As happens from time to time, there have been some recent posts/threads on the subject of mental illness. Notably, this thread about depression and suicidal thoughts, which I found presented some interesting insights into the views of those both with or without lived experience. In addition, Daley recently spoke about her experience with social anxiety. I thank those that have revealed something about their personal experiences, and find I am now inspired to do the same and perhaps start a conversation about mental illness in our culture. Everyone's experience is different, so what I say may not ring true for all, but this is what I have observed.
To begin with myself, I have generalized anxiety disorder and recurrent major depressive disorder. At one point I was given a potential diagnosis of borderline personality disorder, though diagnoses of this nature are often very difficult and subjective, so the jury never came to a verdict on that one. For those that do not have direct experience it might be illustrative to talk about symptoms. Physical symptoms for me that mental illness have caused or contributed to include, but are not limited to: muscle tension, shortness of breath, voice problems, panic attacks (inability to breathe, inability to move, uncontrollable shaking), skin problems, nausea, increased pain response, headaches, insomnia and fatigue. There are cognitive symptoms such as inability to concentrate, recurrent nightmares, racing thoughts and suicidal ideation. Sometimes my thoughts get stuck on a single topic for long periods of time. And I literally mean that there can be something at the forefront of my mind from the moment I wake up in the morning until the moment I fall asleep (and then appearing in my dreams) for days or even weeks. Behavioural effects are of course significant. I've experienced a lot of loss in my life as a result. And, notably, I have multiple suicide attempts in my past, the first of which was at the age of 10.
My experience is that there is a very slow shift in the attitude of our culture towards mental illness. As someone who has dealt with both anxiety and depression, I have noticed it has become socially acceptable to talk about and acknowledge anxiety in some contexts. But this is rarely true of other conditions. There is a prejudice in our culture about mental illness that runs so deep that most people do not even recognize it when it appears. A person cannot be blamed for not understanding a thing beyond their own experience, but there are many mistaken and insulting beliefs that are deeply ingrained in society, and that people work under without ever considering the possibility that they're wrong. To name some:
Many of these are actually perpetuated by a health care system that is under-equipped to deal with and overtaxed by mental health issues; I've had doctors repeat some of these very things to my face. In some cases I've encountered wonderfully sympathetic health care workers that show a genuine desire to provide the best possible treatment, but I've also encountered those who abuse patients by swearing at them, threatening them when they've taken no action to harm themselves or others, violating their rights by restraining them without cause or explanation, and the like. And I've seen those with little or no ability to empathize with the suffering of those they treat, either because they never had any or because it was worn away. I have little doubt that it is a difficult job, but I believe there are too many doing it who simply shouldn't be. For anyone experiencing mental illness who has experienced a significant improvement to quality of life through treatment, that is wonderful. For me, the system is a failure that has as often as not done more harm than good.
Personal relationships undergo a great deal of strain from mental illness. Many people simply cannot deal with being around it. The most common reactions in my experience are either to immediately withdraw when faced with it, or to put in a short effort to help and then withdraw when they realize how difficult it actually is. I have had the benefit of some extremely supportive people in my life, often those with mental illness themselves but occasionally those without lived experience but the motivation and ability to remain supportive, and I am very grateful for them. For anyone that knows someone struggling with mental illness, know that you do not have to be perfect. You will not always know what to do or what to say. But the effort to do and say count for so much on their own. Be present. Be there. Show that you care.
This has been my reality. I welcome others to share theirs.
To begin with myself, I have generalized anxiety disorder and recurrent major depressive disorder. At one point I was given a potential diagnosis of borderline personality disorder, though diagnoses of this nature are often very difficult and subjective, so the jury never came to a verdict on that one. For those that do not have direct experience it might be illustrative to talk about symptoms. Physical symptoms for me that mental illness have caused or contributed to include, but are not limited to: muscle tension, shortness of breath, voice problems, panic attacks (inability to breathe, inability to move, uncontrollable shaking), skin problems, nausea, increased pain response, headaches, insomnia and fatigue. There are cognitive symptoms such as inability to concentrate, recurrent nightmares, racing thoughts and suicidal ideation. Sometimes my thoughts get stuck on a single topic for long periods of time. And I literally mean that there can be something at the forefront of my mind from the moment I wake up in the morning until the moment I fall asleep (and then appearing in my dreams) for days or even weeks. Behavioural effects are of course significant. I've experienced a lot of loss in my life as a result. And, notably, I have multiple suicide attempts in my past, the first of which was at the age of 10.
My experience is that there is a very slow shift in the attitude of our culture towards mental illness. As someone who has dealt with both anxiety and depression, I have noticed it has become socially acceptable to talk about and acknowledge anxiety in some contexts. But this is rarely true of other conditions. There is a prejudice in our culture about mental illness that runs so deep that most people do not even recognize it when it appears. A person cannot be blamed for not understanding a thing beyond their own experience, but there are many mistaken and insulting beliefs that are deeply ingrained in society, and that people work under without ever considering the possibility that they're wrong. To name some:
- Mental illness is a choice. People think this all the time. They see it as a lack of willpower, something you should be able to get rid of if you're smart/tough/resourceful enough. As with many health issues, you might have some control about how you deal with it and some ability to manage it, but you can't simply wish it away. No one would tell a person with cancer or a heart condition to simply get over it, yet they will say that to someone with depression. There is an irony here that we may actually have much more understanding of the controllable risk factors and treatment of many physical conditions.
- People with mental illness are bad people. This is in no small part perpetuated by a media culture that highlights episodes of violence by those suffering from mental illness. People with mental illness are no more or less prone to immoral or illegal acts than anyone else. The suffering of mental illness can lead to "compassion fatigue" but can also engender a great deal of empathy for the suffering of others.
- If a person has mental illness, you'll know it. Most of the time you won't. The stigma is so powerful that a person with mental illness usually learns many strategies to hide it.
- Asking someone if they are struggling or have thoughts of harming themselves will put ideas in their head. No one struggling with this needs someone else to put ideas in their head; the thoughts come all on their own.
- Suicide is an act of selfishness. A person who commits suicide is in so much pain that perhaps the most basic of all human instincts--to survive--is overwritten. Do we not recognize the hypocrisy in asking that person to take responsibility for the pain their death will cause others? I speak from personal experience when I say that I am often concerned with the burden my mental illness places on others and do my very best to accept the generosity of those who lend support while reciprocating with what I have to offer and contributing to society in general, a society that can often show a callous disregard for suffering--the equivalent of "shut up and deal." When a person dies from suicide it is a terrible tragedy, one that we only compound when we blame that person.
Many of these are actually perpetuated by a health care system that is under-equipped to deal with and overtaxed by mental health issues; I've had doctors repeat some of these very things to my face. In some cases I've encountered wonderfully sympathetic health care workers that show a genuine desire to provide the best possible treatment, but I've also encountered those who abuse patients by swearing at them, threatening them when they've taken no action to harm themselves or others, violating their rights by restraining them without cause or explanation, and the like. And I've seen those with little or no ability to empathize with the suffering of those they treat, either because they never had any or because it was worn away. I have little doubt that it is a difficult job, but I believe there are too many doing it who simply shouldn't be. For anyone experiencing mental illness who has experienced a significant improvement to quality of life through treatment, that is wonderful. For me, the system is a failure that has as often as not done more harm than good.
Personal relationships undergo a great deal of strain from mental illness. Many people simply cannot deal with being around it. The most common reactions in my experience are either to immediately withdraw when faced with it, or to put in a short effort to help and then withdraw when they realize how difficult it actually is. I have had the benefit of some extremely supportive people in my life, often those with mental illness themselves but occasionally those without lived experience but the motivation and ability to remain supportive, and I am very grateful for them. For anyone that knows someone struggling with mental illness, know that you do not have to be perfect. You will not always know what to do or what to say. But the effort to do and say count for so much on their own. Be present. Be there. Show that you care.
This has been my reality. I welcome others to share theirs.

