The Amnesty video did appear to show four phosphorus shells off to the left side of the video. You're positive those aren't phosphorus?
Yes. 100%. Those are paraflares. Compare to this video of white phosphorus illumination:
I'll also point out that it's kind of shit for illumination. A white phos grenade in the dark woods or a basement or something is like turning the sun on. But for wide-area illumination it's kind of poopy.
WP is great for smoke, as long as you can keep redeploying it because it doesn't last long, and it's outstanding for target marking. For all other uses, it's garbage.
I don't think their summary is as far off as you argue. Saying that a device's 'primary use' is close to what the CCW says, they just call it 'incidental effects'. That's a tomato/tomato differentiation. The question in this case would be is the use of phosphorus bombs 'primary use' to burn things on the ground or is it 'primarily designed' to as illumination. Is the illumination an 'incidental effect' to burning things and people or is that what its 'primarily designed' to do?
It's not tomato/tomato. Their summary said Article III of CCW doesn't apply if you use incindiary munitions for non-incindiary proposes, but that's not that CCW says at all.CCW says they straight up aren't incindiary and therefore don't apply. Those are very different things.
Can you find a legit source that backs up your claim that white phosphorus is not considered incendiary? And in airburst?
If you didn't airburst it, it would be the world's worst illumination. "Oh great, we called in an artillery illumination and it exploded in the ground illuminating exactly as much as we could have accomplished with a grande or flare but with he added fun of worrying about getting it on us and melting our skin."
Both HRW and Amnesty say it is. As far as I know there is no official ruling, so you can claim it isn't but it isn't but there is nothing to back claim up.
You want me to prove a negative? That's tough to do. You can check the US DOD Law of War Manual. It calls out WP as not falling under the CCW. But aside from that, what part of the exception from CCW do you think doesn't apply? The only munition manufactured as an incindiary that contains WP is the Mk 77 bomb, where the WP is a small portion used only as an accelerant and Israel owns 0 of them. You're asking me to explain why the words mean what they say though. Why are you trusting Amnesty and their shitty summary rather than just reading the CCW yourself? It's not like it's so big it needs a summary, and the difference is glaringly obvious.
Though HRW says there are loopholes and have been campaigning to have it reclassified on 'effect' as compared to 'primary design'. Otherwise you can drop it on people and claim you were using for its primary designed purpose to just light them up.
I assume you're taking about this page?
https://www.hrw.org/news/2023/10/12...israels-use-white-phosphorus-gaza-and-lebanon
I'd suggest you dig deeper. On it, HRW says, "Human Rights Watch and many CCW states parties have recommended closing that loophole and strengthening the restriction on the use of ground-launched incendiary weapons." There's a link there that takes you here:
But in the very first point on that factsheet, it says:
"By describing incendiary weapons as those “primarily designed” to set fires or burn humans, Protocol III’s definition of incendiary weapons excludes most multipurpose incendiary munitions.
The definition does not encompass munitions, such as white phosphorus, that are “primarily designed” to create smokescreens or signal troops, yet have the same cruel incendiary effects."
So HRW endorses a document which explicitly says "WP is not covered by article III". I'm not sure what more I can give you.
There was a 2013 Israeli ruling on Israel's use in 2008, where Israel promised they wouldn't use it again in populated areas. Goldstone also reported that Israel was using it on populated areas.
Strawman. We're talking about if its correct to say using WP is by itself is a war crime. Israel's own federal laws have no bearing. I've also never argued they are correct to use WP or that I support it. I'm saying you posted a tweet that said using WP is a war crime, and I'm not going to get strawmanned into debating something else.
Even if, as you argue, its a poor choice as an incendiary weapon that doesn't mean when its not behaving like an incendiary weapon when you drop it on people's homes.
Irrelevant. You can't drop any weapon on a civilians home. That's what I've been saying. Using any weapon against civilians is unlawful except when proportional proportionality applies. There is not extra rule about WP, and the use of WP does not by itself constitute a war crime. Yes, that means you can't use it on a civilian house. But you also can't shoot machine gun bullets or throw grenades into a civilian house. That doesn't mean you can post a video of the IDF shooting machine guns or chucking grenades and automatically say it's a war crime. You certainly can't post a video of them eating an orange, say it's them throwing a grenade and declare it's a war crime, which seems like a more apt comparison.