Are Baseball Players Soft?

Demien, I think you are being a bit too harsh. However, I think that baseball players, unlike athletes in football and hockey, do tend to be fragile and get hurt more easily. For example, Beltran hit a padded wall at a very slow speed and had to leave the game, contrast that with a hockey player who is slammed into the boards and gets back into the play.

Beltran was wearing a jersey, and probably a tee shirt underneath.
Hockey players wear hard padding, some might say armor, designed to protect them from 100 m.p.h. shots and 220 lb. defencemen.

If you listen to the sound made when Beltran hit the wall, you might want to reevaluate 'padded'.
While there is some cushion, he hid a hard object. Beltran contacted the wall at a seam in the padding. You can hear the collision.

 
Here is an interesting question: Is poker a sport?
Is chess a sport? I've seen that debated. Chess players (at least some do) do a lot of physical training to help maintain their concentration and focus. Sound body...sound mind.
 
Is chess a sport? I've seen that debated. Chess players (at least some do) do a lot of physical training to help maintain their concentration and focus. Sound body...sound mind.

Good question. Chess, poker, darts, etc. Are they sports? BTW: Anybody here see that commercial where the guy imply that race car drivers are not athletes?

Do we all agree that fornication is a sport?
 
"hitting" a padded wall at an extremely slow speed ]
By the way, did you ever walk into a wall or door when you weren't looking? It fucking hurts. Imagine if someone is running towards the wall and their focus is on the ball so his head is turned opposite the wall and can't properly brace himself.

So your characterization of hitting at "extremely slow speed" is not valid. Also, a hockey player getting hit into the boards is very often stationary and in spite of how fast player can skate up and down the ice, hits are rarely delivered at that same speed and again, the hockey player can usually brace himself. Delivering a hit at that speed would probably be charging/boarding and usually suspensionable when the guy taking the hit gets hurt (which happens a lot even to hickey players). I'd warrant that Beltran running into the wall was probably at a speed comparable to some of the hardest hits.
 
I don't think so. Baseball players are largely just a bunch of steroid injected fat pusses who spend most of the 'game' either standing idly by the periphery or sitting on a bench watching others standing idly by. Sporadic and intermittent episodes of physical exertion followed by more errant standing around of 3+ hours. Standing is inter-spersed with occasional spitting of chew tobacco or absent minded scratching of the groin. All the intensity and excitement of watching grandma's face wrinkle. They're all a bunch of prima donnas, and for the majority, should be considered soft. Very soft.

Sounds like football.
 
If we look at the top 4 professional sports in North America, I think most people will agree that football and hockey players are the toughest. That leaves baseball and basketball and some (not all) people have questioned the toughness (or lack thereof) of players in those two sports.
http://www.ign.com/boards/threads/are-nba-players-just-really-soft.452969070/ (hope the link works)

Four? What? Which ones?

The NFL, NBA and MLB come easily to mind. What's the Fourth?

Because Tennis, NASCAR and even Golf are bigger in North America than anything else that comes to mind.
 
If anyone thinks baseball players are soft try watching soccer. Watching a whole soccer match should come with a warning.


If you watch this you may sprout a vagina
 

Four? What? Which ones?

The NFL, NBA and MLB come easily to mind. What's the Fourth?

Because Tennis, NASCAR and even Golf are bigger in North America than anything else that comes to mind.

Sad and terribly predictable "rubbish" from DD
 
If anyone thinks baseball players are soft try watching soccer. Watching a whole soccer match should come with a warning. If you watch this you may sprout a vagina

Sad and terribly predictable "rubbish" from....well, just Sad.
 
Sad and terribly predictable "rubbish" from....well, just Sad.

You're too easy Don...easily baitable. Sadly disappointing. I thought you were brighter than that. Your father would be "cross" at you for responding so predictably to my admittedly juvenile jab at you
 

Four? What? Which ones?

The NFL, NBA and MLB come easily to mind. What's the Fourth?

Because Tennis, NASCAR and even Golf are bigger in North America than anything else that comes to mind.

Wow ... really ? lol
You are such an idiot.
 
Prince Fielder an athlete?????
A 260 lb pile of goo who can hit a ball with a stick (except in the playoffs)
 
True there's no "contact" but a 162 game schedule and an average of 6 games a week not to mention the travel should tell you these guys aren't soft.
In reality, how many players actually play 162 or even 150 games and how many pitchers actually pitch 9, 8 or even 7 innings?
 
Stand in the outfield for a few innings with nothing coming your way. Then a line drive screams out of the infield. Without benefit of a stretch beforehand, you break into an Olympic quality 50 yard dash, while concentrating on a moving ball instead of a stationary tape. At the last second you leap for it and land flat out, smashing your body into the ground and sliding for a few yards. Then you have to jump to your feet, find out exactly what's going on, who is where, and attempt to get the ball to a base that a runner is trying to get to.

Yeah, pussies.

Glad someone agrees!
 
Thanks for your contribution but the discussion was not about athleticism.

No, it's about baseball players that are SOFT. Prince Fielder should be the poster boy for soft.

Here's a good example...when was the last time you saw a baseball player put on a performance of sheer toughness like RGIII last year before his knee finally blew? How bout never!? There are examples of this type of thing every week during each and every NFL season, so try not to sound so foolish when you talk comparatively about baseball players with boo-boos on their pinky fingers that prevent them from playing, or a sore ankle that keeps them from flopping around the bases like cows.