An interesting pro-renting piece:
http://jlcollinsnh.com/2013/05/29/why-your-house-is-a-terrible-investment/
http://jlcollinsnh.com/2013/05/29/why-your-house-is-a-terrible-investment/
An interesting pro-renting piece:
http://jlcollinsnh.com/2013/05/29/why-your-house-is-a-terrible-investment/
Renting is for losers.
The only times someone should rent is if they are broke and can't afford/bank won't approve a mortgage. Or you're someone who doesn't want responsibility of ownership.... repairs, going through the motions of getting a mortgage, etc.... or someone is a lazy fuck and when the toilet doesn't work, they immediately call the landlord to fix it instead of taking the top off and looking at the insides to see if something came loose. If someone is like that, then fine, be a renter for life. I'm not even a good at handy work, but even I figured out how to fix a washing machine watching YT videos. Took me 10x longer to do it vs. the professional plumber who fixed it in 2 minutes, but hey felt good doing it myself.
People in the last 10 years is a great example of people making money off real estate appreciations. Granted, the last year or two it's been extra crazy, but even if you exclude the last few years, home prices have been skyrocketing for 10 years.
I've made money flipping homes, moving, and am in process of moving again. Made a sweet $250,000 on my current home playing the flipping game. No renter is making that.
Of course, most of the gains just sink into another property, so people making lots of money in real estate might might not be cash-rich. But doesn't matter. As long as something drastic doesn't happen sinking property prices like that US crisis 10 years ago, real estate investors are asset-rich. At some point down the line, they will cash out and have a million plus dollars. Some people I know have had their property go up $1 MILLION!!! over the past 10 years. No joke, a million. They bought some normal family home back then for $300,000, and now it's somehow worth over a million.
At the same time, a renter has nothing to show for. Rents are getting more expensive too.
The only way a renter is doing as well as a property owner is if they are scrimping and saving money and getting lucky in the stock market picking stocks that are doubling every year. Very hard to do and unlikely.
I'd ballpark over the past 10-15 years alone, my property flipping (combo of personal home and being landlord) has made me about $500,000+. Fucking easy to do too.
As a landlord, I look at the rents I charged, compared to what I'd pay if I owned the place with a mortgage. It' basically a wash. As landlord, I might pay an extra $100 a month, big deal. Since it's mortgage, I'd get back about half the value of my mortgage as equity every month. So my cash might drop $100 more than my rental income, but when I sell, I'll gain back $700/mth in equity. So it's a gain. One of my investment condos went up almost $200,000!, so take away commission, lawyer fees, other fees, but add back equity gains etc.... I made $150,000. Minus off capital gain taxes and I cleared $100,000 or so.
For someone who is a renter: You might pay a bit more in monthly cash-outlay expenses if you buy a place (property tax is the main cost you have to figure out as auto-enrolled through your mortgage, or you handle it yourself with the city), but you should make it all back in monthly equity. At low interest rates, your monthly mortgage should be about 50/50 split between interest (lost costs), and equity (principal gain). Even if home prices stayed flat, the equity you bank should cover future expenses of moving out, commissions etc.... So any home appreciation is gravy.
I hope renters don't think owning a home is hard. All you have to do is pay your bills and do some repairs here and there. Big time money to be banked.
Article was written 4 years ago.
Most homes have probably gone up 50% since then. Home owners making gobs of equity. And landlords getting the mortgages paid off by renters. Landlords also have their own home the own, which makes their asset pool going up even more. I had a renter paying me $2,400/mth!!! She could probably get a mortgage, pay for every cost herself and have a month cash-outlay of about the same money. Instead, she rented, paid me the money, which helped cover my mortgage and costs and she missed out on a place that appreciated $200,000 in 3 years.
People who haven't bought have missed out on the biggest real estate appreciation period ever. All you had to do is take the dip. Even if you got into ownership late in the game (lets say 2 years ago), your property is still up.
Now if you're a home owner for 5 year, 10 years...... mom and pop who bought their place in Etobicoke 30 years ago..... you're up big.
IMO, when so many people are jumping on the bandwagon, it's a bad time to buy. The evidence is very clear to see when people are getting routinely outbid. For me, it's a poor time to buy if you're basically guaranteed to be overpaying.
I hear ya.Some of your points make sense if you're trying to time the market. I know someone that was convinced that the market was going to crash a few years ago. So he sold his fully paid-off home and started renting at a much smaller place to wait for the eventual crash. This obviously did not happen and now he's priced out of the housing market.
That being said, we can't say definitively say if renting or owning is better. Like anything else in life "it depends" on your lifestyle choices and what else you are doing with your money. There are pros and cons to both. Renters and owners need to be putting money to work outside of their residence.
You also have to realize that not everyone has the desire or know how or time to search for and flip houses despite it being 'easy' for you. Someone mentioned this earlier too, but your home is worth nothing if you have no intention of selling. Even if you are going to sell, there are still a couples of problems 1. where are you going to live and 2. what investment do you put the extra money to get a meaningful return without any risk? You obviously cannot leave it as cash.
Let's say you want to sell your home and end up making a good profit. Now you have to find another place for yourself. You're almost guaranteed to be paying more for a smaller space in this market. You can certainly move far outside the city, but you then have the potential issue of commuting further.
Downsizing doesn't make sense to me either especially if you move into a condo. You're now living in a much smaller space and your maintenance fees are basically guaranteed to go up every year.
Bidding wars have been going on for 10 years. It's just now it's more extreme. Anyone who bought "at the high end" back then now has a place worth probably double.
I hear ya.
I'm just talking in general for people in normal situations.
Of course someone... let's say... who has a job that takes him from city to city every year, or someone who doesn't have the desire or physical ability anymore to do yard work, is more suited to a smaller place, be a renter, or stick to condo life.
As for the hassles of owning a home or flipping, that's something everyone who owns a home experiences for a first time. I got zero guidance from family. I just did it on my own. First time I saw the sales and agreement doc and all the gazillion pages, it's like "holy shit". But hey, you experience it for the first time and learn from it. No different than the other millions of people in the world buying a home for the first time.
No different than buying a car. Some people might not want to bother with car loans, shopping around dealers and car payments and repairs. It costs more, but gives you freedom. Some people don't want the hassle and they prefer taking the bus and subway. That's their choice.
If you want more freedom, it's a car. but it costs more, has more hassles and at some point you have to take the plunge and do a deal for the first time.
For sure.The 'hassles' of owning vs flipping are totally different. You can delay renovations or repairs on the home that you're living in. When you're flipping, you have to get these things done in a limited period of time to either sell or get a tenant in there. There is a danger (however limited) that you will be selling or renting in a bad market.
You touched on a very good point in that people are very ill prepared to go into the home buying process. Important financial topics like this are never talked about in school so we're left to try and figure it out. That's part of the reason why we have this crazy housing market; a whole generation of buyers and sellers that have no idea what they are doing and that causes the prices to go up like crazy. You could argue that was also the cause of the subprime mortgage mess too.
I've never understood why people offer to pay more for a house than what people are asking. When you go out and buy a new or used vehicle do you offer more than the asking price? . New condos and new housing are popping up everywhere. Even down here in the Niagara Region housing prices have gotten out of control.
I've never understood why people offer to pay more for a house than what people are asking. When you go out and buy a new or used vehicle do you offer more than the asking price? Same with other big ticket items.
It's not like there is a lack of housing. New condos and new housing are popping up everywhere. Even down here in the Niagara Region housing prices have gotten out of control.
Article was written 4 years ago.
Most homes have probably gone up 50% since then. Home owners making gobs of equity. And landlords getting the mortgages paid off by renters. Landlords also have their own home the own, which makes their asset pool going up even more. I had a renter paying me $2,400/mth!!! She could probably get a mortgage, pay for every cost herself and have a month cash-outlay of about the same money. Instead, she rented, paid me the money, which helped cover my mortgage and costs and she missed out on a place that appreciated $200,000 in 3 years.
People who haven't bought have missed out on the biggest real estate appreciation period ever. All you had to do is take the dip. Even if you got into ownership late in the game (lets say 2 years ago), your property is still up.
Now if you're a home owner for 5 year, 10 years...... mom and pop who bought their place in Etobicoke 30 years ago..... you're up big.
True about home appreciation over the past few years however prices may plateau or correct or inch up in the coming years bringing average yearly appreciation back to the inflation average. Rents are no longer in line with prices... you need an extremely large down payment on multi unit property in Toronto now to get cash flow. I'm looking in the $1 million - $1.2 million range for another income property and I find that it usually takes about a 40% down payment to obtain good cash flow which is far above the 25% traditionally needed (or apparently in the past when the numbers allowed for zero percent down and the property paid for itself). I wonder these prices are the new normal or inflated (based on record debt levels) screaming for a correction/recession.
Your budget is higher than mine.
My investment properties over the years are condos costing $300-500k. Rent them out for a few years and sell them for $100-200 gross profit. $100k down is all that's needed.
https://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20...e-prices-brooklyn-queens-hit-new-record-highs
So why not GTA reaching prices of living space in tune with other well developed cities?
![]()
Are you investing in the core or around the city?
Article was written 4 years ago.
Most homes have probably gone up 50% since then. Home owners making gobs of equity. And landlords getting the mortgages paid off by renters. Landlords also have their own home the own, which makes their asset pool going up even more. I had a renter paying me $2,400/mth!!! She could probably get a mortgage, pay for every cost herself and have a month cash-outlay of about the same money. Instead, she rented, paid me the money, which helped cover my mortgage and costs and she missed out on a place that appreciated $200,000 in 3 years.
People who haven't bought have missed out on the biggest real estate appreciation period ever. All you had to do is take the dip. Even if you got into ownership late in the game (lets say 2 years ago), your property is still up.
Now if you're a home owner for 5 year, 10 years...... mom and pop who bought their place in Etobicoke 30 years ago..... you're up big.