Anti-Semitism

hey ironhead....Jews aren't the only ones who practice this...chinese,koreans and indian people do this as well....i think the idea of "working within " your own community derives from the insecurity immigrants feel when they come to a new country.

I dunno about Chinese.

My experience is that Jews stick together, Italians stick together, etc. and they will actually defend their ethnic brothers, protect them even. (Though they all deny this, but it's true.)

Chinese however, the ones I've seen, will stab each other in the back, work to keep their brothers down. They are very competative with each other.

I'm stereotyping I know, but stereotypes are often based on observations.
 
In fact, some of the worst experiences I have had in business are when I've dealt with someone recommended through the community to me.

Madroff is the worst example of that. Also, the partners of Goldman Sachs would stab their own mother in the back to make a buck.

However, when the history of the world is written by impartial observers like me, it will be noted:
1) The Jews did not massacre 1.5 million Amenians.
2) The Jews did not kill 28 million Russians.
3) The Jews did not starve 2 million indigenous Irish to death.
 
If criticizing the policies of the State of Israel makes one an anti-Semite then I guess I'm an anti-Semite.

More times than not I feel that Israel is full of shit.

Paradoxically, I don't deny Israel the right to exist, or defend itself. I just wish they would stop persecuting and killing the Palestinians.

And what is your view on the government(s) and actions of Palestinian factions?
 
I do not dislike anyone for their religion or views, however I find Jews to be a people who would prefer to deal within their own community more so then other people. This is just an observation I have made over the years. Maybe I am way off.
My experience is that the newer the immigrant group, the more likely they are to prefer dealing with their own kind (safety? comfort? ease of communication? helping out their community?). Future generatins are more integrated with the wider community. I don't see Jews as much different from anyone else with this.

You might be surprised to go to little Italy and see old folks who have been in Canada for 40 or 50 years who still have limited English (or substitute any ethnic group in their areas (Polish, Chinese, ....) I've actually learned a smattering of Polish to ensure better service at a couple places.


Do some Jews dislike/not agree with the existence of Israel ?
Absolutely. Many will disagree with specific aspects of Israeli politics. While most will support Israel's right to exist, noticable numbers are actively opposed to Israel's existance or actions. This is true in Israel itself as well. Read http://www.haaretz.com/ and you will see numerous Jewish columnists who are adamantly against most government actions. Also it was already mentioned that some ultra-orthodox Jews don't accept Israel as a nation.

Can Israel survive on it's own in the Mid-East ?
Interesting question. I don't know what that answer would entail and would be highly dependent on how 'alone' they were (Jordan is one of Israel's larger trading partners). If you are talking total isolation amidst hostile nations bent on it's destruction, I doubt any country could survive.
 
I remember channel surfing one time and caught the end of a story. The commentator said that 'x' Jews do not like or agree(or something like that) with Israel's existence. This kind of surprised me. This was on TV not too long ago, a month or two maybe.

x - Meaning I did not hear the kind of Jew(forgive the nonpolitical correct term) he was talking about.


'Israel cannot survive.' I heard this a few years ago, then a few times since, on talk shows both TV and radio. Just wondered if this was a widely held belief or not.
 
When Israel was created in the 1940's the Orthodox Jews opposed its creation because they believed that only the Messiah could lead the Jews back to the Holy Land, not the United Nations.

Never the less, once it was created, they just figured, "well, it's here so who am I to argue with the facts."

Let me correct you, it's the "Neturei Karta" ultra orthodox sect that opposes the existence of the state of Isarel ( a very small sect at that). Those loonies even went to Iran to support Ahmenidejad. And you're right, they believe the Messiah will only come when Israel is ruled by non jews. On the flip side, Angelical Christians overwhelmingly support Israel as they believe the Messiah will come only with Jews ruling Israel.
 
I have noticed a large increase in anti-semitism. I have been in situations where the other party does not realize I have links to Israel and there is a long anti-semitic diatribe. Anyone else been in similar situations.
 
Let me correct you, it's the "Neturei Karta" ultra orthodox sect that opposes the existence of the state of Isarel ( a very small sect at that). Those loonies even went to Iran to support Ahmenidejad. And you're right, they believe the Messiah will only come when Israel is ruled by non jews. On the flip side, Angelical Christians overwhelmingly support Israel as they believe the Messiah will come only with Jews ruling Israel.

Thanks, now let me correct you....(har)

It's the EVANGELICAL Christians who believe that Jesus will RETURN in corporal form (the Rapture as per the Book of Revelations) after the final Battle between Good and Evil (The Battle of Armageddon).

In order for the Rapture to occur, there must be many things in place on Earth, and one of them is that the Jews must be in control of the Holy Land.

Hence why Evangelical Christians so fervently support the State of Israel. Not because they love Israel, or even Jews for that matter. They are hoping to meet Jesus up close and personal.

Now the best part.

During the Battle of Armageddon, fully half of all the Jews in Israel get wiped out. The half that doesn't get killed during the Battle realizes the error of their ways when they see sweet Jesus with their own eyes and convert to Christianity.
 
I have noticed a large increase in anti-semitism. I have been in situations where the other party does not realize I have links to Israel and there is a long anti-semitic diatribe. Anyone else been in similar situations.

Criticizing Israel does not equal "Anti-Semitism"

Israel is not a country to be held in high regard and they don't get a pass on their behaviour.
 
Again if you're always singling out Israel, out of proportion to the brutality commited by other Middle east countries you're antisemitic.

"As New York Times commentator Thomas Friedman put it: "Criticizing Israel is not anti-Semitic, and saying so is vile. But singling out Israel for opprobrium and international sanctions, out of all proportion to any other party in the Middle East is anti-Semitic, and not saying so is dishonest."
 
I have noticed a large increase in anti-semitism. I have been in situations where the other party does not realize I have links to Israel and there is a long anti-semitic diatribe. Anyone else been in similar situations.

Yes. For much of the middle-east, it is okay to protests Isreal's actions. On the other hand, protesting your government's actions will get you killed. This fuels unfair perceptions, which spread.
 
Why is it that people of the jewish faith always feel they are so special? In this instance, they have a name for prejudice that relates specificlaly to them.
 
Judaism is both a Religion AND a Culture from what I have gathered over the years. ie: ever heard of a Catholic Restaurant !!!!!!! but Jewish Deli's are popular. Is there Anglican food but there is Jewish food etc. Just to clarify I am not Jewish.

I am Jewish and have never heard of a Jewish deli in my life.
 
Why is it that people of the jewish faith always feel they are so special? In this instance, they have a name for prejudice that relates specificlaly to them.

The Jews had the fortune (misfortune) of being attacked by the Nazi's. The Nazi's were sticklers for documentation, and proceeded to name and document everything. "Anti-semetic" stuck.

Both Israel, and the subsequent neo-Nazi hate groups continued to use the term, each for its own ends.

As a counter-point, the Palestinian's named the 1947-1949 conflict as "The Catastrophe". Key figures supported Hitler, and subsequently depended on the backing of a series of Arab monarchies that were unwilling to support them in the clutch. Reading Palestinian history is like reading about a great disaster where every leader, made precisely the worst decision at the worst time and received the worst results. Hence, "The Catastrophe." The unremarkable name is just one of the many poor decisions.

When I read what Ghandi achieved in India, then read what the Palestinian's achieved in the Middle East, I weep.
 
question 4tees....would you also be accepting of a palestiain state? or a joint state?..just curious , i'd like to hear a Jewish person's opinion on this, not someone like gryfin or CF.

The prevalent opinion among university-educated North American Jews (I won't speak for the other side of the world) is that a two-state solution is necessary for the long term viability of the State of Israel. This means complete withdrawals from Gaza and the West Bank, but Jerusalem IS NOT on the table.
 
Again if you're always singling out Israel, out of proportion to the brutality commited by other Middle east countries you're antisemitic.

"As New York Times commentator Thomas Friedman put it: "Criticizing Israel is not anti-Semitic, and saying so is vile. But singling out Israel for opprobrium and international sanctions, out of all proportion to any other party in the Middle East is anti-Semitic, and not saying so is dishonest."

EXACTLY. When a North Korean submarine torpedoes a South Korean ship on a routine patrol and kills 46 sailors, nobody cares. When you compare that to the response of the Gaza-bound flotilla...

Or when was the last time you saw a Gryfin thread detailing the atrocities being committed against the Palestinian refugees stuck in Lebanese camps?

Approximately 425,000 Palestinians are registered as refugees in Lebanon by UNRWA, which provides them services. Many of them live in 12 camps scattered across the country in conditions Lombardo described as deplorable and appalling.

Read more: http://www.kyivpost.com/news/world/detail/71042/#ixzz0rtQDaKFX
 
EXACTLY. When a North Korean submarine torpedoes a South Korean ship on a routine patrol and kills 46 sailors, nobody cares. When you compare that to the response of the Gaza-bound flotilla...

Or when was the last time you saw a Gryfin thread detailing the atrocities being committed against the Palestinian refugees stuck in Lebanese camps?

Approximately 425,000 Palestinians are registered as refugees in Lebanon by UNRWA, which provides them services. Many of them live in 12 camps scattered across the country in conditions Lombardo described as deplorable and appalling.

Read more: http://www.kyivpost.com/news/world/detail/71042/#ixzz0rtQDaKFX

And why are they living in these refugee camps in the first place?
 
And why are they living in these refugee camps in the first place?

The issue is that the releasing the Palestinian refugees from the camps may disrupt the local population, and hence the local dictator's (government's) hold on power. Better to keep them fenced in.

Examples:
- Lebanon doesn't want to let the Palestinian's out of the refugee camps.
- Jordan doesn't want to let the Palestinian's out of the refugee camps.
- Egypt doesn't want to let the Palestinian's out of Gaza.
- Jordan doesn't want the West Bank back.
- Egypt doesn't want Gaza back.
- Iran doesn't want the Palestinian's to relocate there either.

Israel recognizing the problem, provided the Palestinian government under Arafat money to shut down some of the refugee camps. The camps remain.

The Palestinian situation is miserable. In many ways, they are a people who's goals are betrayed by every leader they follow.
 
And why are they living in these refugee camps in the first place?

See, this is where anti-semitism comes into play. Why would you even ask that, and why is it relevant? Does Canada keep their refugees in conditions that are deplorable and appalling? The point is that attention is paid to the refugees' plight in Gaza & West Bank while completely ignoring the fact that is going on in Arab countries as well. And yet you come back to trying to blame the Israelis for the fact they are in those Arab countries - whether or not that's valid isn't the discussion here.