Immigrants and learning English

The irony here is the sad level of the English in so many of the complaints.
 
It gets harder to learn new languages as you get older. Children pick up new languages easily but for adults it’s more difficult.



After the age of seven, it starts to get difficult. After the age of 12, it becomes very difficult. That's why I wish I took French immersion as a child.

I taught some ESL and I have to admit that some people really had no interest in learning English. English is not an easy language to learn.
 
Why bother learning english when everything is free

Hey now... not everyone suckles at the government teet.

I’m not sure how long you’ve been here, but some of your sentences aren’t very good examples of fluency.
 
Why oh why do some perfectly capable immigrants arrive here, and after DECADES living here STILL not have even the slightest decent command of the English language? Don't they want to go through life at least understanding a bit of what is going on in their own environment? To be able to interact with people?

I know quite a few that still can barely get by. I don't get it. One in particular is always moaning and groaning about life, yet has done nothing to get ahead or have the slightest opportunity at employment.

If I were to go live in another country for the rest of my life , and only hung out with expats and spoke English, how much I would be missing out on living in another culture! Yes, I would learn the language. Just learn a few new words every day - there are lots of free lessons around.

I guess a lot of people are content with the bare minimum of everything in life.

I noticed too. I'm a ESL speaker/immigrant and spent a lot of time and money to learn English. I think the problem as far as the workplace is concernced, is that Canadian employers are reluctant to openly criticize newcomers for their barely comprehensible accents or poor English skills, mostly out of tact and political correctness. They won't even correct grammatical or pronunciation errors that people make. I am reminded of the late Randy Pausch:

“When you’re screwing up and nobody says anything to you anymore that means they’ve given up on you…you may not want to hear it but your critics are often the ones telling you they still love you and care about you and want to make you better.” (Randy Pausch)
 
No. I am not talking about perfect grammar, I am talking about the BASICS.
 
If YOU were to move to say, Portugal for the rest of your life, wouldn't you feel you were missing out by not learning Portuguese?

I am just saying that I can't understand why they wouldn't want to get to know their new culture a bit better, and that is impossible without knowing the local language.
 
No. I am not talking about perfect grammar, I am talking about the BASICS.

The vast majority learn those. In fact applicants for immigration must show functionality in either English or French. I believe the only exception are refugee claimants who are supposed to be judged on how dangerous it is for them in their homeland.

But if you want the law to say all Canadians must be fluent in our official languages, I would expect you to hit those FSL classes.
 
I was never under it.

I never said anything about legal rights or laws.
 
No, just learn the one you live in. And by the way, my French is just fine.
 
It's people choices and their freedom. They can choose to use any language that they are capable, comfortable and can get things done in the chosen language. If you choose to use English, that's fine and it's your choice. We respect your choice to use English but don't try to force us to use your language when we chose to use other languages.

You're not our boss. You're just another person who shares the world and land in the planet earth. I know that you systematically prohibited the First Nation or Canadian Natives to use their languages by forcing them and all of their children to be in the "residential school" systems. In this residential school, you prohibited all of the children of the First Nations people to speak their native languages and punished them if they spoke their native languages. What you did in the residential schools and what you want to do now is "cultural and ethnic cleansing ".

If you don't respect our culture and languages, we don't respect your culture and your English language as the same token.
 
What urks me in the U.S. is the huge amount of funds needed to print every thing in so many languages just for those that don't read English (our only national language not like Canada with also French).

I get medical notices with two pages of nothing but small print sayng something in just about every language most anyone might speak.

When I use my VOIP voicemail I have to choose English or Spanish. Likewise many other things. It is so expensive for all of us that have no interest in a 2nd language reading and a waste of time to listen to the speel of choices.

I respect the right of folks to speak their native language in their homes or groups. But I believe anyone coming as a resident of the U.S. should have basic English skills so we don't waste resources trying to appeal to them all. Or, in Canad the choice of English or French.

A good point is as we get older its harder to learn another language or some of our brains are wired differently. I am terrible at grammer in writing and I know it would be next to impossible to be fluent in another language with my detailed analtical but not conceptional brain. Even in 3rd Grade Spanish class I had a terrible time. The only Spanish I remember is "in de central de la caza" (spelled wrong I am sure - and it only does one thing - gets me to the center of a house.
 
It's all for votes

What urks me in the U.S. is the huge amount of funds needed to print every thing in so many languages just for those that don't read English (our only national language not like Canada with also French).

I get medical notices with two pages of nothing but small print sayng something in just about every language most anyone might speak.

When I use my VOIP voicemail I have to choose English or Spanish. Likewise many other things. It is so expensive for all of us that have no interest in a 2nd language reading and a waste of time to listen to the speel of choices.

I respect the right of folks to speak their native language in their homes or groups. But I believe anyone coming as a resident of the U.S. should have basic English skills so we don't waste resources trying to appeal to them all. Or, in Canad the choice of English or French.

A good point is as we get older its harder to learn another language or some of our brains are wired differently. I am terrible at grammer in writing and I know it would be next to impossible to be fluent in another language with my detailed analtical but not conceptional brain. Even in 3rd Grade Spanish class I had a terrible time. The only Spanish I remember is "in de central de la caza" (spelled wrong I am sure - and it only does one thing - gets me to the center of a house.
 
The only reasons to really get peeved about this are

1) you have to interact with this person if you work with them or they are your customer
2) you have to interact with this person and you are the customer
3) they are ahead of you in a line and the communication slows, causing you a delay (was at Service Ontario and this was evident)
4) some cannot maintain a job and their language skills are part of the problem (I know people like this).

I don't expect people to have perfect English but a fair command to write/communicate. At the end of the day, they are only hurting themselves and the schlub who has to translate for them.
 
The real question is, why are we letting immigrants in the country that don't have a moderate to deep grasp of either of our two official languages?
 
The real question is, why are we letting immigrants in the country that don't have a moderate to deep grasp of either of our two official languages?

Money, bleeding heart liberal/refugee policies, and a poor policy that doesn't require English/French as a known language. Obviously a refugee is an exception but then ESL should be mandatory and passing should be mandatory.
 
I noticed too. I'm a ESL speaker/immigrant and spent a lot of time and money to learn English. I think the problem as far as the workplace is concernced, is that Canadian employers are reluctant to openly criticize newcomers for their barely comprehensible accents or poor English skills, mostly out of tact and political correctness. They won't even correct grammatical or pronunciation errors that people make. I am reminded of the late Randy Pausch:

“When you’re screwing up and nobody says anything to you anymore that means they’ve given up on you…you may not want to hear it but your critics are often the ones telling you they still love you and care about you and want to make you better.” (Randy Pausch)
I congratulate you on your achievement; you put a good many native-speakers to shame.

Another aspect of workplace English is that in many lines of work, it's entirely possible to be an effective worker without any great skill in English. Again, as many native speakers prove.
 
Money, bleeding heart liberal/refugee policies, and a poor policy that doesn't require English/French as a known language. Obviously a refugee is an exception but then ESL should be mandatory and passing should be mandatory.

Ahhh yes. The good old days of William Lyon Mackenzie King, where Hitler be-damned, Juden refugees should go back to Europe.

I have to ask... Why should “passing ESL” be mandatory?

I’m sure there are tons of people who don’t want to talk to you. If they “can’t” talk to you, why would it matter to you?

[Countdown to “They’re only here for welfare...” zingers.]
 
Money, bleeding heart liberal/refugee policies, and a poor policy that doesn't require English/French as a known language. Obviously a refugee is an exception but then ESL should be mandatory and passing should be mandatory.

More like our birth rate has been declining for decades. The only way we're going to grow the population is to encourage immigration. If some people hate immigrants so much, then they better getting busy making babies.
 
The only reasons to really get peeved about this are

1) you have to interact with this person if you work with them or they are your customer
2) you have to interact with this person and you are the customer
3) they are ahead of you in a line and the communication slows, causing you a delay (was at Service Ontario and this was evident)
4) some cannot maintain a job and their language skills are part of the problem (I know people like this).

I don't expect people to have perfect English but a fair command to write/communicate. At the end of the day, they are only hurting themselves and the schlub who has to translate for them.

In the grand scheme of things, these are silly things to get peeved about. They are the definition of first world problems IMO.

1) As a business owner, you are getting paid to deal with customers with poor language skills.
2) If you are the customer, you can always take your business elsewhere if you're unhappy.
3) If they are ahead of you in line and it causes a delay, it's a minor inconvenience at best
4) It's not your problem to solve if someone cannot maintain a job because of poor language skills.

At the end of the day, you have no control over how other people conduct themselves. Complaining about them will not change immigration policy nor does it enrich your life. It basically amounts to a bunch of old angry white men that have nothing else better to complain about. Take that frustration and better your own situation rather than shit on someone else.
 
If some people hate immigrants so much, then they better getting busy making babies.

Exactly. Someone needs to be paying taxes to support all the old people, or this country is screwed.