Cooling Toronto House Prices

it's 5 percent of the sales but it is the top bidders on the houses which is going to have a negative impact on the prices of houses - their bids were wiping out the locals' bids
The 5% is wild ass guess since there's no data. That's what they said about Vancouver and, as it turned out, it it was actually 13%, if I remember correctly. But, that's neither here or there, the fact that we are seeing bidding wars is a symptom of shortage of houses. The low supply is what's driving the prices, not the foreigners. Is the exclusion of, say, 10% of purchasers the cure for this problem?
 
The 5% is wild ass guess since there's no data. That's what they said about Vancouver and, as it turned out, it it was actually 13%, if I remember correctly. But, that's neither here or there, the fact that we are seeing bidding wars is a symptom of shortage of houses. The low supply is what's driving the prices, not the foreigners. Is the exclusion of, say, 10% of purchasers the cure for this problem?

The Vancouver real estate tax only had short term effects on prices it's not the solution. I agree that supply (particularly of detached homes) needs to increase significantly. The Ontario government has been stalling on approving land zoning for development which has only exacerbated the problem. That being said I have a cousin who is a real estate agent in Oakville and she says about 70-80% of the buyers are foreign. That's a big difference from the the 5-13% we have been told it is.
 
I have a cousin who is a real estate agent in Oakville and she says about 70-80% of the buyers are foreign. That's a big difference from the the 5-13% we have been told it is
And he is right, real estate is an EXTREMELY safe investment in Canada right now (not just GTA but also Vancouver and other Canadian cities).

The 5-13% figure is a pile of bullshit perpetuated by the real estate industry who dont wanna see their Cash Cow croak on them!!

I dont really know what the long-term answer is when it comes to Wynne's latest legislation, but I do know that something needs to be done before the whole market gets out of control!
 
Last edited:
The Vancouver real estate tax only had short term effects on prices it's not the solution. I agree that supply (particularly of detached homes) needs to increase significantly.

This is part of the problem. The single family home is just not practical and a very poor use of land resources. These days, you have to be prepared to move way outside of the city and drive 2+ hours each way. To me, that simply does not make sense since any money you saved on the cost of your home you're burning in your gas tank driving into work.
 
This is part of the problem. The single family home is just not practical and a very poor use of land resources. These days, you have to be prepared to move way outside of the city and drive 2+ hours each way. To me, that simply does not make sense since any money you saved on the cost of your home you're burning in your gas tank driving into work.
forget about gas, it's 2+ hours out of 8 hrs of your free time left after 8 hrs work and 8hrs sleep. It's more than 25% of your fucking life.
 
Some people do work on their laptops while on trains,

I was referring to drivers. Even those that commute by transit still spend a lot of time waiting around. And then you have to factor in the time driving to the subway / GO station and fighting for parking.
 
My house is for sale now.. if I get what I'm asking that 2 hour drive is where I'm going TO RETIRE !!!!!!
 
I'm renting out an old Econoline van in my driveway, getting $1700 per month plus hydro.
Thinking of parking a second one behind it. :nod:
 
I'm renting out an old Econoline van in my driveway, getting $1700 per month plus hydro.
You must be kidding. You can't have humans living in a car in your driveway.

On the other hand, I can have humans living in my coach house behind my mansion.
 
Hard to believe the City is not rubbing it's hands in glee, over anticipation of the increased revenue as a result of the next round of property tax assessments.
Many will not be able to afford to continue to live in their own homes after that increase comes out.
 
Good article in Wall Steet Journal front page Business and Finance section "Home-Price Boom Migrates to Toronto"

The new taxes on foreign buyers in B.C. Resulted in plummeting home sales in Vancouver and a 28.6% increase in ave home value over the last year in Toronto to just under C$1 million - making it one of the fastest growing markets in North America. Much of the surge is from Chinese buyers. The worry is the bubble could burst - "bubble is of historic proportion." and could risk Canada's financial system as debt also rises to alarming levels.
 
I still own a home in Toronto. I rented it out when I moved away. Thinking about selling it but also willing to hold it for the next ten years or so. Though the rent control thing makes me wonder.
 
Hard to believe the City is not rubbing it's hands in glee, over anticipation of the increased revenue as a result of the next round of property tax assessments.
Many will not be able to afford to continue to live in their own homes after that increase comes out.

If property value assessments go up, the tax mill rate goes down. Essentially not a windfall for the City.
 
This increase that has been seen in the housing market is unprecedented and who is affording these houses should be the question. Between speculators and foreign buyers, the market has been pushed beyond normal growth. How is this normal and sustainable? When the job market and wages haven't shot through the stratosphere, like housing has. Walmart is talking about a "restructuring" here, which means a loss of jobs. A house is worth nothing unless you sell it or use the equity within it. The later means debt and the former means you still have to put money out somewhere to live, but where? Unless you are willing to move a nominal distance, adding to your commute, this doesn't really fit into plans unless you're retired.