Franco Harris..R.I.P

I narrowed it down to 1 player about 5 posts ago.
Yes, I'm aware of that and we appreciate it. The comment was a sarcastic/humourous editorial on the nature of the Raider teams and their reputation back in the day.
 
Yes, I'm aware of that and we appreciate it. The comment was a sarcastic/humourous editorial on the nature of the Raider teams and their reputation back in the day.
Gotcha. Mr. Davis loved the scoundrels.

I think Tatum had to be near the top of the class.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tml
Gotcha. Mr. Davis loved the scoundrels.

I think Tatum had to be near the top of the class.

For that time though, was Tatum really that much different than a lot of his peers.

Dick Butkus stands out too me as being one of the most feared players in NFL history.

Steelers had guys like Donnie Shell and Jack Lambert that would gladly take your head off if given a chance.

Ronnie Lott......
 
  • Like
Reactions: tml
For that time though, was Tatum really that much different than a lot of his peers.

Dick Butkus stands out too me as being one of the most feared players in NFL history.

Steelers had guys like Donnie Shell and Jack Lambert that would gladly take your head off if given a chance.

Ronnie Lott......
Even Conrad Dobler said Tatum was mean.
And that's from someone who was deemed the dirtiest player in the game...by his Peers!..lol
Guys, the usual suspect will jump in and rant this is a Franco Harris thread.
 
For that time though, was Tatum really that much different than a lot of his peers.

Dick Butkus stands out too me as being one of the most feared players in NFL history.

Steelers had guys like Donnie Shell and Jack Lambert that would gladly take your head off if given a chance.

Ronnie Lott......
Lambert, Butkus, Nitzchke (sp) and so many more were all considered really, really tough. They all had to be tough to play then because there wasn't the same emphasis on player safety than there is now. If they weren't tough, they didn't last long. Different sport, but Dave Keon had to be tough to survive in the NHL in that era for as long as he did.

For his era, I believe that Tatum may have been tough, but he was also considered dirty. Another name I remember as being dirty was Conrad Dobler, an offensive lineman for the St. Louis Cardinals.

IMO, tough and dirty have some overlap but they are definitely different qualities.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: tml
IMO, tough and dirty could be combined but they are definitely different qualities.

There's a fine line though right?.....In the heat of the moment.

Tatum lived on his reputation as ''the assassin'' . Receivers were scared to go across the middle with him out there. Three time pro bowler.

Kind of reminds me of Scott Stevens in the NHL. Was he a dirty player? Paul Kariya and Eric Lindros' careers were it could argued adversely affected by his violent intentions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tml
Guys, the usual suspect will jump in and rant this is a Franco Harris thread.
Lots of threads go off topic.

Only one person, however, stands out up and above all the rest in having no compunction to hijack threads on a regular basis, no matter what the topic, and as a result has a very well deserved reputation. Maybe you never noticed, but he is the ONLY person that I criticize for doing so. To my knowledge, I've never criticized anyone else for this behaviour. So, to warn others, is totally unnecessary and inappropriate because it's applicable to no one else. Maybe I'm living in his head because he loves to warn others about me from out of nowhere. He seems to always think about me. LOL. I'll take it as a compliment. As well, this person will never, ever admit that they hijack threads.

That unnamed person does it, not for the sake of furthering a discussion, but because they think they are impressing others with their worldly knowledge (aka something to do with their hometown), which in reality is simply the ability to look up something on Wikipedia.

Of course, for the sake of propriety I won't name names. That's just the kind of guy I am. ;) :rolleyes::D
 
There's a fine line though right?.....In the heat of the moment.

Tatum lived on his reputation as ''the assassin'' . Receivers were scared to go across the middle with him out there. Three time pro bowler.

Kind of reminds me of Scott Stevens in the NHL. Was he a dirty player? Paul Kariya and Eric Lindros' careers were it could argued adversely affected by his violent intentions.
As far as I remember these were the terms used back in the day, not in a retrospective sense using today's standards. That's how other players and analysts/writers described them. Tatum was known as dirty before he paralyzed Stingley. That hit or ending a career was not what defined him as dirty.

If you don't want to believe me, take it from the source:
"I like to believe that my best hits border on felonious assault." - Jack Tatum

And, yeah, I consider Stevens to be a borderline dirty player, but he was also very, very tough.
 
Last edited:
As far as I remember these were the terms used back in the day, not in a retrospective sense using today's standards. That's how other players and analysts/writers described them. Tatum was known as dirty before he paralyzed Stingley. That hit or ending a career was not what defined him as dirty.

If you don't want to believe me, take it from the source:
"I like to believe that my best hits border on felonious assault." - Jack Tatum

And, yeah, I consider Stevens to be a borderline dirty player, but he was also very, very tough.

I'm a Flyers fan and both hits on Lindros I would consider clean. Hit on Kariya was dirty.
 
There's a fine line though right?.....In the heat of the moment.

Tatum lived on his reputation as ''the assassin'' . Receivers were scared to go across the middle with him out there. Three time pro bowler.

Kind of reminds me of Scott Stevens in the NHL. Was he a dirty player? Paul Kariya and Eric Lindros' careers were it could argued adversely affected by his violent intentions.
Tatum's teammate, George Atkinson, was dubbed "The Assassin".
 
Kind of reminds me of Scott Stevens in the NHL. Was he a dirty player? Paul Kariya and Eric Lindros' careers were it could argued adversely affected by his violent intentions.
Since he played for New Jersey, I didn't see Stevens play all that much. I always thought of him as a physical player but not necessarily dirty (unlike D-man Chris Pronger). He will probably always be remembered as the guy who hit Lindros.

BTW: Looks like this thread has morphed from Harris to Tatum to Stevens. The usual suspect (singular) hasn't complained yet that the thread has gone off-topic. Other than the usual suspect none of the other members bitch or only very rarely bitch about a thread being hijacked.

Stevens still smarting over sidelining Lindros | CBC Sports
 
Since he played for New Jersey, I didn't see Stevens play all that much. I always thought of him as a physical player but not necessarily dirty (unlike D-man Chris Pronger). He will probably always be remembered as the guy who hit Lindros.

BTW: Looks like this thread has morphed from Harris to Tatum to Stevens. The usual suspect (singular) hasn't complained yet that the thread has gone off-topic. Other than the usual suspect none of the other members bitch or only very rarely bitch about a thread being hijacked.

Stevens still smarting over sidelining Lindros | CBC Sports


Lots of threads go off topic.

Only one person, however, stands out up and above all the rest in having no compunction to hijack threads on a regular basis, no matter what the topic, and as a result has a very well deserved reputation. Maybe you never noticed, but he is the ONLY person that I criticize for doing so. To my knowledge, I've never criticized anyone else for this behaviour. So, to warn others, is totally unnecessary and inappropriate because it's applicable to no one else. Maybe I'm living in his head because he loves to warn others about me from out of nowhere. He seems to always think about me. LOL. I'll take it as a compliment. As well, this person will never, ever admit that they hijack threads.

That unnamed person does it, not for the sake of furthering a discussion, but because they think they are impressing others with their worldly knowledge (aka something to do with their hometown), which in reality is simply the ability to look up something on Wikipedia.

Of course, for the sake of propriety I won't name names. That's just the kind of guy I am. ;) :rolleyes::D