Any electricians here?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Threads like this would be a lot less entertaining if only people who knew what they were talking about contributed. I am only going to comment on the voltage versus amperage question.

The goal of a circuit is to deliver power to the job, with as little loss due to conductor heating as possible. For a given amount of power delivered, you get the least loss with the higher voltage. That is why the big wires from a power plant are thousands of volts. But the higher the voltage, the wider an air gap it can arc, so the more dangerous it is. That is why high voltage lines have big insulators and need more insulation than low voltage systems. So the European system is more efficient in terms of transmission losses, but more susceptable to arcing and short circuits.
 
LateComer said:
...This latter type of wire is probably what you were referring to. I know it is used for baseboard heaters but I am not sure about central air. ...

Yes to central air
 
data1960 said:
I agree with what you say, but wire has two ratings; current and voltage. Higher current means a larger gauge (i.e 12 vs 14). Higher voltage means a thicker insulator. In residential wiring this typically doesn't matter but in industrial work, I have seen some pretty thick insulators.

Agreed, but the really thick insulated wire is for stuff that your average person would never deal with. I don't work with anything above 600v so I never installed any of that heavy duty stuff hydro works with.
 
data1960 said:
...I was once electrocuted my 600V. My arm shook for hours afterwards. I don't think it was the full 600. ....

You are lucky to be alive. 600 VAC is considered to be the deadliest voltage. Once you draw an arc, there is no way practical way to extinguish it without cutting the power off. By then, most people will have lost a limb.
 
C Dick said:
...The goal of a circuit is to deliver power to the job, with as little loss due to conductor heating as possible. For a given amount of power delivered, you get the least loss with the higher voltage. That is why the big wires from a power plant are thousands of volts. But the higher the voltage, the wider an air gap it can arc, so the more dangerous it is. That is why high voltage lines have big insulators and need more insulation than low voltage systems. So the European system is more efficient in terms of transmission losses, but more susceptable to arcing and short circuits.

The US/euro 110/240 VAC debate dates back to the birth of electricity. Edison was pushing 120 VDC while Tesla pushed 240 VAC. Edison won here, but had to convert to AC later. Germany went with Tesla and began a wide spread conversion across the entire country which lead to the euro 240 standard.

High voltage transmission generally selected at 1KV per mile. A 230KV line can run up to 230 miles. A 27 KV line runs 27 miles.
 
squirrelly04 said:
If your not an electrician, maybe you should not be commenting on this thread.

Maybe you should take your own advice??? Are YOU a licenced electrician?

If you're not STFU.....and instead of giving your opinion, do the sane thing, tell him to consult a licenced electrician which is the common sense thing to do.

baci2004 said:
As already stated in this thread the gauge of wire required is based on the current that runs through it not the voltage. 14ga. is rated for 300 volts but you wouldn't know that because you're not an electrician right??? :

Ok, so you have 240V 40 amp.....hence why a 10 or 12 ga wire is used. Higher current draw and higher voltage. To put it another way, maybe if you needed a 240v circuit that would only draw 20 amps, you could get away with a 14/2 but when does that happen? I've never seen that.....so, we have a higher voltage circuit that also draws a higher current, hence why one can commonly refer to a higher voltage circuit requiring a larger gauge of wire.

Maybe it is common in Europe to use a higher voltage, lower amperage circuit hence why they can get away with a smaller gauge of wire but, ahem, we're not in europe are we? And mmmmouse isn't asking about wiring hi hifi in europe.....so...fuck off already lol


baci2004 said:
Oh really? The rest of the house is wired with 14 and 20 gauge. Please tell me where you have used or have had your electrician use 16 ga wire???? Oh wait...my bad you were referring to speaker wire right?? No...wait...*rubs temples* you meant putting new cords on appliances!!! Fuck...maybe I'm Kreskin? :

LOL @ 20 ga....if you've seen, or used 20 ga in a house, you should be arrested for reckless endangerment......now really, who doesn't know what the fuck they are talking about?

At least I continually reccommend to those here that don't know what they're talking about to contact an electrician.

I find it funny that you laughed at me saying 16 ga when you come back with 20...lol.... (I couldn't remember the normal 14/2 numbers at the time, so sue me).



baci2004 said:
Me too!!
I particularly love when people post multiple times in a thread and attack posters when by their own admission don't know what the fuck they are talking about. Methinks they just like the sound of their own voice. :rolleyes:

If you refer back to the original poster, I specifically said to NOT try what he wants to try and to just buy the $10.00 adapter.

Point out WHERE on this thread I attacked anybody?
 
l69norm said:
You are lucky to be alive. 600 VAC is considered to be the deadliest voltage. Once you draw an arc, there is no way practical way to extinguish it without cutting the power off. By then, most people will have lost a limb.



Again.. that is not true as DC is more deadly than AC... 347V is also deadly.. 120V can also kill

It is not the voltage that kills you... it is the current
 
Tangwhich said:
Wire size is based on amperage, not voltage. Items that usually use 240v in Ontario are high amperage units. That's why the wire is thicker. Comparing 2 items of the same wattage, the one using a higher voltage will use less current so doesn't require wire to be a large.

BTW, 16 gauge wire is not allowed in Ontario for electrical purposes.

Ok, as i stated in my previous post I couldn't recall the std 14/2 numbers....

As I stated above, I never said a larger wire is needed because of the higher voltage, I simply stated ..well, lol what I stated, which is still true.

Anyways, thanks for the clarification without condemnation....cheers!
 
data1960 said:
I think I was hit by one phase to ground. It was one of those controllers where a 120V circuit energies a set of mechanical contacts (I forget the proper terms). Scared the crap out of me.

I think you are talking about a magnetic contactor.
 
tboy said:
Ok, so you have 240V 40 amp.....hence why a 10 or 12 ga wire is used. Higher current draw and higher voltage. To put it another way, maybe if you needed a 240v circuit that would only draw 20 amps, you could get away with a 14/2 but when does that happen? I've never seen that.....so, we have a higher voltage circuit that also draws a higher current, hence why one can commonly refer to a higher voltage circuit requiring a larger gauge of wire.


40A requires a minimum of 8AWG wire, 6AWG if you want to use aluminum.

20A requires a minimum of 12AWG wire

14/2 is only good for 15A.... and if you go by the code... it should only ever carry a maximum of 12A (80% of what it is rated).. the distance of a run must also be taken into consideration before determining the proper wire gauge to use.

It is unbelievable how much BAD advice has been given in this thread.

Tangwhich said:
BTW, 16 gauge wire is not allowed in Ontario for electrical purposes.

Could you direct me to the section of the CEC that says this??

You are also WRONG... 16AWG is allowed, as is 18AWG & 20AWG.. and so on.. What the fuck do you think is used for many extension cords, control wiring.. in panels & machinery (that is ALL electrical)??????????
 
tboy said:
Maybe you should take your own advice??? Are YOU a licenced electrician?

If you're not STFU.....and instead of giving your opinion, do the sane thing, tell him to consult a licenced electrician which is the common sense thing to do.

Ok, so you have 240V 40 amp.....hence why a 10 or 12 ga wire is used. Higher current draw and higher voltage. To put it another way, maybe if you needed a 240v circuit that would only draw 20 amps, you could get away with a 14/2 but when does that happen? I've never seen that.....so, we have a higher voltage circuit that also draws a higher current, hence why one can commonly refer to a higher voltage circuit requiring a larger gauge of wire




I am a licenced electrician. Have been for almost 30 years. I am also a licenced contrator with ESA.
I still don't think you know what you are talking about.
40Amps you need #8 It doesn't matter what the voltage is.
20Amps you need #12 wire.
 
data1960 said:
Just curious. I don't believe consumers can still buy Aluminum wire - can they? Is it still common in the trade? My parents house was wired with aluminum (1974ish). We rewired it with copper in the early 80s. Mostly driven by fear of fire and house insurance rates.


It is common practice to install aluminum wire for the main service (from service entrance to main panel)... dryer, range & hot tubs. It is not used for smaller circuits (light switches / receptacles).. it is also commonly used in commercial & industrial applications.

Aluminum is less than 1/2 the price of copper.. that is why it is used

There is absolutely nothing wrong with aluminum wire.. when installed & used correctly
 
Papi Chulo said:
Again.. that is not true as DC is more deadly than AC... 347V is also deadly.. 120V can also kill ..It is not the voltage that kills you... it is the current

With 600 VAC, you usually hear the words "My friend was electrocuted (and died)". You don't normally hear someone say "I was electrocuted..". If you do, chances are he's missing one or more limbs.

With 120 VAC, it's a lot easier to break the current path if you accidentally make contact, (unless you can't let go of the conductor).

With 600 VAC, all that has to happen is an accidental contact and once an arc starts, it's almost impossible to break the current path without shutting off the power. Imagine an arc going 10-15 feet away from the conductor through the air and into the victim. All it takes is one mistake.

Above 750 VAC, OHSA says special rules apply for work with live conductors, so it's actually safer.
 
data1960 said:
Thanks. That makes sense. Can I buy the aluminum wire from Home Depot or is it just for licensed trades? I ask because it was such a nasty situation in the late 70s with all the problems, I'm curious how they handle it now.


As far as I know, they sell to anyone as do most electrical wholesalers, but like most other electrical products.. it should only be installed by a qualified professional.

However... there are a few home owners who do it themselves. In some areas, the electrical inspectors are very helpful (with advice)
 
squirrelly04 said:
...I am a licenced electrician. Have been for almost 30 years. I am also a licenced contrator with ESA.
I still don't think you know what you are talking about.
40Amps you need #8 It doesn't matter what the voltage is.
20Amps you need #12 wire.

ok, sorry, my mistake, if you are in fact a licenced sparky then I bow to your knowledge....but, with that being said, aren't most 240v applications in ontario, two 120v @20 amps each thereby making a 240v 40 amp circuit? WHich would allow a 10 or 12 ga wire albeit more of them (which is similar to engineering specs which are: if you don't have room for 1 large support, 2 or more smaller supports do just as well).
 
tboy said:
ok, sorry, my mistake, if you are in fact a licenced sparky then I bow to your knowledge....but, with that being said, aren't most 240v applications in ontario, two 120v @20 amps each thereby making a 240v 40 amp circuit? WHich would allow a 10 or 12 ga wire albeit more of them (which is similar to engineering specs which are: if you don't have room for 1 large support, 2 or more smaller supports do just as well).

It is a total of 40A, but it is 2 x 20A (using a double pole breaker) which is why it this would be done with #12. It would be a 240V circuit if you used 12/2 (red) & it would be 120/240 if you used 12/3 (yellow) as line to line is 240V and line to neutral is 120.

Most 240V applications are NOT 2 x 120V 20A as you put it, in residential. Most are 2p30A or 2p40A (range or dryer)... or hot tubs which can range from 2p15-2p60A. 2p20A in resi is usually used for electric heating.
 
Papi Chulo said:
Could you direct me to the section of the CEC that says this??

You are also WRONG... 16AWG is allowed, as is 18AWG & 20AWG.. and so on.. What the fuck do you think is used for many extension cords, control wiring.. in panels & machinery (that is ALL electrical)??????????

No, you are WRONG. I don't have a CEC, only the Ontario code book, but I'm not going troll through it for your benefit. What I will point you to is Section 0 - Scope where you will see what it applies to. Notice it says nothing about electronic wiring. I'm talking about installations, not about wiring within devices. That's got nothing to do with electrical installations, which by code have a minimum of 14 on residential and 12 on commercial.
It have a 1500w kettle that uses #18 wire. Very dangerous IMO. It's get quite hot but that's got absolutely nothing to do with the electrical code.

Edit: I just did a quick flick through and the section you seek is 4-002 as a starting point.
 
tboy said:
ok, sorry, my mistake, if you are in fact a licenced sparky then I bow to your knowledge....but, with that being said, aren't most 240v applications in ontario, two 120v @20 amps each thereby making a 240v 40 amp circuit? WHich would allow a 10 or 12 ga wire albeit more of them (which is similar to engineering specs which are: if you don't have room for 1 large support, 2 or more smaller supports do just as well).


No that is not how it works. You don't add the 2 voltages together.The voltage is the difference in polarity between the 2 wires. The gauge of the wire is what the wire is rated for. You would have 240 at 20 amps and the wire is #12. If you have 120 at 20 amps , the wire is #12.
 
Tangwhich said:
No, you are WRONG. I don't have a CEC, only the Ontario code book, but I'm not going troll through it for your benefit. What I will point you to is Section 0 - Scope where you will see what it applies to. Notice it says nothing about electronic wiring. I'm talking about installations, not about wiring within devices. That's got nothing to do with electrical installations, which by code have a minimum of 14 on residential and 12 on commercial.
It have a 1500w kettle that uses #18 wire. Very dangerous IMO. It's get quite hot but that's got absolutely nothing to do with the electrical code.

Edit: I just did a quick flick through and the section you seek is 4-002 as a starting point.

read what you wrote (it says nothing about BUILDING WIRING.. just a broad general statement saying that 16ga wire cannot be used in Ontario... which is absolutely false).. let me refresh your memory

Tangwhich said:
BTW, 16 gauge wire is not allowed in Ontario for electrical purposes.

If I install a piece of machinery in my plant & need to install a small pendant station to control it, using a control voltage of 120V (for example) and choose a curly cord (SOW 16/5 or even 18/5- for example)... It is an electrical "purpose" (not electronic)... and it is perfectly OK in Ontario

Low voltage applications are also considered "electrical"

Now look at your statement above, again, and show me any section in the current CEC or Ontario Electric Codebook that specifically says that under no circumstance can 16Ga wire be used for all electrical purposes....

Control circuits are not considered "electronic".
 
I believe you will find that 16AWG is not allowed for branch or feed circuits for voltages over 70 volts; but would be acceptable in a control circuit.

In a 24 volt fire alarm system 16AWG would be acceptable for te signal circuits.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.