Former NDP leader Tom Mulcair tells Canadians not to vote NDP

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
35,062
66,975
113
NDP and Liberal have very distinct policy views. Forcing a merger is fantasy and not necessary as most people will jump ship.
Did most people jump ship when the Cons and Reform merged?
Those were different policy views as well.

But they had become convinced they could never win an election if they stayed split.

That is not the current NDP / Liberal situation.
I'm not talking "forced", I'm talking people deciding to merge for strategic reasons due to the nature of the First Past the Post system.

He's a former NDP leader. It's a questionable move. Even at Justin's lowest point, former leaders were not calling for voters to leave the party.
Were there former leaders as paid CBC analysts?

There's something going on. Things ain't tasting right.
Meh.
This all looks like very typical plurality voting tactics to me.
 

DesRicardo

aka Dick Dastardly
Dec 2, 2022
3,268
3,528
113
Did most people jump ship when the Cons and Reform merged?
Those were different policy views as well.

But they had become convinced they could never win an election if they stayed split.

That is not the current NDP / Liberal situation.
I'm not talking "forced", I'm talking people deciding to merge for strategic reasons due to the nature of the First Past the Post system.



Were there former leaders as paid CBC analysts?



Meh.
This all looks like very typical plurality voting tactics to me.
You are being kind of pretentious now. Cons and Reform were always the same thing. They stem directly from the same Party. The NDP are a Socialist party, The Liberals are not. They don't stem from the same parties.

Being an Analyst makes it worse because he should be neutral on the subject.
 

JohnLarue

Well-known member
Jan 19, 2005
18,190
3,696
113
You are being kind of pretentious now. Cons and Reform were always the same thing. They stem directly from the same Party. The NDP are a Socialist party, The Liberals are not. They don't stem from the same parties.
The NDP are a Socialist party, The Liberals are were not.


Being an Analyst makes it worse because he should be neutral on the subject.
it was on the CBC
 
  • Like
Reactions: DesRicardo

squeezer

Well-known member
Jan 8, 2010
22,484
17,627
113
I think it's more the left merging into one party.

He clearly sounds like he wants NDP voters to go Liberal.
Bingo! It's stop the nasty asparagus-smelling Pee Pee at all costs. Merge and flourish with a dose of strategic voting.

There will always be an NDP but they will be down to a few seats for now. The only way they are somewhat spared an embarrassing loss is if the Conservatives are close to a landslide and NDP voters decide it's not worth propping up the Libs to take out the devil.

I didn't realize Pee Pee was such a good diver.

Lets send him down with a good tune, all together now

šŸŽ¶šŸŽ¶Piss Piss
Flush Flush
OH, WHAT A RELIEF IT IS. šŸŽµšŸŽµ




šŸŽ¶ šŸŽµ šŸŽ¶ šŸŽµ šŸŽ¶ šŸŽµ šŸŽ¶
 
Last edited:

DesRicardo

aka Dick Dastardly
Dec 2, 2022
3,268
3,528
113
Bingo! It's stop the nasty asparagus-smelling Pee Pee at all costs. Merge and flourish with a dose of strategic voting.

There will always be an NDP but they will be down to a few seats for now. The only way they are somewhat spared an embarrassing loss is if the Conservatives are close to a landslide and NDP voters decide it's not worth propping up the Libs to take out the devil.

I didn't realize Pee Pee was such a good diver.

Lets send him down with a good tune, all together now

šŸŽ¶šŸŽ¶Piss Piss
Flush Flush
OH, WHAT A RELIEF IT IS. šŸŽµšŸŽµ




šŸŽ¶ šŸŽµ šŸŽ¶ šŸŽµ šŸŽ¶ šŸŽµ šŸŽ¶
It won't end well. As I've stated, they are very different Parties and a Party can't serve two masters.

Just look what ended up happening to Trudeau. Liberals resent him now after championing him for ten years.

Not every election is going to have a wild card like Trump to save Liberals.
 

K Douglas

Half Man Half Amazing
Jan 5, 2005
28,106
9,033
113
Room 112
I think it's more the left merging into one party.

He clearly sounds like he wants NDP voters to go Liberal.
Its a tactic. Strategic voting. France did the same thing to stop the conservatives from winning plurality. Sadly a shift away from democracy and towards totalitarianism.
 

DesRicardo

aka Dick Dastardly
Dec 2, 2022
3,268
3,528
113
They dont have to exactly agree on policy in every aspect.
It is enough to want to keep the conservatives out atleast in the short term.
Keyword is distinct.

This is why I will vote Conservative. Like it or Not, Conservatives campaign on policies and plans, Liberals campaign on blocking Conservatives. Liberals have no vision.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JohnLarue

Butler1000

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2011
31,346
5,408
113
Bingo! It's stop the nasty asparagus-smelling Pee Pee at all costs. Merge and flourish with a dose of strategic voting.

There will always be an NDP but they will be down to a few seats for now. The only way they are somewhat spared an embarrassing loss is if the Conservatives are close to a landslide and NDP voters decide it's not worth propping up the Libs to take out the devil.

I didn't realize Pee Pee was such a good diver.

Lets send him down with a good tune, all together now

šŸŽ¶šŸŽ¶Piss Piss
Flush Flush
OH, WHAT A RELIEF IT IS. šŸŽµšŸŽµ




šŸŽ¶ šŸŽµ šŸŽ¶ šŸŽµ šŸŽ¶ šŸŽµ šŸŽ¶
This not what is going on. The calculus has changed from more worry over domestic politics to more worry over international politics. Especially when it comes to trade.

Carney is seen, as better to deal with getting other trade deals. It really has little to do with "strategic voting". Voters are not that sophisticated. Or that organized.

The next few weeks are going to tell a lot. If things go down hill with Trump, then he may be seen as a liability.

Right now he is enjoying a honeymoon. But these things can turn pretty quickly. Don't count chickens yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DesRicardo

DesRicardo

aka Dick Dastardly
Dec 2, 2022
3,268
3,528
113
Voting to stop the CPC which is seen as the Canadian equivalent of MAGA, and stopping the far right turn the world is taking from coming to Canada is the most important right now.
That's just a narrative. I won't vote based on fear tactics, especially when Carney himself is very sketchy on details, previous businesses and connections.
 

JohnLarue

Well-known member
Jan 19, 2005
18,190
3,696
113
The Liberals have policies.
policies copied from the conservatives
Liberals have policies not because they believe that is the right direction for the country,
rather Liberals have policies because they believe that those policies will get them elected

But this election is about ideology. Not policy.
therein lies the biggest issue

policy should determine ones ideological view
you foolishly have that reversed
and adopting an ideological view that is predetermined by others is the thinking of a lemming
 

bver_hunter

Well-known member
Nov 5, 2005
30,013
8,008
113
Tom Mulcair has constantly made excuses for Pee Pee's avoidance of his Security Clearance. His arguments on Vassy Kapelos' Power Play show has shockingly been in favour of the Conservatives more often than any other party. For goodness knows what reasons, he has remortgaged his home 11 times though he lived for free as leader of the opposition, besides getting an annual salary close to $250,000. Anyway, we have to thank Mulcair as originally the Progressives were moving to the Conservatives, but his remarks seem to have pushed them towards The Liberals. Originally, I was okay with the Conservatives being voted in with a minority Government. However, this shift has been seismic towards Mark Carney and The Liberals!!šŸ‘
 

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
35,062
66,975
113
You are being kind of pretentious now. Cons and Reform were always the same thing. They stem directly from the same Party. The NDP are a Socialist party, The Liberals are not. They don't stem from the same parties.
And?
Plurality voting has specific incentives.
One of those is to coalesce into a two-party system.

Right now, there is insufficient pressure to cause that.
I don't expect it to happen anytime soon.
(You're the one who suggested it in post #7.)

But that you see collapse like this when the threat seems high enough is telling.
If, for whatever reason, it seemed that the way the votes were split across NDP/Liberal meant the Cons could never lose then there would be STRONG pressure for a "Unite the Left" movement that might result in a single party.
It's a consequence of the election system.

Being an Analyst makes it worse because he should be neutral on the subject.
I've never seen a CBC analyst be neutral on a subject.
They are brought in for their expertise and opinions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
95,704
24,486
113
policies copied from the conservatives
Liberals have policies not because they believe that is the right direction for the country,
rather Liberals have policies because they believe that those policies will get them elected


therein lies the biggest issue

policy should determine ones ideological view
you foolishly have that reversed
and adopting an ideological view that is predetermined by others is the thinking of a lemming
So you just against these policies because liberals support them, but back them when PeePee does?
 

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
35,062
66,975
113
Bingo! It's stop the nasty asparagus-smelling Pee Pee at all costs. Merge and flourish with a dose of strategic voting.

There will always be an NDP but they will be down to a few seats for now. The only way they are somewhat spared an embarrassing loss is if the Conservatives are close to a landslide and NDP voters decide it's not worth propping up the Libs to take out the devil.
If there hadn't been a Liberal resurgence due to the timing of Trump poking the bear just as Carney was taking over, I think a lot of Libs might have gone NDP to stick it to Trudeau but not prop up PP.
The cards played out differently.
 

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
35,062
66,975
113
Its a tactic. Strategic voting. France did the same thing to stop the conservatives from winning plurality. Sadly a shift away from democracy and towards totalitarianism.
LOL.
I'm sorry, tactical voting is a shift towards totalitarianism?

Is that only when it is being used to block parties you like?
I haven't exactly seen you begging for reform of the electoral system.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
Toronto Escorts