Consent or No Consent?

You seem to be implying that a drunk may know what's right and what's wrong but at the same time be too drunk to consent.
I don't think that it is easier to figure out what's right and what's wrong than to figure out whether you want to fuck. Even for a sober person.
The reason the law is the way it is it's only because of the public policy. We simply recognize that taking the intoxication defence away from drunk drivers and rapists and bar brawlers goes a long way in ensuring law and order. That's it. Not because it's fair or reasonable. Only because it works well.
If we were completely honest in some sort of an ideal society we would all agree hopefully that if a good citizen got so drunk that he didn't know what he was doing (which we all did) and assaulted somebody or drove drunk then intoxication should be available to him as a defense.

The $64,000 answer. Thank you Counselor.
 
Have to agree fully with Fuji. I don't get drunk often, but when I have, consider myself pretty much the identical mind set as above.

I have seen people so drunk they have no idea of their actions. But it was their own decision to keep drinking until they reached that state of mind.

What are you guys saying? She had it coming?
 
People are failing to see there are TWO parties involved.

YES the woman made a mistake getting that drunk. But she did the reasonable and responsible thing which was to take a cab home. It is reasonable to expect that a cab ride should not include a sexual encounter/assault.

BUT it is also the cab driver's responsibility to not take advantage of a drunk person.

Flat out this guy took advantage of a person who was in no condition to fight back/consent.

Some people use the analogy of "Well two people get drunk and fuck all the time" but that is not what happened here. In this case a sober person took advantage of a drunk person. In some ways its like the difference between two kids having sex vs an adult having sex with a child.

Also there is a difference between two drunks who hook up at a bar vs one drunk and one sober person in a cab. Typically, drunk or sober you don't expect sex with your waiter, cab driver, cop etc.

Didn't a TO cop get in trouble for taking a drunk girl home and fucking her? How is this different? Also wasn't there a gang assault against three cops on a drunk parking meter maid? Wasn't there a guy who fled the country with the case of the drunk girl in the hotel? Or the two doctors and the drunk girl in the hotel? Or the college swimmer and the girl behind the dumpster? I think if you plan on getting your freak on with a stumbling drunk girl you are really taking your chances. I'd be especially worried if things are heading towards a gang bang with anal.

Flat out I get enough sex that I really don't need to take unnecessary chances like these sorts of scenarios.

I realize I have mixed in US and Canadian incidents but I think in North America it is commonly agreed upon that using drunk or passed out people for sex is frowned upon.
 
If in your mind you think "I better fuck her while she is drunk because it's now or never" then that's a good sign you should get her home safe and leave. Because you know in your heart of hearts that sober she ain't touching your dick.
 
What are you guys saying? She had it coming?

Not at all. She was easily duped or taken advantage of in having sex with that cabbie. Not her fault.

But she was well aware to take a cab and not drive. If she drove, she would be charged if caught.
 
She was unconscious and the legs propped up on the seats.

"The constable found a female passenger was lying unconscious and naked from the waist down, with her breasts exposed, in the back of the cab with her legs propped up on the two front seats."
 
So what about children? Should they be responsible for things they cannot consent to?

We aren't talking about children in this thread.

I think you're talking Fuji's quick statement out of context (and he might have misspoke when he said 'Absolutely').

He's been saying all along that you can't give consent about having sex if you're inebriated let alone passing out.

But you can't use drunkenness as a defense in an impaired driving charge. Fuji says you still know the difference between right and wrong, even when you're drunk (and maybe he's right). EternalBachelor says that it is a matter of public policy not to afford an accused the defense of intoxication in a DUI charge.
 
My god no.

I just agreed on his take regarding drinking, decision making, and knowing the difference of right/wrong when becoming intoxicated.

Not everyone holds their liquor the same way, some are addicts and alcoholics, some blackout. Many lose control, they lose the ability to tell the difference between right or wrong.
 
We aren't talking about children in this thread.

I think you're talking Fuji's quick statement out of context (and he might have misspoke when he said 'Absolutely').

He's been saying all along that you can't give consent about having sex if you're inebriated let alone passing out.

But you can't use drunkenness as a defense in an impaired driving charge. Fuji says you still know the difference between right and wrong, even when you're drunk (and maybe he's right). EternalBachelor says that it is a matter of public policy not to afford an accused the defense of intoxication in a DUI charge.

Then he's even more wrong than I originally thought.

being intoxicated doesn't exempt you from the law. The comparison is not on equal terms.
 
There is no such thing as right and wrong on a basic level or really on any level, except legal or religious. This is why there are different laws in different countries. Calling someone a motherfucker is a criminal offence in some countries. Is it right? Wrong? Who knows. Is fucking a prostitute wrong for a married person? Is smoking pot wrong?

Meanwhile wanting or not wanting to fuck someone really is as basic as it gets. A monkey knows whether it wants to fuck another monkey. That's how basic it is. And it's not really comparable to signing a contract. Being drunk doesn't enhance your enjoyment from signing. Signing is not "fun". Sex is. So people don't really drink before they sign. But they often drink or get high before sex. A lawyer who would kick a slightly drunk client out of the office may happily and legally fuck similarly slightly intoxicated person after an evening at the bar.

Of course in the case at hand she was not 'slightly drunk' but so plastered she pissed herself. A serious legal or scientific argument could be made as whether even one drink makes someone unable to consent but in this case there was absolutely no doubt.
 
So what about children? Should they be responsible for things they cannot consent to?

We judge they are incapable of knowing right from wrong until they are 12 if I recall correctly. After that she we try then as juveniles, until age 18 at which point we treat them as adults.

Note that is consistent with the idea that your can be criminally responsible even when you can't consent. A 13 year old can be charged and convicted of a crime, bit cannot consent, for example.
 
Then he's even more wrong than I originally thought.

being intoxicated doesn't exempt you from the law. The comparison is not on equal terms.

Nowhere did I say being intoxicated exempts you from the law. On the contrary I have said that intoxication is no defence.
 
We judge they are incapable of knowing right from wrong until they are 12 if I recall correctly. After that she we try then as juveniles, until age 18 at which point we treat them as adults.

Note that is consistent with the idea that your can be criminally responsible even when you can't consent. A 13 year old can be charged and convicted of a crime, bit cannot consent, for example.

Like I said, your comparisons are not on equal terms.

Yes you can be criminally responsible even when you can't consent. But what crime did she commit? Last time I check, it not illegal to hop in a cab drunk.

Nowhere did I say being intoxicated exempts you from the law. On the contrary I have said that intoxication is no defence.

This woman is not being charge with the crime, why would she need defence?
 
Like I said, your comparisons are not on equal terms.

Yes you can be criminally responsible even when you can't consent. But what crime did she commit? Last time I check, it not illegal to hop in a cab drunk.



This woman is not being charge with the crime, why would she need defence?

I never claimed she committed any crime. On the contrary she's the victim of one.
 
Read what you just wrote: if you have zero ability to make a rational decision then why are you responsible for THE DECISION to operate a motor vehicle?
There are many levels of drunkenness and most people are not totally mindless when drunk ( unless they black out). They make decisions ( probably bad ones) and they are not totally unaware of consequences. Caution is thrown to the wind and they act out in a less inhibited way. Drunk people have sex all the time, and it usually works out ok, apart from the STD's.