Garden of Eden Escorts
Toronto Passions

Israel at war

Previous Thread
F

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
90,911
21,919
113
shack said:
Oh. Is the conflict over? How many IDF have died? How many Hamas have died?

I asked who WILL pay the bigger price. Just to help you, it means when the conflict is over. At this point, it is far from over.
Click to expand...
How big should the disproportionate response be, shack?
There have sadly been 1000 Israelis killed so far and equally as sadly a few more Palestinians.

Usually Israel kills 10x, so you do you think Israel needs to kill another 9-10,000 Palestinians or is this a special case and do you need to kill more to really teach them a lesson?

You should have a head start soon, with all the water, food and electricity gone all the hospitals are about lose all patients on machines.
So you will get the death of 200 newborns on ventilators and 1100 dialysis patients.

Then you only have to kill another 8-20,000 humans.

But that could be trickier cuz Trent Telenko thinks if Israel invades Gaza they might lose another 1,000 soldiers so then you'd need to kill another 10,000.

Personally, I find this all incredibly disgusting. From your and other Israeli supporters call for war crimes and terrorism to your refusal to discuss any way to peace other than killing more of the native population. You need to find a way to deescalate. Killing people will not lead to peace, even if you use nukes.

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1712202006712992062
 
F

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
90,911
21,919
113
Kautilya said:
Countries are made of people. Saying a country has no right to exist, is as good as saying, the people have no right to exist.
Click to expand...
No, countries are pieces of land with human decided borders.
There is no such thing as a country's right to exist.
 
F

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
90,911
21,919
113
jalimon said:
It's an absolute crazy situation because these territories should have never existed. A piece of land should simply have been given to palestine people... (if I can call them like that).

By not having their land they have become inhuman and who can blame them...

Now they go to war.

War is crazy.

War is performed by 20 year old or so who would rather go all to a rave together and who in normal circumstance would love each other.

But war is decided by old fart who hate each other out of ego, greed and men who grew into old fucking fart.
Click to expand...
Its totally fucked.

Colonial Britain decided to deal with a group of refugees they didn't want by forcing them on another country they didn't want to make another people they liked even less take care of Germany and Europe's problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jalimon
F

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
90,911
21,919
113
Kautilya said:
No countries are not just pieces of land with human decided borders. They are a cultural entity and an identity both of which are deeply connected to individuals who live there. So a countries right to exist, automatically translates to a person's right to identify as belonging to something. You are advocating for imperialism and colonialism here.
Click to expand...
You are confusing the right to live on land with the right of the land to have humans.
Palestinians have the Right to Return to their homes in historic Palestine, but 'Palestine' doesn't have a right to those people.
Countries have no rights.
 
F

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
90,911
21,919
113
Kautilya said:
Right to live on the land is an immigration or legal status.

Right of a country to exist is the about the country's sovereignty, and its people's right to self-identify and self-determine their identities.

To say countries have no rights, is to say that anyone can invade anyone else.

By saying this you are justifying colonialism and arguing against yourself. You are justifying Israel's occupation of Palestine. You are justifying the Russian invasion of Ukraine. You are justifying American invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan. And so on.
Click to expand...
No, that right is still about the people living there to defend their right to live there. Its not about the country itself has a right to attack another piece of land.

Colonialism is about one people deciding they have the right to rule over another group of people on a separate piece of land. Its still about the people.

For instance, the Israeli supporters here argue that Palestinians have zero rights, no right to live on their homeland, no right of return, no right to self defence and no right to vote. Those are all human rights stifled by a colonial power, Israel. Nobody in their right mind would argue that the land was deemed to be Palestine in 1948 by the UN so Palestine the country has the right to tell all illegal settlers to leave. That would be ridiculous.

Or are you arguing that you think Palestine, as internationally ordained as a country by the UN, has rights that are being curtailed by the piece of land that the UN ordained as Israel in 1948?
 
H

HungSowel

Well-known member
Mar 3, 2017
2,823
1,714
113
Kautilya said:
Right to live on the land is an immigration or legal status.

Right of a country to exist is the about the country's sovereignty, and its people's right to self-identify and self-determine their identities.

To say countries have no rights, is to say that anyone can invade anyone else.

By saying this you are justifying colonialism and arguing against yourself. You are justifying Israel's occupation of Palestine. You are justifying the Russian invasion of Ukraine. You are justifying American invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan. And so on.
Click to expand...
Rights are guaranteed by a higher authority that has the power to impose penalties, fines, violence, and imprisonment. If your rights as a citizen of this country are violated then the justice system is used to enforce your rights. If this country is invaded by another country, who is the authority that will stop them? The UN?
 
H

HungSowel

Well-known member
Mar 3, 2017
2,823
1,714
113
Kautilya said:
The individual countries have to defend themselves. But countries are also recognized by others. A self-identifying country has natural rights. They dont have to be conferred upon them by a higher power.
Click to expand...
This is a list of former sovereign states, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_former_sovereign_states, countries have no natural right to even exist never mind rights beyond that.

The only higher power governing all countries is the age-old adage; if you can defend it then it is yours. By that metric Israel has earned its existence, I want to say earned its right to exist but it would be a mischaracterization as rights do not apply to countries.
 
Last edited:
S

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
51,273
9,914
113
Toronto
Frankfooter said:
How big should the disproportionate response be, shack?
There have sadly been 1000 Israelis killed so far and equally as sadly a few more Palestinians.

Usually Israel kills 10x, so you do you think Israel needs to kill another 9-10,000 Palestinians or is this a special case and do you need to kill more to really teach them a lesson?

You should have a head start soon, with all the water, food and electricity gone all the hospitals are about lose all patients on machines.
So you will get the death of 200 newborns on ventilators and 1100 dialysis patients.

Then you only have to kill another 8-20,000 humans.

But that could be trickier cuz Trent Telenko thinks if Israel invades Gaza they might lose another 1,000 soldiers so then you'd need to kill another 10,000.

Personally, I find this all incredibly disgusting. From your and other Israeli supporters call for war crimes and terrorism to your refusal to discuss any way to peace other than killing more of the native population. You need to find a way to deescalate. Killing people will not lead to peace, even if you use nukes.

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1712202006712992062
Click to expand...
Hamas brought all this on the Gazans. Use whatever "justifications" you want, Hamas' actions set all this in motion. And any "justification" for Hamas' attack is also justifying the death and suffering of Gazans that will be coming. And you knew that the Gazans would suffer as soon as Hamas launched their attack. And that's OK with you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
You must log in or register to reply here.
Previous Thread
Toronto Escorts
Top Bottom