Predict Jays 2018 record

Jays 2018 wins


  • Total voters
    46
  • Poll closed .
Seriously, I am not trying to stir things up or imply anything. This is simply an observation that I thought was interesting.

Most of the optimistic voters are staunch conservatives/Trump supporters in the politics forum, Phil, Kathleen and Butler and I don't think there were any of that stripe that picked a poor outlook for the Jays. The libs among us trended to lower win totals, me and oagre. Apologies if I misrepresented anyone and their affiliations. These were just the names that I seem to see the most in the politics forum.

Maybe it means that conservatives are more optimistic people by nature.

Nah. It's spring and hope springs eternal.

20 games in I will be a grouch about things if they aren't above .500.
 
Wow. You think all of those bad things will happen in one season?

Guys on Bluebirdbanter are much more positive.

The critical thing for me is how strong the starting pitching is. If it is close to 2016 standards we are in with a chance of a WC.

As far as catching, batting and defence is concerned, this seasons addition will be an overall upgrade on 2017. But I don't expect Smoak to be as good.

Problem is that we are in the AL-E. Yanks look like a superpower. Boston looks pretty good. Jays look........... okay. I guess. If they're lucky.
 
Injury bugs again, Donaldson has a dead arm, just lobbing throws to 1st.

Man, that Yankees lineup ls scary!
 
Your initial hunch was correct and you failed to convince yourself haha.

Anyway, read this
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Games_behind

In particular: "The "games behind" number is sometimes made in reference to ".500" (even in wins and losses) although in this particular context, the word "behind" is replaced by "under" or "below". In making this calculation, however, the division by two is not done. For example, a team with a record of 19 wins and 20 losses is considered as being "one game under .500", in contrast to being "one-half game behind" a team with a ".500" record of 20 wins and 20 losses."

But with a 76-86 record they would only be 5 full games back of a team at 81-81 (.500). Just asking. This is why I was never sure, and I am still not convinced.
 
But with a 76-86 record they would only be 5 full games back of a team at 81-81 (.500). Just asking
But you would still have to win 5 games and the other team would have to lose 5 games for those 2 teams to draw even in the standings.

Games below or above .500 has nothing to do with catching the team thats ahead of you

I predict Gibbons will be fired by June
I hope so.

So yes we played like shit yesterday, but its only 1 game and anything can happen. Aaron Judge can get injured, Stanton could possibly test+ for steroids. Who knows what can happen.

I'll admit though, the Jays dont really look good on paper
 
Your initial hunch was correct and you failed to convince yourself haha.

Anyway, read this
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Games_behind

In particular: "The "games behind" number is sometimes made in reference to ".500" (even in wins and losses) although in this particular context, the word "behind" is replaced by "under" or "below". In making this calculation, however, the division by two is not done. For example, a team with a record of 19 wins and 20 losses is considered as being "one game under .500", in contrast to being "one-half game behind" a team with a ".500" record of 20 wins and 20 losses."

I don't think I had an initial hunch. I've always been unsure because I could see it both ways. But your last part makes sense to me, i.e. the differentiation between games behind and games under. Thanks.
 
:blue: I think I’m the only guy in the city who likes John Gibbons.
I'm a fan of the guy.

I predicted he would be fired. I didn't call for it.

If the team ever becomes significantly younger, then he might not be the proper fit. But the Jays are one of the oldest teams in the majors. He's a good man. A straight shooter. I am fine with him.
 
I'm a fan of the guy.

I predicted he would be fired. I didn't call for it.

If the team ever becomes significantly younger, then he might not be the proper fit. But the Jays are one of the oldest teams in the majors. He's a good man. A straight shooter. I am fine with him
But what do you do when he stops getting results?? Do you keep him because a good man and a straight shooter??
 
But what do you do when he stops getting results?? Do you keep him because a good man and a straight shooter??
I guess there is a statute of limitations. But a lot depends on what he is given to work with. If it seems that the results are bad because the players won't put out for him, then he must go.

He got us pretty close to the WS two years in a row (I know some say it only counts if you win it all) and last year's team he was given was not as good as previously and this year's team looks even worse (notwithstanding your 91 win projection). IMO, another poor season this year is a reflection on upper management. I know with your prediction, you would not give him as much leeway, which makes sense.

Since you projected 91 wins, is that based more on the roster or on Gibbons' managing abilities or a combo? Or maybe Pete Walker and Brook Jacoby's combined tutelage, or the rest of the AL east involved in plane crashes? Have you seen any pro analysts giving them 1st or 2nd in the div, because that is what 91 wins would probably produce? Not that I've looked hard, but I haven't seen it.
 
Right now after 35 votes we have exactly 60% calling for a losing (not loosing) season and 40% winning (not yet whining like the rest of us).
 
:blue: I think I’m the only guy in the city who likes John Gibbons.

Well I'm an out of towner, I have no issues with Gibby. He works with what he has, and for the most part he has done well with what he has to work with. The team has little going for it this year and looking at Donaldson yesterday, probably less than expected. Tired arm they say, we will see! If the arm doesn't improve quickly, that big contract Josh is expecting will be toast!
 
Tired arm they say, we will see! If the arm doesn't improve quickly, that big contract Josh is expecting will be toast!

As it looks right now, there is no way Josh throws anyone out on a slow roller or a bunt. I imagine we'll be seeing a few bunts up the third base line over the next few games to see if he can actually get any juice on the throw.

I am trying to find a positive from yesterday. Happ pitched well I thought, he deserved better than the line shows...and the line isn't all that bad.
 
Since you projected 91 wins, is that based more on the roster or on Gibbons' managing abilities or a combo? Or maybe Pete Walker and Brook Jacoby's combined tutelage, or the rest of the AL east involved in plane crashes? Have you seen any pro analysts giving them 1st or 2nd in the div, because that is what 91 wins would probably produce? Not that I've looked hard, but I haven't seen it
My prediction is based on 4 out of our 5 starters posting 3 or 4 games above .500 numbers plus we get some decent hitting.

I admit its a bit overly optimistic, but what the hey