Cooling Toronto House Prices

This increase that has been seen in the housing market is unprecedented and who is affording these houses should be the question. Between speculators and foreign buyers, the market has been pushed beyond normal growth. How is this normal and sustainable? When the job market and wages haven't shot through the stratosphere, like housing has. Walmart is talking about a "restructuring" here, which means a loss of jobs. A house is worth nothing unless you sell it or use the equity within it. The later means debt and the former means you still have to put money out somewhere to live, but where? Unless you are willing to move a nominal distance, adding to your commute, this doesn't really fit into plans unless you're retired.

People forget that their primary residence is not an asset even if it's paid off because there's always going to be the carrying costs of property taxes and utilities. If you're lucky enough to have a house in the GTA, hang onto it. Even if you make a tidy profit, there's realistically no place to put that money to work.
 
Maybe my Portuguese and Italian neighbours knew what they were doing when they were buying 1, 2, 3 houses in addition to their principal residence. These houses will be passed to their children and grandchildren.
 
You must be kidding. You can't have humans living in a car in your driveway.

On the other hand, I can have humans living in my coach house behind my mansion.

It's not a car, it's a van. Includes free wi-fi and a tea kettle.
 
This is what $500K gets you in Toronto: http://www.cp24.com/news/a-few-detached-homes-still-listed-in-toronto-for-500k-or-less-1.3377563

image.jpg
 
It's not a car, it's a van. Includes free wi-fi and a tea kettle.

Which major intersections are you located at?

My folks have a lot of land attached to their house in the downtown core. They do not want to sell as it's been in my dad's family for 5 generations and my late grandparents left it for my dad because he was the one child they could rely on to maintain it. However, the upkeep is costly for 2 people and they are looking at ways to offset this. They have been approached by developers but they just want to increase their cash flow in retirement. Not having to deal with the problems of construction happening next door would be ideal.

My only concern is by renting a van/trailer on the property it may be in violation of some bylaw.
 
My folks have a lot of land attached to their house in the downtown core. They do not want to sell as it's been in my dad's family for 5 generations and my late grandparents left it for my dad because he was the one child they could rely on to maintain it. However, the upkeep is costly for 2 people and they are looking at ways to offset this. They have been approached by developers but they just want to increase their cash flow in retirement. Not having to deal with the problems of construction happening next door would be ideal.
My only concern is by renting a van/trailer on the property it may be in violation of some bylaw.

IF your folks are over age 55 and really don't want to pass on to the next generation, monthly payments to your folks in a reverse mortgage is a possiblity. I see in Canada there is only a govt option vs lots of private lenders in the U.S. In the U.S. it use to have a bad rap and high fees, but since about 5 years ago with new regs and competition bringing down costs I have clients that are considering it for retirement income. No paymens due until death (both spouses if married), and interest rates a bit higher vs regular mortgage. I work with mortgage brokers that waive the points (front end fee) which use to be one of the cost issues. BTW, I am a CFP, RIA (with a CPA background) but only for U.S. residents due to regulation issues of Canada/U.S.

In Canada its: https://www.canada.ca/en/financial-consumer-agency/services/mortgages/reverse-mortgages.html
 
IF your folks are over age 55 and really don't want to pass on to the next generation, monthly payments to your folks in a reverse mortgage is a possiblity. I see in Canada there is only a govt option vs lots of private lenders in the U.S. In the U.S. it use to have a bad rap and high fees, but since about 5 years ago with new regs and competition bringing down costs I have clients that are considering it for retirement income. No paymens due until death (both spouses if married), and interest rates a bit higher vs regular mortgage. I work with mortgage brokers that waive the points (front end fee) which use to be one of the cost issues. BTW, I am a CFP, RIA (with a CPA background) but only for U.S. residents due to regulation issues of Canada/U.S.

In Canada its: https://www.canada.ca/en/financial-consumer-agency/services/mortgages/reverse-mortgages.html

It makes me a bit nervous when I see statements like these. No payments due until death means that the next generation has to pay that loan. That can be quite a headache while you're trying to handle final expenses, etc.
 
It makes me a bit nervous when I see statements like these. No payments due until death means that the next generation has to pay that loan. That can be quite a headache while you're trying to handle final expenses, etc.

No, the next genaration has to sell the house and only get the excess of value vs loan. As I said, only if don't want to pass on home to next generation. Some folks say, let them earn their own wealth instead the luck of the womb and inheritance.
 
I've never understood why people offer to pay more for a house than what people are asking. When you go out and buy a new or used vehicle do you offer more than the asking price? Same with other big ticket items.
It's not like there is a lack of housing. New condos and new housing are popping up everywhere. Even down here in the Niagara Region housing prices have gotten out of control.
 
I've never understood why people offer to pay more for a house than what people are asking. When you go out and buy a new or used vehicle do you offer more than the asking price? Same with other big ticket items.
It's not like there is a lack of housing. New condos and new housing are popping up everywhere. Even down here in the Niagara Region housing prices have gotten out of control.

Actually there is a lack of housing. Well not condos but single family dwellings.

With 100,000 new people arriving into Toronto every year they have to live somewhere.

But what I've said before is that people are going to have to adjust there definition of housing. Density is going to become the new norm in the city. And so will high rises. Hopefully the boulders will adjust and start creating more 3+ bedroom units too accommodate.

No doubt prices are going up in Niagara. They were about half of Toronto. Hamilton has gone crazy as well.
 
Does anybody know what the historical numbers are?

It wouldn't be difficult to figure out. Some city website would have year to year changes.

That number is from recent articles I've read and may actually be low.
 
There are many cities around the world where home ownership is out of the realm of possibility for the majority of the population. Toronto is a very desirable city and is becoming one of those places.

Home ownership is not a right, and we have to get used to the idea that fewer people will be able to afford to own. Renting is the future, as is increased density.

The city needs to make it easier for developers to buy 5 or 6 single family homes and knock them down to create low to medium rise apartments and condos.

There is little vacant land in Toronto, and the only way to make room for the number of people coming to the city every year and to provide space for businesses so that those people can have jobs is to build up- building further afield is no longer possible.

It may be a harsh reality and parents may feel bad for their children but many vibrant cities in the world make due, and Toronto will adjust.

Renters will just need to be much wiser with their money as they won't have the safety net of their house as a next egg.
 
No, the next genaration has to sell the house and only get the excess of value vs loan. As I said, only if don't want to pass on home to next generation. Some folks say, let them earn their own wealth instead the luck of the womb and inheritance.

Wanting to have their kids "make it on their own" is a perfectly good reason not to pass the home to them. But you put the responsibility on them to sell said home during an emotionally difficult period of time.
 
The average sales price for Brooklyn homes was $788,529, the report found. The average price in Queens was $452,304.

In Williambsurg and Greenpoint, for instance, the median price jumped more than 22 percent over the past year to $1.05 million. In Brooklyn Heights, Park Slope and Fort Greene, the median price rose more than 7 percent to $910,000.

In Manhattan, too, where the average rental price was $4,007 a month in June — the fifth consecutive month above $4,000 — smaller sized apartments saw bigger price growth, with studios rising nearly 3 percent to $2,652 a month and one-bedrooms rising 3.5 percent to $3,500 a month, the report found.

https://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20...e-prices-brooklyn-queens-hit-new-record-highs

So why not GTA reaching prices of living space in tune with other well developed cities?

200.webp
 
There are many cities around the world where home ownership is out of the realm of possibility for the majority of the population. Toronto is a very desirable city and is becoming one of those places.

Home ownership is not a right, and we have to get used to the idea that fewer people will be able to afford to own. Renting is the future, as is increased density.

The city needs to make it easier for developers to buy 5 or 6 single family homes and knock them down to create low to medium rise apartments and condos.

There is little vacant land in Toronto, and the only way to make room for the number of people coming to the city every year and to provide space for businesses so that those people can have jobs is to build up- building further afield is no longer possible.

It may be a harsh reality and parents may feel bad for their children but many vibrant cities in the world make due, and Toronto will adjust.

Renters will just need to be much wiser with their money as they won't have the safety net of their house as a next egg.

We've been brought up on the myth that renting is for losers. If that were truly the case, then why do most Europeans rent instead of purchase their home? I agree that more emphasis needs to made on building purpose built rental buildings around town. We've been too obsessed with ownership for decades.

I do think that we need to use our existing land a lot more efficiently to build housing. For example, here is an interesting house that is basically inside the Etobicoke Centennial Park: https://goo.gl/maps/omUZJk1mJ6B2 You'll notice that there is a whole lot of empty land in this section of the park and there's no park benches, or shelters, or other amenities. It certainly won't be popular, but it might be time to develop this land for housing.

Another thing that can be done is build over top of subway stations especially in the suburbs. A lot of stations are giant areas of concrete and parking lot.
 
I've never understood why people offer to pay more for a house than what people are asking. When you go out and buy a new or used vehicle do you offer more than the asking price? Same with other big ticket items.
It's not like there is a lack of housing. New condos and new housing are popping up everywhere. Even down here in the Niagara Region housing prices have gotten out of control.

1) Because if you don't offer more, the other person who wants it will offer more, or the seller will decline your offer and wait for a better one

2) Unlike vehicles which depreciate in value and are relatively easy to replace, houses increase in value over time, are more expensive, and there is no substitute for the land your home is on.
 
We've been brought up on the myth that renting is for losers. If that were truly the case, then why do most Europeans rent instead of purchase their home? I agree that more emphasis needs to made on building purpose built rental buildings around town. We've been too obsessed with ownership for decades.

I do think that we need to use our existing land a lot more efficiently to build housing. For example, here is an interesting house that is basically inside the Etobicoke Centennial Park: https://goo.gl/maps/omUZJk1mJ6B2 You'll notice that there is a whole lot of empty land in this section of the park and there's no park benches, or shelters, or other amenities. It certainly won't be popular, but it might be time to develop this land for housing.

Another thing that can be done is build over top of subway stations especially in the suburbs. A lot of stations are giant areas of concrete and parking lot.

Renting is for losers.

The only times someone should rent is if they are broke and can't afford/bank won't approve a mortgage. Or you're someone who doesn't want responsibility of ownership.... repairs, going through the motions of getting a mortgage, etc.... or someone is a lazy fuck and when the toilet doesn't work, they immediately call the landlord to fix it instead of taking the top off and looking at the insides to see if something came loose. If someone is like that, then fine, be a renter for life. I'm not even a good at handy work, but even I figured out how to fix a washing machine watching YT videos. Took me 10x longer to do it vs. the professional plumber who fixed it in 2 minutes, but hey felt good doing it myself.

People in the last 10 years is a great example of people making money off real estate appreciations. Granted, the last year or two it's been extra crazy, but even if you exclude the last few years, home prices have been skyrocketing for 10 years.

I've made money flipping homes, moving, and am in process of moving again. Made a sweet $250,000 on my current home playing the flipping game. No renter is making that.

Of course, most of the gains just sink into another property, so people making lots of money in real estate might might not be cash-rich. But doesn't matter. As long as something drastic doesn't happen sinking property prices like that US crisis 10 years ago, real estate investors are asset-rich. At some point down the line, they will cash out and have a million plus dollars. Some people I know have had their property go up $1 MILLION!!! over the past 10 years. No joke, a million. They bought some normal family home back then for $300,000, and now it's somehow worth over a million.

At the same time, a renter has nothing to show for. Rents are getting more expensive too.

The only way a renter is doing as well as a property owner is if they are scrimping and saving money and getting lucky in the stock market picking stocks that are doubling every year. Very hard to do and unlikely.

I'd ballpark over the past 10-15 years alone, my property flipping (combo of personal home and being landlord) has made me about $500,000+. Fucking easy to do too.

As a landlord, I look at the rents I charged, compared to what I'd pay if I owned the place with a mortgage. It' basically a wash. As landlord, I might pay an extra $100 a month, big deal. Since it's mortgage, I'd get back about half the value of my mortgage as equity every month. So my cash might drop $100 more than my rental income, but when I sell, I'll gain back $700/mth in equity. So it's a gain. One of my investment condos went up almost $200,000!, so take away commission, lawyer fees, other fees, but add back equity gains etc.... I made $150,000. Minus off capital gain taxes and I cleared $100,000 or so.

For someone who is a renter: You might pay a bit more in monthly cash-outlay expenses if you buy a place (property tax is the main cost you have to figure out as auto-enrolled through your mortgage, or you handle it yourself with the city), but you should make it all back in monthly equity. At low interest rates, your monthly mortgage should be about 50/50 split between interest (lost costs), and equity (principal gain). Even if home prices stayed flat, the equity you bank should cover future expenses of moving out, commissions etc.... So any home appreciation is gravy.

I hope renters don't think owning a home is hard. All you have to do is pay your bills and do some repairs here and there. Big time money to be banked.
 
There are many cities around the world where home ownership is out of the realm of possibility for the majority of the population. Toronto is a very desirable city and is becoming one of those places.

Home ownership is not a right, and we have to get used to the idea that fewer people will be able to afford to own. Renting is the future, as is increased density.

The city needs to make it easier for developers to buy 5 or 6 single family homes and knock them down to create low to medium rise apartments and condos.

There is little vacant land in Toronto, and the only way to make room for the number of people coming to the city every year and to provide space for businesses so that those people can have jobs is to build up- building further afield is no longer possible.

It may be a harsh reality and parents may feel bad for their children but many vibrant cities in the world make due, and Toronto will adjust.

Renters will just need to be much wiser with their money as they won't have the safety net of their house as a next egg.

As for people who can't afford homes in the GTA, Vancouver or any other Canadian city (or foreign city) that costs a lot. Well, too bad. Nobody is forcing someone to choose the GTA.

There's lots of cities where you can buy a nice 3 or 4 bedroom family home for cheap..... but it's not going to be close to the GTA. If you want it, you got to pay up.

Home prices might be getting sky high in the GTA, but interest rates are absurdly low. Everyone with decent credit rating should be able to get a mortgage for about 2.5%. 10 years ago, it was double that. I remember my variable mortgage rate at 5.5% when interest rates were going up 0.25% or 0.50% every quarter.

So what has increased home prices is both demand/supply and also low rates which the banks (using their fancy calculators to determine maximum value) churns out big mortgage limits. People see that and they go nuts maxing out mortgages, so they buy more expensive homes. It's like a credit card. The bigger the max limit, the more some people will max it out.

I'm in process of moving, but when I did a pre-approval my mortgage cap was something stupid like $700,000. And that didn't even take into account the equity in my current place. Add that to the mix, and I can buy a million dollar+ home no problem. I didn't, but I'm sure some people in the same shoes will see that available credit and max it out. If I got magically teleported to 2005 when mortgage rates were double, there is no way my bank would give me $700,000. It would probably be half that.