privileges not rights and Canada has less gun crimes than the U.S between 100-200 people a year are killed by guns in Canada the U.S it is over 9000-10,000

And over 15,000 die each year in drunk driving accidents in america.

MADD Canada estimates there are somewhere between 1,250 and 1,500 impairment-related crash deaths in Canada each year (3.4– 4.1 deaths per day).

http://www.madd.ca/madd2/en/impaired_driving/impaired_driving_statistics.html


Looks to me like alcohol is winning in the body count.

It really doesn't surprise me that the poll doesn't reflect this.
People really don't care about human tragedy. They just want their sacred drink and blame anything and everything else.

I do wonder though, how many of these crazed gunmen had a drink to get up the nerve before doing their deadly deed? I wonder if tests are ever done.
 
And over 15,000 die each year in drunk driving accidents in america.

MADD Canada estimates there are somewhere between 1,250 and 1,500 impairment-related crash deaths in Canada each year (3.4– 4.1 deaths per day).

http://www.madd.ca/madd2/en/impaired_driving/impaired_driving_statistics.html


Looks to me like alcohol is winning in the body count.

It really doesn't surprise me that the poll doesn't reflect this.
People really don't care about human tragedy. They just want their sacred drink and blame anything and everything else.

I do wonder though, how many of these crazed gunmen had a drink to get up the nerve before doing their deadly deed? I wonder if tests are ever done.

So...are guns and alcohol different?
 
So...are guns and alcohol different?

Ok yes you are right. They are different.
Alcohol is a poison.
A gun is a tool that can be used in many different ways. Sometimes for good, sometimes for fun and sometimes to kill.

But alcohol causes 5 times more death then guns. See my above post for link.
 
So...are alcohol and guns different?

Yes, very. They aren't really all that similar, the problems they create are not similar, the solutions to those problems are not similar.

Guns, to me, are more like cars and should be managed like cars. Unsafe use of either is problematic, you want to make sure the operators have some safety training, etc.
 
They're similar in the sense that neither are actually "necessary" in a "civilized" society. They're different; one causes way more deaths yet remains socially acceptable. Oh the hypocrisy.
 
They're similar in the sense that neither are actually "necessary" in a "civilized" society. They're different; one causes way more deaths yet remains socially acceptable. Oh the hypocrisy.

FWIW...the numbers are similar:

Gun Deaths vs Drunk Deaths
According to the Guardian in 2010 there were 8775 murders caused by guns in the U.S (http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2011/jan/10/gun-crime-us-state). For the same year, MADD reports that there were 10,228 deaths caused by drunk drivers in the US (http://www.madd.org/statistics/).
 
FWIW...the numbers are similar:

Gun Deaths vs Drunk Deaths
According to the Guardian in 2010 there were 8775 murders caused by guns in the U.S (http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2011/jan/10/gun-crime-us-state). For the same year, MADD reports that there were 10,228 deaths caused by drunk drivers in the US (http://www.madd.org/statistics/).

Well then they are different for sure, because look at this:

2009 drunk driving deaths in Canada - 1,074 (http://www.madd.ca/madd2/en/impaired_driving/impaired_driving_statistics.html)
2009 gun homicides in Canada - 210 (http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/85-002-x/2010003/article/11352-eng.htm#a6)

So drunk driving kills five times as many people in Canada as firearm violence.

There were 305m Americans and 34m Canadians in 2009 which means that the drunk driving deaths are happening at a statistically similar rate, but gun homicides are much lower in Canada than in the United States. In fact ALL homicides are much lower in Canada than in the United States, homicidese across the board, in every category, is much rarer here.

This goes back to my previous point about firearm policy being probably the least significant of all government policies when it comes to crime rates.
 
Well then they are different for sure, because look at this:

2009 drunk driving deaths in Canada - 1,074 (http://www.madd.ca/madd2/en/impaired_driving/impaired_driving_statistics.html)
2009 gun homicides in Canada - 210 (http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/85-002-x/2010003/article/11352-eng.htm#a6)

So drunk driving kills five times as many people in Canada as firearm violence.

There were 305m Americans and 34m Canadians in 2009 which means that the drunk driving deaths are happening at a statistically similar rate, but gun homicides are much lower in Canada than in the United States. In fact ALL homicides are much lower in Canada than in the United States, homicidese across the board, in every category, is much rarer here.

This goes back to my previous point about firearm policy being probably the least significant of all government policies when it comes to crime rates.

I think the difference between 2009 drunk driving deaths in Canada - 1,074 and 2009 gun homicides in Canada - 210 is far more pronounced than it appears. How many of the 210 gun deaths were by illegal firearms? I agree that firearm policy is probably the least significant of all government policies when it comes to crime rates. So much gun policy has been silly not to say expensive PC tokenism. The latest bright idea was Adam Vaughan wanting to ban the sale of bullets in the city. I mean, I could have just jumped on the Gardiner and headed to Mississauga. :)

I am not a gun owner, so my views have no self interest.