Eight steps to immediately accelerate climate action

Your thoughts that Western Nations are "More Evil than THE USSR" sums up your true colours especially as you are now defending Communism and authoritarianism. Wonder why the refugees fled the USSR to come to live in a more "evil nation" like the USA? Why was it just a one way traffic and hardly anyone moving in the opposite direction? You definitely follow the likes of RT News. No use wasting any more time or band width in discussing Russia. Maybe you have a statue of Putin that you adore!!

Oh please stop dishonestly twisting my words. I did not say western nations were more evil than the USSR - that is like blaming the culture and the people. For that matter, from a culture/people standpoint soviet (former nations) people are actually very warm and nice people.

Fundamentally:

- Both the US and Russia are not "good" - from a foreign policy stand point. They have both done horrible things, but the US and NATO, as a matter of fact, have done worse.
- You have more immigration to the west because you have more freedom here and more wealth. But freedom in the US has nothing to do with what it does in foreign countries when it invades them.
- A country being authoritarian, corrupt etc does not mean it cannot defend its sovereignty or attempt to do so. That includes neutralizing threats at its borders. This is the same principle that the US follows/followed.
 
Putin moved first.
He put troops around Ukraine's border in 2021.
By Jan 2022 the US knew about the plans and warned Ukraine.
Then Putin made his NATO demand, knowing full well that he was going to attack anyways, this would just give him a rationale to sell to his people and the GOP.

There were no threats or changes from NATO before 2021 when Putin started the buildup.

It is expected he would do so, because he did so in response to NATOs military activities (Defender Europe). He then asked for security guarantees starting around December 2021, which were rejected. Then the invasion happened. So no, NATO moved first.
 
Oh please stop dishonestly twisting my words. I did not say western nations were more evil than the USSR - that is like blaming the culture and the people. For that matter, from a culture/people standpoint soviet (former nations) people are actually very warm and nice people.

Fundamentally:

- Both the US and Russia are not "good" - from a foreign policy stand point. They have both done horrible things, but the US and NATO, as a matter of fact, have done worse.
- You have more immigration to the west because you have more freedom here and more wealth. But freedom in the US has nothing to do with what it does in foreign countries when it invades them.
- A country being authoritarian, corrupt etc does not mean it cannot defend its sovereignty or attempt to do so. That includes neutralizing threats at its borders. This is the same principle that the US follows/followed.

Forgot what you stated:

However, countries like the US that consider themselves bastions of freedom and democracy, and call themselves capitalistic have done just as much, if not MORE evil than the USSR.

If you have done "More Evil" than it implies that you are more EVIL!!
 
Forgot what you stated:
If you have done "More Evil" than it implies that you are more EVIL!!

There is a huge difference between a country's government and its citizens. The US performed human experiments on its citizens through the MKUltra program. So who is evil? The citizens that make up the country (who were victims in this case) or the government? The US also purposefully infected people with Syphillis in Guatemala. So does that make the US evil or no?

To be fair, the USSR has done so as well, but the US has done more damage overall on a global scale, while the USSR mostly brutalized their own people.

 
There is a huge difference between a country's government and its citizens. The US performed human experiments on its citizens through the MKUltra program. So who is evil? The citizens that make up the country (who were victims in this case) or the government? The US also purposefully infected people with Syphillis in Guatemala. So does that make the US evil or no?

To be fair, the USSR has done so as well, but the US has done more damage overall on a global scale, while the USSR mostly brutalized their own people.


Holodomor
Maybe this is not considered to be evil to you:

The Holodomor (Ukrainian: Голодомо́р, romanized: Holodomor, IPA: [ɦolodoˈmɔr];[2] derived from морити голодом, moryty holodom, 'to kill by starvation'),[a][3][4][5] also known as the Terror-Famine[6][7][8] or the Great Famine,[9] was a man-made famine in Soviet Ukraine from 1932 to 1933 that killed millions of Ukrainians. The Holodomor was part of the wider Soviet famine of 1932–1933 which affected the major grain-producing areas of the Soviet Union.[10]

While scholars universally agree that the cause of the famine was man-made, whether the Holodomor constitutes a genocide remains in dispute.[11][12][13] Some historians conclude that the famine was planned and exacerbated by Joseph Stalin in order to eliminate a Ukrainian independencemovement.[14][15] Others suggest that the famine arose because of rapid Soviet industrialisation and collectivization of agriculture.[16][17][18]

Ukraine was one of the largest grain-producing states in the USSR and was subject to unreasonably higher grain quotas, when compared to the rest of the country.[19][20][21] This caused Ukraine to be hit particularly hard by the famine.[10] Early estimates of the death toll by scholars and government officials vary greatly.[22] A joint statement to the United Nations signed by 25 countries in 2003 declared that 7–10 million died.[23][24]However, current scholarship estimates a range significantly lower, with 3.5 to 5 million victims.[25][26][27][28][24] The famine's widespread impact on Ukraine persists to this day.[25]

Since 2006, the Holodomor has been recognized by Ukraine[29] alongside 22 countries, as a genocide against the Ukrainian people carried out by the Soviet regime.[30]

 
Holodomor
Maybe this is not considered to be evil to you:

The Holodomor (Ukrainian: Голодомо́р, romanized: Holodomor, IPA: [ɦolodoˈmɔr];[2] derived from морити голодом, moryty holodom, 'to kill by starvation'),[a][3][4][5] also known as the Terror-Famine[6][7][8] or the Great Famine,[9] was a man-made famine in Soviet Ukraine from 1932 to 1933 that killed millions of Ukrainians. The Holodomor was part of the wider Soviet famine of 1932–1933 which affected the major grain-producing areas of the Soviet Union.[10]

While scholars universally agree that the cause of the famine was man-made, whether the Holodomor constitutes a genocide remains in dispute.[11][12][13] Some historians conclude that the famine was planned and exacerbated by Joseph Stalin in order to eliminate a Ukrainian independencemovement.[14][15] Others suggest that the famine arose because of rapid Soviet industrialisation and collectivization of agriculture.[16][17][18]

Ukraine was one of the largest grain-producing states in the USSR and was subject to unreasonably higher grain quotas, when compared to the rest of the country.[19][20][21] This caused Ukraine to be hit particularly hard by the famine.[10] Early estimates of the death toll by scholars and government officials vary greatly.[22] A joint statement to the United Nations signed by 25 countries in 2003 declared that 7–10 million died.[23][24]However, current scholarship estimates a range significantly lower, with 3.5 to 5 million victims.[25][26][27][28][24] The famine's widespread impact on Ukraine persists to this day.[25]

Since 2006, the Holodomor has been recognized by Ukraine[29] alongside 22 countries, as a genocide against the Ukrainian people carried out by the Soviet regime.[30]


You can quote things like this for every country. UK which is a member of NATO. Like I said USSR brutalized their own people, while US and NATO brutalize other countries. Which in my opinion is more outrageous.

 
You can quote things like this for every country. UK which is a member of NATO. Like I said USSR brutalized their own people, while US and NATO brutalize other countries. Which in my opinion is more outrageous.


So what makes Russia "less Evil" than the USA with the Bengal Famine?
Ukraine is not a part of Russia, yet they brutalized Ukraine!!
 
So what makes Russia "less Evil" than the USA with the Bengal Famine?
Ukraine is not a part of Russia, yet they brutalized Ukraine!!

The Holodomor happened in the USSR in the 30s. Ukraine was a part of the USSR. It isn't less evil, but like I said, the USSR brutalized their own people. US and NATO brutalize other countries which I consider more outrageous.
 
The Holodomor happened in the USSR in the 30s. Ukraine was a part of the USSR. It isn't less evil, but like I said, the USSR brutalized their own people. US and NATO brutalize other countries which I consider more outrageous.

If you take that same analogy then Bengal was a part of the British Colony. Then using the same logic the British brutalized those under their rule!! Hahahaha!!
Presently, the Russians are also bombing and killing thousands in Syria!!
 
If you take that same analogy then Bengal was a part of the British Colony. Then using the same logic the British brutalized those under their rule!! Hahahaha!!

No it is not the same.

Ukraine, was a part of the USSR - they were citizens of the Soviet Union.

India was a colony/dominion. Indians were not UK citizens nor did they retain any of the privileges of UK citizenship. It was same as Canada (with a lot more oppression and racism) - Canadians are not citizens of the UK and vice versa even though we are subjects of the crown.
 
No it is not the same.

Ukraine, was a part of the USSR - they were citizens of the Soviet Union.

India was a colony/dominion. Indians were not UK citizens nor did they retain any of the privileges of UK citizenship. It was same as Canada (with a lot more oppression and racism) - Canadians are not citizens of the UK and vice versa even though we are subjects of the crown.

Prior to independence there were two types of citizenship. British Subjects and British Protected. There were no individual nation citizenships as such. This was no different from the USSR that annexed 14 other nations. They became independent only after the breakup of the Soviet Union!!
 
Prior to independence there were two types of citizenship. British Subjects and British Protected. There were no individual nation citizenships as such. This was no different from the USSR that annexed 14 other nations. They became independent only after the breakup of the Soviet Union!!

This was not the case. The Russian Empire composed of all of those nations already - including Finland btw until 1917 when it gained independence. After the revolution, the USSR was formed and continued until 1991 when the USSR collapsed and the former soviet republics became independent nations.

The Crown's subjects are not citizens of the UK. Canadians for example are subjects of the crown, not citizens of UK.
 
Once again we are talking about before Independence. All those nations under British Rule in continents Africa, Australia, America and Asia, that were part of the British Colonies did not have their own national citizenships. You were either a British Protected Person or a British Subject. Once you gained Independence like Canada then it is no different as to the individual nations like Ukraine that broke away from The Soviet Union and now have their own Citizenships. People with British Protected Passports were stateless after Independence, but those British Subjects could apply to be British Citizens. That is why many Asians and those from Caribbean countries went to reside in the UK after Independence of those nations!!
 
Once again we are talking about before Independence. All those nations under British Rule in continents Africa, Australia, America and Asia, that were part of the British Colonies did not have their own national citizenships. You were either a British Protected Person or a British Subject. Once you gained Independence like Canada then it is no different as to the individual nations like Ukraine that broke away from The Soviet Union and now have their own Citizenships. People with British Protected Passports were stateless after Independence, but those British Subjects could apply to be British Citizens. That is why many Asians and those from Caribbean countries went to reside in the UK after Independence of those nations!!

Right, but British subjects neither qualify as citizens of the UK nor do they retain any of its privileges. They were foreign nations that were OCCUPIED by a foreign force and held down with force. This was certainly the case with India.
 
Right, but British subjects neither qualify as citizens of the UK nor do they retain any of its privileges. They were foreign nations that were OCCUPIED by a foreign force and held down with force. This was certainly the case with India.

Wrong. British Subjects were allowed to emigrate to the UK. The British Protected Citizens could travel without visas but received a maximum of 6 months residency and if they could be employed then they could renew their visas and after 5 years apply for full citizenship. The vast majority of Indians neither applied for those British passports or automatically opted for Indian Citizenship. Many of these Indians who had British Subjects or Protected status went to nations in Africa, or The West Indies to live as these were still under British rule!!

But Russia annexed all those 14 nations, meaning that they occupied them. All these nations were glad to show Russia the finger after the Wall came down!!

Also read:

 
It is expected he would do so, because he did so in response to NATOs military activities (Defender Europe). He then asked for security guarantees starting around December 2021, which were rejected. Then the invasion happened. So no, NATO moved first.

No, I just showed you that Putin moved first with a buildup of armed forces around Ukraine starting in early 2021.
Putin had his troops in place for an invasion before any NATO talk came up and the US already knew his plans.

I agree that the US has started at least as many wars.
The choice is to stand up against those as well as Putin's, not say one is bad and one is good.
 
No, I just showed you that Putin moved first with a buildup of armed forces around Ukraine starting in early 2021.
Putin had his troops in place for an invasion before any NATO talk came up and the US already knew his plans.

I agree that the US has started at least as many wars.
The choice is to stand up against those as well as Putin's, not say one is bad and one is good.

Even if he did that, he is moving troops within his borders. What is wrong with that? I understand it represents an adversarial position, however the Ukrainian war was well underway. That said the buildup happened after Ukraine arrested Viktor Medvedchuk who was pro Russian, so perhaps the reasoning was to pre-empt Ukraine from joining NATO?
 
Even if he did that, he is moving troops within his borders. What is wrong with that? I understand it represents an adversarial position, however the Ukrainian war was well underway. That said the buildup happened after Ukraine arrested Viktor Medvedchuk who was pro Russian, so perhaps the reasoning was to pre-empt Ukraine from joining NATO?

You answered your own question.

The NATO thing was Putin's Bay of Tonkin.
He knew what he was going to do before, as did the US.
 
Wrong. British Subjects were allowed to emigrate to the UK. The British Protected Citizens could travel without visas but received a maximum of 6 months residency and if they could be employed then they could renew their visas and after 5 years apply for full citizenship. The vast majority of Indians neither applied for those British passports or automatically opted for Indian Citizenship. Many of these Indians who had British Subjects or Protected status went to nations in Africa, or The West Indies to live as these were still under British rule!!

But Russia annexed all those 14 nations, meaning that they occupied them. All these nations were glad to show Russia the finger after the Wall came down!!

Also read:


Emigrating to Britain and British citizenship are very different things. Also British India was not a British Protectorate.

The fact that there were immigration rules means they were NOT citizens. Every country allowed people to immigrate, UK wasn't special. Indians were subjects of the crown, and British India was a dominion. Indians were not citizens, couldn't vote in British elections etc., You said it yourself, they had to immigrate, claim residency and then apply for citizenship. So they were NOT citizens.

On the other hand, Russia did NOT annex those 14 current nations. They were part of the Russian Empire. The Empire was ended with the Russian Revolution and USSR was formed. When it collapsed the former SSRs, split into independent nations. So NO, they were NOT annexed.

You are just replying for the sake of replying and engaging in revisionism.
 
You answered your own question.

The NATO thing was Putin's Bay of Tonkin.
He knew what he was going to do before, as did the US.

But it is war. Ukraine's moves against pro-Russian politicians, starting with the ousting of Yanukovych, would have raised suspicions about NATO/US involvement, if you see it from Putin's shoes.