You deny the chart's existence because you cant fix a link ?
Here it
https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/cag/natio...se_prd=true&begbaseyear=1901&endbaseyear=2000
Here are the numbers you need
1. U.S. Temperatures 2019 down 2.25 C from 2016
2. U.S. Temperatures 2019 down 2.6 C from 2012
Now answer the questions
In the 7 years since 2012 CO2 has increased , however US temperature have declined. This is inconsistent with your premise and I want you to explain how this could happen
In the 3 years since 2016 CO2 has increased , however US temperature have declined. This is inconsistent with your premise and I want you to explain how this could happen
Seven years is certainly long enough to want to know why?
After all you are demanding we have to change .......... well everything, because you say CO2 is the control knob on climate
I think we are entitled to enquire when your all-knowing prediction does not work.
I think seven years is a quite reasonable amount of time ask, " Hey, why is it getting colder , CO2 increased past the all important 0.04% level, yet it is colder by 2.6 degrees celsius in the USA over the last seven years?"
It seems a very reasonable question for anyone to ask
It is as simple as that
Answer the questions
mr science, I answered the questions with direct numbers from your link.
And its obvious you just copied and pasted claims from another site and haven't been able to understand the points in your question.
Your numbers refer to Celsius temps but the link gives out clear numbers for Fahrenheit when you click on years.
Which is why my rebuttal is in ºF while your claim is clearly not from actually looking at the chart but from copying pasting from some denier site.
That also explains why you are totally unable to understand that you look incredibly foolish posting the same claim without understanding when you've been out argued.
So, once more.
I can't believe you still don't understand that you are cherry picking dates, so here is the answer to your questions.
1. U.S. Temperatures 2019 down 2.25 C from 2016
2. U.S. Temperatures 2019 down 2.6 C from 2012
The denier site you copied from picked the two biggest peaks and two biggest low points to cherry pick your claim, yet you still aren't bright enough to understand what you copied and pasted.
Instead you keep repeating it, showing that, like copyandpasteman, you are capable only of copying arguments, not understanding them.
Example 1 - you picked 2016 (peak year) to 2019 (coolest year in a few years). move your dates 3 years earlier and all of a sudden you show massive warming.
2013-2016 - increase of 2.5ºF
2016-2019 - decrease of 2.2ºF
Your claim only works if you cherry pick the warmest year to the next coolest year because the rest of the chart shows the same warming we've seen in every other fucking chart here.
Example 2 - try the seven years before your start date and again that 7 year period shows warming, not cooling.
2005 - 2012 - 1.8ºF warmer
2012 - 2019 - 2.7ºF cooler
Obviously there is no long term warming trend and the place you copied and pasted your argument from picked the warmest year to the coolest year to fool suckers like you.
I don't fall for that shit.
That shit is really stupid.
But what's even more sad is despite me explaining this to you 3 times in three different ways you still don't understand what you copied.
That makes you worse than CM, as when you corner him he just ignores it and pastes some different claim from his denier sites, until he got so ashamed that he had to put me on ignore.
Kind of like phil pretends to do, because he's been embarrassed here too many times to keep trying that shit with me.
But you?
That's sad.