A frank conversation about mental illness

Roleplayer

Active member
Jun 29, 2010
223
94
43
As happens from time to time, there have been some recent posts/threads on the subject of mental illness. Notably, this thread about depression and suicidal thoughts, which I found presented some interesting insights into the views of those both with or without lived experience. In addition, Daley recently spoke about her experience with social anxiety. I thank those that have revealed something about their personal experiences, and find I am now inspired to do the same and perhaps start a conversation about mental illness in our culture. Everyone's experience is different, so what I say may not ring true for all, but this is what I have observed.

To begin with myself, I have generalized anxiety disorder and recurrent major depressive disorder. At one point I was given a potential diagnosis of borderline personality disorder, though diagnoses of this nature are often very difficult and subjective, so the jury never came to a verdict on that one. For those that do not have direct experience it might be illustrative to talk about symptoms. Physical symptoms for me that mental illness have caused or contributed to include, but are not limited to: muscle tension, shortness of breath, voice problems, panic attacks (inability to breathe, inability to move, uncontrollable shaking), skin problems, nausea, increased pain response, headaches, insomnia and fatigue. There are cognitive symptoms such as inability to concentrate, recurrent nightmares, racing thoughts and suicidal ideation. Sometimes my thoughts get stuck on a single topic for long periods of time. And I literally mean that there can be something at the forefront of my mind from the moment I wake up in the morning until the moment I fall asleep (and then appearing in my dreams) for days or even weeks. Behavioural effects are of course significant. I've experienced a lot of loss in my life as a result. And, notably, I have multiple suicide attempts in my past, the first of which was at the age of 10.

My experience is that there is a very slow shift in the attitude of our culture towards mental illness. As someone who has dealt with both anxiety and depression, I have noticed it has become socially acceptable to talk about and acknowledge anxiety in some contexts. But this is rarely true of other conditions. There is a prejudice in our culture about mental illness that runs so deep that most people do not even recognize it when it appears. A person cannot be blamed for not understanding a thing beyond their own experience, but there are many mistaken and insulting beliefs that are deeply ingrained in society, and that people work under without ever considering the possibility that they're wrong. To name some:
  1. Mental illness is a choice. People think this all the time. They see it as a lack of willpower, something you should be able to get rid of if you're smart/tough/resourceful enough. As with many health issues, you might have some control about how you deal with it and some ability to manage it, but you can't simply wish it away. No one would tell a person with cancer or a heart condition to simply get over it, yet they will say that to someone with depression. There is an irony here that we may actually have much more understanding of the controllable risk factors and treatment of many physical conditions.
  2. People with mental illness are bad people. This is in no small part perpetuated by a media culture that highlights episodes of violence by those suffering from mental illness. People with mental illness are no more or less prone to immoral or illegal acts than anyone else. The suffering of mental illness can lead to "compassion fatigue" but can also engender a great deal of empathy for the suffering of others.
  3. If a person has mental illness, you'll know it. Most of the time you won't. The stigma is so powerful that a person with mental illness usually learns many strategies to hide it.
  4. Asking someone if they are struggling or have thoughts of harming themselves will put ideas in their head. No one struggling with this needs someone else to put ideas in their head; the thoughts come all on their own.
  5. Suicide is an act of selfishness. A person who commits suicide is in so much pain that perhaps the most basic of all human instincts--to survive--is overwritten. Do we not recognize the hypocrisy in asking that person to take responsibility for the pain their death will cause others? I speak from personal experience when I say that I am often concerned with the burden my mental illness places on others and do my very best to accept the generosity of those who lend support while reciprocating with what I have to offer and contributing to society in general, a society that can often show a callous disregard for suffering--the equivalent of "shut up and deal." When a person dies from suicide it is a terrible tragedy, one that we only compound when we blame that person.

Many of these are actually perpetuated by a health care system that is under-equipped to deal with and overtaxed by mental health issues; I've had doctors repeat some of these very things to my face. In some cases I've encountered wonderfully sympathetic health care workers that show a genuine desire to provide the best possible treatment, but I've also encountered those who abuse patients by swearing at them, threatening them when they've taken no action to harm themselves or others, violating their rights by restraining them without cause or explanation, and the like. And I've seen those with little or no ability to empathize with the suffering of those they treat, either because they never had any or because it was worn away. I have little doubt that it is a difficult job, but I believe there are too many doing it who simply shouldn't be. For anyone experiencing mental illness who has experienced a significant improvement to quality of life through treatment, that is wonderful. For me, the system is a failure that has as often as not done more harm than good.

Personal relationships undergo a great deal of strain from mental illness. Many people simply cannot deal with being around it. The most common reactions in my experience are either to immediately withdraw when faced with it, or to put in a short effort to help and then withdraw when they realize how difficult it actually is. I have had the benefit of some extremely supportive people in my life, often those with mental illness themselves but occasionally those without lived experience but the motivation and ability to remain supportive, and I am very grateful for them. For anyone that knows someone struggling with mental illness, know that you do not have to be perfect. You will not always know what to do or what to say. But the effort to do and say count for so much on their own. Be present. Be there. Show that you care.

This has been my reality. I welcome others to share theirs.
 
It should be clear that I know it has been discussed before, given that you just linked the same thread that I linked in the OP. That is not a reason to not bring it up again. Especially as the context of this thread is different, being directed more specifically towards the attitudes of our culture towards mental illness.

Think of it this way: if someone raised the topic of sexism or racism based on their experience, would you dismiss it by saying it's been discussed before? And those are topics that have been at the fore of discussions about prejudice far more.
 
Fantastic post Roleplayer.

Mental illness is so underestimated. Even if you don't suffer from a mental illness yourself, chances are you know someone who does, even if you don't know they do.
Personally, I had a moderate case of social anxiety in my teens (likely on or about the same level as Daley), I found ways to overcome it as I progressed through my twenties. It's still there, but doesn't effect my life as it did previously.
Aside from that, I was fairly oblivious to mental illness, until a close relation of mine was diagnosed. The destructive path that set him on also set our entire family on fire. It saps everything from you. Happiness, time, money, attention, health...everything. Not just for the person with the illness, but for everyone close to them. It's a catastrophic epidemic that we are almost completely unequipped for in our healthcare system. And it's catching up with us.

I think #1 and #5 of your list of misconceptions are so important, because we've seen those opinions expressed here, particularly #5. I have to ask everyone, if you were kidnapped by a terrorist group and tortured daily for months or years on end, with little to no prospect of escape, would it make sense to call taking your life in that circumstance selfish because it'd make you close relations sad at your passing? I feel like those who say suicide is selfish have no concept of how painful mental illness can be.
 
Last edited:
Thanks rhuarc29. I think your analogy makes the point very well, and completely agree that such a statement represents a complete lack of understanding of the level of suffering involved.

#1 and #5 are definitely ones I have encountered a great deal. #4 (asking someone if they have thoughts of self-harm puts thoughts in their head) is one that I didn't realize existed until recently. It came from a conversation I had with a friend of mine who is a police officer. She explained that this was part of their training and that until that time she thought this herself. She has since suffered from PTSD and gone through suicidal episodes herself, and now knows firsthand that this isn't how it works. I think it's actually very important because the fear of doing or saying the wrong thing when a person in your life is suffering with mental illness can be a major reason people choose to withdraw rather than help. Dispelling this myth would encourage more people to take the risk of being "wrong" and connect with those in need. And ultimately the effort to be present counts far more than the particular way in which one tries to help, because isolation is one of the biggest threats of mental illness.

It occurred to me that another misconception is mental illness is a sign of immaturity. I've been referred to myself and seen others referred to as children because of anxiety, and told to grow up. It's a variation on the belief that mental illness is a choice.
 
Last edited:
It occurred to me that another misconception is mental illness is a sign of immaturity. I've been referred to myself and seen others referred to as children because of anxiety, and told to grow up. It's a variation on the belief that mental illness is a choice.

Similarly, people often equate depression with their own experiences of sadness...say, at the death of a loved one. They were eventually able to move on from such sadness, so why can't a person with depression? That's the mindset anyway. They don't seem to realize that grief and depression are two very different mental states.

On one level, you can understand that people try to relate to something based on their own experiences. But that often leads to the misconceptions you listed. A moment of fright does not equate to a recurring anxiety disorder, nor does a moment of grief equate to chronic depression.
 
Similarly, people often equate depression with their own experiences of sadness...say, at the death of a loved one. They were eventually able to move on from such sadness, so why can't a person with depression? That's the mindset anyway. They don't seem to realize that grief and depression are two very different mental states.

On one level, you can understand that people try to relate to something based on their own experiences. But that often leads to the misconceptions you listed. A moment of fright does not equate to a recurring anxiety disorder, nor does a moment of grief equate to chronic depression.

I think this is directly on point.

Sadness (even at its most extreme) =/= depression. There is certainly a relationship between them, but they are not the same thing. I've been through periods of depression that were not characterized by sadness, and I've had periods of time when I wasn't depressed but felt a great deal of sadness as a result of something happening. In my experience, when depression gets bad enough it will be accompanied with a deep sadness, but it might be more accurate to describe it as a feeling of emptiness.

Often the advice people receive when dealing with depression is to find things that give them joy. That might be good life advice in general, but it must be understood that in severe cases of depression you can't feel joy. The part of your brain that generates a sense of pleasure simply isn't working. This can come in stages; sometimes certain things in my life that normally give me joy are no longer providing that, but there are still a couple (for me, listening to my favourite music or being around the people I care about most) that do. In the worst moments of depression, even those last havens give me no pleasure. There is a kind of void left behind, and painful emotions (which might include sadness, or many other things) are what rushes in to fill that void, even without any apparent cause. Over time this leads to an emotional burnout or a rejection of emotion as a defense mechanism, leaving one with nothing but a sense of being hollow and inhuman. This is very difficult to explain to someone who may have experienced sadness—even of a deep and lasting nature—that has a “natural” rise and fall with events and that coexists with more "desirable" emotions such as joy, and is not representative of depression (though it may of course be very painful in itself).

This is similar to the advice that is pervasive throughout our culture to “be positive,” “always look on the bright side,” etc. Again, perhaps good life advice in general, but a person experiencing depression may simply have no capacity to do this. The part of the brain that generates hope, energy and a balance of thoughts between good and bad may simply shut down. But implicit—or sometimes explicit—in this advice is the attitude if you aren’t looking at the bright side then you are unwanted. One can perhaps imagine what this does to the psyche of a person already struggling with a sense of being isolated, lacking self-worth and/or feeling hopeless.

In the case of depression, advice of this nature is simply not likely to have the desired effect. Imagine you were walking around with a little devil over your shoulder that every few seconds whispered in your ear “purple elephants, purple elephants, purple elephants….” Having a single thought repeat itself with that frequency is enough in itself to drive you mad. Now if a person’s advice was “think about something other than purple elephants,” and the thing you subsequently told yourself was “think about something other than purple elephants,” how likely do you think it is that would help?

A more helpful response is acceptance—the recognition that a person feels this way and the willingness to be with a person feeling this way. That can generate a sense of safety and tolerance that may paradoxically provide an opening for other, more pleasurable emotions to return.
 
The thing about mental illnesses is they can often be treated by yourself. You know yourself best and you're on the scene 24/7. The brain is not a bone that can be broken; it can adapt and change over time. Of course brain damage is another story. The most important thing is that people realise the first and most effective treatment is self-help. The last thing you want to do is think it's not your responsibility to deal with it.
 
I thought carefully about how to respond to this.

The thing about mental illnesses is they can often be treated by yourself.

It depends what you mean by treatment, but this statement comes dangerously close to being just a rephrasing of "mental illness is a choice." I see a fine but important distinction between treatment and management, in the sense that a person can learn to cope with the symptoms of mental illness and lead a productive life with it, in some circumstances. But in general people can no more treat their mental illness by themselves than they could treat their heart condition by themselves. You might be able to manage the condition with lifestyle changes, medication and general resilience, but that doesn't necessarily mean you can alter the underlying issue, and in some cases no matter what you do the condition will significantly damage your health or even kill you. Access to proper care is vitally important, but there are many reasons why this is particularly difficult with mental illness:
  • The mental health care system is very difficult to navigate. It can be hard to find care at all. Wait times are often long. It is luck of the draw whether you find a good match between patient and caregiver, which is especially important here. Much of what treatment is available is not covered. Mental health issues continue to be very poorly understood and frequently misdiagnosed. Many mental health care providers are burnt out and cannot approach patients with the compassion their conditions require.
  • Treatment is often unpleasant in itself (to be fair, this is not unlike many other health concerns.) Medication for mental health conditions often have dramatic, pervasive side effects. Treatments such as exposure therapy likely exacerbate symptoms in the short term, and so often are in direct contradiction to a person's instinctual response.
  • Mental health conditions very likely diminish the exact capabilities needed to effectively manage them. This notably includes the ability to recognize that one has a health condition at all.
  • There is a lot of stigma associated with mental illness. This has ripple effects through one's interpersonal and professional relationships, takes an emotional toll and worsens pragmatic concerns.
Look, I absolutely agree that a person dealing with mental illness cannot abdicate responsibility for their own care. There are few people in my personal life that I feel comfortable talking to about this (there are three, and they know who they are), but I make it a point to clearly state that I am not looking for them to fix this for me. It's not their responsibility, and they couldn't even if it was. But I think people might be surprised to learn how adamantly those suffering with mental illness learn not to rely on anyone else for support, because you are likely going to be very disappointed very quickly and very often if you do. People suffering with mental illness have the responsibility to care for themselves; society has a responsibility to treat them with dignity and consideration--as it does with all its members--but has often come up far short of the mark. While another health concern is viewed as an unfortunate but natural challenge a person faces in life, a mental health concern is too often viewed as a character flaw. As a rule, people should think very carefully before treating a mental illness as wholly different from another illness; certainly true in some ways, but certainly not true in others. Which brings me to this:

The brain is not a bone that can be broken; it can adapt and change over time.
Tell that to someone with PTSD. Yes, the brain adapts and changes over time. The belief held not too long ago that the brain is largely fixed by adulthood is falling away as we come to understand neuroplasticity. While that means it is possible to respond positively to challenges, it also means the brain can rewire itself in ways that are detrimental. It can be damaged in both acute and chronic ways. When a bone breaks it generally needs to be set and then have a cast applied so the body's natural healing process can do its work properly; if only we knew more about how to "set" and "cast" the brain when it is broken.
 
Look, I absolutely agree that a person dealing with mental illness cannot abdicate responsibility for their own care.

This is very important. Just as someone without mental illness can have misconceptions about it, so too can someone with a mental illness. I've seen a tendency from some to succumb to feeling like a victim, and placing all responsibility for a "cure" on either their doctors or family members. There are two things wrong with this line of thinking. Firstly, I'm still not convinced there is a cure-all for mental illness to begin with; it's more about managing and overcoming limitations. Secondly, managing a mental illness effectively takes major effort on the part of the sufferer, so if they're looking for a magic pill from their practitioners, they're going to fail. Medication, therapy, etc., are only half the solution.

So in that way I think mmouse's post is half accurate: it IS your responsibility to deal with it. That said, it is NOT your responsibility to deal with it alone, and I'd suggest anyone who is suffering should go out and seek the available help.
 
The stigma is the problem. There was a time in my life when I would have casually described someone as "crazy". Now I understand that that word is the same as a racial epithet. It only took me 40 years to realize that "sanity" is a continuum, and I am not the poster child for it. I wouldn't ever have had any empathy for people whose reality doesn't match mine until I realized it and, as I said, it took 40 years to sink in. All that said, how do we deal with it? Understanding, encouragement, and a thoughtful approach to what it means to be a human being.
 
This is very important. Just as someone without mental illness can have misconceptions about it, so too can someone with a mental illness. I've seen a tendency from some to succumb to feeling like a victim, and placing all responsibility for a "cure" on either their doctors or family members. There are two things wrong with this line of thinking. Firstly, I'm still not convinced there is a cure-all for mental illness to begin with; it's more about managing and overcoming limitations. Secondly, managing a mental illness effectively takes major effort on the part of the sufferer, so if they're looking for a magic pill from their practitioners, they're going to fail. Medication, therapy, etc., are only half the solution.

So in that way I think mmouse's post is half accurate: it IS your responsibility to deal with it. That said, it is NOT your responsibility to deal with it alone, and I'd suggest anyone who is suffering should go out and seek the available help.

A number of things to reply to here.

When it comes to a cure-all for mental illness, I am quite convinced there isn't one. Depending on the nature of the illness, it may pass with time. Or it may not. Either way you do the best you can to maintain quality of life.

While sometimes people are looking for the quick fix, it is hard to blame them when they are desperately looking for an escape from suffering (which in turn of course potentially leads to maladaptive coping mechanisms.) And this is just as true with other illnesses; ask a health care worker how often a patient wants to fix a diagnosis right away with a pill or surgery and see what response you get.

But I especially want to highlight the notion that someone with mental illness can have misconceptions about it. I would actually go further and say they almost certainly will have misconceptions about it. I alluded to this earlier, but mental illness often does an extraordinarily good job of hiding itself from the sufferer, because the illness can normalize itself by skewing your perception of reality. It convinces you that its effects are not an illness, but simply a reflection of the way things really are. This often comes with shame, guilt, and a low sense of self-worth, which can generate a reinforcing cycle with the judgments of society. Mental illness also generally doesn't just appear one day; it grows over time, and like a cancer it will probably have been there a while before the effects become apparent to anyone. I've been in and out of depression enough times that I've gotten pretty good at recognizing the signs one is coming even months in advance, though that doesn't necessarily mean I can do anything about it, and sometimes I just don't see it coming. It can be incredibly difficult to understand what is happening to you. In my OP, I chose to include the fact I attempted suicide at 10 to highlight that sometimes a person suffering from mental illness is helpless against it. I defy anyone to think it right to tell that little boy he was weak or selfish because he wanted to die if they could go back in time to do so. I simply had no means to comprehend what was transpiring or what to do about it. Looking back now, I know I was in a depression then and for three years after, and I effectively went through it with no treatment at all. I had no tools to deal with my illness or with the judgment that came at me from peers and adults.

And that's why the advice to get help is so important. With luck, you will be able to work with (a) health care professional(s) to improve your quality of life. Just be prepared for ups and downs, a variety of approaches that may or may not work, and the need to advocate for yourself.



The stigma is the problem. There was a time in my life when I would have casually described someone as "crazy". Now I understand that that word is the same as a racial epithet. It only took me 40 years to realize that "sanity" is a continuum, and I am not the poster child for it. I wouldn't ever have had any empathy for people whose reality doesn't match mine until I realized it and, as I said, it took 40 years to sink in. All that said, how do we deal with it? Understanding, encouragement, and a thoughtful approach to what it means to be a human being.
When used as a pejorative, I agree 'crazy' can be every bit as hateful and damaging as other epithets that demean a group of people. As for how we deal with it, what you said implicitly is just as valuable as what you said explicitly: suspending one's preconceived judgments and evolving one's understanding with a compassionate frame of mind.
 
Well, I've heard much of alternative ways to fight the depression. Some docs say that CBD oil and anxiety can't live together. They use that stuff to help rumors despair. I wonder if this oil really helps or it's just rumours.
 
The thing about mental illnesses is they can often be treated by yourself. You know yourself best and you're on the scene 24/7. The brain is not a bone that can be broken; it can adapt and change over time. Of course brain damage is another story. The most important thing is that people realise the first and most effective treatment is self-help. The last thing you want to do is think it's not your responsibility to deal with it.

Oh for sure. Bi-polar and schizophrenia suffers just need some self help. Dr. Phil books and such. :rolleyes:
 
I've had problems with social anxiety and panic attacks. Been accused by certain people of being schizophrenic or 'crazy'. My doctor said that I'm actually one of the most sane people she knows.
 
Well, I've heard much of alternative ways to fight the depression. Some docs say that CBD oil and anxiety can't live together. They use that stuff to help rumors despair. I wonder if this oil really helps or it's just rumours.

Labeling something as alternative already has negative connotations because it equates it to "snake oil" type remedies. I don't know anything about CBD, so the moment you said "alternative" I had to resist the urge to discard its usefulness outright.
 
  1. Mental illness is a choice. People think this all the time. They see it as a lack of willpower, something you should be able to get rid of if you're smart/tough/resourceful enough. As with many health issues, you might have some control about how you deal with it and some ability to manage it, but you can't simply wish it away. No one would tell a person with cancer or a heart condition to simply get over it, yet they will say that to someone with depression. There is an irony here that we may actually have much more understanding of the controllable risk factors and treatment of many physical conditions.
  2. People with mental illness are bad people. This is in no small part perpetuated by a media culture that highlights episodes of violence by those suffering from mental illness. People with mental illness are no more or less prone to immoral or illegal acts than anyone else. The suffering of mental illness can lead to "compassion fatigue" but can also engender a great deal of empathy for the suffering of others.
  3. If a person has mental illness, you'll know it. Most of the time you won't. The stigma is so powerful that a person with mental illness usually learns many strategies to hide it.
  4. Asking someone if they are struggling or have thoughts of harming themselves will put ideas in their head. No one struggling with this needs someone else to put ideas in their head; the thoughts come all on their own.
  5. Suicide is an act of selfishness. A person who commits suicide is in so much pain that perhaps the most basic of all human instincts--to survive--is overwritten. Do we not recognize the hypocrisy in asking that person to take responsibility for the pain their death will cause others? I speak from personal experience when I say that I am often concerned with the burden my mental illness places on others and do my very best to accept the generosity of those who lend support while reciprocating with what I have to offer and contributing to society in general, a society that can often show a callous disregard for suffering--the equivalent of "shut up and deal." When a person dies from suicide it is a terrible tragedy, one that we only compound when we blame that person.

1- Mental Illness itself is not a choice; the issue is *EVERYTHING* is being called a mental illness these days. Although I kind of snicker at the response you quote for cancer or heart conditions because for most of them they ARE told get over it. Don't sit around sulking they were dealt a bad hand in life and enjoy what they have.

* I also have a very strong dislike for how every kid these days is suddenly ADHD or Autistic or whatever the school decides to call them

2- I can't think of anyone ever saying a person with a mental illness is a bad person (besides the obvious fake mental illness to get anything from sympathy to acquittal in a court room)

3- Very skeptical that any real mental illness is not obvious.

4-

5- Most suicides have nothing to do with a mental illness. Most are people giving up on life (again from your first example, a cancer patient could certainly prefer suicide over chemo, there is no mental illness here). You need to seperate these threads; a person with mental illness could choose suicide as a way out, but the illness itself in no way pushes them towards that way out (no diff than your #4 example, talking to someone about harming themself in no way makes them harm themself, same here, a mental illness itself does not cause a suicidal thought)
 
You may have these opinions TeeJay, but many of them are just plain wrong and representative of the prejudiced culture that I'm talking about. They are as offensive as if you came here to insult people based on their race or sexuality.

1- Mental Illness itself is not a choice; the issue is *EVERYTHING* is being called a mental illness these days. Although I kind of snicker at the response you quote for cancer or heart conditions because for most of them they ARE told get over it. Don't sit around sulking they were dealt a bad hand in life and enjoy what they have.

This hasn't been my experience, at least not in the same way that people respond to mental illness, but perhaps it has been yours and that's fair enough.

2- I can't think of anyone ever saying a person with a mental illness is a bad person (besides the obvious fake mental illness to get anything from sympathy to acquittal in a court room)

Then I suggest you pay more attention to the cultural attitudes surrounding mental illness. While people generally don't say "you have mental illness hence you are a bad person" in such an explicit way, referencing mental illness and insulting someone in the same breath is ubiquitous. People make the connection all the time, though I'm quite sure they frequently don't realize they're doing it. Again, because the prejudice against mental illness is so deep that it usually isn't recognized as prejudice.

3- Very skeptical that any real mental illness is not obvious.

Some time ago when I was doing my first degree, I was sitting in a class in which the professor raised the question of whether a person would see a doctor if they had a mental illness. There was a large number of very interesting (read: ignorant) responses, one of which was "I never really interact with people with mental illness." This was at York University, where you associate with hundreds of people every day. How likely was it that among hundreds of people, none of them had a serious mental illness that one simply wasn't aware of? There are many, many reasons why you could be around someone with serious mental illness and not know it, not the least of which is that we learn to hide it.

5- Most suicides have nothing to do with a mental illness. Most are people giving up on life (again from your first example, a cancer patient could certainly prefer suicide over chemo, there is no mental illness here). You need to seperate these threads; a person with mental illness could choose suicide as a way out, but the illness itself in no way pushes them towards that way out (no diff than your #4 example, talking to someone about harming themself in no way makes them harm themself, same here, a mental illness itself does not cause a suicidal thought)

Wow. I'm sorry, but, wow. You think mental illness isn't connected to suicide?

Years ago a friend of mine from high school committed suicide. He had no previous history of mental illness, until he was prescribed some different medications to treat multiple health issues. Someone didn't do their homework, and there was a severe drug interaction resulting in an acute case of depression and suicidal ideation. He was dead within a couple of weeks.

Mental illnesses affect the manner in which one thinks (kinda by definition) and many of them have a very high comorbidity with suicidal ideation. You want to be extremely careful with the terms "way out" and "choose suicide." The person I just referenced had no choice. Using the term "way out" is also reminiscent of a society that thinks suicide is the "easy way out," which is so much nonsense it boggles the mind (and yet many believe it). No one who has experienced acting to bring about their own death would dare associate the word easy with it. It's incredibly painful.

The problem here is that so much of what you're saying amounts to claiming mental illness isn't real, which is extremely offensive.
 
Last edited: