A Surprising Request from a former S.O.

Don Draper

Cufflinks & Cognac
Nov 24, 2009
6,354
645
113
A former S.O. that I still have benefits with calls me up and asks if I'll have drinks with her seeing as she wants to ask me something. She's rather lovely, I enjoy her company and the reason why we're not together is because she won't give up her filthy smoking habit (deal breaker for me.)

This is what she wants to ask me: "I want to have a baby and would you be the donor? No strings attached, no responsibilities. I'm in my mid-thirties, will always have a little crush on you and think a baby with our genes will be good looking and smart. I don't want to miss this train."

My reply was: "If I wanted children, I would have had them by now. I prefer the notion of the 'Family Unit' and not fractured as such. Since I have no interest in being a Father or Husband, I'd rather be honest with you and respectfully decline your request."

Now, her reply to this is what I found really interesting. She said: "Honey, don't you realize that women don't really care what men want? It's only what we want that's important. At the top of this list is children and security. Most women can't afford the responsibility to have children by themselves so they look for a man that will help provide the life that they want. So long as the woman likes him, she doesn't have to love him, and he puts in his contribution, she'll get what she wants out of the marriage or relationship. I have achieved security but in order to do so I sacrificed relationships. I though I'd have more time but it ran out quicker than I thought. A woman can achieve anything a man can except get pregnant by herself. I don't want to go through the whole red tape process of adoption and I want to know who the baby's father is, not through some anonymous bank. This is all I need and my life will be complete."

I said: "I'm definitely not the man for you and much less who you want a baby with. Your whole process to Motherhood is very cold, calculating and clinical. Granted, I am not from North America and am very proud of my warm European roots. I think a child deserves both a Mother and Father that will love him together so I'd rather not do it at all instead of half way, as you propose. I could never disassociate myself emotionally from any child of mine. Love is the Higher Law, not money or security."

She said: "I see. Very sorry to have wasted your time."

I know her so I could tell that she was trying to hold her tears in. I tried to get her to stay until she calmed down but she insisted on leaving. I feel awful about making her feel bad but I stand by my convictions. Love should bring a child into this world not the desire to complete a check-off list.

Just wanted to share this since I found it a very clarifying conversation about what women truly want and who they are when it comes to their desires.
 
Last edited:
Aren't women funny?
I had one ask the same of me a couple of years back (And we are both older than you are) and I told her that it was fine and that we would need to try repeatedly and ...... after a long discussion about it I said - "Shame that you didn't talk to me a couple of years ago - before my vasectomy." Tick tock.
At least she'll quit smoking now!
 
Very interesting, DD!

Keep an open mind and think about it again... I think she was trying to say something very important. You may or may not agree with her, but think it through again. :cool:

Perry
 
Good for you.. stick with your values! Also always go with your instincts… LOVE does trump all especially with kids!!
 
The "no strings attached" part is not legally binding. If she loses her job or changes her mind she can force you to pay child support until your child is an adult.
 
You are right. Just make sure the next time you have benefits you stick to anal.
 
Suppose she quits smoking, would that change your mind?

It's good you were both honest about this, clarity is best.
I wouldn't say either of you were wrong either, I understand the reasoning behind both views.

You can't argue with her basic desire for children, she can easily find an arrangement these days through plentyoffish or craigslist and find a man who has the attributes she's looking for without having any ties to him emotionally or financially.

You would probably be allowed to treat the child as your own niece or nephew, give her support no matter what she decides.
 
Don Draper Says....."Just wanted to share this since I found it a very clarifying conversation about what women truly want and who they are when it comes to their desires"
Don't you mean "Just wanted to share this since I found it a very clarifying conversation about what this woman truly wants and who she is when it comes to her desires."
Also,I don't believe a word of what you said.JMO
 
"Honey, don't you realize that women don't really care what men want? It's only what we want that's important."
And, in other news today, it has been revealed that the Pope is Catholic. Film at 11.

Seriously - and I intend no insult whatsoever to you, DD - does this come as a surprise?
 
"It's only what I want that's important."

A lot of people in my life enjoy this frame of reference and they aren't necessarily women.
 
I'd say the "benefits" part of the relationship just ended!
 
Very interesting, DD!

Keep an open mind and think about it again... I think she was trying to say something very important. You may or may not agree with her, but think it through again. :cool:

Perry

I agree that when someone drops something this big on you, the right response is to listen to what they have to say, and tell them you will have to think about it. This is both to show some respect to their feelings, it's quite an honour to be asked really. It's also because it probably does take awhile to absorb something like that.

That said, DD, I tend to agree with your choice too.
 
Seriously - and I intend no insult whatsoever to you, DD - does this come as a surprise?

It's not a surprise at all. It's just confirmation. I do believe that since she was putting all her cards on the table, she might as well be blunt and direct.

As per her conversation (and many of our experiences in The Brotherhood), women think this but are loath to actually, verbally express it.
 
Oh yeah, she is all "independant" until that baby comes and decides that working isn't for her anymore but it is for the Babydaddy and you are on the hook for support.

You made the right decision, let her find some other chump.
 
well at least she didnt try to seduce you , get pregnant and make you look after it ... least she was honest about wanting to have a child
 
A former S.O. that I still have benefits with calls me up and asks if I'll have drinks with her seeing as she wants to ask me something. She's rather lovely, I enjoy her company and the reason why we're not together is because she won't give up her filthy smoking habit (deal breaker for me.)

This is what she wants to ask me: "I want to have a baby and would you be the donor? No strings attached, no responsibilities. I'm in my mid-thirties, will always have a little crush on you and think a baby with our genes will be good looking and smart. I don't want to miss this train."

My reply was: "If I wanted children, I would have had them by now. I prefer the notion of the 'Family Unit' and not fractured as such. Since I have no interest in being a Father or Husband, I'd rather be honest with you and respectfully decline your request."

Now, her reply to this is what I found really interesting. She said: "Honey, don't you realize that women don't really care what men want? It's only what we want that's important. At the top of this list is children and security. Most women can't afford the responsibility to have children by themselves so they look for a man that will help provide the life that they want. So long as the woman likes him, she doesn't have to love him, and he puts in his contribution, she'll get what she wants out of the marriage or relationship. I have achieved security but in order to do so I sacrificed relationships. I though I'd have more time but it ran out quicker than I thought. A woman can achieve anything a man can except get pregnant by herself. I don't want to go through the whole red tape process of adoption and I want to know who the baby's father is, not through some anonymous bank. This is all I need and my life will be complete."

I said: "I'm definitely not the man for you and much less who you want a baby with. Your whole process to Motherhood is very cold, calculating and clinical. Granted, I am not from North America and am very proud of my warm European roots. I think a child deserves both a Mother and Father that will love him together so I'd rather not do it at all instead of half way, as you propose. I could never disassociate myself emotionally from any child of mine. Love is the Higher Law, not money or security."

She said: "I see. Very sorry to have wasted your time."

I know her so I could tell that she was trying to hold her tears in. I tried to get her to stay until she calmed down but she insisted on leaving. I feel awful about making her feel bad but I stand by my convictions. Love should bring a child into this world not the desire to complete a check-off list.

Just wanted to share this since I found it a very clarifying conversation about what women truly want and who they are when it comes to their desires.

with all due respect to you, i'm not sure what your issue was here. she asked you to be a donor, not a father or husband. as a previous poster mentioned, you should take this as a compliment and an honour that she would ask you in the first place. you have your own outlook on childrearing which you are completely entitled to, but was there really a reason for you to come down on her because her ideas about childrearing and the concept of family differ from yours? lots of people come from mixed families, single parent families.... sure i also think that its ideal for both a mother and father to be present in a childs life, but just because that isnt possible for this woman, does that mean she should be denied a child of her own?

furthermore, i dont really think that you can consider the desire to have a child as a "checklist" item. its not like you can just go have a kid and then say, ok great! got that one done! most women feel the biological urge to have children, its not like she wants to keep up with the jones'es by having one.

love definitely is the higher law, but maybe she wants a child so she can experience that kind of love (the love between a mother and child)?

i didnt really see the "cold calculating and clinical" that you saw. wouldnt it be more calculating and clinical to go get a sperm donor? she obviously thought highly enough of your good qualities that she wanted you to be the father, that seems quite warm and thoughtful.

i feel that you may owe this lady an apology...
 
She missed the train. Now she wants to drag it back into the tunnel.
DD as much as you may want to revisit that tunnel the best move is not to.
This is becoming a common modus operandi for women now.
 
with all due respect to you, i'm not sure what your issue was here. she asked you to be a donor, not a father or husband. as a previous poster mentioned, you should take this as a compliment and an honour that she would ask you in the first place. you have your own outlook on childrearing which you are completely entitled to, but was there really a reason for you to come down on her because her ideas about childrearing and the concept of family differ from yours? lots of people come from mixed families, single parent families.... sure i also think that its ideal for both a mother and father to be present in a childs life, but just because that isnt possible for this woman, does that mean she should be denied a child of her own?

furthermore, i dont really think that you can consider the desire to have a child as a "checklist" item. its not like you can just go have a kid and then say, ok great! got that one done! most women feel the biological urge to have children, its not like she wants to keep up with the jones'es by having one.

love definitely is the higher law, but maybe she wants a child so she can experience that kind of love (the love between a mother and child)?

i didnt really see the "cold calculating and clinical" that you saw. wouldnt it be more calculating and clinical to go get a sperm donor? she obviously thought highly enough of your good qualities that she wanted you to be the father, that seems quite warm and thoughtful.

i feel that you may owe this lady an apology...

I don't see any need for an apology. She presented her desire for a fatherless child, he responded by declining, explaining that he did not wish to have his genes be used in that manner. If she is entitled to have a child on her own,then he is entitled to decide not to have his genes be used in that manner.

That's completely ignoring the fact that regardless what is said now, he could be dunned for child support at anytime down the road.