Why are they not flooding the tunnels then?It is not about the hostages because Israeli strikes has killed 60 of them. Israel does not care about the hostages.
Their priority is to collectively punish the Palestinians, because that is just how racist they are. That also happens to be a war crime.
Yeah right like anyone in the world wants Gaza land.They probably don't even know where the tunnels are. The goal is to punish Palestinians, create pressure for them to leave and steal land. They know regardless of what they flood, they won't be able to eradicate a terrorist group.
Also if they are legitimate refugees isn’t it supposed to make it easier for them to move south where it’s safer? They don’t have houses and farms and property to worry about. Just get up and go, no?The fact that they are "refugees" 60 years after their grandparents were evicted from their residences in what is now Israel, means that they are not legitimate refugees. They are people whose parents and grandparents were not resettled elsewhere in the Arab world and given opportunities by those other Arab countries because they were - and are - exploited as human pathos trophies.
I have a buddy whose grandparents fled Stalin from Latvia in 1955. My buddy is a successful real estate agent. By what stretch of the imagination can people whose ancestors fled a country a half century ago be called "refugees".
I sympathize with the Gazans. They are trapped. But the people who trap them are the other Arab states and the corrupt HAMAS hierarchy who are billionaires and live outside the Gaza enclave.
Israel left Gaza in 2006.The Israelis seem to want it. After all isn't their claim that they are the chosen people and the land is ALL theirs? To be fair, the Palestinians say the same too, which is why this conflict is unresolvable.
I think the Israelis just want to be safe from HAMAS. They don't really want Gaza.The Israelis seem to want it. After all isn't their claim that they are the chosen people and the land is ALL theirs? To be fair, the Palestinians say the same too, which is why this conflict is unresolvable.
You can eradicate terrorist groups. ISIS got hunted down and killed. Killing the vile beliefs that caused that terrorist group is more difficult.They probably don't even know where the tunnels are. The goal is to punish Palestinians, create pressure for them to leave and steal land. They know regardless of what they flood, they won't be able to eradicate a terrorist group.
But it's NOT a collective punishment.Huh?
Germany in 1940 was an active enemy and the leader of the Axis powers. So that is hardly an appropriate comparison, to compare a terrorist group to a nation that you were fighting against.
That said even though war crime rules did not exist at that time, everyone committed war crimes back then:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_war_crimes_committed_during_World_War_II
My argument is that collective punishments of Palestinians is a racist war crime. Don't endorse or commit racist war crimes.
ISIS still exists, but its a shadow of its former self. And thats the ultimate goal of Israel, to reduce Hamas to the point where it no longer poses any major threat to IsraelisNo you cannot. Al-Qaeda and ISIS still exist. They lost the land they controlled, but they exist and they still conduct attacks and what not
They were in Gaza because they were pushing back Egyptian army.So they were in Gaza because they wanted it. Now they will attempt to take it back. I posted several videos, watch them.
But it IS an appropriate comparison because Germany - like HAMAS - still had the ability to attack and injure the Allied powers until it was finally conquered. Exact same parallel.Huh?
Germany in 1940 was an active enemy and the leader of the Axis powers. So that is hardly an appropriate comparison, to compare a terrorist group to a nation that you were fighting against.
It's not collective punishment. Let me explain to you what collective punishment would look like.That said even though war crime rules did not exist at that time, everyone committed war crimes back then:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_war_crimes_committed_during_World_War_II
My argument is that collective punishments of Palestinians is a racist war crime. Don't endorse or commit racist war crimes.
Israelis say differently. They say they want Gaza and West Bank and they want all the Palestinians to leave. So I'll take what the Israelis say as more relevant here.
Collateral damage is unavoidable damage.Collateral damage is accidental. These are not accidental deaths. These are a result of indiscriminate bombings, which are war crimes and collective punishments.
As I said, if there are military installations in civilian areas, and if it is going to result in a huge amount of civilian deaths, then MAKE THE CHOICE TO NOT bomb that target. Handle it a different way. They make the choice to bomb it knowing it will cause numerous civilian deaths. That is a war crime.
And these civilian deaths SHOULD get a reaction from anyone who does not endorse war crimes. It is the right reaction.
I call bullshit. Provide proof or stop lying. And not what some random Israeli who lost relatives or friends have saidIsraelis say differently. They say they want Gaza and West Bank and they want all the Palestinians to leave. So I'll take what the Israelis say as more relevant here.
No. What you write is just simply wrong.Germany was a state. Hamas is a terrorist group. So the comparison between Germany and Hamas is apples and oranges.
No. Re read what I wrote more carefully. You're not absorbing the distinctions that I am drawing for you.And that is what they are doing now. They have razed 25% of Gaza to the ground, 9000+ people dead, half of them children and counting, while the Hamas is still going strong. Collective punishment per your own definition.
Hezbollah better watch its step. The IDF is big enough to eat HAMAS and Hezbollah both for breakfast.Looks like Hezbollah may be giving Israel a preview of its own Gaza.
You have NO IDEA what the IDF commanders consider, what their intel is and how feasible it is to do any of the imaginary military operations that you suggest. It's my opinion that a slow house-by-house assault is probably the only way this could be done.Yes. And the majority of deaths in the current conflict were avoidable. Had Israel adopted another approach, say via covert military operations, other than indiscriminate aerial bombing, these deaths could have been avoided. That said, don't forget that Israel's goal is not just to kill Hamas, it is to also punish the Palestinians and steal their lands. Its unacknowledged state policy. There is tons of evidence for it.