Ferguson or Probert?

Darts

Well-known member
Jan 15, 2017
22,944
11,295
113
Everybody loves a good fight. I know I do. I would pick Fergie in a heartbeat. He could score as well.

On a person note I got my hands on a Ferguson stick once. I noticed he taped wire on the top end of the stick. Fergie wanted his stick back. I said "no, make me" and he backed off. Lucky for him.)
 
Ferguson was a bit before my time, never saw him fight, going on physical size alone, I would take Probert, taller and longer reach.
 
Bob Probert had a tragic life with an addictive personality. He had the skill to become the Wings version of Al Secord but that's not what Jacques Demers wanted him to do. He couldn't fight when he was sober, that's when Tie Domi (with the Rangers) fought him - he was intoxicated when fought Wendel Clarke. Domi ended up as heavyweight champion of the NHL and Clarke ended up with a back injury.

I've never forgiven Don Cherry for putting Probert on the spot on his shitty show Grapevine. He was clearly drunk and didn't understand questions he was being asked.

John Ferguson made his name by breaking Bobby Hull's jaw with a cross-check to the face. When he did that the Blackhawks were favorites to win the Stanley Cup in 1968. He was good enough to win 5 Stanley Cup with the Canadiens. Hull never forgave him for that incident, when Ferguson became GM of the Winnipeg Jets, Hull walked out on the team.

https://i.pinimg.com/originals/84/0d/67/840d677c573539582c74db944fae418e.jpg
 
secord never played for the wings, just so you know.

I don't believe anyone said Secord played for Detroit.
Notably for some, neither did Steve Shutt.
 
John Ferguson made his name by breaking Bobby Hull's jaw with a cross-check to the face...
Hull never forgave him for that incident...

I wonder if any of Hull's wives ever forgave him for abusing them?

Is Hull still a Nazi sympathizer?
 
I wonder if any of Hull's wives ever forgave him for abusing them? Is Hull still a Nazi sympathizer?

Bobby Hull is a complicated man, I heard these stories and Brett said growing up around him was extremely hard. He was a nasty drunk who hurt those closest to him. Difficult to reconcile that with his public image of being generous with his fans and frequently visiting children's hospitals.
 
Bobby Hull is a complicated man, I heard these stories and Brett said growing up around him was extremely hard. He was a nasty drunk who hurt those closest to him. Difficult to reconcile that with his public image of being generous with his fans and frequently visiting children's hospitals.

I remember a study that showed the effect of drinking on people's brains.
They found that a specific part of the brain was triggered in those that became violent or very aggressive,
and not in in those that didn't behave that way.
I had an alcoholic uncle, 6'-3", powerful, the gentlest, easiest going guy you would ever meet, who became the angriest, scariest guy although not violent when he drank.

No point judging a player's performance or on ice reputation by his off ice demons.
 
Tough to pick between Ferguson and Probert.
Ferguson was more consistent and stable throughout the length of his career but nobody was as
dominant as Probert in his prime when he was on the ice.
I met Probert at a hockey banquet not to long before he died, a really nice guy and very thoughtful in conversation.
 
Ferguson was only 180 Lb's not really in Probert's weight class at 225 lb's.

Advantage Probert......

Just to clarify, I don't mean a "mano a mano" encounter between Fergie and Probert. I mean who would you want on your team?

"In 1963–64, he was promoted to the Canadiens as an "enforcer" to protect captain Jean Beliveau from aggressive defenders—merely twelve seconds into his first NHL game, he was in a fight with Ted Green of the Boston Bruins; Ferguson won the fight.[1] It was said that his unexpected retirement in 1971 caused problems for the Canadiens, who then started getting roughed up by other teams. Rumours persisted that General Manager Sam Pollock wanted to bring him out of retirement. [1]

During his playing career, he won the Stanley Cup five times: in the years 1965, 1966, 1968, 1969, and 1971, and always earned more than 100 penalty minutes in a regular season."

BTW: Is it true that Fergie ordered Clarke to break the Russian's ankle in 1972? It could be true because nobody wanted victory more than Fergie.
 
I would take Probert especially if he was on coke.
 
I would take Probert especially if he was on coke.

The coke eventually killed him but in the early years it was the alcohol that made Probert an animal. I've forgotten that Clarke fought Probert 4 times, I could make a case that John Brophy nearly ruined Wendel Clarke's career. The Leafs were so bad under him that Clarke was pushed to be a goal scorer and enforcer at the same time. As tough as he is, Clarke isn't built like Larry Robinson. This fight cost him almost the rest of the season.

 
Yes different eras indeed. I remember when a 200lb player was huge. Over 6ft was huge. Thus can't compare. Seemed Ferguson was more plugged into his team, Probert at times did lunkheaded things to hurt his team.