Is the housing bubble about to burst

......................
Today’s immigrants are larger users of the welfare state and contribute less to the countries GDP. And less willing to assimilate into Canadiana. Thats the 30 thousand view from the top. This is a result of governments proactively encouraging this out of some moralistic reason. Or maybe there IS a hidden agenda here! .............


I think the GDP was actually boosted in the short run. More migrants, permanent
and non-permanent, led to higher housing and rental cost, higher revenue for colleges
and universities as well as more government and consumer spending. The hidden
agenda is for the Liberals to show voters good performance by pointing to a rising GDP.
 
When You Import the Third World , You Become the Third World! Not a racist saying. It’s a cultural difference that has a direct effect on the fabric of a country. Today’s immigrants are larger users of the welfare state and contribute less to the countries GDP. And less willing to assimilate into Canadiana. Thats the 30 thousand view from the top. This is a result of governments proactively encouraging this out of some moralistic reason. Or maybe there IS a hidden agenda here! (Don’t want to be conspiratorial but hard not to draw certain conclusions). The sentiment in Canada as to where the country is headed is brutal and very sad. Social Media is on fire with people posting how bad it is and that people should simply leave. Better opportunities for a good life elsewhere.

Just like when we let all those Irish in. Canada has never recovered. Look at those slovenly Mic Monkeys.


1767716442125.png
 
I think the GDP was actually boosted in the short run. More migrants, permanent
and non-permanent, led to higher housing and rental cost, higher revenue for colleges
and universities as well as more government and consumer spending. The hidden
agenda is for the Liberals to show voters good performance by pointing to a rising GDP.
Rising GDP but decreasing GDP per capita. Decreasing productivity. Increasing unemployment. Increasing inflation. Increasing taxes. Increasing food insecurity. Increasing debt. A markedly decreased standard of living for the every day Canadian. This is a horrible legacy started by a low IQ PM with nice hair and colorful socks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MatureMan
No you are wrong. It is exactly mass uncontrolled immigration.
]

^^^^^ Here. Since Trudeau got elected the numbers skyrocketed. Canada did well with 1 percent population growth but when Trudeau came especially since covid, the numbers went to over 3 percent which was total madness.

]
^^^^ In 2024 they published this article as to how Canada’s population increased by one million in 9 months. The data does not lie.
Why does population increase automatically mean “uncontrolled mass immigration”?
Population growth and a reduction in median age are explicit goals of Canadian immigration policy due to an aging population and shrinking workforce.
Accordingly, targets were set and achieved.
That is controlled immigration.
Just because you do not like the numbers does not make it “uncontrolled”.
He lowered the barriers
Lowering barriers is the correct approach.
You want qualified immigrants to enter legally rather than resort to illegal immigration like in the US.
Trudeau lowered barriers while maintaining a robust immigrant selection system.
Canada uses points based selection for permanent residents and job offer based selection for temporary foreign workers.
This is basic policy reality.
As for pensions and social services, then why give full immigration to the retired parents of recent arrivals??? Does not make much sense to me and contradicts what you said.
No it does not. You are simply unfamiliar with the data.
Family reunification has measurable economic benefits to Canada.
https://www.cicnews.com/2020/10/the...parents-and-grandparents-program-1016022.html
There is a strong economic case in favour of the Parents and Grandparents Program.
Research shows parents and grandparents contribute to household income, increase purchasing power, and enable higher workforce participation by providing child care.
Immigrant family homeownership rates are comparable to Canadian born families at around 70 percent.
...then why bring in hundreds of thousands of asylum seekers to give them a free hotel and monthly paychecks?
Asylum seekers are the worst type of immigrants to bring in. I call them gimmegrants. They are here for freebies such as free hotels, monthly paychecks, subsidized housing, and cellphones.
Canada has binding international obligations to accept asylum seekers.
Not all asylum seekers qualify for financial assistance.
Those who do receive minimal temporary support, generally limited to 12 months.
Asylum seekers are not the worst type of immigrants. That is a false narrative.
Refugees show comparable long term outcomes to native born Canadians and higher rates of entrepreneurship.
https://www.unhcr.ca/wp-content/upl...anadian-Refugee-Integration-November-2019.pdf
Canada has moved away from the points based system.
No we have not. Why are you lying?
https://www.canada.ca/en/immigratio...migrate-canada/express-entry/check-score.html
We are bringing in way more people than houses can be built.
We need to keep building until inventory exceeds demand so prices drop.
You are hilariously naive about how economics actually works.
Canada has structurally underbuilt housing relative to population growth for decades.
Housing construction depends on demand.
When population growth slows, investment slows, projects get cancelled, and supply tightens further.
Immigration supports housing construction by sustaining rental and ownership demand.
Why would an investor buy housing or builders build housing for people who do not exist?
Builders are not idiots who will blindly flood the market while demand weakens.
Look at the real estate market right now.
Your entire post is built on ignorance.
 
7) the immigrant angle again, is effecting government policy and how Canadians are being taxed to support those policies. That is the true impact of the immigration. Its effect on affordability is the burden on Canadians with taxes and other policies which drive inflation in the cost of life !
Not sure I understand this bit.
Are you saying immigration increases taxes?
 
No you are wrong. It is exactly mass uncontrolled immigration.


^^^^^ Here. Since Trudeau got elected the numbers skyrocketed. Canada did well with 1% population growth but when Trudeau came especially since covid, the numbers went to over 3% which was total madness.


^^^^ In 2024 they published this article as to how Canada's population increased by one million in 9 months. The data does not lie.



I know, like I said Trudeau opened the floodgates. He lowered the barriers and made it easy for any to get in for the Century Initiative, a crooked organization that is there to make the rich more richer. As for pensions and social services, then why give full immigration to the retired parents of recent arrivals??? Does not make much sense to me and contradicts what you said. Social services, then why bring in hundreds of thousands of asylum seekers to give them a free hotel and monthly paychecks? Ford apparently asked the Federal government for $1 billion last year for asylum seekers. They also get universal healthcare and taxpayers get the bill. Canada is under serious debt, we cannot afford this.

No we don't.



Are you joking??? Or did you smoke too much? I dunno. Canada has moved away from the points based system. As I said before, Trudeau opened the floodgates. Asylum seekers are the worst type of immigrants to bring in. I call them gimmegrants. That is what I call them because they are here to get the freebies. The free hotels, the free monthly paychecks, subsidized housing, cellphones, etc.. Stop the freebies, and if asylum seekers had to pay for everything like the average Canadian watch their numbers drop. Furthermore most of them are fake refugees, they just want to the freebies. We need doctors, engineers, lawyers. Not Uber drives and asylum seekers who have 5+ kids to get free money.



You sound like Carney's current crooked housing minister. No, it is not just about building more houses, the two are interrelated. We are bringing in way more people then houses can be built. Look at it this way, imagine pouring water into a glass with a hole, now you keep on pouring water to keep it full. But to keep the glass full you need to close the hole. Same principal. Trudeau brought in so many people, there needs to be a moratorium on it for a good five years. Then investors need incentives to build more housing. We need to keep building till the inventory is more then demand, when you achieve that prices will drop. Also, people come to Canada for the dream to own a single detached home with a backyard and more like the wide open spaces. No one voted to live in overprices cramped condos, with traffic everywhere and taking the bus and subway. That is not the life most people want yet garbage like Trudeau is bringing that to Canada.

But they will not do it because it does not benefit the rich. The greedy corporations, real estate, rich people, politicians want rapid population growth. It makes them richer while making the average joe working a job poorer. How many people in Toronto are working 80hr workweeks just to pay for the overprices rent or mortgage? Does not make sense. Canada has a serious productivity crisis and it will never be solved till the housing crisis is solved. Just piling more and more people to make the GDP grow and show to the world that Canada is doing well is not the solution.

like you said, there needs to be an incentive for developers to build, so if immigration slows down, so will builds.

now they're making apartments instead as they make more sense in today's market.

even if PP wins the next election, I wouldn't expect a moratorium on immigration, only the People's Party of Canada will do that (but they'll never win)

you have a valid point regarding the financialization of housing ; think Trump just announced today that he wants to ban institutional investors from buying single-family homes. i think that's a good idea and actually needs to go a step further and apply to all types of housing.

at this point, if youre trying to buy a place, you gotta just focus on making more money and invest


 
Rate hikes would almost certainly collapse the housing market.

OTOH I am afraid we will be facing worsening inflation.
 
Rate hikes would almost certainly collapse the housing market.

OTOH I am afraid we will be facing worsening inflation.


Cars are expensive esp used cars are INSANE. (several years of low pandemic production has crushed the fleet and high prices and supply chain disruptions ensure we never rebuilt it. So used car prices remain high and the fleet ages on. Restaurants are also expensive. Some foods are pricy but some are cheaper. I have been buying Honey for 5.99 a KG that is super cheap!! Some amazing deals still to be had . Rents are down, gas seems low. So where is the inflation other then those 3 things I don't see a ton of it TBH. I bought a shitload of clothes from old navy to flip my casual clothes, some stuff from Temu and Ali, a few items from Amazon. Very happy with the pricing in general.
 
Can the Commercial Real Estate market get some spotlight too


Restaurants going out of business will only help deflate that industry. If you do hybrid work-from-home, it's probably over in 2026.
 
As with all things financial, there are multiple issues at play here. The housing market has definitely burst and will likely stay depressed for the next 4-5 years and be flat for the next 10. Un affordability has been talked about for 40 years. I remember in early 2000s , the same arguments were being made, why does a house cost $500k when in 1980 that same house was $150k. The issue is the wage gap to housing cost. When people made $30k and a house cost $150k (5X wage gap ratio) that’s affordable. When today people make 90k and a house cost over $1M, thats 10X + wage gap ratio. Unaffordable! The scam is the interest rate. Everything is framed in a monthly payment context. And not in an overall investment context. The equity growth that has been experienced was the bubble or game of musical chairs. Whoever got out early, got lucky. New buyers are left holding the bag. The real estate investment thesis being a good one is OVER.

An earlier messaged said that anyone under 40 should consider leveling Canada. I actually very much agree with that. Canada has a sad future unfortunately. Shrinking opportunities, Difficult for entrepreneurs. Government is a constant weight on your ability to have a nice life because of taxes, beaurocracy and sentiment. The world is a big place , there are much better opportunities in Asia, Eastern Europe and even Dubai. But you gotta be brave and start thinking out of the box !
I can rant in this for a while , but don’t want to sound depressing 😂. I do however speak from some life experience and clear foresight.
It's very difficult to not become a doomsayer, but how can you not when looking at the facts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HungSowel
Not sure I understand this bit.
Are you saying immigration increases taxes?
It increases spending so that's funded either through increased taxes or increased debt.
 
Can the Commercial Real Estate market get some spotlight too


Restaurants going out of business will only help deflate that industry. If you do hybrid work-from-home, it's probably over in 2026.
Yes. I have a couple friends who were working hybrid 3 days in the office 2 days at home. They have now been ordered back 5 days. One of them gets to take 24 work from home days per year.
 
It increases tax revenue.
Not marginal tax rate.
That's a myth. The reality is that immigration has cost taxpayers net billions of dollars. About $5,300 per immigrant per year. This was from late 2000's.

Since then I'd say that $5,300 per immigrant has ballooned significantly. I've read that asylum seekers are given about $80K annually in gov't benefits for shelter, food, clothing and communications. That's about 3 times what an annual welfare recipient receives. It wouldn't surprise me if someone told me the net annual cost of immigration to Canada is approaching $50B per year.
 
That's a myth. The reality is that immigration has cost taxpayers net billions of dollars. About $5,300 per immigrant per year. This was from late 2000's.

Since then I'd say that $5,300 per immigrant has ballooned significantly. I've read that asylum seekers are given about $80K annually in gov't benefits for shelter, food, clothing and communications. That's about 3 times what an annual welfare recipient receives. It wouldn't surprise me if someone told me the net annual cost of immigration to Canada is approaching $50B per year.
Read the article.
It’s a static snapshot, not a lifetime analysis.
Immigrants are younger, use far less services, especially healthcare, and pay taxes for decades longer than citizens who are older. The article fails to consider this.
It also assumes average government spending, which overstates costs since much of the spending is fixed or age-related.
It makes the ridiculous claim that lower income means fiscal burden.
It ignores the counterfactual: without immigration, the tax base shrinks and costs rise without the revenue to address it.
As such this article is a partisan opinion piece, based on erroneous assumptions and not reflective of actual real world data.
PS: You owe me a $100 by the way for chickening out of the bet after throwing down the gauntlet.
 
Carney must have done the wrong thing by cutting immigration. Now
we are facing a $70--80 billion deficit in the year to come.
 
Read the article.
It’s a static snapshot, not a lifetime analysis.
Immigrants are younger, use far less services, especially healthcare, and pay taxes for decades longer than citizens who are older. The article fails to consider this.
It also assumes average government spending, which overstates costs since much of the spending is fixed or age-related.
It makes the ridiculous claim that lower income means fiscal burden.
It ignores the counterfactual: without immigration, the tax base shrinks and costs rise without the revenue to address it.
As such this article is a partisan opinion piece, based on erroneous assumptions and not reflective of actual real world data.
PS: You owe me a $100 by the way for chickening out of the bet after throwing down the gauntlet.
You clearly don't understand what you are saying. Especially in the two statements that I bolded. The study shows that there is a NET cost to immigration. And to call it partisan is ignorant. Look at the authors backgrounds and research methods before you throw that out there.
As far as the bet is concerned I didn't chicken out. Did you agree to my terms?
 
Carney must have done the wrong thing by cutting immigration. Now
we are facing a $70--80 billion deficit in the year to come.
Or maybe we would have been facing a $90-$100B deficit if he didn't cut it.
 
You clearly don't understand what you are saying. Especially in the two statements that I bolded. The study shows that there is a NET cost to immigration. And to call it partisan is ignorant. Look at the authors backgrounds and research methods before you throw that out there.
The two bolded statements are factual.
The “net cost” in that research is calculated as lower income and lower taxes paid versus average services consumed.
However, averages are the wrong central tendency for services consumed, since they are heavily skewed by seniors.
Likewise, younger immigrants earning less is expected, as they are earlier in their careers. That is precisely what we want: young working professionals.
Using their lower incomes without accounting for career stage, while assigning them average service costs inflated by seniors, is partisan. It is a clear fumbling of the numbers.
This is the kind of opinion pieces that will not be allowed in our NYC bet should you choose to take it.
As far as the bet is concerned I didn't chicken out. Did you agree to my terms?
You dont get to set terms.
You threw down the gauntlet and in your own words, asked anyone to "name their price", which I did.
You cannot add terms after the fact.
Even so, I agreed to everything else except the signatures because I do not have one, and I hide everyone else's as well.
You seem to have gotten cold feet.