FBI investigating death of suspect after Minneapolis police officer put knee on neck

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
32,637
60,568
113
I don't think that is exactly true. It depends on the policy. The nuances can be shown with two simple questions. Is it systemic racism that blacks are convicted of crimes disproportionately more than whites? Is it systemic racism that blacks are sentenced to longer sentences for the same crime than whites?
Yes. Because the system makes those outcomes more likely.

I have personally found people make ridiculous arguments of systemic racism in reference to common public policy. Do schools that punish black students disproportionately practicing systemic racism? Should schools strive to punish students in proportion to the school's racial composition? The Obama Administration thought so.
I have no idea what you are talking about for that Obama bit.
 

Gooseifur

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2019
3,829
441
83

There was systemic racism re hiring, lending to and housing blacks into at least the 1980's. I remember my good ol' boy Brit father explaining to me that blacks couldn't be quarterbacks in the NFL because they weren't "smart like white men". End of the 1970's that was.

So you need to do a lot of reading up before you share your opinions around.
I guess you didn't read my post because it states they they have never had it better than they do now. I agree it was a lot worse back then but to say it hasn't gotten a lot better is false.
 

Gooseifur

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2019
3,829
441
83
I'm not sure how you think your ancestors experience in any way relates to slavery in the USA, the legacies of it which include Jim Crow and the fight for civil rights. You thought because slavery was over black's weren't hunted and killed with their killers going free? Do you think it was ok to form USA PD departments using KKK members? You thought that was a good idea?

Do you even know what the US justice system does and why for the same crime blacks get the 3 years while whites go home if they don't 6 months? Would you believe me if I told you a white judge refused to convict a white adult for using an object to sodomise a disabled black child that it wasn't sexual assault or even sexual in nature and sent him home?

Speaking of slavery and the legacies, do you know why confederate statues were erected? Do you know why it was a big deal to FINALLY remove them just the other day? Are there Nazi statues all over Germany? Then you'd wonder why they were all over the southern part of the USA right?

There is a lot to say on this subject that you clearly don't understand. You'll need to get the education outside of TERB. Any time you're ready for it, just say so. Every group's experience in the USA will be different Blacks and Native Americans were the two who here heavily targetted and everything they built was destroyed.

As for what happened hundreds years ago not mattering now, you should go tell that to Haiti. LOL. Enslaved. Fight for freedom. Owe your slave masters because you won and kicked them out. Debt finally paid off in 1947. Poor as fuck now. Piece of shit leaders (probably beholden to France) who steal from the people doesn't help, but still...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/External_debt_of_Haiti
Because my ancestors had the same struggles as the blacks did. They were slaves, the women were raped and forced to have the Turks children and the men were brutalized and killed, so yes I do know what I'm talking about. If they were even accused of a crime there was no trial. They were just killed. My point is that was a long time ago. It's not relevant now. I do agree with you when it comes ti justice. They do get higher sentences for the same crimes. When it comes to that including policing there needs to be much improvement but when it comes to everything else they have the same opportunities as everyone else. If they get a good education. They can make a good life for themselves.
 

Gooseifur

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2019
3,829
441
83
The race baiters love to provide all kinds of race based statistics except statistics on black crime and black criminals.

BTW: You are wasting your time trying to reason with that other poster as his posts are nothing more than rants and false racist accusations. Thank you for trying anyway.
Agreed.
 

Gooseifur

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2019
3,829
441
83
When you're ready to have an intelligent conversation you can let us know. We are talking about the American system and the legacy of it, and your bringing in a lot of pointless nonsense. The laughable parts are listing who was 'treated like dirt'. Go away with your false equivalences and come back with a real argument about US chattel slavery, the civil war, Jim crow, and everything that followed.

If you need the education, just let me know. I can help you find the information. You clearly know nothing about the American system and it's history.

I honestly think you lack reading comprehension skills, and I hope it's because English is not your first language. I am not sure how Canada jumped in this conversation.

I mean, are you well?

PS: There were Irish indentured servants in Jamaica during slavery. Although Irish were poorly treated, do you think they had the same experience as African slaves in Jamaica at the same time?? East Indians were also brought to the Caribbean under the same indentured servitude. What do you know about indentured servitude as opposed to slavery?? Start here if you wish: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indentured_servitude

PPS: But alas all that has nothing to do with the legacies of USA and what we see taking place now....in the USA.
I love it how you dismiss what everyone else went through. Like he said slavery is not unique to the blacks in the U.S. Get over it. Only the black experience matters, Right?
 

Gooseifur

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2019
3,829
441
83
Again, what does black on black crime have to do with paid public servants committing crime and not being held accountable?? You still can't explain this?

Is it tax dollars well spent to have state sanctioned murder and brutality?

When black people kill each other, they go to prison. The cops who murder...DO NOT. Are you seeing the point yet, or do you need someone to draw you a picture to colour?

Or are you saying that since black people kill each other, it's only fair that police get to murder black people too? Fair enough. Everyone should get to murder black people, but they all should go to prison. DEAL????

Then there's the corrupt system that over charges and over punishes black criminals more than they do white ones for the same crime.

Please pay attention!!
No balck people don't always go to prison when they kill another black. A lot of those crimes go unsolved because you are considered the lowest form of life if you are are rat. Very few are willing to step forward and do the right thing.
 

basketcase

Well-known member
Dec 29, 2005
61,358
6,671
113
...My ancestors were brutalized and oppressed by the Turks during the Ottoman empire, nobody is crying about it now....
Really? So why does recognition of the Armenian genocide keep coming up?

You also miss a major difference. Your family chose to come here and weren't freed from slavery into sharecropping or factory work which wasn't much different.

I guess you do have a point though, black people today have it better than they did under the whip or Jim Crow (though no idea what that is supposed to prove).
 

basketcase

Well-known member
Dec 29, 2005
61,358
6,671
113
...

Many different races and groups have been enslaved, and have enslaved others. Blacks don't have the monopoly on being victims, and whites don't have the monopoly on victimization. So bringing it up now to justify political opinion on current day events is a straw man argument, and simply shows your inability to grasp current concepts and events.
....
Of course Blacks aren't the only victims over the years. They are the only group that were transported en masse to a new place as slaves then faced a post-slavery world where they still had essentially zero rights.


BTW. My Irish ancestors became indistinguishable from the WASPs when they used the 'proper' way of speaking they learned as indentured servants. Not so easy for descendants of slaves to pretend to be white and escape the racism that was absolutely undeniable for at least 100 years after the civil war.
 

basketcase

Well-known member
Dec 29, 2005
61,358
6,671
113
I don't think that is exactly true. It depends on the policy. The nuances can be shown with two simple questions. Is it systemic racism that blacks are convicted of crimes disproportionately more than whites? Is it systemic racism that blacks are sentenced to longer sentences for the same crime than whites?....
Those two polices are clear examples of systemic racism.

The only counter argument for the first is the individual racism proposed by darts that blacks are inherently criminal.

Do schools that punish black students disproportionately practicing systemic racism? Should schools strive to punish students in proportion to the school's racial composition?
The sure as hell should be looking at why its happening. Like with the courts each individual punishment should be considered based on its merits but if nationwide stats are that much out of kilter, it likely means there is something significantly wrong.
 

basketcase

Well-known member
Dec 29, 2005
61,358
6,671
113
I love it how you dismiss what everyone else went through. Like he said slavery is not unique to the blacks in the U.S. Get over it. Only the black experience matters, Right?
The industrial nature of US slavery is what makes it different. Some of my ancestors came to Canada essentially as slaves but when their term of indenture was up, they were allowed to go their way. That is far different to being freed from slavery and immediately being put in debt to try and survive followed by a hundred years of continuing persecution.

p.s. any anti-Irish laws were pretty much gone by WWI and I don't know of any anti-Armenian laws in Ontario but anti-black laws were still on the books in parts of the US 50 years ago.
 

Gooseifur

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2019
3,829
441
83
Really? So why does recognition of the Armenian genocide keep coming up?

You also miss a major difference. Your family chose to come here and weren't freed from slavery into sharecropping or factory work which wasn't much different.

I guess you do have a point though, black people today have it better than they did under the whip or Jim Crow (though no idea what that is supposed to prove).
I'm not Armenian. Check your history again and see who else the Turks brutalized. My family came here to escape the Nazi occupation in their country which wasn't much better than the Turks and all they could get was work in sweatshops at first because they didn't know the language. They also were insulted and rude comments were made to them on a regular basis, yet they never complained because regardless of what they went through they were happy to be in Canada. Are you telling me a job in a sweatshop is better than a sharecropper of factory work. Did you expect them to go straight from slavery into the corporate world?
 

Gooseifur

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2019
3,829
441
83
The industrial nature of US slavery is what makes it different. Some of my ancestors came to Canada essentially as slaves but when their term of indenture was up, they were allowed to go their way. That is far different to being freed from slavery and immediately being put in debt to try and survive followed by a hundred years of continuing persecution.

p.s. any anti-Irish laws were pretty much gone by WWI and I don't know of any anti-Armenian laws in Ontario but anti-black laws were still on the books in parts of the US 50 years ago.
Yes over 50 years ago yet some of them speak like that exists today which it doesn't. Some leaders keep saying they have been oppressed for 400 years which is not the case
 

Gooseifur

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2019
3,829
441
83
Those two polices are clear examples of systemic racism.

The only counter argument for the first is the individual racism proposed by darts that blacks are inherently criminal.


The sure as hell should be looking at why its happening. Like with the courts each individual punishment should be considered based on its merits but if nationwide stats are that much out of kilter, it likely means there is something significantly wrong.
I don't think blacks are in inherently criminal at all. If you listen to men like Denzel Washington and and Morgan Freeman who don't believe in systemic racism. They believe it has to do with the breakdown of the black family. To many black men without father figures to guide them through life and teaching them right from wrong. It's not in their DNA to be criminals.It's not in anyone's.
 

WyattEarp

Well-known member
May 17, 2017
7,232
2,041
113
Those two polices are clear examples of systemic racism.

The only counter argument for the first is the individual racism proposed by darts that blacks are inherently criminal.


The sure as hell should be looking at why its happening. Like with the courts each individual punishment should be considered based on its merits but if nationwide stats are that much out of kilter, it likely means there is something significantly wrong.
That is your opinion. You might be inadvertently making a case that society is responsible for crime and disruptive/violent school children. I'm not sure.
 

WyattEarp

Well-known member
May 17, 2017
7,232
2,041
113
I don't think that is exactly true. It depends on the policy. The nuances can be shown with two simple questions. Is it systemic racism that blacks are convicted of crimes disproportionately more than whites? Is it systemic racism that blacks are sentenced to longer sentences for the same crime than whites?

"Yes. Because the system makes those outcomes more likely."

I have personally found people make ridiculous arguments of systemic racism in reference to common public policy. Do schools that punish black students disproportionately practicing systemic racism? Should schools strive to punish students in proportion to the school's racial composition? The Obama Administration thought so.

"I have no idea what you are talking about for that Obama bit."
Your first response regarding outcomes is a major difference in our views. I don't think you should just solely look at outcomes and declare systemic racism exists. You can say it existed, but I don't agree with the claim it still exists just because a culture, a race has not achieved equal economic outcomes.

As far as the Obama Administration's guidelines for school discipline, let's just say they unduly focus on outcomes and they encouraged teachers to ignore disruptive students in the name of desired outcomes. These Obama/Holder policies were fairly well-known. Don't get too hung up on the Parkland shootings. It's just one incident where opponents of the Obama guidelines felt that the discipline policies had gone awry. There were moves to rollback the guideline before the incident.

https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/...-rescind-obama-era-school-discipline-policies
 

Darts

Well-known member
Jan 15, 2017
23,042
11,220
113
Why am I not surprised that you think blacks are to blame for being poor?
Why did you quote me and said the exact opposite of what I said?

"Quote Originally Posted by Darts View Post
Not all the blame for black poverty should be placed on blacks....."
 
Ashley Madison
Toronto Escorts