Immigrants and learning English

barnacler

Well-known member
May 13, 2013
1,781
1,304
113
Why oh why do some perfectly capable immigrants arrive here, and after DECADES living here STILL not have even the slightest decent command of the English language? Don't they want to go through life at least understanding a bit of what is going on in their own environment? To be able to interact with people?

I know quite a few that still can barely get by. I don't get it. One in particular is always moaning and groaning about life, yet has done nothing to get ahead or have the slightest opportunity at employment.

If I were to go live in another country for the rest of my life , and only hung out with expats and spoke English, how much I would be missing out on living in another culture! Yes, I would learn the language. Just learn a few new words every day - there are lots of free lessons around.

I guess a lot of people are content with the bare minimum of everything in life.
 
Why oh why do some perfectly capable immigrants arrive here, and after DECADES living here STILL not have even the slightest decent command of the English language? Don't they want to go through life at least understanding a bit of what is going on in their own environment? To be able to interact with people?

I know quite a few that still can barely get by. I don't get it. One in particular is always moaning and groaning about life, yet has done nothing to get ahead or have the slightest opportunity at employment.

If I were to go live in another country for the rest of my life , and only hung out with expats and spoke English, how much I would be missing out on living in another culture! Yes, I would learn the language. Just learn a few new words every day - there are lots of free lessons around.

I guess a lot of people are content with the bare minimum of everything in life.

What you don’t know is that all those lazy immigrants you’re interacting with actually all speak English quite fluently, but don’t only when you’re around. It’s mostly to piss you off.

I’ve spent entire years in countries and barely gotten beyond pidgin, particularly in SEA. If my job or my interests required me to interact extensively with non-English speaking nationals, I tend to learn more of a language. If I don’t, I learn what I need to in-order to get by.

How many years have you been in this country? How’s your Algonquin? Mine’s shit. Comment te débrouilles-tu en Français?
 
 
It gets harder to learn new languages as you get older. Children pick up new languages easily but for adults it’s more difficult.
 
I've seen a few immigrants who are exactly as the OP describes. Usually they come here at an age where they've finished schooling so there's been no schooling in the language. Anyone who comes here and is still in high school generally has to pick up the language to get through.

What it comes down to is they work and live in environments where English is not needed. If a Chinese person works at a business with other Chinese people and never interacts with customers, they will just communicate in their native tongue. Then they speak the same language at home and in the neighborhood and can get by without ever having to really use English. Any interactions where English is needed involves a translator, usually their kid. And now a variety of businesses are adding additional language options to cater to large groups.
 
ESL has proven time and time again that school age kids do NOT learn languages and fail out of school

Old people just don't care
 
I met this Scottish guy who had been here since the age of 13 and he was now about 55. You could barely comprehend his brrrrrogue
 
Why oh why do some perfectly capable immigrants arrive here, and after DECADES living here STILL not have even the slightest decent command of the English language? Don't they want to go through life at least understanding a bit of what is going on in their own environment? To be able to interact with people?

I know quite a few that still can barely get by. I don't get it. One in particular is always moaning and groaning about life, yet has done nothing to get ahead or have the slightest opportunity at employment.

If I were to go live in another country for the rest of my life , and only hung out with expats and spoke English, how much I would be missing out on living in another culture! Yes, I would learn the language. Just learn a few new words every day - there are lots of free lessons around.

I guess a lot of people are content with the bare minimum of everything in life.
The English used by many, who were born and raised with no other language, is often poorer than the English learned as a second language by immigrants. Your observations apply at least as much to those Canadians, and your question even more so.

None of us is perfect, or even as accomplished as we'd like. Or think we are.
 
I know Im going to hear about this but, in my opinion no one should be allowed to immigrate here unless they had some command of English.
 
My neighbour is an older Asian woman who speaks very little English. That however hasn't stopped her from renting out 5 rooms in her house to English speaking students. She pulls in $4,500 a month them. So in her case, why learn English. Like others have said, many of them get along just fine, conversing with friends, hiring help, shopping at stores, going to doctors all who speak the same language.

Personally, I don't care one way or the other.
 
There's lots of reasons why people come here: to start a job, business, family, or retire. They all contribute by paying taxes and buying things. What difference does it make if they don't speak English?
 
There's lots of reasons why people come here: to start a job, business, family, or retire. They all contribute by paying taxes and buying things. What difference does it make if they don't speak English?
They dont ALL come here for the reasons you say they also come here for the free health care, and our generous welfare system. this a a predominantly english speaking country how do these people expect to work or start a business if they dont speak the language.
 
They dont ALL come here for the reasons you say they also come here for the free health care, and our generous welfare system. this a a predominantly english speaking country how do these people expect to work or start a business if they dont speak the language.

What is wrong for coming here for those reasons? If you had a choice between staying in a war-torn region and Canada, would you honestly choose to stay there? Regardless, people sitting on welfare still contribute to the economy by buying things.

Before you get upset about immigrants, ask yourself how many Canadian-born people are sitting on welfare that moan and groan about life and seemingly do nothing to get themselves ahead.

You can start a business that serves a particular ethnic group or work for one. Maybe you feel slighted by a business not catering to your group, but you have plenty of other options.
 
They dont ALL come here for the reasons you say they also come here for the free health care, and our generous welfare system. this a a predominantly english speaking country how do these people expect to work or start a business if they dont speak the language.

Bingo. But they can make money fine by dealing with other immigrants who speak their language. Goodbye Canadian "culture".
 
I know Im going to hear about this but, in my opinion no one should be allowed to immigrate here unless they had some command of English.

They used to force you to learn English or French for citizenship

Now Trudeau thinks that is too tough so no language for anyone!
 
Bingo. But they can make money fine by dealing with other immigrants who speak their language. Goodbye Canadian "culture".

Or you can work illegally and send every penny back to your home country since you pay no taxes
Sadly most of those filipinas do speak english lol
 
I met this Scottish guy who had been here since the age of 13 and he was now about 55. You could barely comprehend his brrrrrogue

Same with Polish and Italian people I've met. I'm sure many other ethnicities as well.

Fact is that with our ethnic centred communities such as Little Italy and Ronces, people in the first generation can get by without needing to become literate in English. Their kids do though.

Get over it. Canada isn't a Melting Pot and if people want to speak other languages then they have that right.
 
They dont ALL come here for the reasons you say they also come here for the free health care, and our generous welfare system. this a a predominantly english speaking country how do these people expect to work or start a business if they dont speak the language.

If integration is the point then we should demand ALL Canadians be fluent in BOTH of our official languages. You can start the trend by signing up for French lessons.
 
...

Now Trudeau thinks that is too tough so no language for anyone!

Do you realize that Trudeau isn't the one who changed things? As I said, I've met people who have been here since the 40's or 50's who still struggle with English.