Sports Changes

Back to soccer, i would like to see two more things - Get rid of the offside rule and penalty kick for when a player does the fake injury routine.
 
In a woman's soccer match US player takes the ball to the offensive corner and uses her body to protect the ball just to waste time as they had the lead. Crowd was booing. Surely, there must be a rule to stop something like this.
 
So hear me out here.

I would mandate that all goalie equipment would go back to exact same size that they used in the 70's. No need to increase the size of the nets now.

Also I would do away with these hybrid sticks and allow only wooden sticks.

This way not every player could fire rockets from the blue line. But with the goalies being smaller there is still ample chance to score. Would also cut down on injuries from players getting hit with the puck going 100mph.

Cuts down on all the broken sticks as well. Making the game cheaper right down through the minor leagues and Rep hockey to beer leagues.

That's right a return to the past in some regard but with the modern lighter goalie equipment of today.

I know most will hate this........
I don't disagree but it will never happen because the NHLPA will cite safety concerns for their goalies. There will still be some guys who will be able to shoot it really hard with wooden sticks. It was before my time but I was told that goalies were afraid of Bobby Hull's shot and would actually move out of the net in certain situations when he was close to the net. I also saw with my own eyes goalies doing this when Al MacInnis was winding up from the point. Goalies aren't afraid of anyone now because they have bomb proof equipment on now. The easy solution is bigger nets.
 
I don't disagree but it will never happen because the NHLPA will cite safety concerns for their goalies. There will still be some guys who will be able to shoot it really hard with wooden sticks. It was before my time but I was told that goalies were afraid of Bobby Hull's shot and would actually move out of the net in certain situations when he was close to the net. I also saw with my own eyes goalies doing this when Al MacInnis was winding up from the point. Goalies aren't afraid of anyone now because they have bomb proof equipment on now. The easy solution is bigger nets.

Goose I think you missed my point.

You keep the bomb proof equipment but you reduce the size of it. Now there's more of the net for the shooter to see.

Of course that will piss off the goalies. So just to balance it out you go back to the wooden sticks so not every opponent can take their head off with a shot.

Plus we don't see 5 or so broken sticks a game during key moments. This of course drives down the price of sticks. So when your son wants a stick to play in his rep league you don't have to fork out $150 or so.
 
Don't get me wrong, your premise makes sense. I just think it's to many changes for the players accept. If you ask them what they prefer, smaller equipment and wooden sticks or bigger nets. I bet the vast majority pick bigger nets. Don't forget the NHLPA has to ok the changes.
 
The size of the net has been the current standard for a very long time. Making it bigger is like making the basketball net smaller because the players shoot too well or increasing the distance between bases because the players are too fast or making the tennis court bigger because the players get to too many balls. You can change rules and equipment but fucking with the most basic of standards of dimensions of the playing and scoring area, IMO, is too drastic.

Having a huge catching glove does not provide more protection to the hand. It just gives the shooter less room to work with. Having leg pads that extend out probably 6 inches beyond the periphery of the leg on each side, does not provide more protection. The improved materials provide lots of protection.

Making the net bigger may be easier, but I don't think that that makes it the proper approach.
 
In a woman's soccer match US player takes the ball to the offensive corner and uses her body to protect the ball just to waste time as they had the lead. Crowd was booing. Surely, there must be a rule to stop something like this.

Scenario: Say it is the start of the second half and your team has a one goal lead in a must win game. As soon as you have possession of the ball your team forms a tight circle around the ball so no intruder can get in. Team stays in that position until the final whistle. Is that against the rules?
 
Yes, agree (assuming it is doable). If MLB can reduce the height of the mound ("Bob Gibson Rule"), one would think the NHL can increase the size of the net.
Absolutely, not only did the lower the mound they move the fences in at ballparks to create more offence.
 
Scenario: Say it is the start of the second half and your team has a one goal lead in a must win game. As soon as you have possession of the ball your team forms a tight circle around the ball so no intruder can get in. Team stays in that position until the final whistle. Is that against the rules?
Precisely. Same situation more or less. Wasting time. Basketball got through that with a shot clock to generate turnovers. Guess the only thing soccer has going for it is the spirit of the game. I'm sure teams waste time with a lead but it's not as overt.

How about hockey. Why can't a player just stand behind the net forever with the puck?
 
Back in olden days, the NHL only allowed no more than one assist per goal. Too often the second assist is given to a player who simply just touched the puck and did nothing more.
 
Precisely. Same situation more or less. Wasting time. Basketball got through that with a shot clock to generate turnovers. Guess the only thing soccer has going for it is the spirit of the game. I'm sure teams waste time with a lead but it's not as overt.

How about hockey. Why can't a player just stand behind the net forever with the puck?

The flyers tried that one game a couple of years ago and were hit with a delay of game penalty.
 
Last edited:
I think the flyers tried that one game a couple of years ago and were hit with a delay of game penalty. I could be mistaken though...
I remember one game a team was playing the trap hanging out in the neutral zone. The other team just passed it back and forth between the 2 defenseman so nothing happened. It was a standstill. What's to stop both teams from doing this for 3 periods and play for the extra point in OT? Say last game of the season. 2 teams from each conference meet. Each requires only a single point to make the playoffs. So in essence if it goes to OT both teams make the playoffs otherwise only 1 team. Where an OT loss is actually a win.
 
Last edited:
The size of the net has been the current standard for a very long time. Making it bigger is like making the basketball net smaller because the players shoot too well or increasing the distance between bases because the players are too fast or making the tennis court bigger because the players get to too many balls. You can change rules and equipment but fucking with the most basic of standards of dimensions of the playing and scoring area, IMO, is too drastic.

Having a huge catching glove does not provide more protection to the hand. It just gives the shooter less room to work with. Having leg pads that extend out probably 6 inches beyond the periphery of the leg on each side, does not provide more protection. The improved materials provide lots of protection.

Making the net bigger may be easier, but I don't think that that makes it the proper approach.
I don't think it's drastic at all. Baseball has moved fences in and changed dimensions to ballparks to increase scoring. The NBA added the 3 point shot changing the scoring area. Has the game suffered because of this? No. You will never get the NHLPA to agree the smaller goalie equipment. They will cite safety concerns because the players are bigger and shoot harder than they ever did. The logical idea is to increase the scoring area. I wouldn't increase the height just from post to post. The playoffs were very boring, due to the style of play and lack of scoring.
 
So hear me out here.

I would mandate that all goalie equipment would go back to exact same size that they used in the 70's. No need to increase the size of the nets now.

Also I would do away with these hybrid sticks and allow only wooden sticks.

This way not every player could fire rockets from the blue line. But with the goalies being smaller there is still ample chance to score. Would also cut down on injuries from players getting hit with the puck going 100mph.

Cuts down on all the broken sticks as well. Making the game cheaper right down through the minor leagues and Rep hockey to beer leagues.

That's right a return to the past in some regard but with the modern lighter goalie equipment of today.

I know most will hate this........
Actually, I don't hate it at all. If anything, it makes stats comparisons more equal to the past.
 
I don't think it's drastic at all. Baseball has moved fences in and changed dimensions to ballparks to increase scoring. There is no uniformity of ballparks. No 2 ballparks have the same dimensions. I think the individual teams control that as opposed to a mandate from the league. The size of the goal has been uniform for all teams and throughout history. A comparison to baseball to changing the size of the goal, would be changing the size of home plate. Do you think that baseball would ever do that? I don't. It is historical.

The NBA added the 3 point shot changing the scoring area. That did not change the size of the court or change the size of the net. Do you think that basketball would increase or decrease the circumference of the net? All sports evolve and change rules. Very few, make changes to the playing/scoring areas.

You will never get the NHLPA to agree the smaller goalie equipment. They will cite safety concerns because the players are bigger and shoot harder than they ever did. I can see the goalies arguing that to the hilt. Not so sure about the shooters. I don't think that they'd mind padding their stats. I had previously pointed out how extra large catching gloves or extra wide leg pads do not provide extra protection. If the hand is fully covered, having the glove extend (just picking a random number here) 6 inches beyond the hand as opposed to 4 inches beyond the hand does not protect the hand anymore. Same with the width of the leg pads. As long as the leg is fully covered extra width provides no extra protection. It just takes up more room. They just take away space for the puck to get past the goalie. I agree it would be a battle, but IMO, one worth fighting for.

The logical idea is to increase the scoring area. I wouldn't increase the height just from post to post. The playoffs were very boring, due to the style of play and lack of scoring.
I don't know what can be done about it, but I think the boring play is because the game is overcoached. Players are not allowed to freewheel like they used to. Their assignments are so specific that there is very little improvisation nowadays. How many players rush the puck now, the way Orr, Robinson or Gil Perrault used to do? Those were exciting guys/plays. Now the D'men, especially, would get called out by the coach for being out of position from taking those solo rushes. How do you stop coaches from thinking defence first? But I think that is a major, major cause of the boring play.

It wouldn't work for the playoffs, but in the regular season, if the winning team scores 5 or more goals (or some other number) they'd get 3 points instead of two. You wouldn't see teams sitting on a 4-1 lead. A lot of coaches would want that extra goal for the extra point in the standings. It would open things up.