A Surprising Request from a former S.O.

Good for the OP to actually care about what really matters most in such a situation: the child.

Shame on others in this thread for suggesting that what he wants, or what she wants, should be paramount. Shame!
 
Holy crap, I can't believe all this. Let me get this straight.

A woman comes to you and asks you to do something very personal, financially and emotionally risky. She wants to have YOUR son or daughter. YOUR son would be completley raised by another person. No contact from you to your own flesh and blood. It is to meet her needs, her life goals. Then she tells you that she (and women in general, which I think is insulting to all women) doesn't care about your wants and needs, that she is just using you for something that SHE needs.

And you are WORRIED that she might be offended when you turn her down?

At this point, my response would be for her to FOAD.
 
She said: "Honey, don't you realize that women don't really care what men want? It's only what we want that's important.


Sounds like she'll make a great mother. Maybe she'll have a different attitude with her children, but I don't think that kind of utter selfishness is something you can just switch off.
 
...She said: "Honey, don't you realize that women don't really care what men want? It's only what we want that's important. At the top of this list is children and security. Most women can't afford the responsibility to have children by themselves so they look for a man that will help provide the life that they want. So long as the woman likes him, she doesn't have to love him, and he puts in his contribution, she'll get what she wants out of the marriage or relationship. I have achieved security but in order to do so I sacrificed relationships. I though I'd have more time but it ran out quicker than I thought. A woman can achieve anything a man can except get pregnant by herself. I don't want to go through the whole red tape process of adoption and I want to know who the baby's father is, not through some anonymous bank. This is all I need and my life will be complete."

You might do her a kindness by forwarding this link to the Atlantic Monthly article by Lori Gottlieb who chose to be a single mom via donor sperm. She might need the reality check:

http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/03/marry-him/6651/

Here's a snippet of what single mom Gottlieb has to say in that (very) lengthy article:

"Each time I read about single women having babies on their own and thriving instead of settling for Mr. Wrong and hiring a divorce lawyer, I felt all jazzed and ready to go. At the time, I truly believed, “I can have it all—a baby now, my soul mate later!”

Well … ha! Hahahaha. And ha.

Just as the relationship books fail to mention what happens after you triumphantly land a husband (you actually have to live with each other), these single-mom books fail to mention that once you have a baby alone, not only do you age about 10 years in the first 10 months, but if you don’t have time to shower, eat, urinate in a timely manner, or even leave the house except for work, where you spend every waking moment that your child is at day care, there’s very little chance that a man—much less The One—is going to knock on your door and join that party.

They also gloss over the cost of dating as a single mom: the time and money spent on online dating (because there are no single men at toddler birthday parties); the babysitter tab for all those boring blind dates; and, most frustrating, hours spent away from your beloved child. Even women who settle but end up divorced might be in a better position than those of us who became mothers on our own, because many ex-wives get both child-support payments and a free night off when the kids go to Dad’s house for a sleepover. Never-married moms don’t get the night off. At the end of the evening, we rush home to pay the babysitter, make any houseguest tiptoe around and speak in a hushed voice, then wake up at 6 a.m. at the first cries of “Mommy!”

Try bringing a guy home to that."
 
I'd say the "benefits" part of the relationship just ended!

Yeah no shit.

What she mean no strings attached / its still be your freaking kid. I could not turn my back on it. Who cares what the law might say, morals sometimes come first. (yeah I'm a Terbbie who cares about morals, lol)

Its pretty cool she was honest with U. Some gals would just poke a few holes in the condom wrappers and ask if U wanna spend the weekend in the Falls with her, lol

So it be really mean to cut everything off with her.....then again a kid lives forever and in my opinion it still be 50% your responsibility
 
i think its a little shallow to dump a wonderful caring person just because she smokes but each to their own... instead of helping her quit its easier just to throw up your hands and break up
 
DD,

Your former SO wants a child to fill a void in her life. She might also want one for the financial stability that you would bring as the biological father. While I don't judge her for wanting to fulfill these goals I don't think you need to feel any guilt or doubt for denying her them. Bringing a new life into this world for either purpose does not ensure that the child will have the greatest possible life of its own. That's the most important factor. What you feel is really just sympathy for someone that you care about on some level. She's experiencing a notable amount of suffering and you are sympathetic. I am as well based on what you are telling us.
 
Always???

If you mean the moment in which the question was REALLY asked, rather than the formal question, I think it's ALWAYS let me think.

In your own way you should have asked and answered the question before actually asking the question. My wife knew I was going to propose to her long before I actually did. We had already had had enough "what if" conversations that I already knew what her answer would be. The actual proposal when it came was just a formality--an event I tried to make beautiful and memorable, but we both already knew what was going to be asked, and what was going to be answered.

Certainly the first time we had those "what if" conversations the "what if" answer was "let me think about it".

Guess I must be outside the norm then, because my wife was floored when I asked and I was far from sure she'd say yes.
 
I felt that since I knew what my reply would be, it would be cruel to string her along for a day or two more. Please keep in mind that she is a former S.O. and we have a history. We lived together for two years at one point and the topic of children came up then but she decided she wasn't ready. I was one of the relationships she sacrificed in order to advance her career. I suppose she thought I could always be her 'Plan B'. I am nobody's 'Plan B'. Nobody should be.

Sounds like you had an axe to grind and that you were reasonably happy that she was on the verge of tears when you left.
 
Very true.

Did you know that under Ontario law that even an anonymous sperm donor is considered the legal father of a child. And as such, is obligated to support that child under any circumstances. The mother cannot sign away the rights of the child.

But if the sperm donor is anonymous how are you going to know who he is in order to get child support from him?
 
Sounds like you had an axe to grind and that you were reasonably happy that she was on the verge of tears when you left.

Having read DD's postings carefully more than once, I don't see it that way at all. He doesn't appear to be showing any sort of Malice, just honesty.
 
there's this amazing thing i noticed about women...

when they get the biological clock ticking inside them thats ticking so loud that they don't care or are no longer aware of their own common sense anymore...

they become hell bent on having children. they'll even throw out the window the notion of any other potential they might have, any other promising future they could have, any dreams or hopes they had or could pursue...


snip


suddenly, she hits her 25th birthday.
and she starts talking about how she is getting really old...

and she starts dating guys like mad.

the first player gets her pregnant and he turns out to be a total asshole, dumps her immediately and only wanted NSA and FWB. so she decides to go through the pregnancy alone and delivers her first baby. forgetting all about school and landing a job and forgetting she graduated college in youth counselling.



snip

she and her husband is flat broke. they can barely afford to pay the rent. the landlord is trying to get them evicted. They are trying to fight it in court and trying to pay the legal fees as well. she's flat broke, she has two kids and yet.....she's still in her 20's and even after all this...she still wants to have one or two or three more kids before she hits 30. Even with all the legal troubles, with the looming threat of being homeless with 2 kids already and while feeling seriously depressed....

she wants to get pregnant yet again. have another kid before she hits 30....even though she's struggling through some serious issues...and even though she might not even be able to afford to feed 1 extra mouth. its amazing that women don't even think about these things when they suddenly feel the need to have children.
----

the bottom line?

when a woman wants to have kids. they want to have kids before it is too late. they want to have kids before they hit 30 years old - which is the age that is considered by all women to be the age number where it is too late to have kids amongst all women. they will get impregnated by any guy if necessary. nothing else matters. not money. not their current situation. not their financial situation, not their future, not their career. not their s.o. nothing else matters.

Lemme guess, you're about 26 years old.
 
Having read DD's postings carefully more than once, I don't see it that way at all. He doesn't appear to be showing any sort of Malice, just honesty.

Thank You, Tangwich.

This is very true. I mean no malice to her at all. In fact I wish all the best for her. I am not the man suited to her needs. I truly believe honesty is better than false hope, no matter how brief.

I will always have a soft spot for her. I wouldn't keep in touch with her after all this time if I did not, much like other former couples who move on and do not dwell on past bitterness.

However, she is not my present S.O., she is a former one and that time is gone. I could not knock someone else up with my lovely, present S.O. in my life.

I very much value all the responses presented. It has added more depth, richness and perspective than I had anticipated.
 
Unwilling sperm donor? Baby daddy? I just want your genetics?? Been there, done that.. Her "opinion" that " Oh... don't worry, I just want your sperm, you don't have to worry, you don't need to take anymore part in their life than you want to".. is just such a temporary mind set.. Run!!! Run!! Anyone who can be so selfish as to think that raising a child is a one person job, hasn't got a fucking clue about what it's all about. I know what it means when they say...you'll pay for sleep..At the end of the day, what is in the best interests of the child? Why do adoption agencies usually only look at couples who want children but can't conceive? She wants a child as a concept, but the reality of the twenty year commitment to raise one without a partner seems to be something that is beyond her comprehension. She's looking for a " when I get there, I'll be happy" reality, and thinking that a child will fill in the gap, instead of " I'm happy, but, a stable relationship with someone who would want a child with me would add to it" Her biological clock's agenda shouldn't negatively impact her life, your life, and the quality of life of the yet unborn. My mom and my dad stayed married "'till death do us part".. Trouble with that was that he died whenI was thirteen months old. I know that my life would have been significantly different if I would have had a stable male influence in my life when I was growing up.. I would like to think that my mother wouldn't have considered single motherhood as an option.

What does she do for a living that she could maintain her current lifestyle and actually have the time to raise a child alone.? What does she feel that her chances are of establishing a stable relationship with someone else in the near future is with the "baggage" of a child with an un named father? At least with a divorce, there's a good chance that a child has a dad that takes the kid regularily and assists with the financial burden of their upbringing..
 
@DD, Good for you. They way you handled it was honest and direct. I don't see any rudeness or meanness in your posts on this subject. She was direct and honest with you and I give you credit in being the same with her.
If you had said that you would take time to think about it, that would be cruel because it would give her hope that you might say yes, when you had no intention of giving that answer.

@fuji, your posts on this topic sound like you live in a fantasy world. The truth isn't always nice and while she is honest, she shows no thought at all in thinking about what he wants or any willingness to find out what he thinks is best.

Anyone who thinks that the man would not be on the hook for financial support, irrespective of what she says before the child is born, is a fool. The man who got her pregnant, would have to worry about her taking him to court for child support.
If she's that hell bent on getting pregnant, she should find some random guy to try to get her pregnant or go to a sperm bank.

Always in the Groove...
 
The "no strings attached" part is not legally binding. If she loses her job or changes her mind she can force you to pay child support until your child is an adult.

I was thinking the same thing, but couldn't that be solved with an agreement that he will never have to provide for the child if she fails in her child-rearing responsbilities? I mean, shouldn't we give her the benefit of the doubt that she only wants his sperm and nothing more, and will succeed as a single mother?
 
I was thinking the same thing, but couldn't that be solved with an agreement that he will never have to provide for the child if she fails in her child-rearing responsbilities? I mean, shouldn't we give her the benefit of the doubt that she only wants his sperm and nothing more, and will succeed as a single mother?

"family law" overrides any agreement of that sort.