When Citing US Laws in Canada Goes Horribly Wrong

Georgia man body slammed by deputy

US cops are disgusting.

The dude suffered a left clavicle fracture and currently has pins in his shoulder that will be with him for the rest of his life, his right hand and skull were also fractured. He ruptured an eardrum, suffered a concussion, and was diagnosed with a traumatic brain injury.
 
Plenty of US constitution experts here on terb.


If he wasn't operating a vehicle though...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bordeaux
I think the narrator of this video is out to lunch. We don't always have to surrender our "papers", we have basically the same rights as provided by the US Constitution. In Ontario at least, you do have to surrender driver's license etc if you are driving a car, however in this video it appears as though he is parked on private property, I don't think the cops can enforce documentation laws on private property.
 

Not in Canada cupcake...
I thought the posted rule was that political threads in the lounge would be deleted vs. relocated. Are some people just that special?
 
Last edited:
I think the narrator of this video is out to lunch. We don't always have to surrender our "papers", we have basically the same rights as provided by the US Constitution. In Ontario at least, you do have to surrender driver's license etc if you are driving a car, however in this video it appears as though he is parked on private property, I don't think the cops can enforce documentation laws on private property.
He is in the driver seat. Private property doesn’t matter. Plazas are private property and they can still demand papers
 
If it was the old days, the cops would have beat the shit out if him.
Miss the old days.
 
I think the narrator of this video is out to lunch. We don't always have to surrender our "papers", we have basically the same rights as provided by the US Constitution. In Ontario at least, you do have to surrender driver's license etc if you are driving a car, however in this video it appears as though he is parked on private property, I don't think the cops can enforce documentation laws on private property.
may have been the owner or tennant of the private property that called as they may have feared employee or customer safety. The officer did point out that he was being suspicious in filming people coming in and out. I for one would not want to be filmed coming out of a Specialist office or a rehab clinic.
 
If it was the old days, the cops would have beat the shit out if him. Miss the old days.

The old days have not gone, the brain dead driver is lucky those weren't Peel Region cops.

His conduct reminds of an old creepy classic: The silicon chip inside his head is switched to overload.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon1
Are you sure about that? I'm not an expert but I was told that the reason that you can 'teach' your kid to drive in a parking lot is that police can't ticket you on private property. Same reason you don't get a ticket for not stopping at a stop sign in a parking lot.

At least the stop sign I can pretty much prove, at least with anecdotal evidence. Had a cop behind me this morning in a parking lot after getting a Tim's. As there was nobody else approaching, I just drove right through the stop sign that was in the lot. Pretty sure the cop did the same thing and we both went our separate ways when we hit the actual road.
But you can’t be drinking in your car in the Tim’s parking lot.

I don’t know but I believe they can still ask you for your ID if on private property. But I don’t know for fact.
 
I think the narrator of this video is out to lunch. We don't always have to surrender our "papers", we have basically the same rights as provided by the US Constitution. In Ontario at least, you do have to surrender driver's license etc if you are driving a car, however in this video it appears as though he is parked on private property, I don't think the cops can enforce documentation laws on private property.
Not a lawyer, but my understanding that if you are in a motor vehicle, the police can ask for your license, registration and insurance at any time. We have different protections from the police in Canada. But, again, I admit that I might be wrong.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jenesis
Like they say….Play stupid games, win stupid prizes. What did he hope to accomplish? Show your license and explain what you are doing in a rational manner and go about your business.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joyrection
Same issue. I don't think it matters what private property you are on. If you are sitting in your car in your driveway you can be drinking. It's only if you try to drive out into the road that you are screwed. So, a Tim's parking lot should be fine. Of course, in a Tim's parking lot they will probably just wait for you to leave as it is doubtful that you are going to jump on a bus if you have your car there, lol.

I'm not sure if there are special rules regarding identifying while in a vehicle vs. as a pedestrian. But, I do know that you are not obligated to identify yourself to any police in Canada unless they are RCMP. Of course they, the police, circumvent that little rule by saying they are detaining you for an investigation, which I believe allows them to force you to identify yourself.
If you are in “care and control” of a car, you cannot be drunk/ drinking. Full stop. Doesn’t matter where you are.

In Ontario, HTA offences may not apply on private property, but criminal code offences apply everywhere.
 
Not a lawyer, but my understanding that if you are in a motor vehicle, the police can ask for your license, registration and insurance at any time. We have different protections from the police in Canada. But, again, I admit that I might be wrong.
It is better to go with the premise that you have no protection but what they (the police) are willing to grant at the time of contact. Your protection would come through a decision by the crown attorney or judge, mind you this is after your detour to tune town, possibly sprayed with pepper spray, dragged face on pavement, handcuffed, having your car towed(impound fees) and possible bail hearing. Don't get stuck on the person being a driver so much as videotaping people coming or going from a particular. property may be a case of criminal harassment, stalking and at the lower end if he was parked on private property then he would be subject to provincial trespassing laws. Failing to identify yourself during the case of a lawful police investigation can lead to detention and arrest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: silentkisser
Thanks. I didn't necessarily mean intoxicated as I almost never drink more than one or two at a time, but your response caused me to look into it some more. I had thought that being at a private residence would negate care or control laws but apparently not.

"Even sitting in a parked car to listen to the radio can land you a conviction for and impaired or over 80. The accused in R. v Baboolall [2004] O.J. No. 2878 (S.C.J.) had been drinking at a party when he decided to get into his car in the driveway and listen to the radio with a friend. He turned the radio on by putting the keys in the ignition and put the parking brake on. The Ontario Superior Court upheld the trial judge’s finding that the accused was in care or control of the vehicle, as there was a risk of the accused putting the vehicle in motion unintentionally. Crucial to this finding was the fact that the accused had accessed the ‘operating apparatus’ of the vehicle, thereby increases the risk of setting the car in motion."

Just in case this helps anyone here.
I subscribe to the old rule of "don't be a shit magnate." The only times I was stopped by the police was for doing stupid things or for being around other people who were doing stupid things as a teenager, such as hitting undercover car with eggs as a teen back in the 80's, buddy squealing tires while leaving an underage booze party resulting in getting booze seized and tickets. Sadly many folks don't learn the that rule, and the other life rule of "fuck around and find out."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Carvher