Denying Holocaust Will be Illegal

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, in your OPINION, was the Holocaust an intentional plan by Nazi Germany to first lock up and later execute people specifically because their religion, ethnicity, or sexual orientation?
I predict more bobbing and weaving and covering up than Floyd Mayweather, whom I considered a big chicken.
 
Is it too confusing for you?








So, in your OPINION, was the Holocaust an intentional plan by Nazi Germany to first lock up and later execute people specifically because their religion, ethnicity, or sexual orientation?
No, it is not too confusing for me, but what is too confusing obviously for you is to tell me why exactly you feel that some opinions cannot be heard.

For the record, the holocaust IMO was the extermination by NAZIs of millions of Jews and Homosexuals and Gypsies. In the same conflict 20million Russians were killed because they were Russians and stood in the way of the Nazis plans. In fact, millions of people of every description were killed.

That is my opinion, but if someone else has a different opinion, I would be interested in hearing that opinion, and why they believe it.

Now, please again tell me again what opinion I am afraid to share? I have already in fact said that thi sis not about a specific opinion, it is about the right to express it.

And please tell me, do you feel that MY opinion here in TERB against censorship - since you are obviously (to yourself) right, do you wish TERB to censor my views on this subject?
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
We all know why you are ducking an answer. You are afraid to express your true views. They would be too revealing.

I'm sure you have expressed lots of opinions in the last 9 years. All of a sudden you are shy. Your silence is a self-indictment.
WHAT opinion is it I am afraid to share? I can hardly answer your question if you aren't straight up courageous enough to ask me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
Disagreeing with the shape of the earth does not help to foment hate against a race.

There is no point of view regarding the Holocaust. It happened. Same as above, it foments more hate initiated by people who hate. That's the risk. I know it does not put YOU at risk, so why should you care?

So you are OK with somebody yelling "FIRE" in a crowded theatre? Or somebody yelling "I HAVE A BOMB" on an airplane?

It's free speech, right? Not allowing somebody to yell fire is totalitarian.
So, that's it, you are saying that some things are just true - you have decided it, it is soooooo obvious - and that therefore....

dum roll...

since it is so obvious, so EASILY proven, we are afraid to hear an opposing point of view!

Question:

WHAT IF YOU GET IT WRONG?

And what if a political power misuses this precedent of shutting off discussion of things that may actually argue against their hold on power? Which is PRECISELY what history shows that happens all the time, an dwhat precisely (and IRONICALLY!) th eNAZIS thenmselves did!

Do you really think that the NAZIS allowed a fair and open discussion about jews to occur? Of course they didn't.

And what would have been their response to such a request?

THE EXACT SAME AS YOURS: they were right, so why should they of allowed an opposing point of view.

You have only one argumentative tactic: you are right, its obvious, so everyone else has to shut up.
 
The bobbing and ineffectual weaving is coming from you two.

You clearly are naiive in your understanding of the nature of history, power, and the necessity for checks and balances on government power.

Censorship is a cancer, it grows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
Also, the two of you have yet to respond to my simple question:

If you are right, then are you in favour of TERB censoring my (obviously incorrect) views on free speech?

To be internally consistent, since you apparently KNOW I am wrong, you should seek to ensure that my opinions are not heard.

Have you made such a request, and if not, why not?
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
WHAT opinion is it I am afraid to share? I can hardly answer your question if you aren't straight up courageous enough to ask me.
It's been asked.
Do you deny that the Holocaust was an intentional plan by Nazi Germany to first lock up and later execute people specifically because their religion, ethnicity, or sexual orientation?
[/QUOTE
 
No, it is not too confusing for me, but what is too confusing obviously for you is to tell me why exactly you feel that some opinions cannot be heard.
...
Where did you see me post that honest opinions shouldn't be heard?

Denying the scope of the Holocaust is as dumb as believing in a flat Earth. The only difference is that Holocaust denial is used explicitly as a racist endeavour. Are you upset that Canada is looking to ban racist trolling as even TERB does?



But thank you for giving a straight answer about the Holocaust. Most people who complain about this issue are people who are simply upset that Jews and others complain about being targeted by it.
 
...

WHAT IF YOU GET IT WRONG?
...
In the case of the Holocaust, there is zero percent chance of that. There is Nazi documentation, there is documentation from the armies that liberated the camps, there are the mass graves, piles of bones or teeth, lamps made of skin, the testimony of both survivors and the perpetrators, and property of dead victims. People who intentionally ignore all that can only be motivated by obsessive hatred and have no interest in promoting any kind of truth.

We absolutely know all the big picture elements of the Holocaust even if we can't say to the exact number of people were butchered was slightly above or below 6 million.
 
Speaking of targeting Jews..


Can't you keep you anti-"israel" obsession out of the thread about Jew hatred?

I'm posting about Jews who show love, Jews who are against hate in the form of apartheid.
If you want to take the side of those who defend apartheid you can choose to do so.
But claiming you speak for an entire race is a trope.

There are so many moral Jews and Jewish groups, this board needs to be reminded of that fact in contrast to your posts.
Ifnotnow
IJVCanada
B'tselem
BreakingtheSilence
 
In the case of the Holocaust, there is zero percent chance of that. There is Nazi documentation, there is documentation from the armies that liberated the camps, there are the mass graves, piles of bones or teeth, lamps made of skin, the testimony of both survivors and the perpetrators, and property of dead victims. People who intentionally ignore all that can only be motivated by obsessive hatred and have no interest in promoting any kind of truth.

We absolutely know all the big picture elements of the Holocaust even if we can't say to the exact number of people were butchered was slightly above or below 6 million.
So.....

if it is al lso obvious, why stop free speech on the matter?

You are cowardly in that you NEVER answer this question.
 
Where did you see me post that honest opinions shouldn't be heard?

Denying the scope of the Holocaust is as dumb as believing in a flat Earth. The only difference is that Holocaust denial is used explicitly as a racist endeavour. Are you upset that Canada is looking to ban racist trolling as even TERB does?



But thank you for giving a straight answer about the Holocaust. Most people who complain about this issue are people who are simply upset that Jews and others complain about being targeted by it.
So YOU decide what is an "HONEST" opinion?

What is th ebig problem with just letting all opinions be heard.

Again, I call you a coward because you will not answer this.
 
Hateful racism tears our world apart and leads to genocide. The Holocaust is proof of that.
Censorship and a closed dialogue aids racism.

Dictatorships and governments that grossly abuse human rights routinely, I will dare say, ALWAYS, employ censorship and denial of of free speech, as a tool to further their hateful propaganda and lies.

This is the very tool that you embrace ...because ... "you know you are right".

forget who "knows" what . prove it. In an open forum. You are trying to shut down debate. I do not care what the issue is, shutting down debate is dangerous. and you are falling for it.

if you are right in a free speech democracy - win the debate. You should welcome the chance to prove your point.

The Holocaust is proof that human rights are the most important guarantor that the Holocaust and countless other tragedies will never occur again.

Unfortunately, there you are, you seem to feel that the VERY tool used by the Holocaust perpetrators - censorship - is something that you bizarrely feel will in fact stop it from occurring!

Hello,.....McFly! Can you say , hypocrisy????
 
Status
Not open for further replies.