Consent or No Consent?

Let me see if I get this straight:

Case 1: You are drunk and you proceed to drive a car. The law says, no excuse, you should of known better.

Case 2: You are drunk and you get in a cab and sex occurs. The law says you have zero ability to make a rational decision.

Can't have it both ways, either you are totally innocent and incapable of making rational decisions while drunk, or you can and are still liable for your decisions.
 
Let me see if I get this straight:

Case 1: You are drunk and you proceed to drive a car. The law says, no excuse, you should of known better.

Case 2: You are drunk and you get in a cab and sex occurs. The law says you have zero ability to make a rational decision.

Can't have it both ways, either you are totally innocent and incapable of making rational decisions while drunk, or you can and are still liable for your decisions.

logic is on your side yet the law is not ;)

an even more glaring inconsistency would be when the accused is so drunk that he had no ability to make a decision and he had assaulted the victim. Criminal Code specifically stops the accused from relying on an intoxication as a defence to an assault or sex assault http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-46/section-33.1.html.
So when the accused and complainant are both shitfaced, he is responsible for his actions but she is not.
 
On the topic of consent: the absence of a No is NOT a Yes.

On the topic of personal accountability: yes the law has an inherent sexist double-standard, but why are we surprised by this when there are so many anachronisms still floating about protecting women but crucifying men?

Basic lesson for life: Don't penetrate anybody... EVER (unless you're paying them for it and they can be trusted for discretion)
 
Last edited:
This is a dangerous era to fuck a stranger. I wouldn't want to take a girl on a date, have a few drinks - and then move on to sex. One person's remorse could ruin the other person's life.

Aside from that - the cabbie is a complete douche for taking advantage of an intoxicated woman. Also, somehow, friends need to do a better job of looking out for each other when alcohol is involved. Assuming a cabbie will pour you out of the car and safely into your bed is a bad assumption.
 
On the topic of consent: the absence of a No is NOT a Yes.

On the topic of personal accountability: yes the law has an inherent sexist double-standard, but why are we surprised by this when there are so many anachronisms still floating about protecting women but crucifying men?

Tired Double-Standards:
  • Female teacher has sex with underage student = slap on the wrist. Male teacher does it and he's going to jail.
  • Wife decks husband and he complains to cops = laughter. Man slaps wife and he's in lock-up.
  • Primary child custody is almost a 100% slam dunk for the woman unless she's a drunk/addict, regardless of whether she's actually a horrible person compared to the Dad.
  • Woman accuses man of sexual assault fallaciously without consequence. Man's life is ruined for years / permanently even after she recants her falsehoods.
  • Men can't be raped (i.e. we're always willing)
  • Woman inseminates herself without her partner's consent (condom tampering, semen extraction, etc.) and he's on the hook for support.
Basic lesson for life: Don't penetrate anybody... EVER (unless you're paying them for it and they can be trusted for discretion)

I would clarifiy the Basic Lesson with "Don't penetrate any stranger, especially if they are intoxicated; and if not drunk, only if they can be trusted, and always wear a condom (or don't cum inside)".

Just to tell you a short story, I met a gal off a chat line at a restaurant. She was waiting for me and already drunk. I carefully brought her to my place so that she could cool off and sober up (I couldn't let her drive - I had to help her from falling over in the walk to my car). I did not reciprocate with her advances on me at my home (She was a spinner and fairly attractive, but I resisted temptation and also felt I could get into trouble if it escalated to full blown sex). She got offended and told me to fuck off, and left my apartment at the time. I didn't know where she went, and her car was parked 2 miles away. I kind of worried. Then she called me and had calmed down. I went down to meet her. I took her back to her car but we 1st both had a coffee. She was sober. She said she liked me. She made another advance. Again, I kindly rejected her (it was futile at that point to proceed on a rocky start). She told me to fuck off again but luckily, left to go back to her car. I watched her from my car but didn't want to drive away as I was afraid she might follow me. Then I saw her, to my surprise, change into something else (yes, in the front seat of the car, she removed her summer dress and put something else on - hmmm, maybe she was going back to her husband). She called me the next day and left a voice mail message on my home phone. She apologized profusely. I ignored her.

If this were to happen to me in the future, I would just take her to a coffee shop (if not her home), and let that person sober up.

Something like this happened to a friend on a blind date. She had a hotel room upstairs from the hotel restaurant at the ground floor. She passed out on the dinner table over wine. He got help from a baggage guy to bring her to her room. They put her down on the bed. He left. She called next day to apologize and wanted another chance. He ignored her call. She was gorgeous.
 
Unlike many other Common Law jurisdictions including the United States in Canada the Crown can appeal. However, appeals by the Crown are quite rare, and generally confined to errors in law.

I'm not sure intoxication voids consent as a matter of law. I think it becomes a question of fact whether the intoxication was so severe that consent could not be given. I am quite sure that this particular woman was too intoxicated to give consent. Indeed, every fact in the story screams out that she was incapable of giving consent, highly intoxicated and that she was raped.

That said, if I am defence counsel, I am arguing that the Crown is trying to appeal on mixed fact and law and the court of appeal has no jurisdiction to hear the case.

The judge is clearly toast and his career is over.
 
At a certain point, error of fact can become error of law if the court proceeds to make a finding of fact with no admissible evidence in support of that fact. The Crown argument here is that there is NO POSSIBLE EVIDENCE OF CONSENT in any realistic form. That gives an appeal on a point of law.
 
At a certain point, error of fact can become error of law if the court proceeds to make a finding of fact with no admissible evidence in support of that fact. The Crown argument here is that there is NO POSSIBLE EVIDENCE OF CONSENT in any realistic form. That gives an appeal on a point of law.

this is easily a proper crown appeal on error of law. Here's the leading case:

R v JMH, 2011 SCC 45 at paras 24-32:

(1) It is an error of law to make a finding of fact for which there is no evidence – however, a conclusion that the trier of fact has a reasonable doubt is not a finding of fact for the purposes of this rule;

(2) The legal effect of findings of fact or of undisputed facts raises a question of law;

(3) An assessment of the evidence based on a wrong legal principle is an error of law;

(4) The trial judge’s failure to consider all of the evidence in relation to the ultimate issue of guilt or innocence is an error of law.


apart from lack of evidence of consent there's evidence of lack of ability to consent (urinated clothes etc) that arguably was not considered
 
On the topic of consent: the absence of a No is NOT a Yes.

On the topic of personal accountability: yes the law has an inherent sexist double-standard, but why are we surprised by this when there are so many anachronisms still floating about protecting women but crucifying men?

Tired Double-Standards:
  • Female teacher has sex with underage student = slap on the wrist. Male teacher does it and he's going to jail.
  • Wife decks husband and he complains to cops = laughter. Man slaps wife and he's in lock-up.
  • Primary child custody is almost a 100% slam dunk for the woman unless she's a drunk/addict, regardless of whether she's actually a horrible person compared to the Dad.
  • Woman accuses man of sexual assault fallaciously without consequence. Man's life is ruined for years / permanently even after she recants her falsehoods.
  • Men can't be raped (i.e. we're always willing)
  • Woman inseminates herself without her partner's consent (condom tampering, semen extraction, etc.) and he's on the hook for support.
Basic lesson for life: Don't penetrate anybody... EVER (unless you're paying them for it and they can be trusted for discretion)

Your points are inaccurate.

1. Wife decks husband. She gets charged by the cops and may well go to jail. If there is any difference between men and women in this situation, it might be that the judge discounts the assault because the woman is too weak to do any real harm in a mano a mano with a guy and because an assault by a guy also carries the stigma of bullying a weaker person.
2. You have NO IDEA how Family Courts award custody and your conclusion is totally at odds with how it happens in the real world.
3. A woman can be sued for malicious prosecution if she invents allegations. As well, she can be charged with "public mischief". And guys make stuff up as well BTW.
4. Men can't be raped? Physically no. But women have been charged with sexual assault for groping men.
5. Woman inseminates herself. Yup, guy is on the hook But that's because the court always covers for the kid. It's not about the woman.

Take it from a lawyer. Ain't no double standard except in the tormented fantasies of guys on TERB.
 
Your points are inaccurate.

1. Wife decks husband. She gets charged by the cops and may well go to jail. If there is any difference between men and women in this situation, it might be that the judge discounts the assault because the woman is too weak to do any real harm in a mano a mano with a guy and because an assault by a guy also carries the stigma of bullying a weaker person.
2. You have NO IDEA how Family Courts award custody and your conclusion is totally at odds with how it happens in the real world.
3. A woman can be sued for malicious prosecution if she invents allegations. As well, she can be charged with "public mischief". And guys make stuff up as well BTW.
4. Men can't be raped? Physically no. But women have been charged with sexual assault for groping men.
5. Woman inseminates herself. Yup, guy is on the hook But that's because the court always covers for the kid. It's not about the woman.

Take it from a lawyer. Ain't no double standard except in the tormented fantasies of guys on TERB.

Lol. Well said Counsellor!
 
I'm sorry a woman who is so drunk that she can not even make it to the bathroom and possibly has no idea of whats happening can not give consent IMO.I as a woman and I'm sure many other women on here will agree that when I/ we get into a cab and I/ we are drunk my intentions are NOT to have sex with the driver. The article says that instead of taking her home he took her to opposite side of town where he parked up. He seen that she was drunk, the first thing he should have done was taken her home.
Did you read my post? I agree with you . The cab driver appears to be guilty of rape. But my point was that you can't just say "drunks can't give consent" in every case. There are scenarios where drunks can and do give consent and are responsible for their drunken decisions. Sometimes 2 people are drunk and decide to have sex... in fact , all the time... it depends on the facts of each case.
 
Let me see if I get this straight:

Case 1: You are drunk and you proceed to drive a car. The law says, no excuse, you should of known better.

Case 2: You are drunk and you get in a cab and sex occurs. The law says you have zero ability to make a rational decision.

Can't have it both ways, either you are totally innocent and incapable of making rational decisions while drunk, or you can and are still liable for your decisions.

I don't see the conflict. If you have zero ability to make a rational decision (case 2) then you shouldn't be operating a vehicle (case 1). Where's the conflict?
 
sorry yes there was a misunderstanding. Yes that is true but that doesn't appear to be the scenario in this case.He deliberately took her to another end of town opposite of her house direction where he proceeded to rape her.


Did you read my post? I agree with you . The cab driver appears to be guilty of rape. But my point was that you can't just say "drunks can't give consent" in every case. There are scenarios where drunks can and do give consent and are responsible for their drunken decisions. Sometimes 2 people are drunk and decide to have sex... in fact , all the time... it depends on the facts of each case.
 
Preface my comment by stating that I did not read the thread, nor the article.
I just want to put my opinion out there.
I believe that No means No, obviously.
I also believe that the absence of a solid, reliable, sober, of sound mind, Yes, means No.

I think that taking advantage of a drunk woman is despicable.
 
You just contradicted yourself right there buddy, or are you too stupid to realize that?

You're an attorney? That's terrifying that they allow people like you to practice law.

Double standard is treating similar things differently. If your 110lb girlfriend slaps you (let's say you are 220lb) across the face and you call the police on her she will still be arrested and charged. But the crown and court at some point will likely recognize that she posed no real threat to you and she will be able to have this charge dropped a little easier than if you were to slap her.
See how 110lb person slapping 220lb person is not quite similar to 220lb person slapping 110lb person? Well, that's why oagre is allowed to practice law and you are not ;)
 
I don't see the conflict. If you have zero ability to make a rational decision (case 2) then you shouldn't be operating a vehicle (case 1). Where's the conflict?

I think what Barnacler is getting at is if you're too drunk to control yourself and be responsible for your actions (like having sex with a stranger), then you similarly cannot be aware that you're driving under the influence or committing that offence in the first place.
 
Double standard is treating similar things differently. If your 110lb girlfriend slaps you (let's say you are 220lb) across the face and you call the police on her she will still be arrested and charged. But the crown and court at some point will likely recognize that she posed no real threat to you and she will be able to have this charge dropped a little easier than if you were to slap her.
See how 110lb person slapping 220lb person is not quite similar to 220lb person slapping 110lb person? Well, that's why oagre is allowed to practice law and you are not ;)


Well said. Plus Vostok misquoted Oagre or quoted him out of context. Oagre did say that a wife would be charged if she decks her husband but that the courts may discount her assault as explained heretofore.