Duelling Town Halls

This blew my mind, but then I remembered there are Republican politicians who have said Mr Rogers was fundamentally evil and realized these people are sociopaths.

Mr. Rogers is a fascinating subject. A trained musician who spent his entertainment career as a sort of child psychologist and parenting advisor (although he had a strained relationship with one of his own sons at times). I can't think of anything fundamentally evil he ever said, but he was both a very empathetically gifted and a very odd person. Extremely religous in his personal life, it didn't seem to pervade the moralism of his messages to children. From the same small town as Arnold Palmer.

Fred Rogers always seemed in complete control of his faculties and emotions. I can see no comparison to Biden.
 
Really? Do you think his character presents any differently than it did in 2016? I don't. If independents change their minds this go around it won't be because they suddenly realize Trump is Trump.
In 2016 he was a character that did things differently than the standard politician...in 2020, they’ve seen enough.
 
Really? Do you think his character presents any differently than it did in 2016? I don't. If independents change their minds this go around it won't be because they suddenly realize Trump is Trump.

For some yes.
They only got a shielded version of Trump in the runup to 2016. He gets shielded by the press even now.
Unfiltered nonsense Trump isn't something people see a lot of and with everything going to shit people have even less patience for it.

Mr. Rogers is a fascinating subject. A trained musician who spent his entertainment career as a sort of child psychologist and parenting advisor (although he had a strained relationship with one of his own sons at times). I can't think of anything fundamentally evil he ever said, but he was both a very empathetically gifted and a very odd person. Extremely religous in his personal life, it didn't seem to pervade the moralism of his messages to children. From the same small town as Arnold Palmer.

Fred Rogers always seemed in complete control of his faculties and emotions. I can see no comparison to Biden.

And yet comparing Biden to Mr Rogers as if it was an insult is something that happened.
 
New debate rules, mics will be muted during 2 minute rebuttals.
Wonder how long that lasts before Trump starts running right at Biden and his live mic.
 
Not convinced Trump will show up.
He hates debates, he prefers rally crowds, and being under the control of a woman who can shut him up at will would infuriate him.
I think the letter the campaign sent is an excuse to declare it rigged and then run away from the debate again.
 
Not convinced Trump will show up.
He hates debates, he prefers rally crowds, and being under the control of a woman who can shut him up at will would infuriate him.
I think the letter the campaign sent is an excuse to declare it rigged and then run away from the debate again.

One, Trump will show up. Two, he loves debates - his way. He thinks he wins them (it depends on your definition of "winning" as to whether he is right). Three, it's really not the role of a moderator to "shut up" presidential candidates. That's 1984 stuff. The public can decide how the actions of a candidate during a debate will influence their vote. Four, I don't think Trump takes any more kindly to men who get in his way than he does to women. Five, pointing out all the things the media surrogates of the Dems do to interfere in the election is Trump's perpetual theme. He loves to be able to demonstrate his point in a concrete way. These debate scuffles help his argument. He won't abandon the debate if only for that reason alone.

Last of all, the debate moderator IS in the tank for Biden and the Dems. I can't think of any rational reason not to point that out to independent voters before, during, and after the debate. The Dems would never think of doing this, but I think Trump would actually be more uncomfortable with a moderator who focussed his/her heat on Biden. There'd be no room for Trump to play the "last bastion of American freedom" role in that scenario.
 
I'm not in favour of the muted mic, I understand why they are doing it.

If one of the candidates acts like a donkey and constantly interrupts and is a disturbance than he gets judged on his behaviour...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dutch Oven
I'm not in favour of the muted mic, I understand why they are doing it.

I understand the Commission feels entitled to do it and what they think it might accomplish (I think they're wrong about both points). I don't understand why so many people want to cede to a bunch of unelected swamp creatures that kind of authority.
 
I understand the Commission feels entitled to do it and what they think it might accomplish (I think they're wrong about both points). I don't understand why so many people want to cede to a bunch of unelected swamp creatures that kind of authority.
I understand...the first debate was a disgrace, there was no discussions about policy/etc due to Trump's behaviour in which he interrupted 145 times.
 
I understand...the first debate was a disgrace, there was no discussions about policy/etc due to Trump's behaviour in which he interrupted 145 times.

How much more policy, particularly from Biden (who doesn't have any), do you think we'll get from Biden or Trump blathering out their talking points uninterupted? Or are you ok with interruptions, as long as they are by the moderator? How many times do you predict will the moderator interrupt Trump in this format?
 
How much more policy, particularly from Biden (who doesn't have any), do you think we'll get from Biden or Trump blathering out their talking points uninterupted? Or are you ok with interruptions, as long as they are by the moderator? How many times do you predict will the moderator interrupt Trump in this format?
I think the muted mic will, at the very least, give them both a chance to speak.
 
I think the muted mic will, at the very least, give them both a chance to speak.

I noticed you didn't bravely claim that we'll hear a lot more clear policy as a result. ;) Now, the nothingness will be crystal clear. Do voters even care that Biden's Covid plan is to do what Trump has already been doing, and if that doesn't work, shut the economy down with no plan as to how to recover from that?

I still think the public got a lot more out of the dueling town hall format. I think it's the better approach. I wonder if the problem is that the ratings were worse than a head to head debate?
 
I noticed you didn't bravely claim that we'll hear a lot more clear policy as a result. ;) Now, the nothingness will be crystal clear. Do voters even care that Biden's Covid plan is to do what Trump has already been doing, and if that doesn't work, shut the economy down with no plan as to how to recover from that?

I still think the public got a lot more out of the dueling town hall format. I think it's the better approach. I wonder if the problem is that the ratings were worse than a head to head debate?
I said 'they both will have a chance to speak', what do you think they'd be talking about, the World Series, of course there will be more policy talk.

I didn't mind the Town Halls, they got to speak...the power of the debate is that if one of of them, in this case probably both, is way off base with their views and even lying, the other can respond almost immediately.
 
I said 'they both will have a chance to speak', what do you think they'd be talking about, the World Series, of course there will be more policy talk.

I didn't mind the Town Halls, they got to speak...the power of the debate is that if one of of them, in this case probably both, is way off base with their views and even lying, the other can respond almost immediately.

In today's world, claims that the other side is "way off" get "fact checked" afterward, regardless what is said at the debate, and because that fact checking is largely a farce, voters are left to decide what they believe in any event.

I'll bet the proverbial farm that the public learns almost nothing new about either platform. The only thing that is new is the e-mail release about Biden's role in Hunter's business for Sleepy Joe to answer to, but we won't get any clear answers from him even if the moderator deigns to ask him a question about it. Only the lowest information voter (who has been in a coma for the last year) will get anything out of this.
 
In today's world, claims that the other side is "way off" get "fact checked" afterward, regardless what is said at the debate, and because that fact checking is largely a farce, voters are left to decide what they believe in any event.

I'll bet the proverbial farm that the public learns almost nothing new about either platform. The only thing that is new is the e-mail release about Biden's role in Hunter's business for Sleepy Joe to answer to, but we won't get any clear answers from him even if the moderator deigns to ask him a question about it. Only the lowest information voter (who has been in a coma for the last year) will get anything out of this.
Trump will attempt to make Hunter an issue but I'm sure Joe Biden will be prepared for it.
 
One, Trump will show up. Two, he loves debates - his way. He thinks he wins them (it depends on your definition of "winning" as to whether he is right). Three, it's really not the role of a moderator to "shut up" presidential candidates.

It is if they won't shut up.

Four, I don't think Trump takes any more kindly to men who get in his way than he does to women.

He's consistently worse with women.

Five, pointing out all the things the media surrogates of the Dems do to interfere in the election is Trump's perpetual theme. He loves to be able to demonstrate his point in a concrete way. These debate scuffles help his argument. He won't abandon the debate if only for that reason alone.

He already abandoned one. He desperately needs to do these debates. When you are behind you want more debates. That he's dancing with running away again shows that he is even more afraid of them than we thought. He should be BEGGING for a chance to do more debates, but instead we are getting a litany of pre-excuses. I am sure the campaign is fighting tooth and nail to make sure he goes to the debate and to try and convince him it is important, but that they are covering their asses in advance makes it seem like they aren't convinced they can get Trump to go.

If they win on the microphone issue, he will go, because then Trump will probably think of it as him winning the right to just ignore all the rules and yell over everyone.

Last of all, the debate moderator IS in the tank for Biden and the Dems. I can't think of any rational reason not to point that out to independent voters before, during, and after the debate. The Dems would never think of doing this, but I think Trump would actually be more uncomfortable with a moderator who focussed his/her heat on Biden. There'd be no room for Trump to play the "last bastion of American freedom" role in that scenario.

I agree that Trump would hate to feel like the moderator was doing a better job of hitting Biden than he was. The problem is that while the moderators will happily frame the questions with the right wing framing, they won't just go in for conspiracy theory nonsensical bullshit attacks. They would need to get OANN to do the debates. Look at what happened in the first debate. Wallace was happy to frame all the questions in the pro-conservative manner but Trump didn't hear what he wanted and attacked Wallace and stepped on his own dick.

I'm not in favour of the muted mic, I understand why they are doing it.

If one of the candidates acts like a donkey and constantly interrupts and is a disturbance than he gets judged on his behaviour...

Exactly, there should be no need for it. The minor interruption and run on is fine. Given what we saw, though, Trump can't be treated like an adult.

I understand the Commission feels entitled to do it and what they think it might accomplish (I think they're wrong about both points). I don't understand why so many people want to cede to a bunch of unelected swamp creatures that kind of authority.

They agreed to rules, so the refs are enforcing the rules.
Anyone who hosts a debate is going to put rules in. The GOP and the Dems decided years ago to set up a joint commission that wouldn't ask hard questions and would keep third parties out as much as possible. That Trump can't even follow those rules is on him.
If the GOP wants to break with the commission going forward and have no debates or have individual groups pitch debate rules and hope the candidates accept, that' fine with me. .

How much more policy, particularly from Biden (who doesn't have any), do you think we'll get from Biden or Trump blathering out their talking points uninterupted?

Very little. These debates aren't informative. They are designed that way. Turning them into the Trump shock jock show doesn't give you policy either.
If they wanted to actually make the format be the candidates question each other, that would be more interesting (although you would still need to have a moderator and have someone cut the mic when Trump went over time and interrupted.)

How many times do you predict will the moderator interrupt Trump in this format?

How many times do you expect Trump to run over his time limit, try to speak over Biden, or insult the moderator?