Consent or No Consent?

...

There's a huge divide between drunk and incapacitated and even unconscious.

But the cabbie is a real loser for having sex with a passenger that was in a questionable state - regardless if she wanted it.

Did you miss the part where she WAS unconscious?
 
Maybe bars should hand out "no fcuking this pussy" t-shirts in both official languages for drunk women who leave the bar.
 
Maybe bars should hand out "no fcuking this pussy" t-shirts in both official languages for drunk women who leave the bar.
It is equally sad that some men are so clueless that instead of alarm bells going off (she's drunk), instead they see a target indicator light.
 
Needless to say it does. Merely having had a drink does not make you intoxicated. Your unofficial standard of if you shouldn't be driving or feel you shouldn't be driving, then you can't validly sign contracts or give consent is a good and prudent one.

Interesting how in your redaction the "unofficial standard" assists way more potential victims (and less rapists) than it would the way omegaphallic has originally worded it.
 
Needless to say it does. Merely having had a drink does not make you intoxicated. Your unofficial standard of if you shouldn't be driving or feel you shouldn't be driving, then you can't validly sign contracts or give consent is a good and prudent one.

No I said if you CAN'T DRIVE, not should drive.

As it you are physically too drunk to start the car and drive away, if you are sober enough to know your not a safe driver, but could still drive if you choose too, then you are sober enough to fuck if you chose too.

If you can be arrested for drinking a driving, because being drunk is not excuse for drinking and driving, then yes you can consent.

But if you CAN'T drive because you are too out of it to figure out how to use a car, fall unconscious, can't even figure out where you are never mind driving somewhere, then you are too drunk to consent.

Clear?
 
My unofficial standard is based on legal accountability, if you can be accountable for drunk driving, you are accountable for choosing to have sex with someone.

What does this have to do with a sober person choosing to have sex with a drunk person based on your unofficial standard code of legal accountability?
 
this is not true - intoxicated people have the ability to consent

No, they don't. Not people who are as intoxicated as she was. We could debate where exactly that line is, but somebody who is so drunk they piss their pants and pass out is WELL past it
 
It depends on how drunk. The limit to me is can she commit an act of drunk driving. If she could have gotten into a car, started and driven drunk then she can consent, because she can be held to account for drunk driving. If she is incapable of drunk driving even, too drunk to have the ability to commit the act, then there is no way to she or he can consent. If I was a cabbie I'd have a dash cam.

I think that's reasonable.
 
Canadian law recognizes that a capacity to know right from wrong exists in people who are far too drunk too consent to sex.

If you are compable of doing a complex activity like driving drunk, you are capable of knowing right from wrong.

Look at the end of the day you are either capable of being held accountable for you actions or you are not. No one worth talking about accepts being drunk as an excuse for actually raping someone, so it's no excuse for acting like a victim when you did consent.
 
Canadian law recognizes that a capacity to know right from wrong exists in people who are far too drunk too consent to sex.
https://www.thestar.com/news/crime/...ermine-how-drunk-is-too-drunk-to-consent.html
The courts have found “mere drunkenness does not equate to incapacity, nor is imprudent decision-making, loss of inhibitions or self-control,” she said. Or, as another court decision put it: “a drunken consent is still a valid consent.”

She continued: “We have cases where someone is quite literally falling down drunk or vomiting and that, in and of itself, is not enough.”

It’s also not enough to show that the person is making poor or risky decisions and is vulnerable to exploitation.

In one recent Ontario case, a woman who was too drunk to dress herself and was “zigzagging” was found capable of consenting in part because the court found she was able to understand a concerned caution from a friend and chose to ignore it.
 
No one worth talking about accepts being drunk as an excuse for actually raping someone, so it's no excuse for acting like a victim when you did consent.

not just no one worth talking about, it's specifically excluded as a possible defence for all assaults (and more) by s. 33.1 of the crim code.
 
No I said if you CAN'T DRIVE, not should drive.

As it you are physically too drunk to start the car and drive away, if you are sober enough to know your not a safe driver, but could still drive if you choose too, then you are sober enough to fuck if you chose too.

If you can be arrested for drinking a driving, because being drunk is not excuse for drinking and driving, then yes you can consent.

But if you CAN'T drive because you are too out of it to figure out how to use a car, fall unconscious, can't even figure out where you are never mind driving somewhere, then you are too drunk to consent.

Clear?
Well it is clear that is the way you feel.

On the other hand how I paraphrased it is lawyerly advise as to how to avoid the risks and expense of being arrested and tried.

Then again the children need shoes, so feel free to argue.
 
https://www.thestar.com/news/crime/...ermine-how-drunk-is-too-drunk-to-consent.html
The courts have found “mere drunkenness does not equate to incapacity, nor is imprudent decision-making, loss of inhibitions or self-control.”
So far I would entirely agree.

However, when Angela Chaisson cites decisions where the court held that it was not enough that someone was "quite literally falling down drunk or vomiting and that, in and of itself, is not enough.” or the case in Ontario where a woman who was too drunk to dress herself and was “zigzagging” was found capable of consenting in part because the court found she was able to understand a concerned caution from a friend and chose to ignore it.

Then I must say that the state of the law in Canada is years behind that in most parts of the U.S. There is absolutely no way where I practice that a successful defence could be mounted based on she consented where testimony showed that the woman was falling down drunk and vomiting, or that where testimony showed a woman was loosing her balance and staggering in the street* and was incapable of dressing herself, that she would be viewed as capable of consenting because she "blew off" a friend who warned her.

* Which sounds to me as incapable of passing a heal to toe probable cause sobriety test.
 
The judge is clearly toast and his career is over.


http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...ers-sexual-assault-acquittal/article34229340/

“We have conducted a legal analysis of the judge’s decision and have concluded there is a solid basis to appeal the ruling,” Smith said in a statement Tuesday.

She said the judge erred in law by:

-concluding the Crown had offered no evidence of lack of consent from the complainant;
-engaging in speculation about consent rather than drawing inferences from the facts proven in the evidence;
-failing to give proper legal effect to the facts;
-offering an erroneous interpretation and application of the test for capacity to consent;
-failing to direct himself on Criminal Code provisions that deal with aggravated sexual assault;
-failing to determine whether the accused had taken all reasonable steps to ascertain that the complainant was consenting.
 
My unofficial standard is based on legal accountability, if you can be accountable for drunk driving, you are accountable for choosing to have sex with someone.

The duty of law is to protect society and therefore will err towards protection. Drunk driving poses a risk to society and therefore the law is skewed to prevent and prosecute based on the potential harm. With sex, the potential harm is nonconsentual sex so the law is skewed to protect the victims. It's really not that hard to understand.

And philosophical discussions on the nature of law aside, there was absolutely no question the woman in this case was unable to consent, unable (as in physically impossible) to drive, or unable to remain conscious.
 
What happens if both the male and the female are totally intoxicated?

Have they both raped each other and both been raped?