Israel at war

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
51,697
10,105
113
Toronto
Most of those are you, Shazi. Your computer skills are pretty shitty.
Exactly. I wouldn't even know how to make multiple handles without being caught. You just defeated your own claim.

Aside from your TERB KKK, nobody respects you. You asked me for a list and you got it. And that's just from the last 7 days in just 3 threads. This is your reality. You've worn out your welcome. You should just leave before the Feds investigate your hate speech.
 

Klatuu

Well-known member
Dec 31, 2022
5,817
3,370
113
I would dispute that.

The idea of patriotic nationhood is exploited because it is familiar to westerners. Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis are far more absorbed in their religious identity than any idea of being a citizen of countries they probably don't even admit should exits - because of course everything should be the Blessed Caliphate of Islam.
Embarrassing
 

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
51,697
10,105
113
Toronto
Your opinion is worthless.
Based on your TERB rep, your opinion is worth less than zero.

Charges have been submitted to the ICC and ICJ over Israel's killing of between 100,000 to 300,000 Palestinians.
Thank you for just admitting that Israel has not done that. Charges are not a finding of guilt. Innocent until proven guilty. Charges and a finding of guilt are two very, very different things. Did you ever hear of O.J. Simpson?

Until the UN declares that Israel is committing genocide via a resolution from the UNGA Israel is innocent and you are guilty of hate speech every time you make such a statement.5 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GerryB

mandrill

Well-known member
Aug 23, 2001
76,759
88,950
113
The 3 H's are terror groups and are not representative of the average Palestinian. The average Palestinian does hold the identity of a Palestinian today.
Given that present-day Jordan was part of British Mandatory Palestine, where is the surging movement for West Bank and Gaza Arabs to reunite with their Jordanian brethren in a glorious Pan-Palestine reunification???

Doesn't exist, does it?

That's because Jordan is government by a moderate, non fanatic royal family and Hamas and the PA want nothing to do with Jordan and vice versa. That's because Hamas considers the Jordanian government almost as big an enemy as the Jews.
 

Shaquille Oatmeal

Well-known member
Jun 2, 2023
2,398
1,801
113
Given that present-day Jordan was part of British Mandatory Palestine, where is the surging movement for West Bank and Gaza Arabs to reunite with their Jordanian brethren in a glorious Pan-Palestine reunification???

Doesn't exist, does it?

That's because Jordan is government by a moderate, non fanatic royal family and Hamas and the PA want nothing to do with Jordan and vice versa. That's because Hamas considers the Jordanian government almost as big an enemy as the Jews.
Hamas is not representative of the average Palestinian. Jordan has cut itself off from this conflict since 1967, so they are not in the conversation at all.
 

Leimonis

Well-known member
Feb 28, 2020
9,798
9,551
113
But as we discussed the Palestinian label and identity predates the conflict, or even Israel's formation.
It does not. I posted Soviet rep address to UN dated 1947 earlier in this thread. It squarely addresses the issue. Palestinian (as Palestinian Arab) identity only came to existence after the conflict.
 

Shaquille Oatmeal

Well-known member
Jun 2, 2023
2,398
1,801
113
It does not. I posted Soviet rep address to UN dated 1947 earlier in this thread. It squarely addresses the issue. Palestinian (as Palestinian Arab) identity only came to existence after the conflict.
Even if it did, it is still valid today in a very real sense as every Palestinian alive identifies as such.
 

Leimonis

Well-known member
Feb 28, 2020
9,798
9,551
113
Even if it did, it is still valid today in a very real sense as every Palestinian alive identifies as such.
we already agreed that it is real at least as long as the conflict is real (after which it may still be real but no one will really give a shit).
Meanwhile you are giving out labels rather generously. Who is “every Palestinian alive”? Are Arab citizens of israel Palestinians? They sure as hell live between the river and the sea and they ain’t Jews. But they are not in a hurry to move to gaza or West Bank.

Here’s an interesting poll: 502 Arab citizens of Israel above the age of 18 were asked about who should run Gaza the day after the war, most respondents (58.5%) said that the administration should be in the hands of Palestinians. Of those, 24.4% said they would prefer local bodies from Gaza to manage the Strip, followed by 19.4% who said it should be governed by the Palestinian Authority, and 14.7% said by Hamas.
Conversely, 34.4% of respondents said that an external non-Palestinian body should govern the coastal enclave. Of those, 19.4% opted for an international force, 8.4% chose Israel and 6.5% favored a coalition of Arab states.

So their identity and love for Palestine is kinda all over the place as one would expect.
Same with Israelis, same with Canadians. Identity may exist but a lot of people won’t identify as you may expect. Every nation have heroes and traitors and everyone in between.
 

Shaquille Oatmeal

Well-known member
Jun 2, 2023
2,398
1,801
113
Meanwhile you are giving out labels rather generously. Who is “every Palestinian alive”? Are Arab citizens of israel Palestinians?
Many Arab citizens of Israel consider themselves Palestinian by nationality and Israeli by citizenship. There are also those that dont use the Palestinian label. This is a very political issue because anyone who reports has a political agenda.
If you ask people in Gaza or the West Bank, they overwhelmingly consider themselves Palestinian.
 

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
91,806
22,230
113
You're breaking new heights (or new lows) even by your "standards", Adolf :)
Israel and Netanyahu have charges pending at the ICC and ICJ for genocide and extermination.
That is the same crime as the nazis.

Those are the legal standards and Israel and nazis are now forever in the same conversations about genocide.
You just chose to side with genocide and nazis.
 
Toronto Escorts