Do you know what's a real waste of time? This conversation, starting with the bullshit title of the thread which has zero relationship with the intent of the President on this issue. It is not a settled law because a) it has never been tested on point, b)the current interpretation flies against the original intent- Google Sen. Jacob Howard and c) "the subject of the jurisdiction there of" doesn't mean what you think it means. I'm pretty confident how an originalist majority Supreme Court will rule in this case. Another win for Trump.
Aardie as usual is doing his best of obfuscation.
It is correct that it is a somewhat silly law to have, and that few other countries have it.
But the discussion is about Trump being able to change the constitution by decree. There Trump is incorrect.
You dont see whats wrong with your comment?
He has no problem if you become a LEGAL citizen. ...
Now that the Supreme Court is stacked with conservative Justices maybe he can pull it off?
Um, France, Germany, Austrailua, New Zealand abolished it. Others on the EU don't have it. India abolished it I believe, as Did Chile.
And the constitution is a dynamic document. Subject to continually testing laws according to the time and changing social constructs.
There is no such animal as settled law. Just agreed upon ones.
and by happy coincidence BeerBoy happens to believe that a President has unlimited power to circumvent laws. Yes, Kavanaugh truly believes that a President is above the law.
It does say that, back in 1886....
Um, France, Germany, Austrailua, New Zealand abolished it. Others on the EU don't have it. India abolished it I believe, as Did Chile.
And the constitution is a dynamic document. Subject to continually testing laws according to the time and changing social constructs.
There is no such animal as settled law. Just agreed upon ones.
Unless you talk about the 2nd....
However, there was no case law until 2008 as to whether the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution applied to an individual right to ownership and possession of firearms.
Respectfully, if this is NOT already settled law, why was it not litigated a century or half-century ago?
If it is not supported by USSC jurisprudence, then it must be supported by lesser level jurisprudence or simply a long period of acceptance and practice. Otherwise, millions of current US citizens and their descendants are "not really US citizens". The USSC is hardly going to kick over THAT ant hill!
And no, the president is not correct. Simply not liking a legal statute and pointing out that many other countries follow a different practice is hardly the same thing as being "correct".
You seem to know a lot more that the house Speaker Paul Ryan. He categorically said that the President cannot revoke the 14th Amendment through an Executive Order!!
Or a decision by the U.S. Supreme Court.
^^^^ Yup. It's a silly law. But it's going to require a constitutional amendment to change it.
However, there was no case law until 2008 as to whether the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution applied to an individual right to ownership and possession of firearms.
Ryan is right. But what this is is a conversation starter.
Try better to understand that changing bad law starts with identifying it as a problem and then developing enough public support to change it.