Is the housing bubble about to burst

Immigration is not slowing down enough, we need a 5 year moratorium on it. Asylum seekers are still being allowed to enter in record numbers. Free hotels and monthly paychecks. Agreed for those days are gone thanks to Trudeau.
If immigration is the issue you want to discuss, not sure what you are doing on a housing thread.
That said, Canada's population has declined by 76K in the last quarter.
So saying immigration isn't slowing down is objectively false.
Also this will prove disastrous for the real estate market.
2026 will be worse than 2025.
However, I do believe this will be better for first time home buyers.
 
If immigration is the issue you want to discuss, not sure what you are doing on a housing thread.
That said, Canada's population has declined by 76K in the last quarter.
So saying immigration isn't slowing down is objectively false.
Also this will prove disastrous for the real estate market.
2026 will be worse than 2025.
However, I do believe this will be better for first time home buyers.
Mass uncontrolled immigration is the direct cause of unaffordable rents and homes. This thread is about housing. Lol 76k is breadcrumbs. There are 5 million temporary residents that should be gone. We need a 5 million drop in population, at the same time they are bringing in the worst type of immigrants, asylum seekers. It is a disaster for the young generation who want to own their own home and the average joe working a job. Liberals are catering to the owner class and wealthy.
 
Mass uncontrolled immigration is the direct cause of unaffordable rents and homes.
No there is no mass uncontrolled immigration in Canada.
Numbers are set by the federal government.
This thread is about housing. Lol 76k is breadcrumbs. There are 5 million temporary residents that should be gone.
No the 5M temporary residents are here legally, working in jobs, paying taxes, renting condos.
Sending them out is both illegal and will crash not just real estate but the economy and send us into a recession.
Not to mention affect our pensions and social services.
We need a 5 million drop in population,
No we don't.
at the same time they are bringing in the worst type of immigrants, asylum seekers.
No we bring in the best type of immigrants. We have a points system.
Even the temp workers who come here to work in low paying jobs, do their jobs well.
The vast majority immigrants who come here are lawful, do not commit crimes and are successful.
Asylum seekers are also legal immigrants who are a net positive.
It is a disaster for the young generation who want to own their own home and the average joe working a job.
Yes because of 2 primary issues.
a) Not building enough housing.
b) Allowing real estate investors, particularly foreign investors run amok.
 
No there is no mass uncontrolled immigration in Canada.
Numbers are set by the federal government.

No the 5M temporary residents are here legally, working in jobs, paying taxes, renting condos.
Sending them out is both illegal and will crash not just real estate but the economy and send us into a recession.
Not to mention affect our pensions and social services.

No we don't.

No we bring in the best type of immigrants. We have a points system.
Even the temp workers who come here to work in low paying jobs, do their jobs well.
The vast majority immigrants who come here are lawful, do not commit crimes and are successful.
Asylum seekers are also legal immigrants who are a net positive.

Yes because of 2 primary issues.
a) Not building enough housing.
b) Allowing real estate investors, particularly foreign investors run amok.

The fed govt definitely overdid it with immigration, but part of the blame also goes to the provinces, esp Ontario, where , in 2019, the prov govt created a program to increase international students (1), presumably since the prov govt wanted international tuition to make up for the 10 percent cut in domestic tuition (2), and thus the province wouldn't need to pony up the funds.

those are indeed ultimately the two underlying issues:

1) financialization of housing - how much foreigners have an impact is debatable (3,4), but regardless, if there is an attractive price, there will be a wealthy investor (or investors, or company) to scoop it up (5)

2) I'd argue there IS sufficient supply, but INsufficient supply of AFFORDABLE housing.

the thing people often overlook is that, developers aren't obviously in the charity business, so they're not going to build (like right now where housing starts are slow in Ontario) just for the sake of building (6)

eg it's a catch-22, if there is slowing immigration, investors aren't as willing to buy new builds, so developers are going to be wary to build if there arent willing buyers (since you need 70 percent or so of units to be sold to get financing for the project).

so, for example, in Ontario, right now market conditions are such that rental-housing makes more sense than condos and developers have converted existing condo projects as such (6,7)

affordable housing requires government intervention (lots of subsidies), so i wouldn't bet on this being built on a massive scale.

(1) https://news.ontario.ca/en/release/54568/ontario-supports-innovative-college-partnerships

(2) https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/international-student-study-permits-data-1.7125827

(3) https://archive.ph/2025.08.30-00101...rs-foreign-buyers-debate-housing-real-estate/


(4) https://betterdwelling.com/canadian-real-estate-investors-captured-nearly-75-of-ownership-growth/


(5)https://www.cp24.com/local/toronto/...o-faster-than-other-types-of-landlords-study/

(6)https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/ontario-new-home-projections-slowing-down-9.6969568

(7)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
Mass uncontrolled immigration is the direct cause of unaffordable rents and homes. This thread is about housing. Lol 76k is breadcrumbs. There are 5 million temporary residents that should be gone. We need a 5 million drop in population, at the same time they are bringing in the worst type of immigrants, asylum seekers. It is a disaster for the young generation who want to own their own home and the average joe working a job. Liberals are catering to the owner class and wealthy.




Developers and the oligopolies in Canada are so vested in immigration that I wonder how long this "slowdown" will go on.
The problem for a city like Toronto is that we also have NIMBYS and a greenbelt. Not saying to get rid of the greenbelt but the environmentalists will say there is lots of land - if we build on top of libraries and subway stations. Neptis Foundation also includes wetlands and ravines, as well as land intended for business use and residential land that’s already making its way through the planning process as land available.

AI Overview

Canada's immigration rate is
approximately three to four times higher than that of the United States on a per capita basis. While the U.S. accepts a higher absolute number of immigrants due to its much larger population, Canada welcomes a far greater share relative to its total population size.

Per Capita Comparison
The key difference is the scale of each country's population: the U.S. population is roughly nine times larger than Canada's.
  • Canada: In recent years, Canada's immigration rate has stood at nearly 1.2% of its population annually (e.g., 437,120 permanent residents in 2022 with a population around 38 million).
  • United States: The U.S. typically admits around 1.1 million legal permanent residents per year. This equates to a rate of about 0.3% of its population.
When data from 2019 was used for comparison, Canada admitted more than three times the ratio of new permanent residents per 1,000 people compared to the U.S.. Projections for 2025 indicated a rate of 12.5 immigrants per 1,000 residents for Canada, versus 3.0 for the U.S., about four times as many per capita.

Below is from 2017 when we had more land. lol

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: CLOUD 500
1) financialization of housing - how much foreigners have an impact is debatable (3,4), but regardless, if there is an attractive price, there will be a wealthy investor (or investors, or company) to scoop it up (5)
The problem so far in my opinion has been investors buying pre-construction condos and then flipping them before completion and taking home the spread.
This ends up artificially inflated housing prices and rent.
The majority of these condos are cookie cutter, shoe boxes that no body wants to live in.
The only ones to buy it are investors who rent it out and the only ones renting it out are newcomers to Canada.
With a declining population, and reduction of immigration, this is going to prove a disaster in the coming months.
I think allowing foreign investors was a huge mistake in the first place and am happy the ban is in place.
.....INsufficient supply of AFFORDABLE housing.
To qualify it, it is affordable housing, that people want to LIVE in.
What we have are scores of cookie cutter, poorly built, shoeboxes that are only good to rent.
So we are going to see a reduction in condo prices, increase in foreclosures, and a reduction in rent in 2026 and perhaps even in 2027.
But the other segments of the market - freeholds, older buildings with better floor plans, more sqft etc may fare much better. But some of these are still unaffordable.
And, the current market will also benefit first time home buyers who are looking to buy a condo to live in, and potentially hold the property for another 5 to 7 years.
 
The problem so far in my opinion has been investors buying pre-construction condos and then flipping them before completion and taking home the spread.
This ends up artificially inflated housing prices and rent.
The majority of these condos are cookie cutter, shoe boxes that no body wants to live in.
The only ones to buy it are investors who rent it out and the only ones renting it out are newcomers to Canada.
With a declining population, and reduction of immigration, this is going to prove a disaster in the coming months.
I think allowing foreign investors was a huge mistake in the first place and am happy the ban is in place.


To qualify it, it is affordable housing, that people want to LIVE in.
What we have are scores of cookie cutter, poorly built, shoeboxes that are only good to rent.
So we are going to see a reduction in condo prices, increase in foreclosures, and a reduction in rent in 2026 and perhaps even in 2027.
But the other segments of the market - freeholds, older buildings with better floor plans, more sqft etc may fare much better. But some of these are still unaffordable.
And, the current market will also benefit first time home buyers who are looking to buy a condo to live in, and potentially hold the property for another 5 to 7 years.

hence why developers are focusing/converting condos to purpose-built rentals instead

developers are in the business of maximizing profits

if you want below
-market aka affordable housing, that will be at the expense at taxpayers' dollars , period (cause it's below market, lol)

if there's a massive crash, which woild entail a great recession , who's gonna scoop most of the properties asap ? largely institutions, certainly not your average mom-and-pop investor, who likely would capitulate
 
Another couple article I wasn't going to post, but since we are talking might as well.



I think it's almost a certain foreign money will be leverage to help stabilize the housing market by 2027. The current housing minister was the former Mayor of Vancouver (Crazy right?). So we have some idea of how this will be handled.
 
Another couple article I wasn't going to post, but since we are talking might as well.



I think it's almost a certain foreign money will be leverage to help stabilize the housing market by 2027. The current housing minister was the former Mayor of Vancouver (Crazy right?). So we have some idea of how this will be handled.
If my sources are accurate, 2026 is expected to be another slow year on the housing/immigration front but things are set to ramp up again in 2027 (especially with immigration). I know call those born in the late 90s/early 2000s as "generation fucked".
 
If my sources are accurate, 2026 is expected to be another slow year on the housing/immigration front but things are set to ramp up again in 2027 (especially with immigration). I know call those born in the late 90s/early 2000s as "generation fucked".
Oh yeah. There is no other play here and by late 2026 they will have to go for some short-term wins. They are going to repackage a bunch of policies around immigration boosts, foreign investment, re-announcing overdue building projects, etc. But we all know the outcome, it's the same cycle that sinks us further into a hole.

The major issue I have is there is a big difference between "Affordable housing" and "Home ownership". We need a reset not even just in pricing, but what a home is or should represent.

We haven't even addressed mortgage fraud yet. A lot of people got qualified for house they shouldn't have got. It's a mess. :ROFLMAO:
 
Oh yeah. There is no other play here and by late 2026 they will have to go for some short-term wins. They are going to repackage a bunch of policies around immigration boosts, foreign investment, re-announcing overdue building projects, etc. But we all know the outcome, it's the same cycle that sinks us further into a hole.

The major issue I have is there is a big difference between "Affordable housing" and "Home ownership". We need a reset not even just in pricing, but what a home is or should represent.

We haven't even addressed mortgage fraud yet. A lot of people got qualified for house they shouldn't have got. It's a mess. :ROFLMAO:
Yes, the uncomfortable pill people need to swallow is that houses need to come down by at least 50% before we can talk about affordability, at least honestly. With the average salary being around 70k, we still have a long way to go...
 
Yes, the uncomfortable pill people need to swallow is that houses need to come down by at least 50% before we can talk about affordability, at least honestly. With the average salary being around 70k, we still have a long way to go...


Not to say I don't agree with you. Houses and condos even at a 50%
discount is barely affordable. That being said, I am afraid a 50% drop
in housing price would be the cyanide pill the economy cannot possibly
survive swallowing.
 
Not to say I don't agree with you. Houses and condos even at a 50%
discount is barely affordable. That being said, I am afraid a 50% drop
in housing price would be the cyanide pill the economy cannot possibly
survive swallowing.
The problem is it's encouraging people to continue making stupid financial decisions. The system needs to fail for people to learn....but no government wants to take responsibility for letting the market fail.
 
The only solution to the housing crisis I can see is construction of
public rental housing estate on a massive scale. But our government
has more important ventures to finance with borrowed money. I wish
the billions Trudeau and now Carney have given away to Ukraine
could be recouped. Charity begins at home.
 
Yes, the uncomfortable pill people need to swallow is that houses need to come down by at least 50% before we can talk about affordability, at least honestly. With the average salary being around 70k, we still have a long way to go...
It's much worse than that. They're setting Canada up for mass social-housing.

Unless you're a millionaire (or a fraudster), you won't own a home. You will be directed to Government controlled housing asset, probably funded by foreign money.

If you are under 40, keep you migration options open. Sad, but it's the reality.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: K Douglas
It's much worse than that. They setting Canada up for mass social-housing.

Unless you're a millionaire (or a fraudster), you won't own a home. You will be directed to Government controlled housing asset, probably funded by foreign money.

If you are under 40, keep you migration options open. Sad, but it's the reality.

At this point, as long as the housing truly is affordable, I don't care so much how they do it. Because being in a precarious housing situation breeds other problems and network effects. Many of the current financial problems facing Canadians could be mitigated with a healthy/affordable housing market.
 
At this point, as long as the housing truly is affordable, I don't care so much how they do it. Because being in a precarious housing situation breeds other problems and network effects. Many of the current financial problems facing Canadians could be mitigated with a healthy/affordable housing market.
The only way to make housing truly affordable is if Government to step back. The more Government gets into it, the messier it gets.

Let the developers build, then the government fills in the gaps.

Can you name me one service the government on any level is good at? That's why you don't want social housing.

And then, Social housing is non-market housing, so it doesn't really ease the bubble directly.
 
As with all things financial, there are multiple issues at play here. The housing market has definitely burst and will likely stay depressed for the next 4-5 years and be flat for the next 10. Un affordability has been talked about for 40 years. I remember in early 2000s , the same arguments were being made, why does a house cost $500k when in 1980 that same house was $150k. The issue is the wage gap to housing cost. When people made $30k and a house cost $150k (5X wage gap ratio) that’s affordable. When today people make 90k and a house cost over $1M, thats 10X + wage gap ratio. Unaffordable! The scam is the interest rate. Everything is framed in a monthly payment context. And not in an overall investment context. The equity growth that has been experienced was the bubble or game of musical chairs. Whoever got out early, got lucky. New buyers are left holding the bag. The real estate investment thesis being a good one is OVER.

An earlier messaged said that anyone under 40 should consider leveling Canada. I actually very much agree with that. Canada has a sad future unfortunately. Shrinking opportunities, Difficult for entrepreneurs. Government is a constant weight on your ability to have a nice life because of taxes, beaurocracy and sentiment. The world is a big place , there are much better opportunities in Asia, Eastern Europe and even Dubai. But you gotta be brave and start thinking out of the box !
I can rant in this for a while , but don’t want to sound depressing 😂. I do however speak from some life experience and clear foresight.
Yeah. Even in the early 2000s, housing was expensive. It is a tough slog.

 
  • Like
Reactions: MatureMan
No there is no mass uncontrolled immigration in Canada.
Numbers are set by the federal government.

No you are wrong. It is exactly mass uncontrolled immigration.


^^^^^ Here. Since Trudeau got elected the numbers skyrocketed. Canada did well with 1% population growth but when Trudeau came especially since covid, the numbers went to over 3% which was total madness.


^^^^ In 2024 they published this article as to how Canada's population increased by one million in 9 months. The data does not lie.

No the 5M temporary residents are here legally, working in jobs, paying taxes, renting condos.
Sending them out is both illegal and will crash not just real estate but the economy and send us into a recession.
Not to mention affect our pensions and social services.

I know, like I said Trudeau opened the floodgates. He lowered the barriers and made it easy for any to get in for the Century Initiative, a crooked organization that is there to make the rich more richer. As for pensions and social services, then why give full immigration to the retired parents of recent arrivals??? Does not make much sense to me and contradicts what you said. Social services, then why bring in hundreds of thousands of asylum seekers to give them a free hotel and monthly paychecks? Ford apparently asked the Federal government for $1 billion last year for asylum seekers. They also get universal healthcare and taxpayers get the bill. Canada is under serious debt, we cannot afford this.

No we don't.

No we bring in the best type of immigrants. We have a points system.
Even the temp workers who come here to work in low paying jobs, do their jobs well.
The vast majority immigrants who come here are lawful, do not commit crimes and are successful.
Asylum seekers are also legal immigrants who are a net positive.

Are you joking??? Or did you smoke too much? I dunno. Canada has moved away from the points based system. As I said before, Trudeau opened the floodgates. Asylum seekers are the worst type of immigrants to bring in. I call them gimmegrants. That is what I call them because they are here to get the freebies. The free hotels, the free monthly paychecks, subsidized housing, cellphones, etc.. Stop the freebies, and if asylum seekers had to pay for everything like the average Canadian watch their numbers drop. Furthermore most of them are fake refugees, they just want to the freebies. We need doctors, engineers, lawyers. Not Uber drives and asylum seekers who have 5+ kids to get free money.

Yes because of 2 primary issues.
a) Not building enough housing.
b) Allowing real estate investors, particularly foreign investors run amok.

You sound like Carney's current crooked housing minister. No, it is not just about building more houses, the two are interrelated. We are bringing in way more people then houses can be built. Look at it this way, imagine pouring water into a glass with a hole, now you keep on pouring water to keep it full. But to keep the glass full you need to close the hole. Same principal. Trudeau brought in so many people, there needs to be a moratorium on it for a good five years. Then investors need incentives to build more housing. We need to keep building till the inventory is more then demand, when you achieve that prices will drop. Also, people come to Canada for the dream to own a single detached home with a backyard and more like the wide open spaces. No one voted to live in overprices cramped condos, with traffic everywhere and taking the bus and subway. That is not the life most people want yet garbage like Trudeau is bringing that to Canada.

But they will not do it because it does not benefit the rich. The greedy corporations, real estate, rich people, politicians want rapid population growth. It makes them richer while making the average joe working a job poorer. How many people in Toronto are working 80hr workweeks just to pay for the overprices rent or mortgage? Does not make sense. Canada has a serious productivity crisis and it will never be solved till the housing crisis is solved. Just piling more and more people to make the GDP grow and show to the world that Canada is doing well is not the solution.