Israel at war

Last edited:
  • Angry
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu and Kautilya
This thread is misleading. Israel is not at war..a war implies both parties have a military. I haven't seen one Palestinian cadef or Army member. What I have seen is innocent civilians being carpet bombed by the IOF using white phosphorus which is a war crime. We can call it for what it is which is a genocide
 
Gaza: Findings on October 17 al-Ahli Hospital Explosion
Evidence Points to Misfired Rocket but Full Investigation Needed


(Jerusalem) – The explosion that killed and injured many civilians at al-Ahli Arab Hospital in Gaza on October 17, 2023, resulted from an apparent rocket-propelled munition, such as those commonly used by Palestinian armed groups, that hit the hospital grounds, Human Rights Watch said today. While misfires are frequent, further investigation is needed to determine who launched the apparent rocket and whether the laws of war were violated.

Gaza: Findings on October 17 al-Ahli Hospital Explosion | Human Rights Watch (hrw.org)
 
Gaza: Findings on October 17 al-Ahli Hospital Explosion
Evidence Points to Misfired Rocket but Full Investigation Needed


(Jerusalem) – The explosion that killed and injured many civilians at al-Ahli Arab Hospital in Gaza on October 17, 2023, resulted from an apparent rocket-propelled munition, such as those commonly used by Palestinian armed groups, that hit the hospital grounds, Human Rights Watch said today. While misfires are frequent, further investigation is needed to determine who launched the apparent rocket and whether the laws of war were violated.

Gaza: Findings on October 17 al-Ahli Hospital Explosion | Human Rights Watch (hrw.org)

So you think this was the only hospital that Israel didn't destroy?
Does that somehow make the rest of the destruction ok?

 
I had a good discussion with two of them on Friday night. They mentioned its easier to talk the situation with someone like me rather than their more hardcore zionists friends, some of whom they've had to move out of their social worlds.

You should join one of the marches to get a sense of the crowd, at all the Palestine marches there are Jews there who make a point of being visible and being against the occupation. Those ones feel safer out in public than I'd expect shack would ever feel if he took an Israeli flag with him.

You have a choice to join a massive diverse and peaceful crowd or a very white looking, tiny crowd with massive police protection these days.


I would never join the marches and I wish they would commence to shut them down. I don't believe you about your Jewish "friends."

I also have both Jewish, Arab and Muslim friends and they all fall in line for their side except for a couple of Arab friends who are Christians, they side with the Jews. To avoid conflict when I am with the Arab and Muslim crowd we do not bring the topic up and if it does come up among them I stay out of it. You cannot change the minds of folks with skin in the game even if they are wrong.
 
Squeezer, do you support Israel announcing plans to spend more money to build more settlements in what could have been Palestine's two state solution?

Do you think this is a move towards peace or justified?
Do you see this as colonization, theft of land or 'taking what they can'?


They will have to do what is necessary to stop HAMAS from lobbing rockets at them and feel safe within their country. As I've said before HAMAS started it and has brought fire and brimstone to the citizens and naturally Israel will finish it one way or another. THe quickest ending would be release all the Hostages instead of small groups and HAMAS surrender. I know, my GOD, they would have to give up their riches and lavish lifestyles but hey, one has to do what one has got to do.
 
I would never join the marches and I wish they would commence to shut them down. I don't believe you about your Jewish "friends."

I also have both Jewish, Arab and Muslim friends and they all fall in line for their side except for a couple of Arab friends who are Christians, they side with the Jews. To avoid conflict when I am with the Arab and Muslim crowd we do not bring the topic up and if it does come up among them I stay out of it. You cannot change the minds of folks with skin in the game even if they are wrong.

Of course you can't speak about the subject with your Muslim or Arab friends, if you actually have any.
They'd rightfully brand you as a racist.

I can talk to both sides, including those I don't agree with like zionists like you. I talked to the cops guarding those with Israeli flags, the cops around the Palestine marches and quite a few people during.

But more importantly, can you articulate a path forward that you think will lead to peace and the end of this strife?
And how much more killing does it need to make happen?
 
They will have to do what is necessary to stop HAMAS from lobbing rockets at them and feel safe within their country. As I've said before HAMAS started it and has brought fire and brimstone to the citizens and naturally Israel will finish it one way or another. THe quickest ending would be release all the Hostages instead of small groups and HAMAS surrender. I know, my GOD, they would have to give up their riches and lavish lifestyles but hey, one has to do what one has got to do.

Why did you even talk about Hamas in that post?

I asked you about whether you support Israel spending $100 million to take Palestinian land in the West Bank and make new settlements and you immediately pivot to Hamas? Wow.

You start from a position where you refuse to even acknowledge that Israel is a colonial state that is still actively taking and colonizing Palestinian land with military backed 'settlers'. They call the 'settlers', you can't get more blatant than that.

So what does Hamas have to do with Israel announcing more money and plans for 'settlements'?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu and Kautilya
Of course you can't speak about the subject with your Muslim or Arab friends, if you actually have any.
They'd rightfully brand you as a racist.

I can talk to both sides, including those I don't agree with like zionists like you. I talked to the cops guarding those with Israeli flags, the cops around the Palestine marches and quite a few people during.

But more importantly, can you articulate a path forward that you think will lead to peace and the end of this strife?
And how much more killing does it need to make happen?

Why did you even talk about Hamas in that post?

I asked you about whether you support Israel spending $100 million to take Palestinian land in the West Bank and make new settlements and you immediately pivot to Hamas? Wow.

You start from a position where you refuse to even acknowledge that Israel is a colonial state that is still actively taking and colonizing Palestinian land with military backed 'settlers'. They call the 'settlers', you can't get more blatant than that.

So what does Hamas have to do with Israel announcing more money and plans for 'settlements'?

The only choice is a two-state solution with no HAMAS in the mix. This could never happen without level-minded leaders running Palestine. You can jump up and down, cry out as if you or I have any say in it but the reality is WE DON'T. You are so invested in this why are you here? Why are you not there helping out during this ceasefire?
 
Nope. They come over to eat, laugh, and just have fun. Good modern guys. Absolutely my peers, and smarter than me on tech. They don't worship a death cult. That's the point. They observe some things to keep family off their backs, but really lead a North American life.

Tif their types were tunning Gaza, none of this happens.

They would have exploited the Gas deal by having their children educated to work on the platforms, to become engineers, builders, riggers. Then set up a sovereign wealth fund for Gaza infrastructure improvement. The USA and world would have backed this. Even protected them and offered loans and grants. The economic spill over would have added a slow cascade to tourism, food production, some manufacturing, and services that would have created mass employment opportinities.

All that would have led to full recognition of them as a state, with spillover to the West Bank.

And think about how they would be now positioned to supply Europe in light of Russia. The power and position that would have added.

Seriously, the equivalent is if 20 TRILLION was found off the coast of Canada, and the game changer it would be.

Instead they chose to follow the ways of an 8th century desert warlord. Charlie Manson of the Saudi Desert. Its a waste. Its a stagnant culture. Backward. More concerned with rules and the afterlife than growth and progress.

Just another example. Hell even the Saudi Royals get it, why do you think they were signing a peace deal?
Great post, But.
 
They will have to do what is necessary to stop HAMAS from lobbing rockets at them and feel safe within their country. As I've said before HAMAS started it and has brought fire and brimstone to the citizens and naturally Israel will finish it one way or another. THe quickest ending would be release all the Hostages instead of small groups and HAMAS surrender. I know, my GOD, they would have to give up their riches and lavish lifestyles but hey, one has to do what one has got to do.

Delusional.
 
Yup, I saw that but it's been evident in Frankie's nonstop posts in anything to do with Palestine he supports HAMAS and thinks Israel is the monster. I just hope for Frankie's sake he's Palestinian or at the very least Arab because if not, it is a serious obsession. I can understand if one has skin in the game by being very passionate even if he or she is wrong.
People have a hate on for Jews, even if they're not Palestinian. Hitler and eastern Europe.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: xmontrealer
The only choice is a two-state solution with no HAMAS in the mix. This could never happen without level-minded leaders running Palestine. You can jump up and down, cry out as if you or I have any say in it but the reality is WE DON'T. You are so invested in this why are you here? Why are you not there helping out during this ceasefire?

Show me a map where you think this two state solution lies.
Draw it out, or find a proposal, but show us exactly how this is supposed to happen.

Otherwise you're just another mark, like the US was agreeing to the Oslo Accords while Netanyahu bragged about stopping the two state and killing it through 'facts on the ground' the same way that told his government that the best way to stop the two state solution was to fund Hamas.

Go for it.
Its your proposal, show it.